21 best-selling christian fiction books like The Souls of Lost Lake by Jaime Jo Wright

Cover of The Souls of Lost Lake by Jaime Jo Wright

The Souls of Lost Lake

By: Jaime Jo Wright

4.27

Format: 383 pages, Paperback

Wren Blythe has long enjoyed being among the Northwoods, helping her father with programming at a y…

"Noah Pritchard ws cultured. Maybe not rich, but he spoke fine. She was an orphaned child from the woods and had all the etiquette of a groundhog at an evening ball."

-Jaime Jo Wright, The Souls of Lost Lake

"It's holding each other accountable, yes, but it's also not creating our own narrative and forcing others' stories into it. Finding the truth which is nonnegotiable. That is our purpose."

-Jaime Jo Wright, The Souls of Lost Lake

If you liked the christian fiction plot in The Souls of Lost Lake by Jaime Jo Wright , here is a list of 21 books like this:

Cover of For a Lifetime (Timeless, #3) by Gabrielle  Meyer

1. For a Lifetime (Timeless, #3)

By: Gabrielle Meyer

4.55

Format: 400 pages, Paperback

Grace and Hope are identical twin sisters born with the ability to time-cross together between 1692… read more

Similar categories in Gabrielle Meyer's For a Lifetime (Timeless, #3) book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
Cover of A Million Little Choices by Tamera Alexander

2. A Million Little Choices

By: Tamera Alexander

4.44

Format: 394 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes secrets just won’t stay hidden . . . From USA Today bestselling author and Christy Award… read more

Similar categories in Tamera Alexander's A Million Little Choices book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of The Extraordinary Deaths of Mrs. Kip by Sara Brunsvold

3. The Extraordinary Deaths of Mrs. Kip

By: Sara Brunsvold

4.37

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

Aidyn Kelley is talented, ambitious, and ready for a more serious assignment than the fluff pieces … read more

Similar categories in Sara Brunsvold's The Extraordinary Deaths of Mrs. Kip book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"Ours is a God of new life~Mrs. Kip"

-Sara Brunsvold, The Extraordinary Deaths of Mrs. Kip

"Keep the fight in your veins, honey. Never let it fade."

-Sara Brunsvold, The Extraordinary Deaths of Mrs. Kip

"Hard things usually end in the biggest blessings. ~Mrs. Kip"

-Sara Brunsvold, The Extraordinary Deaths of Mrs. Kip

"Lord, you are so good, and your love holds everything together."

-Sara Brunsvold, The Extraordinary Deaths of Mrs. Kip

Cover of Free Fall (The Quantico Files, #3) by Nancy Mehl

4. Free Fall (The Quantico Files, #3)

By: Nancy Mehl

4.36

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

Someone has been abducting women with long dark hair across Virginia. When the FBI is called in to … read more

Similar categories in Nancy Mehl's Free Fall (The Quantico Files, #3) book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • mystery thriller
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of Cold Threat (Ryland & St. Clair #2) by Nancy Mehl

5. Cold Threat (Ryland & St. Clair #2)

By: Nancy Mehl

4.33

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

Twenty years ago, several people were murdered in Des Moines, and the only evidence left behind was… read more

Similar categories in Nancy Mehl's Cold Threat (Ryland & St. Clair #2) book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Souls of Lost Lake by Jaime Jo Wright

6. The Souls of Lost Lake

By: Jaime Jo Wright

4.27

Format: 383 pages, Paperback

Wren Blythe has long enjoyed being among the Northwoods, helping her father with programming at a y… read more

Similar categories in Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • gothic
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
"Noah Pritchard ws cultured. Maybe not rich, but he spoke fine. She was an orphaned child from the woods and had all the etiquette of a groundhog at an evening ball."

-Jaime Jo Wright, The Souls of Lost Lake

"It's holding each other accountable, yes, but it's also not creating our own narrative and forcing others' stories into it. Finding the truth which is nonnegotiable. That is our purpose."

-Jaime Jo Wright, The Souls of Lost Lake

Cover of Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1) by Pepper Basham

7. Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1)

By: Pepper Basham

3.89

Format: 432 pages, Paperback

“Dear Izzy—I feel certain there’s a book-loving man living relatively nearby waiting to speak booki… read more

Similar categories in Pepper Basham's Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1) book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
"The place where they lived within my heart is still being held for them, like a bookmark of sorts - waiting to see them again."

-Pepper Basham, Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1)

Cover of In This Moment (Timeless, #2) by Gabrielle  Meyer

8. In This Moment (Timeless, #2)

By: Gabrielle Meyer

4.48

Format: 416 pages, Paperback

Maggie inherited a gift from her time-crossing parents that allows her to live three separate lives… read more

Similar categories in Gabrielle Meyer's In This Moment (Timeless, #2) book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Count the Nights by Stars by Michelle Shocklee

9. Count the Nights by Stars

By: Michelle Shocklee

4.24

Format: 432 pages, Paperback

A 2023 Christianity Today Book of the Year Award-winner! Count your nights by stars, not shadows… read more

Similar categories in Michelle Shocklee's Count the Nights by Stars book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
Cover of Loyally, Luke by Pepper Basham

10. Loyally, Luke

By: Pepper Basham

4.07

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

Sometimes love means embracing the good, the bad . . . and even the impossible. Dear Reader, … read more

Similar categories in Pepper Basham's Loyally, Luke book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
Cover of All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2) by Nicole Deese

11. All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2)

By: Nicole Deese

4.46

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

When the ever-cautious Val Locklier moves cross-country with her son for a secure job, everything s… read more

Similar categories in Nicole Deese's All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2) book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
"Nothing is easy without practice."

-Nicole Deese, All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2)

"Listen. Feel. Create. Always in that order."

-Nicole Deese, All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2)

"Of all the curveballs I'd been thrown, Val was the one I'd reach to catch over and over again."

-Nicole Deese, All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2)

"I'd much rather my life be defined by a thousand little moments of faithfulness than by one big moment of fame."

-Nicole Deese, All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2)

Cover of Where the Blue Sky Begins by Katie Powner

12. Where the Blue Sky Begins

By: Katie Powner

4.31

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

*2023 Christy Award winner and Selah Award finalist* Sometimes the hardest road of all is the ro… read more

Similar categories in Katie Powner's Where the Blue Sky Begins book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
Cover of The Divine Proverb of Streusel by Sara Brunsvold

13. The Divine Proverb of Streusel

By: Sara Brunsvold

4.29

Format: 324 pages, Paperback

Shaken by her parents' divorce and discouraged by the growing chasm between herself and her serious… read more

Similar categories in Sara Brunsvold's The Divine Proverb of Streusel book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of When the Day Comes (Timeless, #1) by Gabrielle  Meyer

14. When the Day Comes (Timeless, #1)

By: Gabrielle Meyer

4.39

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

How will she choose, knowing all she must sacrifice? Libby has been given a powerful gift: to l… read more

Similar categories in Gabrielle Meyer's When the Day Comes (Timeless, #1) book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"Only God is in control of our destiny. He alone is sovereign. When we try to control the people and events around us we are telling Him He doesn't know what's best for us. We're setting ourselves up …"

-Gabrielle Meyer, When the Day Comes (Timeless, #1)

"And what about faith? Hadn't Mama taught me that God is a good and faithful father, that He knew the plans He had for me, and they were plans to proper me and not to harm me? If she had lived through…"

-Gabrielle Meyer, When the Day Comes (Timeless, #1)

Cover of Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2) by Michelle Griep

15. Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2)

By: Michelle Griep

4.43

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

“The world seems full of good men—even if there are monsters in it.” –Bram Stoker, Dracula Eng… read more

Similar categories in Michelle Griep's Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2) book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • gothic
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
"People need you and you need people. That’s the way of humankind."

-Michelle Griep, Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2)

"Man is not meant to find hope in anything of this world, but rather to lose hope in all things worldly."

-Michelle Griep, Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2)

"God brings people into our lives to walk beside us through our troubles, yet we are the ones who must open the door and let them in."

-Michelle Griep, Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2)

"God is not so limited that He cannot act outside the boundaries of physical law, for it is He alone who decides where those boundaries lie."

-Michelle Griep, Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2)

Cover of Positively, Penelope (Skymar, #2) by Pepper Basham

16. Positively, Penelope (Skymar, #2)

By: Pepper Basham

4.21

Format: 396 pages, Paperback

Told mostly through letters, texts, and email, this contemporary romance will charm its way into he… read more

Similar categories in Pepper Basham's Positively, Penelope (Skymar, #2) book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
"But don’t let all those big dreams in your head stop you from seeing that sometimes the best adventures can still be in the simplest things. Like home and family."

-Pepper Basham, Positively, Penelope (Skymar, #2)

"He’d never met anyone who wore sunshine quite like Penelope Edgewood. At first, it had been too much. Too overpowering and seemingly inauthentic, but then, over the weeks, her vibrancy melded into th…"

-Pepper Basham, Positively, Penelope (Skymar, #2)

Cover of Fatal Code (The SNAP Agency #2) by Natalie Walters

17. Fatal Code (The SNAP Agency #2)

By: Natalie Walters

4.46

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

In 1964, a group of scientists called the Los Alamos Five came close to finishing a nuclear energy … read more

Similar categories in Natalie Walters's Fatal Code (The SNAP Agency #2) book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
"Only in our weakness will we see God come through for us. It requires us to stake everything... on our faith in God."

-Natalie Walters, Fatal Code (The SNAP Agency #2)

Cover of A Lady's Guide to Marvels and Misadventure by Angela   Bell

18. A Lady's Guide to Marvels and Misadventure

By: Angela Bell

4.02

Format: 379 pages, Kindle Edition

Miss Clara Marie Stanton's family may be eccentric, but they certainly aren't insane. London, En… read more

Similar categories in Angela Bell's A Lady's Guide to Marvels and Misadventure book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"You are "

-Angela Bell, A Lady's Guide to Marvels and Misadventure

"You are a maker. Not the Maker."

-Angela Bell, A Lady's Guide to Marvels and Misadventure

"Dearest Clara, I would rather be absurd with you than normal with anyone else."

-Angela Bell, A Lady's Guide to Marvels and Misadventure

"Heaven knows you're precious and worth protecting even when men don't, and heaven will defend you even when men fail."

-Angela Bell, A Lady's Guide to Marvels and Misadventure

Cover of The Songs That Could Have Been by Amanda Wen

19. The Songs That Could Have Been

By: Amanda Wen

4.46

Format: 272 pages, Paperback

Two couples in love. Two sets of impossible circumstances. One powerful God of grace. After a tail… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Wen's The Songs That Could Have Been book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Born of Gilded Mountains by Amanda Dykes

20. Born of Gilded Mountains

By: Amanda Dykes

4.42

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

When newcomer Mercy Windsor arrives in Mercy Peak in 1948 after a scandal shatters her gilded world… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Dykes's Born of Gilded Mountains book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
"Spatts is strong. - Rusty"

-Amanda Dykes, Born of Gilded Mountains

"I sometimes think, when our dreams seem impossible to us, perhaps we just haven't seen yet how God will chase after our hearts with those very dreams, in the unlikeliest ways."

-Amanda Dykes, Born of Gilded Mountains

"Sunsets here were more an experience than a sight. They marked the soul. Pierced it, rearranged things with all that shifting color and light, and sealed it up again, a little more whole than it was …"

-Amanda Dykes, Born of Gilded Mountains

"On a stage of earth, beneath a canopy of stars, with a score of scattered laughter, Mercy watched a story unfold more enchanting than any the Dream Factory of Hollywood could have produced. Even the …"

-Amanda Dykes, Born of Gilded Mountains

Cover of Shadows in the Mind's Eye by Janyre Tromp

21. Shadows in the Mind's Eye

By: Janyre Tromp

4.26

Format: 288 pages, Paperback

Charlotte Anne Mattas longs to turn back the clock. Before her husband, Sam, went to serve his coun… read more

Similar categories in Janyre Tromp's Shadows in the Mind's Eye book and Jaime Jo Wright's The Souls of Lost Lake

  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
"Ain't no light that can get through something solid. It sneaks through the broken places."

-Janyre Tromp, Shadows in the Mind's Eye

"Sometimes you gots to choose what you see. And sometimes God uses broken things to save us."

-Janyre Tromp, Shadows in the Mind's Eye

"You'd think holding joy right up against sadness would shatter a body. But it don't. Joy...it sneaks in all around where things is broke, sticks it all together and finds a way to make you whole. It'…"

-Janyre Tromp, Shadows in the Mind's Eye

"We think everything eventually goes back to what we want it to be. That everything'll be happy and familiar, the good winning. We never want to travel beyond the point where everybody's happy. But li…"

-Janyre Tromp, Shadows in the Mind's Eye

21 must-read fiction books like The Souls of Lost Lake by Jaime Jo Wright

Transform Your Habits

For a Lifetime (Timeless, #3)

Gabrielle Meyer

4.55

Transform Your Habits

A Million Little Choices

Tamera Alexander

4.44

Transform Your Habits

The Extraordinary Deaths of Mrs. Kip

Sara Brunsvold

4.37

Transform Your Habits

Free Fall (The Quantico Files, #3)

Nancy Mehl

4.36

View all the books

21 Top fiction books like Where the Blue Sky Begins by Katie Powner

Transform Your Habits

The Roads We Follow (Fog Harbor, #2)

Nicole Deese

4.39

Transform Your Habits

Within These Walls of Sorrow: A Novel of World War II Poland

Amanda Barratt

4.73

Transform Your Habits

A Million Little Choices

Tamera Alexander

4.44

Transform Your Habits

The Extraordinary Deaths of Mrs. Kip

Sara Brunsvold

4.37

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.