15 must-read high school books like Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2) by Sarah Sutton

Cover of Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2) by Sarah   Sutton

Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

By: Sarah Sutton

3.79

Format: 326 pages, Paperback

FAKE DATING THE CAPTAIN OF THE BASEBALL TEAM IS ALL FUN AND GAMES UNTIL SOMEONE CATCHES FEELINGS. …

If you liked the high school plot in Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2) by Sarah Sutton , here is a list of 15 books like this:

Cover of The Importance of Getting Revenge by Amanda Abram

1. The Importance of Getting Revenge

By: Amanda Abram

3.92

Format: 302 pages, Kindle Edition

Seventeen-year-old Lexi Turner has just been dumped by her boyfriend of three years—on the day she … read more

Similar categories in Amanda Abram's The Importance of Getting Revenge book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
"What are you thinking about?"

-Amanda Abram, The Importance of Getting Revenge

"I was wondering if I could talk to you?"

-Amanda Abram, The Importance of Getting Revenge

"Can we get this makeup thing over before we’re late for school?"

-Amanda Abram, The Importance of Getting Revenge

"I hit him playfully on the shoulder. “You make me sound like such a pig."

-Amanda Abram, The Importance of Getting Revenge

2. Curveball (Barlow Sisters Book 1)

By: Jordan Ford

4.33

Format: 201 pages,

Mystery and romance weave together in a set of fast-paced, sports romance novels. Follow the Barlow… read more

Similar categories in Jordan Ford's Curveball (Barlow Sisters Book 1) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

Cover of Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2) by Sarah   Sutton

3. Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

By: Sarah Sutton

3.79

Format: 326 pages, Paperback

FAKE DATING THE CAPTAIN OF THE BASEBALL TEAM IS ALL FUN AND GAMES UNTIL SOMEONE CATCHES FEELINGS. … read more

Similar categories in Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • baseball
  • young adult romance
  • young adult contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of Hate Notes (Lakeview Prep #1) by Gracie Graham

4. Hate Notes (Lakeview Prep #1)

By: Gracie Graham

3.70

Format: 246 pages, Kindle Edition

Topher Elliot is high school royalty. The king of Lakeview prep. You know the type. Disgustin… read more

Similar categories in Gracie Graham's Hate Notes (Lakeview Prep #1) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • sports
Cover of Challenge Accepted by Amanda Abram

5. Challenge Accepted

By: Amanda Abram

4.03

Format: 392 pages, Kindle Edition

Emma Dawson and Logan Reynolds have been neighbors and enemies for as long as either one can rememb… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Abram's Challenge Accepted book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of A Whole New League (Briarwood High, #2) by Maggie Dallen

6. A Whole New League (Briarwood High, #2)

By: Maggie Dallen

3.80

Format: 149 pages, Kindle Edition

The star quarterback dating a theater geek like me? As if anyone would believe that. If Brian Kirk… read more

Similar categories in Maggie Dallen's A Whole New League (Briarwood High, #2) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of The Dating Dare by A.R. Perry

7. The Dating Dare

By: A.R. Perry

3.71

Format: 192 pages, Kindle Edition

No one gets under Lily Holladay’s skin quicker than her ex-best friend Parker Hayes. Popular and co… read more

Similar categories in A.R. Perry's The Dating Dare book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Only Boy Off Limits (Hallisburg Prep #3) by Emily Lowry

8. The Only Boy Off Limits (Hallisburg Prep #3)

By: Emily Lowry

4.13

Format: 221 pages, Kindle Edition

Get ready for Hallisburg Prep Book 3, Cruz and Avery's story, coming in 2022. read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's The Only Boy Off Limits (Hallisburg Prep #3) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • young adult
Cover of Chase Jones Is My Fake Boyfriend (Rumors and Lies at Evermore High #1) by Emily Lowry

9. Chase Jones Is My Fake Boyfriend (Rumors and Lies at Evermore High #1)

By: Emily Lowry

3.95

Format: 214 pages, Kindle Edition

The All-Star Quarterback. A Fake Relationship. A Sweet and Unexpected Love. Abby Murrow is an in… read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's Chase Jones Is My Fake Boyfriend (Rumors and Lies at Evermore High #1) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
Cover of Something New by Amanda Abram

10. Something New

By: Amanda Abram

4.00

Format: 394 pages, Kindle Edition

Cassie Briggs never thought she’d be married at age sixteen—especially not to Dylan Meyers, her boy… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Abram's Something New book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Fake Notes (Lakeview Prep #2) by Gracie Graham

11. Fake Notes (Lakeview Prep #2)

By: Gracie Graham

4.03

Format: 272 pages, Kindle Edition

Thorne Roberts is a Hollywood Adonis. America's teen heartthrob. Just another raven-haired, s… read more

Similar categories in Gracie Graham's Fake Notes (Lakeview Prep #2) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Love Notes (Lakeview Prep #4) by Gracie Graham

12. Love Notes (Lakeview Prep #4)

By: Gracie Graham

3.87

Format: 235 pages, Kindle Edition

Spending time with my nemesis never felt so good. Carson Brooks has been my enemy since the day … read more

Similar categories in Gracie Graham's Love Notes (Lakeview Prep #4) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Boy I Love to Hate (Hallisburg Prep #1) by Emily Lowry

13. The Boy I Love to Hate (Hallisburg Prep #1)

By: Emily Lowry

3.94

Format: 246 pages, Kindle Edition

Everyone at Hallisburg Prep worships the ground Sutton Reilly walks on. Everyone except me. I ha… read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's The Boy I Love to Hate (Hallisburg Prep #1) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
Cover of The Quarterback Can Kiss: A Sweet YA High School Romance (Glenwood Academy Book 1) by Charli Dixon

14. The Quarterback Can Kiss: A Sweet YA High School Romance (Glenwood Academy Book 1)

By: Charli Dixon

3.62

Format: 226 pages, Kindle Edition

Rule no.1 at Glenwood: Nerds don’t date quarterbacks, especially when they’re your best friend’s br… read more

Similar categories in Charli Dixon's The Quarterback Can Kiss: A Sweet YA High School Romance (Glenwood Academy Book 1) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • sports romance
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
Cover of The Shy Girl & the Jock Next Door (Jackson High #4) by M.L. Collins

15. The Shy Girl & the Jock Next Door (Jackson High #4)

By: M.L. Collins

4.20

Format: 232 pages, Kindle Edition

Shay MacNeil One girl, hiding her scars, ready to escape the stares & whispers of her small town. … read more

Similar categories in M.L. Collins's The Shy Girl & the Jock Next Door (Jackson High #4) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of The Boy Who Steals Hearts (Hallisburg Prep #2) by Emily Lowry

16. The Boy Who Steals Hearts (Hallisburg Prep #2)

By: Emily Lowry

4.24

Format: 252 pages, Kindle Edition

Every girl at Hallisburg Prep has a crush on Arie Jensen. But no one has a bigger crush than me.… read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's The Boy Who Steals Hearts (Hallisburg Prep #2) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Faking What's Real (Haven Valley High #1) by Kenzie Brayne

17. Faking What's Real (Haven Valley High #1)

By: Kenzie Brayne

3.87

Format: 264 pages, Kindle Edition

It was only meant to be one fake date. Emma Caught up in my impulsive friend’s bet, I’m pushe… read more

Similar categories in Kenzie Brayne's Faking What's Real (Haven Valley High #1) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Loving Gavin by Pixie Perkins

18. Loving Gavin

By: Pixie Perkins

4.06

Format: 366 pages, Kindle Edition

How far would you go to keep your crush a secret? Mckessey Owens is in love with Gavin Miller (a… read more

Similar categories in Pixie Perkins's Loving Gavin book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
Cover of Dear Marley (Love Notes #7) by Danielle Keil

19. Dear Marley (Love Notes #7)

By: Danielle Keil

4.01

Format: 154 pages, Kindle Edition

Everyone at Ryder High knows what it means to have a teal envelope taped to their locker on the fir… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Keil's Dear Marley (Love Notes #7) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of My Fake Relationship With the Popular Boy (Bayshore Academy, #1) by Clara Nielsen

20. My Fake Relationship With the Popular Boy (Bayshore Academy, #1)

By: Clara Nielsen

3.83

Format: 330 pages, Paperback

WHO’S THE BEST PERSON TO FAKE DATE? THE ONE YOU KNOW YOU WILL NEVER FALL FOR… I feel like my l… read more

Similar categories in Clara Nielsen's My Fake Relationship With the Popular Boy (Bayshore Academy, #1) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • high school
  • young adult
Cover of Shy Girls Can't Date Billionaires (Shy Girls Sweet Romances) by Milly Rose

21. Shy Girls Can't Date Billionaires (Shy Girls Sweet Romances)

By: Milly Rose

3.37

Format: 286 pages, Kindle Edition

He could have any girl, so why does he look at me? After a fire destroys our home, a billionaire… read more

Similar categories in Milly Rose's Shy Girls Can't Date Billionaires (Shy Girls Sweet Romances) book and Sarah Sutton's Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance

16 Top contemporary books like Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2) by Sarah Sutton

Transform Your Habits

The Importance of Getting Revenge

Amanda Abram

3.92

Transform Your Habits

Out of My League (Love in Fenton County, #2)

Sarah Sutton

3.79

Transform Your Habits

Hate Notes (Lakeview Prep #1)

Gracie Graham

3.70

Transform Your Habits

Challenge Accepted

Amanda Abram

4.03

View all the books

10 must-read fiction books like The Dating Dare by A.R. Perry

Transform Your Habits

The Importance of Getting Revenge

Amanda Abram

3.92

Transform Your Habits

Dreaming About the Boy Next Door (Most Likely To #2)

Sarah Sutton

4.15

Transform Your Habits

The Wrong Bachelor: An Enemies-to-Lovers YA Romantic Comedy (The Wrong Match Book 1)

Alexandra Moody

3.81

Transform Your Habits

Challenge Accepted

Amanda Abram

4.03

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.