5 Best horror books like I Am Not Who You Think I Am by Eric Rickstad

I Am Not Who You Think I Am

By: Eric Rickstad

3.53

Format: 229 pages, Hardcover

One secret. Eight cryptic words. Lifetimes of ruin. Wayland Maynard is just eight years old when…

If you liked the horror plot in I Am Not Who You Think I Am by Eric Rickstad , here is a list of 5 books like this:

1. Blood Will Tell

By: Heather Chavez

3.48

Format: 400 pages, Hardcover

From the author of the acclaimed debut No Bad Deed, a twisty novel about the bond between two siste… read more

Similar categories in Heather Chavez's Blood Will Tell book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
suspense
fiction
horror
mystery
thriller
adult
audiobook

2. She's Not Sorry

By: Mary Kubica

3.81

Format: 330 pages, Hardcover

An ICU nurse accidentally uncovers a patient’s frightening past in this chilling thriller. Megha… read more

Similar categories in Mary Kubica's She's Not Sorry book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
adult
audiobook

3. Long Time Gone

By: Charlie Donlea

4.21

Format: 344 pages, Hardcover

When DNA results reveal a disturbing connection to the mysterious disappearance of a famous baby ne… read more

Similar categories in Charlie Donlea's Long Time Gone book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

"Procrastination is the devil's way of stealing your time."
-Charlie Donlea, Long Time Gone

4. Everyone Is Watching

By: Heather Gudenkauf

3.65

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

The Best Friend. The Confidant. The Senator. The Boyfriend. The Executive. Five contestants hav… read more

Similar categories in Heather Gudenkauf's Everyone Is Watching book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

5. The New Couple in 5B

By: Lisa Unger

3.63

Format: 382 pages, Hardcover

A couple inherits an apartment with a spine-tingling past in this binge-worthy thriller from the Ne… read more

Similar categories in Lisa Unger's The New Couple in 5B book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
suspense
fiction
horror
mystery
thriller
adult
audiobook

"We're always drawn back to our family of origin, aren't we? No matter how much pain they've caused, no matter how far we've run from them."
-Lisa Unger, The New Couple in 5B
"I remember wondering if anything was real, anything was true or if every place, every reality, was just another story you choose to believe."
-Lisa Unger, The New Couple in 5B

6. I Am Not Who You Think I Am

By: Eric Rickstad

3.53

Format: 229 pages, Hardcover

One secret. Eight cryptic words. Lifetimes of ruin. Wayland Maynard is just eight years old when… read more

Similar categories in Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
murder mystery
mystery
thriller
horror
crime
audiobook

7. If Something Happens to Me

By: Alex Finlay

3.79

Format: 324 pages, Hardcover

For the past five years, Ryan Richardson has relived that terrible night. The car door ripping open… read more

Similar categories in Alex Finlay's If Something Happens to Me book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

8. One Perfect Couple

By: Ruth Ware

3.68

Format: 385 pages, Hardcover

Runtime: 14 hours and 9 minutes Harkening to Agatha Christie’s classic And Then There Were None… read more

Similar categories in Ruth Ware's One Perfect Couple book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
adult
audiobook

9. End of Story

By: A.J. Finn

3.10

Format: 408 pages, Hardcover

“I’ll be dead in three months. Come tell my story.” So writes Sebastian Trapp, reclusive mystery… read more

Similar categories in A.J. Finn's End of Story book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

10. What Have We Done

By: Alex Finlay

3.54

Format: 358 pages, Hardcover

In this thriller from Alex Finlay, What Have We Done is a tale about the lives we leave behind and … read more

Similar categories in Alex Finlay's What Have We Done book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
horror
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

11. Fire Exit

By: Morgan Talty

3.79

Format: 243 pages, Hardcover

The blood that came out of me was blood that ran through her veins. It’s strange: all blood looks t… read more

Similar categories in Morgan Talty's Fire Exit book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery
adult
fiction
audiobook

"...what's more sacred than laughter at the dinner table?"
-Morgan Talty, Fire Exit
"That's my life, though--not knowing, but wishing. [Charles Lamosway]"
-Morgan Talty, Fire Exit
"We are made of stories, and if we don't know them--the ones that make us--how can we ever be fully realized? How can we ever be who we really are?"
-Morgan Talty, Fire Exit
"...I was thinking and thinking about how, in just the past year, I had just started to know her, but then I began to unknow her, getting farther and farther away like watching a boat drift from the s…"
-Morgan Talty, Fire Exit

12. Nine Lives

By: Peter Swanson

3.56

Format: 320 pages, Hardcover

Nine strangers receive a list with their names on it in the mail. Nothing else, just a list of name… read more

Similar categories in Peter Swanson's Nine Lives book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

"Just because my boot was tapping didn't mean I liked the song"
-Peter Swanson, Nine Lives

13. The Long Weekend

By: Gilly Macmillan

3.46

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

Three couples. Two bodies. One secret. Dark Fell Barn is a “perfectly isolated” retreat, or so s… read more

Similar categories in Gilly Macmillan's The Long Weekend book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

14. Murder Road

By: Simone St. James

3.72

Format: 341 pages, Hardcover

A young couple find themselves haunted by a string of gruesome murders committed along an old deser… read more

Similar categories in Simone St. James's Murder Road book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
suspense
fiction
horror
mystery
thriller
adult
audiobook

15. Find Me (Ellie Hatcher, #6)

By: Alafair Burke

3.59

Format: 293 pages, Hardcover

Find Me by Carol OConnell . Penguin Group (USA) Inc.,2007 read more

Similar categories in Alafair Burke's Find Me (Ellie Hatcher, #6) book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

16. A Talent for Murder (Henry Kimball/Lily Kintner, #3)

By: Peter Swanson

3.61

Format: 255 pages, Hardcover

A newlywed librarian begins to suspect the man she married might be a murderer—in this spectacularl… read more

Similar categories in Peter Swanson's A Talent for Murder (Henry Kimball/Lily Kintner, #3) book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

17. 56 Days

By: Catherine Ryan Howard

3.75

Format: 305 pages, Hardcover

No one knew they'd moved in together. Now one of them is dead. Could this be the perfect murder? … read more

Similar categories in Catherine Ryan Howard's 56 Days book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

"Dividing people into good and evil is just lazy."
-Catherine Ryan Howard, 56 Days
"Secrets are a different thing. They're destructive."
-Catherine Ryan Howard, 56 Days
"None of us know what we're capable of, if the circumstances were right. Or wrong."
-Catherine Ryan Howard, 56 Days
"Our robot overlords are coming regardless, but I'm not going to hold the door open for them."
-Catherine Ryan Howard, 56 Days

18. Sleeping Giants

By: Rene Denfeld

4.03

Format: 293 pages, Hardcover

From the bestselling author of The Child Finder and The Enchanted, a compelling and poignant story … read more

Similar categories in Rene Denfeld's Sleeping Giants book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

19. Reboot

By: Justin Taylor

3.06

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

A raucous and wickedly smart satire of Hollywood, toxic fandom, and our chronically online culture,… read more

Similar categories in Justin Taylor's Reboot book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

fiction
audiobook

20. The Temple House Vanishing

By: Rachel Donohue

3.39

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

The New York Times Best Thrillers of 2021 "Steamily atmospheric . . . A twisted Gothic tale, emoti… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Donohue's The Temple House Vanishing book and Eric Rickstad's I Am Not Who You Think I Am

mystery thriller
adult
suspense
fiction
mystery
thriller
crime
audiobook

"To create art is to go on a journey inwards. You can have the potential to find and express what you discover on this journey, regardless of the external circumstances in which you may find yourself."
-Rachel Donohue, The Temple House Vanishing

21. Exit Strategy (2) (The Endings Series)

By: Linda L. Richards