14 best-selling mystery books like It Should Have Been Me by Susan Wilkins

Cover of It Should Have Been Me by Susan  Wilkins

It Should Have Been Me

By: Susan Wilkins

3.99

Format: 434 pages, Paperback

A Prequel to The Detective Jo Boden Case Files – an updated new edition for 2023. A murdered sis…

If you liked the mystery plot in It Should Have Been Me by Susan Wilkins , here is a list of 14 books like this:

1. Cold Case (DI Sally Parker Thriller #3)

By: M.A. Comley

3.86

Format: None pages,

DI Sally Parker has been handed a ten-year-old cold case. However, the victim, Aisha Thomas, isn't … read more

Similar categories in M.A. Comley's Cold Case (DI Sally Parker Thriller #3) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

2. Locked Away: A DCI Alice Candy case

By: B.A. Spicer

3.26

Format: None pages,

A young woman wakes to find herself in darkness, lying on bare earth with her mouth taped and her h… read more

Similar categories in B.A. Spicer's Locked Away: A DCI Alice Candy case book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

Cover of It Should Have Been Me by Susan  Wilkins

3. It Should Have Been Me

By: Susan Wilkins

3.99

Format: 434 pages, Paperback

A Prequel to The Detective Jo Boden Case Files – an updated new edition for 2023. A murdered sis… read more

Similar categories in Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
  • audiobook
Cover of Abused (A Casey Cort Legal Thriller Book 10) by Aime Austin

4. Abused (A Casey Cort Legal Thriller Book 10)

By: Aime Austin

4.15

Format: 343 pages, Kindle Edition

He said, she said. He’s dead. Nicole Long is one failed breathalyzer away from unemployment. The… read more

Similar categories in Aime Austin's Abused (A Casey Cort Legal Thriller Book 10) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Say My Name by Joe Clifford

5. Say My Name

By: Joe Clifford

3.59

Format: 266 pages, Kindle Edition

SAY MY NAME is a true-crime story about a crime that never happened—or did it? On the heels of a… read more

Similar categories in Joe Clifford's Say My Name book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery
  • crime
  • fiction
Cover of One Cold Heart: A Detective Max Grady Thriller (Detective Max Grady Thrillers Book 2) by K.J. Kalis

6. One Cold Heart: A Detective Max Grady Thriller (Detective Max Grady Thrillers Book 2)

By: K.J. Kalis

4.42

Format: 332 pages, Kindle Edition

A routine visit to Grady’s hospitalized lieutenant turns into something unimaginable…A bitter man –… read more

Similar categories in K.J. Kalis's One Cold Heart: A Detective Max Grady Thriller (Detective Max Grady Thrillers Book 2) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of The Art Merchant (Detective Esther Penman #1) by J.K. Flynn

7. The Art Merchant (Detective Esther Penman #1)

By: J.K. Flynn

4.27

Format: 285 pages, Kindle Edition

Some pictures are not so pretty... Detective Sergeant Esther Penman is a bit of a mess. She dri… read more

Similar categories in J.K. Flynn's The Art Merchant (Detective Esther Penman #1) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery
  • crime
  • fiction
Cover of Blinding Lies by Amy Cronin

8. Blinding Lies

By: Amy Cronin

4.33

Format: 400 pages, Kindle Edition

In a web of lies, who can you trust? Ten years ago, Anna Clarke’s parents disappeared. The myste… read more

Similar categories in Amy Cronin's Blinding Lies book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of An Early Grave (DI Tara Grogan, #1) by Robert  McCracken

9. An Early Grave (DI Tara Grogan, #1)

By: Robert McCracken

4.09

Format: 259 pages, Kindle Edition

During the investigation into the death of a woman on a Liverpool housing estate, DI Tara Grogan en… read more

Similar categories in Robert McCracken's An Early Grave (DI Tara Grogan, #1) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery
  • crime
  • fiction
Cover of The Silent Quarry (DI Winter Meadows, #1) by Cheryl Rees-Price

10. The Silent Quarry (DI Winter Meadows, #1)

By: Cheryl Rees-Price

4.37

Format: 261 pages, Kindle Edition

The Silent Quarry is the first in the DI Winter Meadows series by Cheryl Rees-Price. In 1987 a quie… read more

Similar categories in Cheryl Rees-Price's The Silent Quarry (DI Winter Meadows, #1) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
  • audiobook
Cover of Eden: A Novel by W. A. Schwartz

11. Eden: A Novel

By: W. A. Schwartz

4.05

Format: 423 pages, Kindle Edition

"Intriguing lead characters strengthen this engaging Southern murder mystery." –Kirkus Reviews On … read more

Similar categories in W. A. Schwartz's Eden: A Novel book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Evil for Evil: (Mimi Goldman Chautauqua Mysteries, #10) by Deb Pines

12. Evil for Evil: (Mimi Goldman Chautauqua Mysteries, #10)

By: Deb Pines

3.95

Format: 238 pages, Kindle Edition

Evil for Evil is the tenth book in Deb Pines' traditional whodunit Chautauqua Mysteries featuring t… read more

Similar categories in Deb Pines's Evil for Evil: (Mimi Goldman Chautauqua Mysteries, #10) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery
Cover of For You by Mike McCrary

13. For You

By: Mike McCrary

3.90

Format: 220 pages, Kindle Edition

He confessed to killing three people. He said he did it… for you. Hannah Rush waited too long to… read more

Similar categories in Mike McCrary's For You book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Of Body and Bone (Detectives Daniels and Remalla #3) by J.T. Bishop

14. Of Body and Bone (Detectives Daniels and Remalla #3)

By: J.T. Bishop

4.19

Format: 343 pages, Kindle Edition

A kidnapper strikes again, but his evil ties to a killer reveal a dangerous threat. After a shocki… read more

Similar categories in J.T. Bishop's Of Body and Bone (Detectives Daniels and Remalla #3) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
Cover of The Nanny's Secret by S.L. Harker

15. The Nanny's Secret

By: S.L. Harker

3.96

Format: 205 pages, Kindle Edition

She's in your home. And she's lying to you... When Imogen hires the immaculate Holly Goodwin as … read more

Similar categories in S.L. Harker's The Nanny's Secret book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery thriller
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Six Sisters (Double Blind #6) by Dan Alatorre

16. Six Sisters (Double Blind #6)

By: Dan Alatorre

4.17

Format: 471 pages, Kindle Edition

A young woman disappears and is feared dead, potentially murdered by her abusive husband - a handso… read more

Similar categories in Dan Alatorre's Six Sisters (Double Blind #6) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Little Broken Things (Georgiana Germaine #3) by Cheryl Bradshaw

17. Little Broken Things (Georgiana Germaine #3)

By: Cheryl Bradshaw

4.40

Format: 258 pages, Kindle Edition

Detective Georgiana Germaine is back on the trail of a cold-blooded killer, and once again, the cas… read more

Similar categories in Cheryl Bradshaw's Little Broken Things (Georgiana Germaine #3) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of The First Cut (Doctors of Darkness, #3) by Ellery A. Kane

18. The First Cut (Doctors of Darkness, #3)

By: Ellery A. Kane

4.17

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

There’s a thin line between love and murder. When “Love Doctors” Ian and Kate Culpepper are brut… read more

Similar categories in Ellery A. Kane's The First Cut (Doctors of Darkness, #3) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
  • audiobook
" Dear Ava, I know you hate this sort of thing, so I'll be brief. Today is not your favorite day. It's cursed apparently, for good reason. But if you let me, I promise to change that. I'll make every …"

-Ellery A. Kane, The First Cut (Doctors of Darkness, #3)

"Ava rolled onto her side to get a better view of Luke. He stood at the dresser, his back to her, his lower half wrapped in a towel. The only light came from the cracked bathroom door, a thin spotligh…"

-Ellery A. Kane, The First Cut (Doctors of Darkness, #3)

"I'm glad you're having one too," I say. "At least I can be sure your mom didn't poison it. She must really hate me. Especially now." Luke rolls his eyes and groans at me. "She doesn't hate you. But s…"

-Ellery A. Kane, The First Cut (Doctors of Darkness, #3)

Cover of The Newlywed (The Cold Case Mysteries #3) by Anna Willett

19. The Newlywed (The Cold Case Mysteries #3)

By: Anna Willett

4.31

Format: 250 pages, Kindle Edition

Detectives dig deep to discover what happened to a lost bride After travelling to the breezy sea… read more

Similar categories in Anna Willett's The Newlywed (The Cold Case Mysteries #3) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
  • fiction
Cover of Forest Park (Logan McKenna #2) by Valerie Davisson

20. Forest Park (Logan McKenna #2)

By: Valerie Davisson

4.12

Format: 300 pages, Kindle Edition

There’s a killer on the loose in Portland and no one is safe. Blocked at every turn, newly widowed … read more

Similar categories in Valerie Davisson's Forest Park (Logan McKenna #2) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
  • fiction
Cover of Into the Red (The Murder Mile #1) by Christine Pattle

21. Into the Red (The Murder Mile #1)

By: Christine Pattle

3.97

Format: 216 pages, Kindle Edition

When the going gets tough, she can give up… or fight for her life. When Rose Marsden takes a job… read more

Similar categories in Christine Pattle's Into the Red (The Murder Mile #1) book and Susan Wilkins's It Should Have Been Me

  • fiction

8 Best mystery thriller books like It Should Have Been Me by Susan Wilkins

Transform Your Habits

It Should Have Been Me

Susan Wilkins

3.99

Transform Your Habits

Abused (A Casey Cort Legal Thriller Book 10)

Aime Austin

4.15

Transform Your Habits

Blinding Lies

Amy Cronin

4.33

Transform Your Habits

The Silent Quarry (DI Winter Meadows, #1)

Cheryl Rees-Price

4.37

View all the books

25 best-selling fiction books like Of Body and Bone (Detectives Daniels and Remalla #3) by J.T. Bishop

Transform Your Habits

Trust No One (Mac Davis, #1)

L.J. Breedlove

4.43

Transform Your Habits

No One There (Sofia Blake FBI Suspense Thriller, #1)

Ava Strong

3.95

Transform Your Habits

Once He Longs (Claire King, #2)

Molly Black

4.31

Transform Your Habits

Her Deadly End (Tanya Stone FBI K9 Mystery Thrillers #1)

Tikiri Herath

4.09

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.