7 Top paranormal books like Cryptid Club by Sarah Andersen

Cover of Cryptid Club by Sarah Andersen

Cryptid Club

By: Sarah Andersen

4.27

Format: 112 pages, ebook

Do you hate social gatherings? Dodge cameras? Enjoy staying up just a little too late at night? You…

If you liked the paranormal plot in Cryptid Club by Sarah Andersen , here is a list of 7 books like this:

Cover of Garlic and the Vampire by Bree Paulsen

1. Garlic and the Vampire

By: Bree Paulsen

4.30

Format: 160 pages, Hardcover

A farm-fresh debut graphic novel starring a heroine who is braver than she realizes. Garlic feel… read more

Similar categories in Bree Paulsen's Garlic and the Vampire book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • fiction
  • fantasy
Cover of The Moth Keeper by Kay O'Neill

2. The Moth Keeper

By: Kay O'Neill

4.08

Format: 257 pages, Paperback

Being a Moth Keeper is a huge responsibility and a great honor, but what happens when the new Moth … read more

Similar categories in Kay O'Neill's The Moth Keeper book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • fiction
  • fantasy
Cover of Cryptid Club by Sarah Andersen

3. Cryptid Club

By: Sarah Andersen

4.27

Format: 112 pages, ebook

Do you hate social gatherings? Dodge cameras? Enjoy staying up just a little too late at night? You… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • humor
  • adult
  • comics
  • fiction
  • horror
  • fantasy
  • supernatural
  • paranormal
Cover of Doughnuts and Doom by Balazs Lorinczi

4. Doughnuts and Doom

By: Balazs Lorinczi

3.69

Format: 136 pages, Paperback

Being a teenage witch—or rock star—is tougher than it looks! But maybe enemies can become friends…o… read more

Similar categories in Balazs Lorinczi's Doughnuts and Doom book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • fantasy
  • fiction
Cover of Unfamiliar, Vol. 2 (Unfamiliar, #2) by Haley Newsome

5. Unfamiliar, Vol. 2 (Unfamiliar, #2)

By: Haley Newsome

4.09

Format: 144 pages, Paperback

Based on the hit webcomic, Unfamiliar Volume 2  continues the exciting witchy adventures of Planche… read more

Similar categories in Haley Newsome's Unfamiliar, Vol. 2 (Unfamiliar, #2) book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • fiction
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Unfamiliar, Vol. 1 (Unfamiliar, #1) by Haley Newsome

6. Unfamiliar, Vol. 1 (Unfamiliar, #1)

By: Haley Newsome

3.94

Format: 160 pages, Paperback

Based on the wildly popular webcomic from Tapas, Unfamiliar is an endearing and whimsical story ful… read more

Similar categories in Haley Newsome's Unfamiliar, Vol. 1 (Unfamiliar, #1) book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • fiction
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Revenge of the Librarians by Tom Gauld

7. Revenge of the Librarians

By: Tom Gauld

3.94

Format: 180 pages, Hardcover

Confront the spectre of failure, the wraith of social media, and other supernatural enemies of the … read more

Similar categories in Tom Gauld's Revenge of the Librarians book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels
  • humor
  • comics
  • fiction
  • adult
Cover of Over My Dead Body: A Witchy Graphic Novel by Sweeney Boo

8. Over My Dead Body: A Witchy Graphic Novel

By: Sweeney Boo

3.87

Format: 240 pages, Hardcover

Fans of Chilling Adventures of Sabrina will love diving into the mysterious and witchy world of awa… read more

Similar categories in Sweeney Boo's Over My Dead Body: A Witchy Graphic Novel book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • fantasy
  • horror
  • paranormal
Cover of Cat's Cafe by Matt Tarpley

9. Cat's Cafe

By: Matt Tarpley

4.39

Format: 168 pages, Paperback

Serving up more than just coffee and tea, Cat’s Café   provides its cast of adorable characters a g… read more

Similar categories in Matt Tarpley's Cat's Cafe book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • humor
  • comics
  • fiction
  • fantasy
Cover of Everything Is OK by Debbie Tung

10. Everything Is OK

By: Debbie Tung

4.31

Format: 189 pages, Paperback

From the bestselling author of Quiet Girl in a Noisy World comes a gently humorous and poignant col… read more

Similar categories in Debbie Tung's Everything Is OK book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • adult
Cover of The United States of Cryptids: A Tour of American Myths and Monsters by J.W. Ocker

11. The United States of Cryptids: A Tour of American Myths and Monsters

By: J.W. Ocker

3.89

Format: 288 pages, Hardcover

Meet the monsters in our midst, from bigfoot to Mothman and beyond! Welcome to the United States… read more

Similar categories in J.W. Ocker's The United States of Cryptids: A Tour of American Myths and Monsters book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • adult
  • paranormal
  • horror
Cover of Hollow by Shannon Watters

12. Hollow

By: Shannon Watters

4.02

Format: 176 pages, Paperback

From Shannon Watters, the co-creator of the bestselling worldwide phenomenon Lumberjanes, and co-wr… read more

Similar categories in Shannon Watters's Hollow book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • fiction
  • horror
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Garlic and the Witch by Bree Paulsen

13. Garlic and the Witch

By: Bree Paulsen

4.36

Format: 160 pages, Hardcover

Bree Paulsen's brave little protagonist, Garlic, is back in this charmingly illustrated standalone … read more

Similar categories in Bree Paulsen's Garlic and the Witch book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • fiction
  • fantasy
Cover of Bad Dreams in the Night by Adam Ellis

14. Bad Dreams in the Night

By: Adam Ellis

4.26

Format: 256 pages, Hardcover

Like a graphic novel version of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark , this collection of original hor… read more

Similar categories in Adam Ellis's Bad Dreams in the Night book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • fiction
  • horror
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of You Are Home (The Catana Comic Collection) by Catana Chetwynd

15. You Are Home (The Catana Comic Collection)

By: Catana Chetwynd

4.54

Format: 128 pages, Hardcover

New York Times bestselling author and creator Catana Chetwynd’s latest collection of comics illustr… read more

Similar categories in Catana Chetwynd's You Are Home (The Catana Comic Collection) book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • humor
  • comics
  • adult
Cover of Why Are You Like This?: An ArtbyMoga Comic Collection by Meg  Adams

16. Why Are You Like This?: An ArtbyMoga Comic Collection

By: Meg Adams

4.22

Format: 176 pages, Paperback

A collection of comics with a millennial take on marriage, adulthood, pet ownership, self-love, and… read more

Similar categories in Meg Adams's Why Are You Like This?: An ArtbyMoga Comic Collection book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • humor
  • comics
  • adult
Cover of One Cup at a Time: A Cat's Café Collection (Cat's Café) by Matt Tarpley

17. One Cup at a Time: A Cat's Café Collection (Cat's Café)

By: Matt Tarpley

4.42

Format: 160 pages, Paperback

Serving up another steaming hot cup of the warm and floofies, this new collection follows your favo… read more

Similar categories in Matt Tarpley's One Cup at a Time: A Cat's Café Collection (Cat's Café) book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • humor
  • comics
  • fiction
  • adult
  • fantasy
Cover of Sorry I Ruined Your Childhood: Berkeley Mews Comics (Volume 1) by Ben Zaehringer

18. Sorry I Ruined Your Childhood: Berkeley Mews Comics (Volume 1)

By: Ben Zaehringer

3.99

Format: 144 pages, Paperback

Berkeley Mews' appealing, accessible art style belies a cartoon world of dark humor, dry wit, and i… read more

Similar categories in Ben Zaehringer's Sorry I Ruined Your Childhood: Berkeley Mews Comics (Volume 1) book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • humor
  • comics
  • fiction
  • adult
Cover of Mr. Lovenstein Presents Failure by J.L. Westover

19. Mr. Lovenstein Presents Failure

By: J.L. Westover

4.13

Format: 248 pages, None

Celebrate Failure Comics for anyone who tried their best. Or didn't. Whatever. In his (incred… read more

Similar categories in J.L. Westover's Mr. Lovenstein Presents Failure book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • humor
  • comics
  • fiction
  • adult
Cover of Twistwood Tales by A.C. Macdonald

20. Twistwood Tales

By: A.C. Macdonald

4.35

Format: 160 pages, Hardcover

Come and join Bucket Boy and the whole Twistwood gang as they live their lives in the forest. Trave… read more

Similar categories in A.C. Macdonald's Twistwood Tales book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • humor
  • comics
  • fiction
  • adult
  • fantasy
Cover of Sensory: Life on the Spectrum by Bex Ollerton

21. Sensory: Life on the Spectrum

By: Bex Ollerton

4.27

Format: 176 pages, Paperback

A colorful and eclectic comics anthology exploring a wide range of autistic experiences—from diagno… read more

Similar categories in Bex Ollerton's Sensory: Life on the Spectrum book and Sarah Andersen's Cryptid Club

  • graphic novels comics
  • graphic novels
  • comics
  • adult

15 must-read fiction books like Cryptid Club by Sarah Andersen

Transform Your Habits

Garlic and the Vampire

Bree Paulsen

4.30

Transform Your Habits

The Moth Keeper

Kay O'Neill

4.08

Transform Your Habits

Cryptid Club

Sarah Andersen

4.27

Transform Your Habits

Doughnuts and Doom

Balazs Lorinczi

3.69

View all the books

15 Best fiction books like Bad Dreams in the Night by Adam Ellis

Transform Your Habits

Alley: Junji Ito Story Collection

Junji Ito

4.11

Transform Your Habits

Dwellings

Jay Stephens

4.00

Transform Your Habits

Stitches

Hirokatsu Kihara

3.14

Transform Your Habits

Plain Jane and the Mermaid

Vera Brosgol

4.38

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.