18 Top dark books like Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1) by Pepper Winters

Cover of Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1) by Pepper Winters

Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

By: Pepper Winters

4.06

Format: 261 pages, ebook

“There was a boy once. A boy who wasn’t strong enough to save me when I was taken.” There was a gir…

If you liked the dark plot in Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1) by Pepper Winters , here is a list of 18 books like this:

Cover of Convicted (Consequences, #3) by Aleatha Romig

1. Convicted (Consequences, #3)

By: Aleatha Romig

4.35

Format: 400 pages, ebook

Book #3 of the bestselling Consequences series: From New York Times and USA Today bestselling au… read more

Similar categories in Aleatha Romig's Convicted (Consequences, #3) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • erotica
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • abuse
"Oh, fucking fuckery,"

-Aleatha Romig, Convicted (Consequences, #3)

"I'm not throwing you away! I'm setting you free."

-Aleatha Romig, Convicted (Consequences, #3)

"A wish, a dream, a miracle—Whatever it is, it's real."

-Aleatha Romig, Convicted (Consequences, #3)

"Lifting his head to gently kiss her lips, he whispered, “I trust you."

-Aleatha Romig, Convicted (Consequences, #3)

Cover of Tormentor Mine (Tormentor Mine, #1) by Anna Zaires, Dima Zales

2. Tormentor Mine (Tormentor Mine, #1)

By: Anna Zaires , Dima Zales

3.91

Format: None pages,

A new dark romance from New York Timesbestseller Anna Zaires He came to me in the night, a cruel, d… read more

Similar categories in Anna Zaires's Tormentor Mine (Tormentor Mine, #1) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • erotica
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
Cover of The Penitent (The Sacrifice #2) by Natasha Knight

3. The Penitent (The Sacrifice #2)

By: Natasha Knight

4.20

Format: None pages, None

A cruel fate. Two souls condemned. An impossible love. I knew he’d choose me before he came to o… read more

Similar categories in Natasha Knight's The Penitent (The Sacrifice #2) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • erotica
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of The Tithing (The Sacrifice #1) by Natasha Knight

4. The Tithing (The Sacrifice #1)

By: Natasha Knight

4.15

Format: 322 pages, Paperback

An ancient curse. Two families bound. A forbidden love. When the Wildbloods presented their daug… read more

Similar categories in Natasha Knight's The Tithing (The Sacrifice #1) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • dark
  • suspense
  • contemporary
Cover of Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1) by Pepper Winters

5. Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

By: Pepper Winters

4.06

Format: 261 pages, ebook

“There was a boy once. A boy who wasn’t strong enough to save me when I was taken.” There was a gir… read more

Similar categories in Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • erotica
  • bdsm
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • erotic romance
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • abuse
Cover of Cage of Ice and Echoes (Frozen Fate, #2) by Pam Godwin

6. Cage of Ice and Echoes (Frozen Fate, #2)

By: Pam Godwin

4.60

Format: 407 pages, Kindle Edition

Frankie’s story continues in this second book in the Frozen Fate trilogy by Pam Godwin. Frankie… read more

Similar categories in Pam Godwin's Cage of Ice and Echoes (Frozen Fate, #2) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Remembering Passion (Sinclair Duet, #1) by Aleatha Romig

7. Remembering Passion (Sinclair Duet, #1)

By: Aleatha Romig

4.18

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

Damien Sinclair is a force of nature, the beauty of a sunset over the ocean while capable of devast… read more

Similar categories in Aleatha Romig's Remembering Passion (Sinclair Duet, #1) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • erotica
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Rekindling Desire (Sinclair Duet, #2) by Aleatha Romig

8. Rekindling Desire (Sinclair Duet, #2)

By: Aleatha Romig

4.29

Format: 318 pages, Kindle Edition

In a blink of an eye, the tables turned. I’m Damien Sinclair, a man always in control. I thrive o… read more

Similar categories in Aleatha Romig's Rekindling Desire (Sinclair Duet, #2) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • suspense
  • contemporary
Cover of Because of Her (Jack & Jill, #6) by Jewel E. Ann

9. Because of Her (Jack & Jill, #6)

By: Jewel E. Ann

4.37

Format: 388 pages, Kindle Edition

“If sin weren’t pretty, it wouldn’t be so tempting.” I was an accomplished music professor. Ha… read more

Similar categories in Jewel E. Ann's Because of Her (Jack & Jill, #6) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Hills of Shivers and Shadows (Frozen Fate, #1) by Pam Godwin

10. Hills of Shivers and Shadows (Frozen Fate, #1)

By: Pam Godwin

4.38

Format: None pages, None

Abducted and taken to a remote cabin in Alaska, Frankie finds herself at the mercy of four feral me… read more

Similar categories in Pam Godwin's Hills of Shivers and Shadows (Frozen Fate, #1) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • abuse
Cover of Midnight Hunter by Brianna Hale

11. Midnight Hunter

By: Brianna Hale

4.00

Format: 382 pages, Paperback

He’s hunting me, and there’s nowhere to run.East Berlin, 1963. I thought I understood the consequen… read more

Similar categories in Brianna Hale's Midnight Hunter book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • erotica
  • dark
  • suspense
Cover of It Breaks Me (Betrayal, #2) by Penelope Sky

12. It Breaks Me (Betrayal, #2)

By: Penelope Sky

4.45

Format: 394 pages, Kindle Edition

Axel betrayed me. As hard as I tried to keep him out of my heart, he broke through it like shatt… read more

Similar categories in Penelope Sky's It Breaks Me (Betrayal, #2) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • adult
Cover of White Lies (Smoke and Mirrors #2) by Skye Warren

13. White Lies (Smoke and Mirrors #2)

By: Skye Warren

3.91

Format: 272 pages, Kindle Edition

Mystery. Mayhem. Anything can happen in the circus.Including kidnapping.Logan Whitmere runs Cirque … read more

Similar categories in Skye Warren's White Lies (Smoke and Mirrors #2) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • erotica
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Stolen Soulmate (Crowne Point #2) by Mary Catherine Gebhard

14. Stolen Soulmate (Crowne Point #2)

By: Mary Catherine Gebhard

4.15

Format: 434 pages, Kindle Edition

There’s a rule in Crowne Hall: never look a Crowne in the eyes. It protects us more than them. I br… read more

Similar categories in Mary Catherine Gebhard's Stolen Soulmate (Crowne Point #2) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • erotica
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • erotic romance
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • abuse
"I can’t come up there,"

-Mary Catherine Gebhard, Stolen Soulmate (Crowne Point #2)

"You’ve corrupted my soul completely."

-Mary Catherine Gebhard, Stolen Soulmate (Crowne Point #2)

"Maybe I've started rooting for you to fail."

-Mary Catherine Gebhard, Stolen Soulmate (Crowne Point #2)

"She wasn't just cleaning-she fucking belonged here. In my bed. In my veins."

-Mary Catherine Gebhard, Stolen Soulmate (Crowne Point #2)

Cover of Taken by My Best Friend (Taken, #1) by Logan Chance

15. Taken by My Best Friend (Taken, #1)

By: Logan Chance

3.85

Format: 212 pages, Kindle Edition

Kidnapping the mafia princess will be the key to my ultimate revenge. Rhiannon Things change. S… read more

Similar categories in Logan Chance's Taken by My Best Friend (Taken, #1) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • erotica
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
Cover of It Kills Me (Betrayal, #1) by Penelope Sky

16. It Kills Me (Betrayal, #1)

By: Penelope Sky

4.31

Format: 298 pages, Kindle Edition

My father has chosen me to succeed him in the family business. But if I want the job, it comes w… read more

Similar categories in Penelope Sky's It Kills Me (Betrayal, #1) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
Cover of Love Like Poison (Corsican Crime Lord, #1) by Charmaine Pauls

17. Love Like Poison (Corsican Crime Lord, #1)

By: Charmaine Pauls

4.08

Format: 310 pages, Kindle Edition

Every year on my birthday, my tormentor returns to claim one of my firsts.A DARK MAFIA / ARRANGED M… read more

Similar categories in Charmaine Pauls's Love Like Poison (Corsican Crime Lord, #1) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Tears Like Acid (Corsican Crime Lord, #3) by Charmaine Pauls

18. Tears Like Acid (Corsican Crime Lord, #3)

By: Charmaine Pauls

4.23

Format: 308 pages, ebook

We’re destined to destroy each other, but we’re going to finish this game, no matter how long or wh… read more

Similar categories in Charmaine Pauls's Tears Like Acid (Corsican Crime Lord, #3) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • abuse
Cover of Kisses Like Rain (Corsican Crime Lord, #4) by Charmaine Pauls

19. Kisses Like Rain (Corsican Crime Lord, #4)

By: Charmaine Pauls

4.28

Format: 408 pages, Kindle Edition

>b>I gave him my innocence and my virtue. I gave him my love and my hate. Is there anything left to… read more

Similar categories in Charmaine Pauls's Kisses Like Rain (Corsican Crime Lord, #4) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • abuse
Cover of Hate Like Honey (Corsican Crime Lord, #2) by Charmaine Pauls

20. Hate Like Honey (Corsican Crime Lord, #2)

By: Charmaine Pauls

4.18

Format: 310 pages, Kindle Edition

The price I paid to claim her cost me too dearly to ever let her go. A deal sealed with a handsh… read more

Similar categories in Charmaine Pauls's Hate Like Honey (Corsican Crime Lord, #2) book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • suspense
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • abuse
Cover of The CEO by Skye Warren

21. The CEO

By: Skye Warren

3.91

Format: None pages, None

My older stepbrother Christopher hates me. Or that’s what I thought. When I plunge into the cold… read more

Similar categories in Skye Warren's The CEO book and Pepper Winters's Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1)

  • romance
  • erotica
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • erotic romance
  • contemporary romance
  • adult

20 Best contemporary books like Once a Myth (Goddess Isles, #1) by Pepper Winters

Transform Your Habits

Convicted (Consequences, #3)

Aleatha Romig

4.35

Transform Your Habits

Tormentor Mine (Tormentor Mine, #1)

Anna Zaires , Dima Zales

3.91

Transform Your Habits

The Penitent (The Sacrifice #2)

Natasha Knight

4.20

Transform Your Habits

The Tithing (The Sacrifice #1)

Natasha Knight

4.15

View all the books

18 Top contemporary books like Tears Like Acid (Corsican Crime Lord, #3) by Charmaine Pauls

Transform Your Habits

Tormentor Mine (Tormentor Mine, #1)

Anna Zaires , Dima Zales

3.91

Transform Your Habits

Terrible Beauty (Molotov Betrothal, #1)

Anna Zaires

4.01

Transform Your Habits

The Penitent (The Sacrifice #2)

Natasha Knight

4.20

Transform Your Habits

The Tithing (The Sacrifice #1)

Natasha Knight

4.15

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.