9 best-selling historical books like Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5) by Catherine Anderson

Cover of Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5) by Catherine Anderson

Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

By: Catherine Anderson

4.40

Format: 172 pages, Mass Market Paperback

In this stirring novel of the Old West from New York Times bestselling author Catherine Anderson, a…

If you liked the historical plot in Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5) by Catherine Anderson , here is a list of 9 books like this:

Cover of Eyes of Silver, Eyes of Gold by Ellen O'Connell

1. Eyes of Silver, Eyes of Gold

By: Ellen O'Connell

4.28

Format: 427 pages, Kindle Edition

Librarian's Note: an alternate cover for this ASIN can be found here. Eyes of Silver, Eyes of Go… read more

Similar categories in Ellen O'Connell's Eyes of Silver, Eyes of Gold book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • westerns
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • western romance
  • historical fiction
"Too much strength could be a curse, leaving a person unable to bend, only break."

-Ellen O'Connell, Eyes of Silver, Eyes of Gold

"Her hands cupped his face, thumbs caressing his cheekbones. "I love you, Mr. Bennett." "Good thing. Hate to be the only one afflicted."

-Ellen O'Connell, Eyes of Silver, Eyes of Gold

"You know how it is. You make up your mind about something, and then you stop seeing anything that doesn't fit the way you already think things are."

-Ellen O'Connell, Eyes of Silver, Eyes of Gold

"Dr. Craig says you're the only patient he ever treated who kept saying nothing hurt when he examined you right until you passed out. You think I believe your ribs are all right?"

-Ellen O'Connell, Eyes of Silver, Eyes of Gold

Cover of Without Words by Ellen O'Connell

2. Without Words

By: Ellen O'Connell

4.21

Format: 334 pages, Kindle Edition

Bounty hunter Bret Sterling kills Rufus Petty, thief and murderer, less than ten feet away from a f… read more

Similar categories in Ellen O'Connell's Without Words book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • westerns
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • western romance
  • historical fiction
"There will be other things to wonder at."

-Ellen O'Connell, Without Words

"Like an old photograph they had no color, no longer seemed real."

-Ellen O'Connell, Without Words

"Tell him? His idea of the best kind of present would be one she’d show him, not tell him."

-Ellen O'Connell, Without Words

"I think this moment right now is worth every day of the years wandering in the wilderness it took to get here."

-Ellen O'Connell, Without Words

Cover of This Heart of Mine (Whiskey Creek, #8) by Brenda Novak

3. This Heart of Mine (Whiskey Creek, #8)

By: Brenda Novak

4.20

Format: 400 pages, Mass Market Paperback

First love. Second chance? As the daughter of a hoarder, Phoenix Fuller had a tough childhood. So w… read more

Similar categories in Brenda Novak's This Heart of Mine (Whiskey Creek, #8) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • fiction
Cover of Eyes Only (Sisterhood, #24) by Fern Michaels

4. Eyes Only (Sisterhood, #24)

By: Fern Michaels

4.33

Format: 369 pages, Kindle Edition

Sisterhood ForeverLush, exclusive Spyder Island is home to many of the world's billionaires. Years … read more

Similar categories in Fern Michaels's Eyes Only (Sisterhood, #24) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • fiction
Cover of Morning Glory by LaVyrle Spencer

5. Morning Glory

By: LaVyrle Spencer

4.00

Format: 256 pages, Paperback

LOVE IN A STRANGER'S EYES... ELLY In town, they called her "Crazy Widow Dinsmore." But Elly was no … read more

Similar categories in LaVyrle Spencer's Morning Glory book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • westerns
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5) by Catherine Anderson

6. Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

By: Catherine Anderson

4.40

Format: 172 pages, Mass Market Paperback

In this stirring novel of the Old West from New York Times bestselling author Catherine Anderson, a… read more

Similar categories in Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • westerns
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • western romance
  • historical fiction
Cover of High Country Bride (McKettricks, #1) by Linda Lael Miller

7. High Country Bride (McKettricks, #1)

By: Linda Lael Miller

4.26

Format: None pages, Mass Market Paperback

One ranch. Three sons. Only one will inherit...and on one condition. Tired of waiting for his sons … read more

Similar categories in Linda Lael Miller's High Country Bride (McKettricks, #1) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • westerns
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • western romance
  • historical fiction
Cover of Simply Unforgettable (Simply Quartet, #1) by Mary Balogh

8. Simply Unforgettable (Simply Quartet, #1)

By: Mary Balogh

3.82

Format: 422 pages, Mass Market Paperback

New York Times bestselling author Mary Balogh returns to the seductive world she knows so well—Rege… read more

Similar categories in Mary Balogh's Simply Unforgettable (Simply Quartet, #1) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction

9. Secondhand Bride (McKettricks, #3)

By: Linda Lael Miller

2.50

Format: 260 pages, Paperback

read more

Similar categories in Linda Lael Miller's Secondhand Bride (McKettricks, #3) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

10. Into the Light (Sutton Family, #2)

By: Ellen O'Connell

3.89

Format: 32 pages, Kindle Edition

Kansas 1899. Deborah Sutton barely remembers her family's feud with the Van Cleves. Her mother died… read more

Similar categories in Ellen O'Connell's Into the Light (Sutton Family, #2) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

11. Silver Lining

By: Maggie Osborne

4.15

Format: None pages, Paperback

Hailed as "one of the best writers in the business" by Susan Elizabeth Phillips, multi-award-winnin… read more

Similar categories in Maggie Osborne's Silver Lining book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

Cover of Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1) by Ellen O'Connell

12. Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1)

By: Ellen O'Connell

4.11

Format: 316 pages, Kindle Edition

In 1866 on the empty Kansas prairie, two children shared a few desperate moments that changed their… read more

Similar categories in Ellen O'Connell's Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • westerns
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • western romance
  • historical fiction
"He parked the wagon beside the church and left Norah there with Early and orders to stay, no matter what she heard. He had more faith in Early obeying — he tied the dog to the wagon."

-Ellen O'Connell, Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1)

"What she'd done was give him a glimpse of something that scared the bejesus out of him, something never meant for men like him that could start a hunger that would eat away what little was left insid…"

-Ellen O'Connell, Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1)

"...she was honest enough to admit she married him because actions other men would not conceive of to start with or carry out to finish with were ordinary for [him]... not that she ever wanted or need…"

-Ellen O'Connell, Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1)

13. The Texan's Wager (Wife Lottery, #1)

By: Jodi Thomas

4.09

Format: 256 pages,

Thrown off a wagon train with two other women and trying to avoid jail for a murder they committed,… read more

Similar categories in Jodi Thomas's The Texan's Wager (Wife Lottery, #1) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

14. Texas Glory (Leigh Brothers Texas Trilogy, #2)

By: Lorraine Heath

4.29

Format: 248 pages, Mass Market Paperback

SHE WAS GIVEN TO A STRANGER Cordelia McQueen was a virtual prisoner in her father's house. Until ev… read more

Similar categories in Lorraine Heath's Texas Glory (Leigh Brothers Texas Trilogy, #2) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

15. A Texan's Luck (Wife Lottery, #3)

By: Jodi Thomas

3.68

Format: 113 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Captain Walker Larson received the shock of his life when a beautiful stranger boldly walked into h… read more

Similar categories in Jodi Thomas's A Texan's Luck (Wife Lottery, #3) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

16. The Promise of Jenny Jones

By: Maggie Osborne

3.88

Format: 373 pages, Paperback

A desperate mother takes Jenny Jones' place in front of a firing squad in exchange for Jenny's prom… read more

Similar categories in Maggie Osborne's The Promise of Jenny Jones book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

17. When a Texan Gambles (Wife Lottery, #2)

By: Jodi Thomas

3.88

Format: 496 pages, Mass Market Paperback

It all started when she got thrown off the wagon train. Now, a crook is dead, and Sarah Andrews has… read more

Similar categories in Jodi Thomas's When a Texan Gambles (Wife Lottery, #2) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

18. The Texan's Reward (Wife Lottery, #4)

By: Jodi Thomas

3.88

Format: 496 pages,

Years ago, Texas Ranger Jacob Dalton bailed an orphaned girl named Nell out of trouble more times t… read more

Similar categories in Jodi Thomas's The Texan's Reward (Wife Lottery, #4) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

Cover of The Unlovely Bride (Brides of Karadok, #2) by Alice Coldbreath

19. The Unlovely Bride (Brides of Karadok, #2)

By: Alice Coldbreath

4.22

Format: 514 pages, Kindle Edition

Lenora Montmayne leads a charmed life as the most beautiful woman at King Wymer’s court, surrounded… read more

Similar categories in Alice Coldbreath's The Unlovely Bride (Brides of Karadok, #2) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"Lenora Montmayne was brave as fuck or foolhardy as hell. He wasn't sure yet which it was."

-Alice Coldbreath, The Unlovely Bride (Brides of Karadok, #2)

"I will change, she vowed. While I will never have a really decent character, true love or even much by way of brains, I can still seek out some semblance of happiness."

-Alice Coldbreath, The Unlovely Bride (Brides of Karadok, #2)

"A roll in the sheets with me at present would likely snap you in half," he added. Lenora blinked. "are you so rough then, that I need to be more robust?" she asked with some acerbity."

-Alice Coldbreath, The Unlovely Bride (Brides of Karadok, #2)

Cover of Wed by Proxy (Brides of Karadok, #1) by Alice Coldbreath

20. Wed by Proxy (Brides of Karadok, #1)

By: Alice Coldbreath

3.87

Format: 411 pages, Kindle Edition

Thrice wedded, but never bedded, Mathilde Martindale has long lived in the shadow of her indomitabl… read more

Similar categories in Alice Coldbreath's Wed by Proxy (Brides of Karadok, #1) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical fiction
  • historical romance
Cover of The Liars (The Seaside Saga Book 20) by Joanne DeMaio

21. The Liars (The Seaside Saga Book 20)

By: Joanne DeMaio

4.56

Format: 278 pages, Kindle Edition

From New York Times bestselling author Joanne DeMaio comes The Liars, Book 20 of The Seaside Saga. … read more

Similar categories in Joanne DeMaio's The Liars (The Seaside Saga Book 20) book and Catherine Anderson's Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5)

9 must-read fiction books like Lucky Penny (Keegan-Paxton #5) by Catherine Anderson

Transform Your Habits

Eyes of Silver, Eyes of Gold

Ellen O'Connell

4.28

Transform Your Habits

This Heart of Mine (Whiskey Creek, #8)

Brenda Novak

4.20

Transform Your Habits

Eyes Only (Sisterhood, #24)

Fern Michaels

4.33

Transform Your Habits

Morning Glory

LaVyrle Spencer

4.00

View all the books

11 must-read fiction books like Simply Unforgettable (Simply Quartet, #1) by Mary Balogh

Transform Your Habits

Gareth: Lord of Rakes (Lonely Lords, #6)

Grace Burrowes

3.93

Transform Your Habits

Matthew (Jaded Gentlemen, #2)

Grace Burrowes

4.11

Transform Your Habits

His Wicked Reputation (Wicked Trilogy, #1)

Madeline Hunter

3.78

Transform Your Habits

The Summer Bride (Chance Sisters, #4)

Anne Gracie

4.25

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.