5 must-read fantasy books like Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2) by E.H. Lupton

Cover of Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2) by E.H. Lupton

Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

By: E.H. Lupton

4.44

Format: 358 pages, Kindle Edition

What's one more deadline? Ulysses Lenkov is on the verge of finishing his PhD when his ex-girlfr…

If you liked the fantasy plot in Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2) by E.H. Lupton , here is a list of 5 books like this:

Cover of The Angel of Indian Lake (The Indian Lake Trilogy, #3) by Stephen Graham Jones

1. The Angel of Indian Lake (The Indian Lake Trilogy, #3)

By: Stephen Graham Jones

4.21

Format: 455 pages, Hardcover

The final installment in the most lauded trilogy in the history of horror literature It’s been f… read more

Similar categories in Stephen Graham Jones's The Angel of Indian Lake (The Indian Lake Trilogy, #3) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • fantasy
  • fiction
  • paranormal
"I used to be all about the final girl standing on top of a pile of the dead at the end of the movie, her face dripping blood, her chest heaving, her eyes fierce. Now I’m all about holding the door of…"

-Stephen Graham Jones, The Angel of Indian Lake (The Indian Lake Trilogy, #3)

Cover of You Should Be So Lucky by Cat Sebastian

2. You Should Be So Lucky

By: Cat Sebastian

4.39

Format: 400 pages, Paperback

An emotional, slow-burn, grumpy/sunshine, queer mid-century romance about grief and found family, b… read more

Similar categories in Cat Sebastian's You Should Be So Lucky book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
"Sometimes you want to look at a guy and say: Well, he’s fucked, but he’s trying."

-Cat Sebastian, You Should Be So Lucky

"But he also wants that feeling he had earlier, that feeling of being seen for who he is, and of being liked anyway."

-Cat Sebastian, You Should Be So Lucky

"This urge to be kind to a relative stranger is unfamiliar and disconcerting, as if he's discovered in himself a hunger for raw meat or an enthusiasm for vaudeville."

-Cat Sebastian, You Should Be So Lucky

"The actual problem is incredibly boring, and Mark hates admitting it even to himself. Unless a couple has the good fortune to get hit by the same freight train, their story ends in exactly one way. H…"

-Cat Sebastian, You Should Be So Lucky

Cover of Two Rogues Make a Right (Seducing the Sedgwicks, #3) by Cat Sebastian

3. Two Rogues Make a Right (Seducing the Sedgwicks, #3)

By: Cat Sebastian

4.01

Format: 304 pages, ebook

Will Sedgwick can’t believe that after months of searching for his oldest friend, Martin Easterbroo… read more

Similar categories in Cat Sebastian's Two Rogues Make a Right (Seducing the Sedgwicks, #3) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
Cover of The Mars House by Natasha Pulley

4. The Mars House

By: Natasha Pulley

4.02

Format: 469 pages, Hardcover

From the author of The Watchmaker of Filigree Street, a queer sci-fi novel about an Earth refugee a… read more

Similar categories in Natasha Pulley's The Mars House book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • fantasy
  • fiction
Cover of Death in the Spires by K.J. Charles

5. Death in the Spires

By: K.J. Charles

4.42

Format: 273 pages, Kindle Edition

The newspapers called us the Seven Wonders. We were a group of friends, that’s all, and then Toby d… read more

Similar categories in K.J. Charles's Death in the Spires book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
Cover of For Real (Spires, #3) by Alexis  Hall

6. For Real (Spires, #3)

By: Alexis Hall

4.21

Format: 512 pages, Paperback

From the acclaimed author of BOYFRIEND MATERIAL and HUSBAND MATERIAL comes a deeply emotional roman… read more

Similar categories in Alexis Hall's For Real (Spires, #3) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
"Shouldn’t we have a safeword?"

-Alexis Hall, For Real (Spires, #3)

"It's not what you do, it's what it means."

-Alexis Hall, For Real (Spires, #3)

"There’s risk inherent in most things that matter."

-Alexis Hall, For Real (Spires, #3)

"Love doesn't just go away when it becomes inconvenient."

-Alexis Hall, For Real (Spires, #3)

Cover of Broadway Butchery (Memento Mori, #3) by C.S. Poe

7. Broadway Butchery (Memento Mori, #3)

By: C.S. Poe

4.45

Format: 311 pages, ebook

The Cold Case Squad of the NYPD is overworked, understaffed, but receiving great press due to star … read more

Similar categories in C.S. Poe's Broadway Butchery (Memento Mori, #3) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
Cover of The Mystery of the Spirits (Snow & Winter, #5) by C.S. Poe

8. The Mystery of the Spirits (Snow & Winter, #5)

By: C.S. Poe

4.40

Format: None pages, ebook

Antique dealer Sebastian Snow and Homicide detective Calvin Winter have been happily married for a … read more

Similar categories in C.S. Poe's The Mystery of the Spirits (Snow & Winter, #5) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
Cover of The Place Between by Kit Oliver

9. The Place Between

By: Kit Oliver

4.02

Format: 413 pages, Kindle Edition

Will Ned finally get a relationship right - even if it's fake? Ned’s exhausted from his divorce,… read more

Similar categories in Kit Oliver's The Place Between book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
Cover of Cascade Failure (Ambit's Run, #1) by L.M. Sagas

10. Cascade Failure (Ambit's Run, #1)

By: L.M. Sagas

3.92

Format: 407 pages, Paperback

L. M. Sagas' debut, Cascade Failure, is a highly commercial, sci-fi adventure blending J. S. Dewes'… read more

Similar categories in L.M. Sagas's Cascade Failure (Ambit's Run, #1) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • fiction
Cover of The Oak and the Ash (The Old Bridge Inn #3) by Annick Trent

11. The Oak and the Ash (The Old Bridge Inn #3)

By: Annick Trent

4.13

Format: 288 pages, Kindle Edition

A standalone M/M historical romance Radical surgeon George Evans is called to the scene of a mid… read more

Similar categories in Annick Trent's The Oak and the Ash (The Old Bridge Inn #3) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
Cover of Murder at Pirate's Cove (Secrets and Scrabble, #1) by Josh Lanyon

12. Murder at Pirate's Cove (Secrets and Scrabble, #1)

By: Josh Lanyon

3.96

Format: 240 pages, Kindle Edition

Ellery Page, aspiring screenwriter, Scrabble champion and guy-with-worst-luck-in-the-world-when-it-… read more

Similar categories in Josh Lanyon's Murder at Pirate's Cove (Secrets and Scrabble, #1) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
Cover of A Rulebook for Restless Rogues (Lucky Lovers of London, #2) by Jess Everlee

13. A Rulebook for Restless Rogues (Lucky Lovers of London, #2)

By: Jess Everlee

3.75

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

Jess Everlee follows up her sparkling debut The Gentleman's Book of Vices  with this charming queer… read more

Similar categories in Jess Everlee's A Rulebook for Restless Rogues (Lucky Lovers of London, #2) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
Cover of The Stardust Grail by Yume Kitasei

14. The Stardust Grail

By: Yume Kitasei

3.78

Format: 312 pages, Hardcover

Save one world. Doom her own. From the acclaimed author of The Deep Sky comes a thrilling anti-c… read more

Similar categories in Yume Kitasei's The Stardust Grail book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • fantasy
  • fiction
Cover of Liar City by Allie Therin

15. Liar City

By: Allie Therin

4.20

Format: 416 pages, Paperback

A murder has Seattle on edge, and it falls to a pacifist empath—and a notorious empath hunter—to fi… read more

Similar categories in Allie Therin's Liar City book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • fiction
  • m m romance
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Unwritten Rules (Unwritten Rules #1) by K.D. Casey

16. Unwritten Rules (Unwritten Rules #1)

By: K.D. Casey

3.82

Format: 338 pages, ebook

Zach Glasser has put up with a lot for the sport he loves. Endless days on the road, playing half-d… read more

Similar categories in K.D. Casey's Unwritten Rules (Unwritten Rules #1) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
Cover of The Rivals of Casper Road by Roan Parrish

17. The Rivals of Casper Road

By: Roan Parrish

3.92

Format: 288 pages, ebook

He’s in it to win it until he falls under his neighbor’s spell. Bram Larkspur’s rugged, sexy lo… read more

Similar categories in Roan Parrish's The Rivals of Casper Road book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
Cover of The Paper Boys by D.P. Clarence

18. The Paper Boys

By: D.P. Clarence

4.29

Format: 358 pages, Kindle Edition

Don’t hold the front page. Hold the guy who wrote it. Sunny Miller’s dream job on London’s Fleet S… read more

Similar categories in D.P. Clarence's The Paper Boys book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
Cover of The Duke at Hazard (Gentlemen of Uncertain Fortune, #2) by K.J. Charles

19. The Duke at Hazard (Gentlemen of Uncertain Fortune, #2)

By: K.J. Charles

4.33

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

Don't miss the second thrilling Regency romance in the Gentlemen of Uncertain Fortune series by KJ … read more

Similar categories in K.J. Charles's The Duke at Hazard (Gentlemen of Uncertain Fortune, #2) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction
Cover of Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2) by E.H. Lupton

20. Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

By: E.H. Lupton

4.44

Format: 358 pages, Kindle Edition

What's one more deadline? Ulysses Lenkov is on the verge of finishing his PhD when his ex-girlfr… read more

Similar categories in E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • fiction
  • m m romance
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of The Kiss Principle (Hazardverse: Sidetracks) by Gregory Ashe

21. The Kiss Principle (Hazardverse: Sidetracks)

By: Gregory Ashe

4.62

Format: 255 pages, Kindle Edition

Keep it simple, stupid. After spending his whole life taking care of his family, Fernando Lopez … read more

Similar categories in Gregory Ashe's The Kiss Principle (Hazardverse: Sidetracks) book and E.H. Lupton's Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2)

  • m m romance
  • fiction

17 Top m m romance books like Old Time Religion (Wisconsin Gothic, #2) by E.H. Lupton

Transform Your Habits

You Should Be So Lucky

Cat Sebastian

4.39

Transform Your Habits

Two Rogues Make a Right (Seducing the Sedgwicks, #3)

Cat Sebastian

4.01

Transform Your Habits

Death in the Spires

K.J. Charles

4.42

Transform Your Habits

For Real (Spires, #3)

Alexis Hall

4.21

View all the books

14 must-read fiction books like The Rivals of Casper Road by Roan Parrish

Transform Your Habits

Heart of the Steal

Avon Gale , Roan Parrish

3.37

Transform Your Habits

How to Blow It with a Billionaire (Arden St. Ives, #2)

Alexis Hall

4.15

Transform Your Habits

Fire Season (Unwritten Rules #2)

K.D. Casey

4.02

Transform Your Habits

Season's Change (Trade Season #1)

Cait Nary

3.98

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.