16 best-selling romance books like Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11) by Tabitha Bouldin

Cover of Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11) by Tabitha Bouldin

Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

By: Tabitha Bouldin

4.41

Format: 200 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes, happily ever after is as elusive as a pirate's treasure. Darcy Riggins dove headfirst…

If you liked the romance plot in Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11) by Tabitha Bouldin , here is a list of 16 books like this:

Cover of Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1) by Pepper Basham

1. Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1)

By: Pepper Basham

3.89

Format: 432 pages, Paperback

“Dear Izzy—I feel certain there’s a book-loving man living relatively nearby waiting to speak booki… read more

Similar categories in Pepper Basham's Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
  • clean romance
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
"The place where they lived within my heart is still being held for them, like a bookmark of sorts - waiting to see them again."

-Pepper Basham, Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1)

Cover of In Her Sights (Pink Pistol Sisterhood, #1) by Karen Witemeyer

2. In Her Sights (Pink Pistol Sisterhood, #1)

By: Karen Witemeyer

4.45

Format: 108 pages, Kindle Edition

He's sworn off love, but she has his heart in her sights and doesn't intend to miss. Stained by … read more

Similar categories in Karen Witemeyer's In Her Sights (Pink Pistol Sisterhood, #1) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
  • clean romance
Cover of Reclaiming Hope (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #18) by Carolyn   Miller

3. Reclaiming Hope (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #18)

By: Carolyn Miller

4.59

Format: 208 pages, Kindle Edition

Opposites attract—and repel. But which is more powerful? Callie Steele might be a bit… focused o… read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Miller's Reclaiming Hope (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #18) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
  • clean romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Under the Hibiscus (Suamalie Islands) by Chautona Havig

4. Under the Hibiscus (Suamalie Islands)

By: Chautona Havig

4.44

Format: 174 pages, Kindle Edition

Do you have to give God two-weeks’ notice when you quit the ministry? After a lifetime of being … read more

Similar categories in Chautona Havig's Under the Hibiscus (Suamalie Islands) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
Cover of Twice Sold Tales (Bookstrings #1) by Chautona Havig

5. Twice Sold Tales (Bookstrings #1)

By: Chautona Havig

4.50

Format: 300 pages, Paperback

If only owning a bookstore didn't mean dealing with people. No one was more surprised than Harper … read more

Similar categories in Chautona Havig's Twice Sold Tales (Bookstrings #1) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
  • christian romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Book, Chapter, & Vows (Independence Islands: Breakers Head #1) by Chautona Havig

6. Book, Chapter, & Vows (Independence Islands: Breakers Head #1)

By: Chautona Havig

4.72

Format: 246 pages, Kindle Edition

Why can't the past stay in the past? Falling in love with Benjamin wasn’t in the plan, but Mallo… read more

Similar categories in Chautona Havig's Book, Chapter, & Vows (Independence Islands: Breakers Head #1) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
Cover of The Title Wave (Suamalie Islands #3) by Chautona Havig

7. The Title Wave (Suamalie Islands #3)

By: Chautona Havig

4.47

Format: 228 pages, Kindle Edition

All he wants to do is help people, but local women want to help themselves… to him! When Henri Tupu… read more

Similar categories in Chautona Havig's The Title Wave (Suamalie Islands #3) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

Cover of Dual Power of Convenience (Merriweather Island #1) by Chautona Havig

8. Dual Power of Convenience (Merriweather Island #1)

By: Chautona Havig

4.44

Format: 210 pages, Kindle Edition

All they wanted was a happily-never-after. When Richard Danforth inherits the family estate on M… read more

Similar categories in Chautona Havig's Dual Power of Convenience (Merriweather Island #1) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
  • clean romance
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of Finding a Memory (Independence Islands #19) by Chautona Havig

9. Finding a Memory (Independence Islands #19)

By: Chautona Havig

4.71

Format: 200 pages, Paperback

He loved her then. Will she love him now? When Mallory Barrows finds an old diary in a box of bo… read more

Similar categories in Chautona Havig's Finding a Memory (Independence Islands #19) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
Cover of Blended Lives: Sparrow Island (Independence Islands Book 20) by Melissa Wardwell

10. Blended Lives: Sparrow Island (Independence Islands Book 20)

By: Melissa Wardwell

4.60

Format: 202 pages, Kindle Edition

Wedding bells are ringing on the islands, but more than romance is in the air. Seth Mikels experie… read more

Similar categories in Melissa Wardwell's Blended Lives: Sparrow Island (Independence Islands Book 20) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

Cover of Sweet Rivals: Sparrow Island (Independence Islands Book 21) by Kari Trumbo

11. Sweet Rivals: Sparrow Island (Independence Islands Book 21)

By: Kari Trumbo

4.49

Format: 178 pages, Kindle Edition

Fay is about to lose her business… …to the only guy she’s ever thought might be good for her. Fay… read more

Similar categories in Kari Trumbo's Sweet Rivals: Sparrow Island (Independence Islands Book 21) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

Cover of Restoring Fairhaven (Merriweather Island #6) by Carolyn   Miller

12. Restoring Fairhaven (Merriweather Island #6)

By: Carolyn Miller

4.46

Format: 235 pages, Kindle Edition

Love hurts, or so the songs say, so who wants it? Taking on her ailing father’s gardening busine… read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Miller's Restoring Fairhaven (Merriweather Island #6) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
  • christian romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Rebuilding Hearts (Independence Islands: Sparrow Island #24) by Carolyn   Miller

13. Rebuilding Hearts (Independence Islands: Sparrow Island #24)

By: Carolyn Miller

4.54

Format: 202 pages, Kindle Edition

Who knew a bank robbery could show a girl that good guys still exist? Tim Franklin. Quiet, shy, alm… read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Miller's Rebuilding Hearts (Independence Islands: Sparrow Island #24) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • christian
  • contemporary
Cover of Hooper Safe Haven (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #16) by Rachel Skatvold

14. Hooper Safe Haven (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #16)

By: Rachel Skatvold

4.47

Format: 184 pages, Kindle Edition

Harbors should be safe havens, but what if you’re harboring secrets? When Alicia Roberts accepts… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Skatvold's Hooper Safe Haven (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #16) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

Cover of 12 Dates of Christmas by Chautona Havig

15. 12 Dates of Christmas

By: Chautona Havig

4.23

Format: 163 pages, Kindle Edition

She's spent the last ten years not forgiving him. Why should she start now?When Reagan runs into he… read more

Similar categories in Chautona Havig's 12 Dates of Christmas book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian romance
  • clean romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Blessings in the Bargain (Independence Islands: Breakers Head #3) by Kari Trumbo

16. Blessings in the Bargain (Independence Islands: Breakers Head #3)

By: Kari Trumbo

4.85

Format: 180 pages, Kindle Edition

Despite a career in logistics, Courtney is unprepared to get lost at sea… A fated trip to the docks… read more

Similar categories in Kari Trumbo's Blessings in the Bargain (Independence Islands: Breakers Head #3) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
Cover of Scrumptious Independence (Merriweather Island #2) by Melissa Wardwell

17. Scrumptious Independence (Merriweather Island #2)

By: Melissa Wardwell

4.33

Format: 204 pages, Kindle Edition

“Taste and see that the Lord is good.” And so is Beth’s cooking! It’s a good thing, too. After a… read more

Similar categories in Melissa Wardwell's Scrumptious Independence (Merriweather Island #2) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian romance
Cover of Seasoned Grace (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #14) by Melissa Wardwell

18. Seasoned Grace (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #14)

By: Melissa Wardwell

4.67

Format: 192 pages, Paperback

You can run from your past, but you can’t escape it. Though he disappeared that day, Raylin McRe… read more

Similar categories in Melissa Wardwell's Seasoned Grace (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #14) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • clean romance
Cover of Secret Beach Boyfriend (Merriweather Island #3) by Kari Trumbo

19. Secret Beach Boyfriend (Merriweather Island #3)

By: Kari Trumbo

4.30

Format: 176 pages, Kindle Edition

Annie Roman believes love is a fairytale. She met Rafe on the beach when she was just five and i… read more

Similar categories in Kari Trumbo's Secret Beach Boyfriend (Merriweather Island #3) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

Cover of The Love Penalty (Northwest Ice Division #2) by Carolyn   Miller

20. The Love Penalty (Northwest Ice Division #2)

By: Carolyn Miller

4.54

Format: 364 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes there's a hefty price to pay when two opposites attract... With her fondness for tattoos… read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Miller's The Love Penalty (Northwest Ice Division #2) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
Cover of Her Merriweather Hero (Merriweather Island #4) by Rachel Skatvold

21. Her Merriweather Hero (Merriweather Island #4)

By: Rachel Skatvold

4.38

Format: 188 pages, Kindle Edition

He just wanted a place to rest and recuperate. She only needed a repairman to help fix up her be… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Skatvold's Her Merriweather Hero (Merriweather Island #4) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • christian romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11) by Tabitha Bouldin

22. Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

By: Tabitha Bouldin

4.41

Format: 200 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes, happily ever after is as elusive as a pirate's treasure. Darcy Riggins dove headfirst… read more

Similar categories in Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
  • clean romance
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of Flipping Hearts (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #13) by Chautona Havig

23. Flipping Hearts (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #13)

By: Chautona Havig

4.51

Format: 252 pages, Paperback

When a hurricane rips through Hooper Island, a tidal wave of TV crews follows and upsets the locals… read more

Similar categories in Chautona Havig's Flipping Hearts (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #13) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
  • clean romance
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of More Than a Heartthrob (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #15) by Kari Trumbo

24. More Than a Heartthrob (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #15)

By: Kari Trumbo

4.41

Format: 174 pages, Kindle Edition

Whoever said beauty is only skin deep lied. Beauty begins from within. Jazzy is comfortable in h… read more

Similar categories in Kari Trumbo's More Than a Heartthrob (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #15) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

Cover of Fire and Ice (Northwest Ice Division #1) by Carolyn   Miller

25. Fire and Ice (Northwest Ice Division #1)

By: Carolyn Miller

4.54

Format: 350 pages, Kindle Edition

Hannah Wade's heart might've once been touched by a rancher's son, but her real passion has always … read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Miller's Fire and Ice (Northwest Ice Division #1) book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

  • romance
  • christian
  • christian romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Something Borrowed, Someone Blue by Chautona Havig

26. Something Borrowed, Someone Blue

By: Chautona Havig

4.51

Format: 215 pages, Kindle Edition

♥ A borrowed dress, half-completed marriage counseling, and a last-minute theft. ♥ Let's face it. … read more

Similar categories in Chautona Havig's Something Borrowed, Someone Blue book and Tabitha Bouldin's Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11)

11 best-selling contemporary books like Stealing the First Mate (Independence Islands, Elnora Island #11) by Tabitha Bouldin

Transform Your Habits

Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1)

Pepper Basham

3.89

Transform Your Habits

Reclaiming Hope (Independence Islands, Hooper Island #18)

Carolyn Miller

4.59

Transform Your Habits

Twice Sold Tales (Bookstrings #1)

Chautona Havig

4.50

Transform Your Habits

Dual Power of Convenience (Merriweather Island #1)

Chautona Havig

4.44

View all the books

20 Best fiction books like 12 Dates of Christmas by Chautona Havig

Transform Your Habits

At Your Request (Apart from the Crowd, #0.5)

Jen Turano

4.07

Transform Your Habits

For a Lifetime (Timeless, #3)

Gabrielle Meyer

4.55

Transform Your Habits

Falling for Your Brother's Best Friend (Love Clichés, #4.5)

Emma St. Clair

4.17

Transform Your Habits

A Lady's Guide to Marvels and Misadventure

Angela Bell

4.02

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.