31 best-selling contemporary books like The Benchwarmer by Jamie Bennett

Cover of The Benchwarmer by Jamie Bennett

The Benchwarmer

By: Jamie Bennett

3.83

Format: 339 pages, Kindle Edition

A benchwarmer? Nope, Teddy Hayes can really start her up! Second-string. That’s been Ellie Wild…

If you liked the contemporary plot in The Benchwarmer by Jamie Bennett , here is a list of 31 books like this:

Cover of Broken Heart Syndrome (Broken Heart, #1) by Susie Tate

1. Broken Heart Syndrome (Broken Heart, #1)

By: Susie Tate

3.88

Format: 136 pages, Kindle Edition

Librarian's Note: this is an alternate cover edition - ASIN: B00JHR3YQE Shy, reclusive Frankie and… read more

Similar categories in Susie Tate's Broken Heart Syndrome (Broken Heart, #1) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary

2. Sticks and Stones (Broken Heart, #2)

By: Susie Tate

3.37

Format: 120 pages,

For Lou it was always Dylan. She loved him from the moment they first met across a cadaver in the d… read more

Similar categories in Susie Tate's Sticks and Stones (Broken Heart, #2) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of My Anti-Hero by Tijan

3. My Anti-Hero

By: Tijan

4.12

Format: 534 pages, Kindle Edition

I shouldn't have agreed to this. What was I thinking?Appearing on a local news show? Just because s… read more

Similar categories in Tijan's My Anti-Hero book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of The Lone Wolf's Rejected Mate (Five Packs, #3) by Cate C. Wells

4. The Lone Wolf's Rejected Mate (Five Packs, #3)

By: Cate C. Wells

3.99

Format: 316 pages, Kindle Edition

After one night, he walked away. He’s going to live to regret it. Mari Growing up alone in Quar… read more

Similar categories in Cate C. Wells's The Lone Wolf's Rejected Mate (Five Packs, #3) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary
Cover of His Curvy Rejected Mate (Five Packs, #4) by Cate C. Wells

5. His Curvy Rejected Mate (Five Packs, #4)

By: Cate C. Wells

3.88

Format: 272 pages, Kindle Edition

He had his chance. He blew it, and I’m out of here. Flora I’m at the bottom of the pack. I’m fe… read more

Similar categories in Cate C. Wells's His Curvy Rejected Mate (Five Packs, #4) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Unworthy by Susie Tate

6. Unworthy

By: Susie Tate

4.04

Format: 277 pages, Kindle Edition

Unreliable, irresponsible, unpredictable, unaccountable —Yaz knows how her family view her. She was… read more

Similar categories in Susie Tate's Unworthy book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of After the Shut Up Ring by Cate C. Wells

7. After the Shut Up Ring

By: Cate C. Wells

3.75

Format: 256 pages, Kindle Edition

shut up ring (noun) – a marriage proposal meant to get you off his back, intended to last indefinit… read more

Similar categories in Cate C. Wells's After the Shut Up Ring book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Heavy (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #6) by Cate C. Wells

8. Heavy (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #6)

By: Cate C. Wells

4.14

Format: 333 pages, Kindle Edition

The bigger they are, the harder they fall. Heavy Dina is off limits. She’s my brother Wall’s li… read more

Similar categories in Cate C. Wells's Heavy (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #6) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Unwanted by Susie Tate

9. Unwanted

By: Susie Tate

4.07

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

Why has the adorable, geeky, fashion-backwards, gangly teenager Verity fell in love with at school … read more

Similar categories in Susie Tate's Unwanted book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of When Gracie Met the Grump by Mariana Zapata

10. When Gracie Met the Grump

By: Mariana Zapata

4.07

Format: 570 pages, Paperback

Of all the things that could have landed in her yard… it had to be him. For most people, finding… read more

Similar categories in Mariana Zapata's When Gracie Met the Grump book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
"I don’t know where this marshmallow filling inside you is coming from, but I’m all about it"

-Mariana Zapata, When Gracie Met the Grump

"I know this is probably hell for you, but you can count to three hundred and then push me off"

-Mariana Zapata, When Gracie Met the Grump

"People think doing the right thing is easy, but it’s not. The right thing is hardly ever convenient."

-Mariana Zapata, When Gracie Met the Grump

"If you can’t worry about losing something you find precious, it probably isn’t all that valuable to you in the first place."

-Mariana Zapata, When Gracie Met the Grump

Cover of Rocket Science by Emily Mayer

11. Rocket Science

By: Emily Mayer

4.03

Format: 237 pages, Kindle Edition

An aerospace engineer and a professional athlete walk into a club…stop me if you’ve heard this one … read more

Similar categories in Emily Mayer's Rocket Science book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of Pretend (Neighbor from Hell, #0) by R.L. Mathewson

12. Pretend (Neighbor from Hell, #0)

By: R.L. Mathewson

4.07

Format: 265 pages, Kindle Edition

There was nothing more painful than falling in love with your best friend. From New York Time’s … read more

Similar categories in R.L. Mathewson's Pretend (Neighbor from Hell, #0) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Hands Down by Mariana Zapata

13. Hands Down

By: Mariana Zapata

3.91

Format: 550 pages, Kindle Edition

Before he was Big Texas, he was Zac the Snack Pack. Bianca Brannen knows time--mostly--heals all… read more

Similar categories in Mariana Zapata's Hands Down book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
"I was his fan because I didn't know how not to be. I was a lifelong fangirl, even though he'd forgotten about me."

-Mariana Zapata, Hands Down

"I was nobody’s puppy. I was a German Shepherd, maybe a Belgian Malinois; not the smallest or the biggest but strong, proud and loyal."

-Mariana Zapata, Hands Down

Cover of Coach (Treasure State Wildcats, #1) by Devney Perry

14. Coach (Treasure State Wildcats, #1)

By: Devney Perry

3.98

Format: 370 pages, Kindle Edition

Football star. Single dad. And once, a long time ago, mine. I’ve spent the better part of a dec… read more

Similar categories in Devney Perry's Coach (Treasure State Wildcats, #1) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of Charge (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #1) by Cate C. Wells

15. Charge (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #1)

By: Cate C. Wells

3.88

Format: 250 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes the things you shouldn’t want are exactly what you need.KaylaLife hasn’t been easy. I ha… read more

Similar categories in Cate C. Wells's Charge (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #1) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Wall (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #4.5) by Cate C. Wells

16. Wall (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #4.5)

By: Cate C. Wells

3.78

Format: 167 pages, Kindle Edition

What's more dangerous than a second chance? Wall I want my wife back, but I lost the right to… read more

Similar categories in Cate C. Wells's Wall (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #4.5) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Fly Bye by C.W. Farnsworth

17. Fly Bye

By: C.W. Farnsworth

4.06

Format: 284 pages, Kindle Edition

The first time I saw Grayson Phillips, I fell. Tripped, to be specific. His seven-year-old self sav… read more

Similar categories in C.W. Farnsworth's Fly Bye book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Winning Mr. Wrong by C.W. Farnsworth

18. Winning Mr. Wrong

By: C.W. Farnsworth

3.96

Format: 267 pages, Kindle Edition

Mr. Wrong /ˈmistər rôNG/ the polar opposite of the perfect man. "A prime example of Mr. Wrong is a… read more

Similar categories in C.W. Farnsworth's Winning Mr. Wrong book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of Luna and the Lie by Mariana Zapata

19. Luna and the Lie

By: Mariana Zapata

4.08

Format: 580 pages, ebook

The problem with secrets is that they’re too easy to keep collecting. Luna Allen has done some t… read more

Similar categories in Mariana Zapata's Luna and the Lie book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Forty (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #5) by Cate C. Wells

20. Forty (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #5)

By: Cate C. Wells

4.00

Format: 245 pages, Kindle Edition

Secrets tore us apart... Nevaeh I burned my bridges a long time ago and headed for the big city… read more

Similar categories in Cate C. Wells's Forty (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #5) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Scrap (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #3) by Cate C. Wells

21. Scrap (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #3)

By: Cate C. Wells

4.05

Format: 212 pages, Kindle Edition

He did ten years for me. Now he's free. This is supposed to be happy ever after, so why does it fe… read more

Similar categories in Cate C. Wells's Scrap (Steel Bones Motorcycle Club, #3) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Everything Girl by Emily Mayer

22. Everything Girl

By: Emily Mayer

4.08

Format: 344 pages, Kindle Edition

Evelyn Mercer has always had a plan. She lives and breathes the plan. The plan and coffee. Go to l… read more

Similar categories in Emily Mayer's Everything Girl book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Preservation (The Walshes, #7) by Kate Canterbary

23. Preservation (The Walshes, #7)

By: Kate Canterbary

4.38

Format: None pages, None

Riley Walsh doesn’t want a fake girlfriend but he needs one. It’s the only thing he can do to de… read more

Similar categories in Kate Canterbary's Preservation (The Walshes, #7) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
"Spider-Man wasn't always on the side of justice. He made some questionable choices. Also, he was a fucking creeper."

-Kate Canterbary, Preservation (The Walshes, #7)

"I resisted every urge to twine my fingers around the silver necklaces at my throat. It was too early for full-on pearl clutching."

-Kate Canterbary, Preservation (The Walshes, #7)

"We were affectionate like an intramural softball team. Sloppy and a little silly, and with no real purpose beyond our own amusement."

-Kate Canterbary, Preservation (The Walshes, #7)

"She was going to be the one beside me for decades to come, the one who opened up my wild and gave it space to roam free, the mother of my children. She was the love of my life, and she was the only o…"

-Kate Canterbary, Preservation (The Walshes, #7)

Cover of Daydreamer by Susie Tate

24. Daydreamer

By: Susie Tate

4.03

Format: 314 pages, Kindle Edition

As a scruffy, disorganised daydreamer, Lucy Mayweather is like a fish out of water at the high-powe… read more

Similar categories in Susie Tate's Daydreamer book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Beyond Repair (Broken Heart, #3) by Susie Tate

25. Beyond Repair (Broken Heart, #3)

By: Susie Tate

4.00

Format: 339 pages, Kindle Edition

Everybody loves Katie; with her bubbly personality, her beauty, her never-ending supply of care and… read more

Similar categories in Susie Tate's Beyond Repair (Broken Heart, #3) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Anything But Easy (Beg, Borrow or Steal #3) by Susie Tate

26. Anything But Easy (Beg, Borrow or Steal #3)

By: Susie Tate

4.33

Format: 284 pages, Kindle Edition

Kira Murphy is a liability: always has been. She might be small but her personality and heart are n… read more

Similar categories in Susie Tate's Anything But Easy (Beg, Borrow or Steal #3) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Pretend With Me (Beacon Hill Book 1) by Emily Mayer

27. Pretend With Me (Beacon Hill Book 1)

By: Emily Mayer

4.15

Format: 357 pages, Kindle Edition

One phone call was all it took to upend my entire life in completely unexpected ways. Whoever sa… read more

Similar categories in Emily Mayer's Pretend With Me (Beacon Hill Book 1) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Mad Love (The Single Dad Playbook, #1) by Willow Aster

28. Mad Love (The Single Dad Playbook, #1)

By: Willow Aster

4.10

Format: 354 pages, Paperback

He's a quarterback, a single dad, and now he's my roommate… For a long time now, I’ve despised W… read more

Similar categories in Willow Aster's Mad Love (The Single Dad Playbook, #1) book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of The Benchwarmer by Jamie Bennett

29. The Benchwarmer

By: Jamie Bennett

3.83

Format: 339 pages, Kindle Edition

A benchwarmer? Nope, Teddy Hayes can really start her up! Second-string. That’s been Ellie Wild… read more

Similar categories in Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • football
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
  • new adult
Cover of How to Lose a Fiancé by Stefanie London

30. How to Lose a Fiancé

By: Stefanie London

3.75

Format: 209 pages, Kindle Edition

Sophia Andreou has always been the “good daughter” who tried to keep her domineering father happy. … read more

Similar categories in Stefanie London's How to Lose a Fiancé book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Unforgettable by Tayla Louise

31. Unforgettable

By: Tayla Louise

4.12

Format: 407 pages, None

From USA Today & Wall Street Journal bestselling author Michelle Heard and debut author Tayla Louis… read more

Similar categories in Tayla Louise's Unforgettable book and Jamie Bennett's The Benchwarmer

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary

31 Best romance books like The Benchwarmer by Jamie Bennett

Transform Your Habits

Broken Heart Syndrome (Broken Heart, #1)

Susie Tate

3.88

Sticks and Stones (Broken Heart, #2)

Susie Tate

3.37

Transform Your Habits

My Anti-Hero

Tijan

4.12

Transform Your Habits

The Lone Wolf's Rejected Mate (Five Packs, #3)

Cate C. Wells

3.99

View all the books

20 Top contemporary books like Beyond Repair (Broken Heart, #3) by Susie Tate

Transform Your Habits

Reckless Hope (Reckless #1)

Nyssa Kathryn

4.11

Transform Your Habits

The Wrong Wife (Golden Knights #1)

Maya Alden

3.74

Transform Your Habits

Scorned Vows (Scorned Fate #2)

Victoria Paige

3.97

Transform Your Habits

Exposed (The Agents, #3)

Brynne Asher

4.37

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.