15 must-read mystery books like The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6) by Anina Collins

Cover of The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6) by Anina Collins

The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

By: Anina Collins

4.33

Format: 207 pages, Kindle Edition

Poppy and Alex are back in this sixth book in the Poppy McGuire series! In the middle of a late su…

If you liked the mystery plot in The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6) by Anina Collins , here is a list of 15 books like this:

1. The Lightning-Struck Heart (Tales From Verania, #1)

By: T.J. Klune

3.45

Format: 105 pages, Paperback

Once upon a time, in an alleyway in the slums of the City of Lockes, a young and somewhat lonely bo… read more

Similar categories in T.J. Klune's The Lightning-Struck Heart (Tales From Verania, #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

2. Southern Spirits (Southern Ghost Hunter Mysteries, #1)

By: Angie Fox

3.78

Format: 288 pages,

One simple mistake... For a girl who is about to lose her family home, Releases the ghost of a long… read more

Similar categories in Angie Fox's Southern Spirits (Southern Ghost Hunter Mysteries, #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies (The Ill-Mannered Ladies, #1) by Alison Goodman

3. The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies (The Ill-Mannered Ladies, #1)

By: Alison Goodman

4.18

Format: 464 pages, Paperback

A high society amateur detective at the heart of Regency London uses her wits and invisibility as a… read more

Similar categories in Alison Goodman's The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies (The Ill-Mannered Ladies, #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
"What makes you think he is trustworthy?’ ‘ He has a sense of humor,’ I said, and then added the final proof. ‘And he found my observations funny too."

-Alison Goodman, The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies (The Ill-Mannered Ladies, #1)

"If you need me, just yell,' he said. 'Ladies do not yell,' I replied over my shoulder. 'But renegades do.' I caught a glimpse of myself in one of the mirrors as I passed; my color was high and I had …"

-Alison Goodman, The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies (The Ill-Mannered Ladies, #1)

"My brother pursed his lips. 'Love? Really, Augusta, this is an important decision. If you think love is essential to a good match it is no wonder you are still unmarried.' 'Duffy, that is unkind,' Ju…"

-Alison Goodman, The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies (The Ill-Mannered Ladies, #1)

"He took the offering and positioned it behind his head with a baleful look. 'If I recall, it is your fault I have lost a great deal of blood,' Undeniable, but then again, I had not started the encoun…"

-Alison Goodman, The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies (The Ill-Mannered Ladies, #1)

Cover of The Clause in Christmas (Poppy Creek, #1) by Rachael Bloome

4. The Clause in Christmas (Poppy Creek, #1)

By: Rachael Bloome

4.37

Format: 292 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes home is where you least expect it... Cassie Hayward hates Christmas. Especially this… read more

Similar categories in Rachael Bloome's The Clause in Christmas (Poppy Creek, #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of The Meaning in Mistletoe (Poppy Creek, #4) by Rachael Bloome

5. The Meaning in Mistletoe (Poppy Creek, #4)

By: Rachael Bloome

4.47

Format: 226 pages, Kindle Edition

A charming small town. An unexpected kiss. And a life-changing Christmas they’ll never forget.... … read more

Similar categories in Rachael Bloome's The Meaning in Mistletoe (Poppy Creek, #4) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of The Faith in Flowers (Poppy Creek, #5) by Rachael Bloome

6. The Faith in Flowers (Poppy Creek, #5)

By: Rachael Bloome

4.52

Format: 206 pages, Kindle Edition

An extravagant wedding to plan. A blossoming childhood crush. And a secret ready to uproot everythi… read more

Similar categories in Rachael Bloome's The Faith in Flowers (Poppy Creek, #5) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of The Whisper in Wind (Poppy Creek, #6) by Rachael Bloome

7. The Whisper in Wind (Poppy Creek, #6)

By: Rachael Bloome

4.54

Format: 230 pages, Kindle Edition

They’re polar opposites not looking for romance. But what will they do when it finds them ? Lucy G… read more

Similar categories in Rachael Bloome's The Whisper in Wind (Poppy Creek, #6) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of Pawsitively Poisonous (Witch of Edgehill, #1) by Melissa Erin Jackson

8. Pawsitively Poisonous (Witch of Edgehill, #1)

By: Melissa Erin Jackson

4.10

Format: 260 pages, Kindle Edition

Every town has its secrets, but no one has a secret like hers. Amber Blackwood, lifelong reside… read more

Similar categories in Melissa Erin Jackson's Pawsitively Poisonous (Witch of Edgehill, #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of A Villa in Sicily: Olive Oil and Murder (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #1) by Fiona Grace

9. A Villa in Sicily: Olive Oil and Murder (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #1)

By: Fiona Grace

3.95

Format: 191 pages, Kindle Edition

A VILLA IN SICILY: OLIVE OIL AND MURDER is the debut novel in a charming new cozy mystery series by… read more

Similar categories in Fiona Grace's A Villa in Sicily: Olive Oil and Murder (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Repo Girl (Repo Girl #1) by Jane Fenton

10. Repo Girl (Repo Girl #1)

By: Jane Fenton

4.28

Format: 272 pages, Kindle Edition

Debt, Dating, and a Dead body...What's a girl to do? Twenty-five-year-old rookie Repo Agent, And… read more

Similar categories in Jane Fenton's Repo Girl (Repo Girl #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Truth in Tiramisu (Poppy Creek, #2) by Rachael Bloome

11. The Truth in Tiramisu (Poppy Creek, #2)

By: Rachael Bloome

4.43

Format: 254 pages, Kindle Edition

Eliza Carter can't keep a secret. Except the one she's been hiding for over eight years. And… read more

Similar categories in Rachael Bloome's The Truth in Tiramisu (Poppy Creek, #2) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of The Harp of Kings (Warrior Bards, #1) by Juliet Marillier

12. The Harp of Kings (Warrior Bards, #1)

By: Juliet Marillier

4.07

Format: 463 pages, Kindle Edition

A young woman is both a bard--and a warrior--in this thrilling historical fantasy from the author o… read more

Similar categories in Juliet Marillier's The Harp of Kings (Warrior Bards, #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of A Very Merry Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #2) by Cindy Kline

13. A Very Merry Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #2)

By: Cindy Kline

4.39

Format: 198 pages, Kindle Edition

Is it the luck of the Irish, or a curse that Molly has found another body? It’s Christmas time i… read more

Similar categories in Cindy Kline's A Very Merry Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #2) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
Cover of A Villa in Sicily: Figs and a Cadaver (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #2) by Fiona Grace

14. A Villa in Sicily: Figs and a Cadaver (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #2)

By: Fiona Grace

4.08

Format: 170 pages, Kindle Edition

A VILLA IN SICILY: FIGS AND A CADAVER is book #2 in a charming new cozy mystery series by bestselli… read more

Similar categories in Fiona Grace's A Villa in Sicily: Figs and a Cadaver (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #2) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Ghostly Grounds: Murder and Breakfast (Canine Casper Cozy Mystery #1) by Sophie Love

15. The Ghostly Grounds: Murder and Breakfast (Canine Casper Cozy Mystery #1)

By: Sophie Love

3.91

Format: 198 pages, Kindle Edition

Marie Fortune, 39, a successful dog groomer in Boston, has had enough of catering to the wealthy an… read more

Similar categories in Sophie Love's The Ghostly Grounds: Murder and Breakfast (Canine Casper Cozy Mystery #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Hope in Hot Chocolate (Poppy Creek, #7) by Rachael Bloome

16. The Hope in Hot Chocolate (Poppy Creek, #7)

By: Rachael Bloome

4.45

Format: 232 pages, Kindle Edition

One charming small town. Two business rivals. And a whole lot of chocolate... Kindhearted candymake… read more

Similar categories in Rachael Bloome's The Hope in Hot Chocolate (Poppy Creek, #7) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of Murder at the Manor (Tommy & Evelyn Christie, #1) by Catherine Coles

17. Murder at the Manor (Tommy & Evelyn Christie, #1)

By: Catherine Coles

4.04

Format: 203 pages, Kindle Edition

Downton Abbey crossed with Murder, She Wrote...set in a Yorkshire village! Evelyn Christie has r… read more

Similar categories in Catherine Coles's Murder at the Manor (Tommy & Evelyn Christie, #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of A Treacherous Tart (Beachfront Bakery #5) by Fiona Grace

18. A Treacherous Tart (Beachfront Bakery #5)

By: Fiona Grace

3.84

Format: 190 pages, Kindle Edition

Allison Sweet, 34, a sous chef in Los Angeles, has had it up to here with demeaning customers, her … read more

Similar categories in Fiona Grace's A Treacherous Tart (Beachfront Bakery #5) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of A Dance with Fate (Warrior Bards, #2) by Juliet Marillier

19. A Dance with Fate (Warrior Bards, #2)

By: Juliet Marillier

4.24

Format: 507 pages, ebook

A young woman who is both a bard--and a warrior--seeks to repay her debts and settle scores in this… read more

Similar categories in Juliet Marillier's A Dance with Fate (Warrior Bards, #2) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of The Promise in Poppies (Poppy Creek #8) by Rachael Bloome

20. The Promise in Poppies (Poppy Creek #8)

By: Rachael Bloome

4.65

Format: 294 pages, Kindle Edition

Weddings, babies, and found-families abound in this heartwarming, emotionally satisfying conclusion… read more

Similar categories in Rachael Bloome's The Promise in Poppies (Poppy Creek #8) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of Bells and Bombshells (Harper and Moon Investigations #1) by Trixie Silvertale

21. Bells and Bombshells (Harper and Moon Investigations #1)

By: Trixie Silvertale

4.67

Format: 298 pages, Kindle Edition

A pattern of murder. A threadbare case. Can our psychic sleuth pick out the guilty before time spoo… read more

Similar categories in Trixie Silvertale's Bells and Bombshells (Harper and Moon Investigations #1) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Secret in Sandcastles (Poppy Creek, #3) by Rachael Bloome

22. The Secret in Sandcastles (Poppy Creek, #3)

By: Rachael Bloome

4.44

Format: 236 pages, Kindle Edition

Two childhood enemies. One adventure-filled summer. And an unexpected romance they're trying hard t… read more

Similar categories in Rachael Bloome's The Secret in Sandcastles (Poppy Creek, #3) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of A Villa in Sicily: Orange Groves and Vengeance (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #5) by Fiona Grace

23. A Villa in Sicily: Orange Groves and Vengeance (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #5)

By: Fiona Grace

4.07

Format: 179 pages, Kindle Edition

A VILLA IN SICILY: ORANGE GROVES AND VENGEANCE is book #5 in a charming new cozy mystery series by … read more

Similar categories in Fiona Grace's A Villa in Sicily: Orange Groves and Vengeance (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #5) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Meeting the Parents Can be Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #6) by Cindy Kline

24. Meeting the Parents Can be Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #6)

By: Cindy Kline

4.62

Format: 239 pages, Kindle Edition

Murder, Mystery and A Deadly Combination!When Molly meets Liam's parents for the first time, she's… read more

Similar categories in Cindy Kline's Meeting the Parents Can be Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #6) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of The Ghostly Grounds: Malice and Lunch (A Canine Casper Cozy Mystery #3) by Sophie Love

25. The Ghostly Grounds: Malice and Lunch (A Canine Casper Cozy Mystery #3)

By: Sophie Love

4.14

Format: 175 pages, Kindle Edition

Marie Fortune, 39, a successful dog groomer in Boston, leaves the stressful life behind and heads t… read more

Similar categories in Sophie Love's The Ghostly Grounds: Malice and Lunch (A Canine Casper Cozy Mystery #3) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Ghosts, Goblins, and Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #4) by Cindy Kline

26. Ghosts, Goblins, and Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #4)

By: Cindy Kline

4.53

Format: 237 pages, Kindle Edition

Come join Molly and the Metheal Sleuth Slayers as they figure out another mystery! Molly is enjo… read more

Similar categories in Cindy Kline's Ghosts, Goblins, and Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #4) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
Cover of Dublin, Dresses and Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #5) by Cindy Kline

27. Dublin, Dresses and Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #5)

By: Cindy Kline

4.53

Format: 275 pages, Kindle Edition

Secrets can be deadly… Molly and the gang are in Dublin to preview an exclusive wedding collecti… read more

Similar categories in Cindy Kline's Dublin, Dresses and Murder (Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries, #5) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Wishing Well Mystery (Molly McGuire Mysteries, #7) by Cindy Kline

28. The Wishing Well Mystery (Molly McGuire Mysteries, #7)

By: Cindy Kline

4.42

Format: 154 pages, Kindle Edition

A Leprechaun's Gift, A Town Mystery, and a Love Tested to the Core...In the enchanting coastal Iris… read more

Similar categories in Cindy Kline's The Wishing Well Mystery (Molly McGuire Mysteries, #7) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

Cover of The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6) by Anina Collins

29. The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

By: Anina Collins

4.33

Format: 207 pages, Kindle Edition

Poppy and Alex are back in this sixth book in the Poppy McGuire series! In the middle of a late su… read more

Similar categories in Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Ghostly Grounds: Death and Brunch (A Canine Casper Cozy Mystery #2) by Sophie Love

30. The Ghostly Grounds: Death and Brunch (A Canine Casper Cozy Mystery #2)

By: Sophie Love

4.05

Format: 182 pages, Kindle Edition

Marie Fortune, 39, a successful dog groomer in Boston, leaves the stressful life behind and heads t… read more

Similar categories in Sophie Love's The Ghostly Grounds: Death and Brunch (A Canine Casper Cozy Mystery #2) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Eve Lloyd's A Deadline Cozy Mystery (Deadline Cozy Mystery #1-5) by Sonia Parin

31. Eve Lloyd's A Deadline Cozy Mystery (Deadline Cozy Mystery #1-5)

By: Sonia Parin

4.32

Format: 717 pages, Kindle Edition

Eve Lloyd's A Deadline Cozy Mystery Series (Clean no graphic violence, sex, or strong language) Su… read more

Similar categories in Sonia Parin's Eve Lloyd's A Deadline Cozy Mystery (Deadline Cozy Mystery #1-5) book and Anina Collins's The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery

15 Best cozy mystery books like The Witching Hour (Poppy McGuire Mysteries, #6) by Anina Collins

Transform Your Habits

Pawsitively Poisonous (Witch of Edgehill, #1)

Melissa Erin Jackson

4.10

Transform Your Habits

A Villa in Sicily: Olive Oil and Murder (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #1)

Fiona Grace

3.95

Transform Your Habits

Repo Girl (Repo Girl #1)

Jane Fenton

4.28

Transform Your Habits

A Villa in Sicily: Figs and a Cadaver (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #2)

Fiona Grace

4.08

View all the books

14 Best fiction books like A Villa in Sicily: Olive Oil and Murder (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #1) by Fiona Grace

Transform Your Habits

Buried (Twisted Cedar Mysteries, #1)

C.J. Carmichael

3.50

Transform Your Habits

Murder on Tyneside (Agnes Lockwood Mysteries, Book #1)

Eileen Thornton

3.88

Transform Your Habits

The Case of the Cat Crazy Lady

Debbie De Louise

4.11

Transform Your Habits

A Villa in Sicily: Olive Oil and Murder (A Cats and Dogs Cozy Mystery #1)

Fiona Grace

3.95

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.