24 Top fantasy books like Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6) by May Sage

Cover of Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6) by May Sage

Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

By: May Sage

3.85

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

In theory, fays could live forever, but each spell they cast cost them a day of life. After three…

If you liked the fantasy plot in Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6) by May Sage , here is a list of 24 books like this:

Cover of A Quick Bite (Argeneau #1) by Lynsay Sands

1. A Quick Bite (Argeneau #1)

By: Lynsay Sands

3.91

Format: 360 pages, Mass Market Paperback

That hot guy tied to Lissianna Argeneau's bed? He's not dessert - he's the main course!Lissianna ha… read more

Similar categories in Lynsay Sands's A Quick Bite (Argeneau #1) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
"Birthdays could be such a bummer when you were older than the country you lived in."

-Lynsay Sands, A Quick Bite (Argeneau #1)

"I'm starved." -Juli "How can you be starved? You just ate a huge bowl of popcorn." -Elspeth "Popcorn isn't food, it's popcorn." -Vicki"

-Lynsay Sands, A Quick Bite (Argeneau #1)

"He was a typical workaholic, driven to succeed and willing to put in the hours to do so. It didn't leave much time for a social life. (Greg)"

-Lynsay Sands, A Quick Bite (Argeneau #1)

"Have you ever noticed how when you're happy, time seems to pass by fast, while when you're miserable it goes real slow? Life would have been a blink with you whether it lasted a millennium or a month."

-Lynsay Sands, A Quick Bite (Argeneau #1)

Cover of Go Fetch! (Magnus Pack, #2) by Shelly Laurenston

2. Go Fetch! (Magnus Pack, #2)

By: Shelly Laurenston

4.21

Format: 255 pages, ebook

How much trouble can one small female be to a modern-day shapeshifting Viking? Well…it really depen… read more

Similar categories in Shelly Laurenston's Go Fetch! (Magnus Pack, #2) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
"Okay. Fine."

-Shelly Laurenston, Go Fetch! (Magnus Pack, #2)

"Deny everything. Admit nothing. Demand proof"

-Shelly Laurenston, Go Fetch! (Magnus Pack, #2)

"Im not looking for marriage here, Zach. I just want to fuck her until one of us dies."

-Shelly Laurenston, Go Fetch! (Magnus Pack, #2)

"Well, so you don't get too cocky, I myself often complete the TV Guide crossword puzzle." He puffed out his chest. "In pen."

-Shelly Laurenston, Go Fetch! (Magnus Pack, #2)

Cover of Dark Needs at Night's Edge (Immortals After Dark #5) by Kresley Cole

3. Dark Needs at Night's Edge (Immortals After Dark #5)

By: Kresley Cole

4.33

Format: None pages, Mass Market Paperback

Bestselling author Kresley Cole continues her seductive Immortals After Dark series with this tale … read more

Similar categories in Kresley Cole's Dark Needs at Night's Edge (Immortals After Dark #5) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Fashionably Fanged (Hot Damned #8) by Robyn Peterman

4. Fashionably Fanged (Hot Damned #8)

By: Robyn Peterman

3.77

Format: 32 pages,

I have to trap the most evil, worst bad dude in existence without actually turning him to ash. So, … read more

Similar categories in Robyn Peterman's Fashionably Fanged (Hot Damned #8) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy

5. Dark Desires After Dusk (Immortals After Dark #6)

By: Kresley Cole

4.30

Format: 324 pages, Mass Market Paperback

RITA Award-winning author Kresley Cole continues her bestselling Immortals After Darkseries with th… read more

Similar categories in Kresley Cole's Dark Desires After Dusk (Immortals After Dark #6) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

6. Croc and the Fox (Furry United Coalition, #3)

By: Eve Langlais

3.33

Format: None pages, ebook

Warning: An ornery croc discovers he does have a pulse when a hot to trot fox decides to latch on, … read more

Similar categories in Eve Langlais's Croc and the Fox (Furry United Coalition, #3) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

7. Pack Challenge (Magnus Pack, #1)

By: Shelly Laurenston

4.24

Format: 200 pages, Paperback

What's an Alpha Male to do when he meets the Alpha Female of his dreams? Step one, hide all sharp o… read more

Similar categories in Shelly Laurenston's Pack Challenge (Magnus Pack, #1) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

8. Kiss of a Demon King (Immortals After Dark #7)

By: Kresley Cole

3.07

Format: None pages, Mass Market Paperback

From New York Timesbestselling author Kresley Cole comes this spellbinding story of a demon king tr… read more

Similar categories in Kresley Cole's Kiss of a Demon King (Immortals After Dark #7) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

Cover of Here Kitty, Kitty! (Magnus Pack, #3) by Shelly Laurenston

9. Here Kitty, Kitty! (Magnus Pack, #3)

By: Shelly Laurenston

4.26

Format: 308 pages, ebook

Angelina Santiago didn't think her life could get any stranger. Her best friend is a shapeshifter. … read more

Similar categories in Shelly Laurenston's Here Kitty, Kitty! (Magnus Pack, #3) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
"Dear God in heaven."

-Shelly Laurenston, Here Kitty, Kitty! (Magnus Pack, #3)

"It wasn’t until someone kicked his legs that Nik woke up. Alek, snoring beside him, his head resting on his shoulder. Ban snoring on the other couch, the noise rivaled only by the dog. He looked into…"

-Shelly Laurenston, Here Kitty, Kitty! (Magnus Pack, #3)

"The full tigers watched him silently. All females. Thankfully. He would be less than happy if he had to take on some territorial male. Well, this little adventure was only going to last through today…"

-Shelly Laurenston, Here Kitty, Kitty! (Magnus Pack, #3)

10. The Vampire's Mail Order Bride (Nocturne Falls, #1)

By: Kristen Painter

4.00

Format: None pages,

Welcome to Nocturne Falls, the town where Halloween is celebrated 365 days a year. The tourists thi… read more

Similar categories in Kristen Painter's The Vampire's Mail Order Bride (Nocturne Falls, #1) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

Cover of Watt and Bothered (Monster Between the Sheets) by Fiona Davenport

11. Watt and Bothered (Monster Between the Sheets)

By: Fiona Davenport

3.95

Format: 88 pages, Kindle Edition

Having his beloved home town turn monstrous overnight was rough for Silas Adler. Even more difficul… read more

Similar categories in Fiona Davenport's Watt and Bothered (Monster Between the Sheets) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of The Vampire's Former Flame (Nocturne Falls #16) by Kristen Painter

12. The Vampire's Former Flame (Nocturne Falls #16)

By: Kristen Painter

4.62

Format: 372 pages, Kindle Edition

Welcome to Nocturne Falls, the town where Halloween is celebrated 365 days a year. The tourists thi… read more

Similar categories in Kristen Painter's The Vampire's Former Flame (Nocturne Falls #16) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of The King's Captive (Gate of Myth and Power, #1) by K.M. Shea

13. The King's Captive (Gate of Myth and Power, #1)

By: K.M. Shea

4.29

Format: 340 pages, Kindle Edition

I can turn into a housecat. It’s a fun magic, except in a world filled with vampires and werewol… read more

Similar categories in K.M. Shea's The King's Captive (Gate of Myth and Power, #1) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
"I recognized the room from my late-night non-fiction reading adventures at Book Nookery as a 'drawing room', because family rooms were for peasants."

-K.M. Shea, The King's Captive (Gate of Myth and Power, #1)

Cover of The King's Shadow (Gates of Myth and Power, #2) by K.M. Shea

14. The King's Shadow (Gates of Myth and Power, #2)

By: K.M. Shea

4.35

Format: 362 pages, Kindle Edition

I just spent the last month pretending to be the pet cat of an elf king. Today, I discovered we’re … read more

Similar categories in K.M. Shea's The King's Shadow (Gates of Myth and Power, #2) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
"Oh shut up!"

-K.M. Shea, The King's Shadow (Gates of Myth and Power, #2)

Cover of Moon Touched (Zodiac Wolves, #1) by Elizabeth Briggs

15. Moon Touched (Zodiac Wolves, #1)

By: Elizabeth Briggs

4.12

Format: 324 pages, Kindle Edition

My fated mate rejected me—and now I've been captured by someone even worse. As the half-human ou… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Briggs's Moon Touched (Zodiac Wolves, #1) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of The Vampire's Sunny Sweetheart (Nocturne Falls, #14) by Kristen Painter

16. The Vampire's Sunny Sweetheart (Nocturne Falls, #14)

By: Kristen Painter

4.52

Format: 370 pages, Kindle Edition

Welcome to Nocturne Falls, the town where Halloween is celebrated 365 days a year. The tourists thi… read more

Similar categories in Kristen Painter's The Vampire's Sunny Sweetheart (Nocturne Falls, #14) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Miss Frost Chills the Cheater (Jayne Frost, #6) by Kristen Painter

17. Miss Frost Chills the Cheater (Jayne Frost, #6)

By: Kristen Painter

4.34

Format: 370 pages, Kindle Edition

Welcome to Nocturne Falls, the town that celebrates Halloween 365 days a year. Jayne Frost is a… read more

Similar categories in Kristen Painter's Miss Frost Chills the Cheater (Jayne Frost, #6) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Cookies for My Orc Neighbor (Sweet Monster Treats, #1) by Michele Mills

18. Cookies for My Orc Neighbor (Sweet Monster Treats, #1)

By: Michele Mills

3.77

Format: 84 pages, Kindle Edition

The big green Orc living next door to me is so very mysterious. He works from home and rarely go… read more

Similar categories in Michele Mills's Cookies for My Orc Neighbor (Sweet Monster Treats, #1) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of The King's Queen (Gate of Myth and Power, #3) by K.M. Shea

19. The King's Queen (Gate of Myth and Power, #3)

By: K.M. Shea

4.38

Format: 446 pages, Kindle Edition

When the elven king of death released me even though my existence is a threat to his kingdom, I too… read more

Similar categories in K.M. Shea's The King's Queen (Gate of Myth and Power, #3) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Fated (Pack of Dawn and Destiny, #3) by K.M. Shea

20. Fated (Pack of Dawn and Destiny, #3)

By: K.M. Shea

4.37

Format: 377 pages, Kindle Edition

I thought I hated not fitting in. Turns out I hate having a target on my back even more. Someone… read more

Similar categories in K.M. Shea's Fated (Pack of Dawn and Destiny, #3) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
"Greyson tilted his head and smirked in a way that used to kick up my self-defense instincts. “What?"

-K.M. Shea, Fated (Pack of Dawn and Destiny, #3)

Cover of How to Marry a Marble Marquis (The Monsters Ball) by C.M. Nascosta

21. How to Marry a Marble Marquis (The Monsters Ball)

By: C.M. Nascosta

3.87

Format: 216 pages, Kindle Edition

Dear Miss Eastwick, On account of the unfortunate incident involving Lord Pemberly and his valet at… read more

Similar categories in C.M. Nascosta's How to Marry a Marble Marquis (The Monsters Ball) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of United (Pack of Dawn and Destiny, #2) by K.M. Shea

22. United (Pack of Dawn and Destiny, #2)

By: K.M. Shea

4.42

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

A wolf is attacking the humans of Timber Ridge and changing them into werewolves—against their will… read more

Similar categories in K.M. Shea's United (Pack of Dawn and Destiny, #2) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Best Knight Ever (A Kinda Fairytale, #4) by Cassandra Gannon

23. Best Knight Ever (A Kinda Fairytale, #4)

By: Cassandra Gannon

4.31

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

What if a warrior fell in love with his fiercest enemy? For years, Trystan and Sir Galahad fough… read more

Similar categories in Cassandra Gannon's Best Knight Ever (A Kinda Fairytale, #4) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • retellings
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Hunted (Pack of Dawn and Destiny, #1) by K.M. Shea

24. Hunted (Pack of Dawn and Destiny, #1)

By: K.M. Shea

4.33

Format: 314 pages, Kindle Edition

Ever feel like you don’t belong? Try being a hunter living with werewolves. I’m the definition o… read more

Similar categories in K.M. Shea's Hunted (Pack of Dawn and Destiny, #1) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Candy for My Orc Boss (Monsterville, USA, #1; Sweet Monster Treats, #2) by Ava Ross

25. Candy for My Orc Boss (Monsterville, USA, #1; Sweet Monster Treats, #2)

By: Ava Ross

3.91

Format: 194 pages, Kindle Edition

A new life, a new job, a new Orc husband . . . Wait, isn’t he supposed to be my boss? After my … read more

Similar categories in Ava Ross's Candy for My Orc Boss (Monsterville, USA, #1; Sweet Monster Treats, #2) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Finding their Omega (Alpha Security Company #1) by Mina Carter

26. Finding their Omega (Alpha Security Company #1)

By: Mina Carter

3.87

Format: 77 pages, Kindle Edition

No woman wants the attention of an alpha. Huge, brutal, dominant... They take what they want, no ma… read more

Similar categories in Mina Carter's Finding their Omega (Alpha Security Company #1) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Omega’s Choice (Alpha Security Company, #5) by Mina Carter

27. Omega’s Choice (Alpha Security Company, #5)

By: Mina Carter

4.41

Format: 202 pages, Kindle Edition

No one wants the attention of an alpha. Huge, Brutal, dominant… but what happens when you’re preten… read more

Similar categories in Mina Carter's Omega’s Choice (Alpha Security Company, #5) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
Cover of Wicked Ugly Bad (A Kinda Fairytale, #1) by Cassandra Gannon

28. Wicked Ugly Bad (A Kinda Fairytale, #1)

By: Cassandra Gannon

3.97

Format: 317 pages, Kindle Edition

Once Upon a Time… Scarlett Riding is NOT an ugly stepsister. Cinderella is the evil one in the f… read more

Similar categories in Cassandra Gannon's Wicked Ugly Bad (A Kinda Fairytale, #1) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • fairy tales
  • retellings
  • paranormal romance
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
"Wonderful."

-Cassandra Gannon, Wicked Ugly Bad (A Kinda Fairytale, #1)

"Esmeralda?"

-Cassandra Gannon, Wicked Ugly Bad (A Kinda Fairytale, #1)

"Sad really."

-Cassandra Gannon, Wicked Ugly Bad (A Kinda Fairytale, #1)

"I'm going to come on the floor"

-Cassandra Gannon, Wicked Ugly Bad (A Kinda Fairytale, #1)

Cover of Beast in Shining Armor (A Kinda Fairytale, #2) by Cassandra Gannon

29. Beast in Shining Armor (A Kinda Fairytale, #2)

By: Cassandra Gannon

4.12

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

Beauty vs. Beast… Avenant is a handsome prince with a dark side. All his life, he’s been labeled… read more

Similar categories in Cassandra Gannon's Beast in Shining Armor (A Kinda Fairytale, #2) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • fairy tales
  • retellings
  • paranormal romance
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
"Are you planning to get married?' She finally asked. 'Like to someone in particular?' He shrugged. 'Aren't most marriages to someone in particular?"

-Cassandra Gannon, Beast in Shining Armor (A Kinda Fairytale, #2)

Cover of Daydreamer by Susie Tate

30. Daydreamer

By: Susie Tate

4.03

Format: 314 pages, Kindle Edition

As a scruffy, disorganised daydreamer, Lucy Mayweather is like a fish out of water at the high-powe… read more

Similar categories in Susie Tate's Daydreamer book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
Cover of Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6) by May Sage

31. Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

By: May Sage

3.85

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

In theory, fays could live forever, but each spell they cast cost them a day of life. After three… read more

Similar categories in May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6) book and May Sage's Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6)

  • romance
  • fairy tales
  • retellings
  • fairy tale retellings
  • paranormal romance
  • fantasy
  • paranormal

26 Best romance books like Rumpelstiltskin (Not Quite the Fairy Tale, #5.6) by May Sage

Transform Your Habits

A Quick Bite (Argeneau #1)

Lynsay Sands

3.91

Transform Your Habits

Go Fetch! (Magnus Pack, #2)

Shelly Laurenston

4.21

Transform Your Habits

Dark Needs at Night's Edge (Immortals After Dark #5)

Kresley Cole

4.33

Transform Your Habits

Fashionably Fanged (Hot Damned #8)

Robyn Peterman

3.77

View all the books

12 Top fantasy books like The Vampire's Former Flame (Nocturne Falls #16) by Kristen Painter

Transform Your Habits

Death at the Drive-In (Southern Ghost Hunter Mysteries, #13)

Angie Fox

4.62

Transform Your Habits

The Vampire's Former Flame (Nocturne Falls #16)

Kristen Painter

4.62

Transform Your Habits

Hellhounds and Angel Cakes (Shifters and Sweets Book 4)

Zoe Chant

4.51

Transform Your Habits

All Quiet On the Witchy Front (Wicked Witches of the Midwest #24)

Amanda M. Lee

4.70

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.