18 best-selling cozy mystery books like Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19) by Susan Page Davis

Cover of Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19) by Susan Page Davis

Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

By: Susan Page Davis

4.24

Format: 311 pages, Hardcover

Chickadee Lake is a magnet for vacationers in Lancaster's idyllic summer-especially. when people s…

If you liked the cozy mystery plot in Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19) by Susan Page Davis , here is a list of 18 books like this:

Cover of A Light in the Darkness (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #1) by Ruth Logan Herne

1. A Light in the Darkness (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #1)

By: Ruth Logan Herne

3.77

Format: None pages, Hardcover

Recently widowed Priscilla moves from Kansas back to an island just off the coast of Massachusetts.… read more

Similar categories in Ruth Logan Herne's A Light in the Darkness (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #1) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Off the Beaten Path (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #6) by Annalisa Daughety

2. Off the Beaten Path (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #6)

By: Annalisa Daughety

3.64

Format: 264 pages, Hardcover

Cheryl Cooper and Levi Miller have painstakingly planned a special "Live Like the Amish" weekend fo… read more

Similar categories in Annalisa Daughety's Off the Beaten Path (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #6) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery

3. The Buggy Before the Horse (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #3)

By: Tricia Goyer

3.86

Format: None pages, Hardcover

As Thanksgiving approaches, Cheryl stumbles across a startling discovery: someone is sleeping in Na… read more

Similar categories in Tricia Goyer's The Buggy Before the Horse (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #3) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

4. A Season of Secrets (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #4)

By: Elizabeth Adams

3.44

Format: 216 pages,

As the frenzy of the Christmas shopping season descends on the Swiss Miss, Lydia Troyer, an Amish g… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Adams's A Season of Secrets (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #4) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

5. Mason Jar Mayhem (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #10)

By: Tricia Goyer , Cara C. Putman

3.71

Format: 436 pages, Hardcover

Spring has come to Sugarcreek, and the community is rallying behind an effort to help victims of do… read more

Similar categories in Tricia Goyer's Mason Jar Mayhem (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #10) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

6. The Christmas Bus

By: Melody Carlson

3.91

Format: None pages,

The people of Christmas Valley always celebrate Christmas to the fullest extent. The mayor plays Sa… read more

Similar categories in Melody Carlson's The Christmas Bus book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

7. Shoo Fly Shoo (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #12)

By: Amy Lillard

4.45

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When Albert Yoder is arrested for illegally transporting and selling raw milk across county lines, … read more

Similar categories in Amy Lillard's Shoo Fly Shoo (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #12) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

8. Simply Vanished (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #8)

By: Nancy Mehl

3.67

Format: 208 pages, Hardcover

As Cheryl Cooper's birthday approaches, she believes her new life in Sugarcreek, Ohio, is the best … read more

Similar categories in Nancy Mehl's Simply Vanished (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #8) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

Cover of Neighbors by Danielle Steel

9. Neighbors

By: Danielle Steel

4.13

Format: 270 pages, Kindle Edition

Meredith White was one of Hollywood’s most recognizable faces. But a personal tragedy cut her actin… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Steel's Neighbors book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

"The women who are being abused stay for the sake of the children, to not break up the family, and what the children go through as a result is worse than any divorce, and damages them far more than if…"

-Danielle Steel, Neighbors

Cover of Stalking Around the Christmas Tree (A Christmas Tree Farm Mystery, #4) by Jacqueline Frost

10. Stalking Around the Christmas Tree (A Christmas Tree Farm Mystery, #4)

By: Jacqueline Frost

4.06

Format: 288 pages, Hardcover

Tis the season to solve a murder—and innkeeper Holly White knows she’ll have to make her list and c… read more

Similar categories in Jacqueline Frost's Stalking Around the Christmas Tree (A Christmas Tree Farm Mystery, #4) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of The President's Daughter by Bill Clinton

11. The President's Daughter

By: Bill Clinton

4.27

Format: 594 pages, Hardcover

There's a new administration in the White House. But it's the previous First Family who tops an int… read more

Similar categories in Bill Clinton's The President's Daughter book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

Cover of Adrift (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #3) by Beth Adams

12. Adrift (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #3)

By: Beth Adams

3.91

Format: 278 pages, Hardcover

Captain Gerald reports to Priscilla that an abandoned houseboat, which had been moored anonymously … read more

Similar categories in Beth Adams's Adrift (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #3) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

Cover of Wider Than An Ocean (#19 Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard) by Beth Adams

13. Wider Than An Ocean (#19 Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard)

By: Beth Adams

3.77

Format: 279 pages, Hardcover

When Priscilla sees a small plane go down over the marsh, she immediately calls 911. But the author… read more

Similar categories in Beth Adams's Wider Than An Ocean (#19 Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Smoke on the Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #11) by Beth Adams

14. Smoke on the Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #11)

By: Beth Adams

4.30

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When Priscilla’s lighthouse is set ablaze, she launches her own arson investigation. Her search for… read more

Similar categories in Beth Adams's Smoke on the Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #11) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13) by Cara C. Putman

15. Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

By: Cara C. Putman

3.98

Format: 262 pages, Hardcover

As the annual Martha’s Vineyard International Film Festival is set to begin, Priscilla accompanies … read more

Similar categories in Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Shifting Sands (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #12) by Elizabeth Ludwig

16. Shifting Sands (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #12)

By: Elizabeth Ludwig

4.15

Format: None pages, Hardcover

The summer tourist season is in full swing, and Priscilla Latham Grant is enjoying the visitors to … read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Ludwig's Shifting Sands (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #12) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Making Waves (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #5) by Tricia Goyer

17. Making Waves (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #5)

By: Tricia Goyer

4.09

Format: 269 pages, Hardcover

When a Congressional Medal belonging to World War II veteran Deanie Spangler goes missing at her hu… read more

Similar categories in Tricia Goyer's Making Waves (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #5) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Sheeps Passing in the Night (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #20) by Elizabeth Ludwig

18. Sheeps Passing in the Night (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #20)

By: Elizabeth Ludwig

3.84

Format: None pages, Hardcover

It’s springtime in Martha’s Vineyard, and Priscilla attends the annual Lambapalooza festival going … read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Ludwig's Sheeps Passing in the Night (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #20) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Beyond the Sea (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #18) by Janice  Thompson

19. Beyond the Sea (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #18)

By: Janice Thompson

4.06

Format: 280 pages, Hardcover

Priscilla is thrilled when her friend Eliza Jamison solicits her help with a special surprise weddi… read more

Similar categories in Janice Thompson's Beyond the Sea (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #18) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Storm Tide (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard) by Elizabeth Penney

20. Storm Tide (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard)

By: Elizabeth Penney

4.00

Format: None pages, Hardcover

Another entry in this series from Guideposts. Priscilla Latham Grant, and her cousin discover a wom… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Penney's Storm Tide (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of A Port in the Storm (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #7) by Elizabeth Penney

21. A Port in the Storm (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #7)

By: Elizabeth Penney

4.14

Format: 265 pages, Hardcover

Martha’s Vineyard is buried in snow. As Priscilla’s first winter in the cottage drags on and snow c… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Penney's A Port in the Storm (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #7) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Don't Rock the Boat (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #6) by Elizabeth Ludwig

22. Don't Rock the Boat (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #6)

By: Elizabeth Ludwig

3.89

Format: 255 pages, Hardcover

Priscilla is adjusting to her new life on Martha’s Vineyard. She loves waking each day to the sound… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Ludwig's Don't Rock the Boat (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #6) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

Cover of The Ties That Bind (Mysteries of Lancaster #7) by Janice  Thompson

23. The Ties That Bind (Mysteries of Lancaster #7)

By: Janice Thompson

4.23

Format: None pages, None

The Ties That Bind is the 7th book in the Mysteries of Lancaster County mystery fiction series. … read more

Similar categories in Janice Thompson's The Ties That Bind (Mysteries of Lancaster #7) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

Cover of Do You See What I See? by Vera Dodge

24. Do You See What I See?

By: Vera Dodge

4.46

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

January arrives in Lancaster, and the whole town is fascinated by a serialized mystery story runnin… read more

Similar categories in Vera Dodge's Do You See What I See? book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

Cover of Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19) by Susan Page Davis

25. Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

By: Susan Page Davis

4.24

Format: 311 pages, Hardcover

Chickadee Lake is a magnet for vacationers in Lancaster's idyllic summer-especially. when people s… read more

Similar categories in Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Mixed Signals (Mysteries of Lancaster County #4) by Beth Adams

26. Mixed Signals (Mysteries of Lancaster County #4)

By: Beth Adams

3.89

Format: None pages, None

Mysteries of Lancaster Mixed Signals by Beth Adams. read more

Similar categories in Beth Adams's Mixed Signals (Mysteries of Lancaster County #4) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Maiden of the Mist (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #4) by Nancy Mehl

27. Maiden of the Mist (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #4)

By: Nancy Mehl

4.05

Format: 274 pages, Hardcover

As autumn leaves and cooler temperatures fall on Martha’s Vineyard, Priscilla finally seems to be f… read more

Similar categories in Nancy Mehl's Maiden of the Mist (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #4) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Thicker than Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #8) by DeAnna Julie Dodson

28. Thicker than Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #8)

By: DeAnna Julie Dodson

4.05

Format: 282 pages, Hardcover

When Priscilla runs into long-time friend Kitty Merrick, mystery starts to unfold. Kitty has just a… read more

Similar categories in DeAnna Julie Dodson's Thicker than Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #8) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Water Flows Uphill (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #16) by DeAnna Julie Dodson

29. Water Flows Uphill (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #16)

By: DeAnna Julie Dodson

3.93

Format: 268 pages, Hardcover

It's Christmas and Priscilla wants to find the perfect gifts for her friends and family. At a local… read more

Similar categories in DeAnna Julie Dodson's Water Flows Uphill (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #16) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Bridge over Troubled Waters (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #10) by Janice  Thompson

30. Bridge over Troubled Waters (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #10)

By: Janice Thompson

4.15

Format: None pages, Hardcover

In the throes of a rough election season, the wife of the town’s slyest, most-reelected politician … read more

Similar categories in Janice Thompson's Bridge over Troubled Waters (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #10) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

Cover of Swept Away (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #9) by Ruth Logan Herne

31. Swept Away (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #9)

By: Ruth Logan Herne

4.15

Format: 291 pages, Hardcover

The arrival of a Hollywood film crew revives memories of three dramatic events in Martha’s Vineyard… read more

Similar categories in Ruth Logan Herne's Swept Away (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #9) book and Susan Page Davis's Beneath the Surface (Tearoom Mysteries, #19)

  • cozy mystery

8 must-read mystery books like Adrift (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #3) by Beth Adams

Transform Your Habits

Nobody's Safe (Mysteries of Silver Peak #2)

Carole Jefferson

4.37

Transform Your Habits

The Bounty (Fox and O'Hare, #7)

Janet Evanovich

3.98

Transform Your Habits

Wildfire (Mysteries of Silver Peak #4)

Carole Jefferson

4.20

Transform Your Habits

Adrift (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #3)

Beth Adams

3.91

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.