23 Top fiction books like It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1) by Grace J. Croy

Cover of It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1) by Grace J. Croy

It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

By: Grace J. Croy

3.96

Format: 300 pages, Kindle Edition

She’s alone and pregnant. He’s been burned by relationships in the past. Pretending to date might b…

If you liked the fiction plot in It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1) by Grace J. Croy , here is a list of 23 books like this:

1. A Longtime -and at one point illegal- Crush

By: Janette Rallison

3.88

Format: 373 pages, ebook

From the day Elsie's older brother brought his friend Kye McBride over to their house, Elsie adored… read more

Similar categories in Janette Rallison's A Longtime -and at one point illegal- Crush book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

Cover of A Groom of One's Own (Appies, #3) by Emma St. Clair

2. A Groom of One's Own (Appies, #3)

By: Emma St. Clair

4.23

Format: 368 pages, Kindle Edition

He always dreamed of getting married—but for love, not to avoid deportation. Eli Hopkins has i… read more

Similar categories in Emma St. Clair's A Groom of One's Own (Appies, #3) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Betrothal or Breakaway (D.C. Eagles Hockey, #3) by Leah Brunner

3. Betrothal or Breakaway (D.C. Eagles Hockey, #3)

By: Leah Brunner

4.16

Format: 320 pages, Kindle Edition

My best friend—and unrequited love—has a hole in her heart. Literally and figuratively. First, A… read more

Similar categories in Leah Brunner's Betrothal or Breakaway (D.C. Eagles Hockey, #3) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Absolutely Not in Love (Sweater Weather, #7; Appies, #2) by Jenny Proctor

4. Absolutely Not in Love (Sweater Weather, #7; Appies, #2)

By: Jenny Proctor

4.26

Format: 326 pages, Kindle Edition

My requirements for a man are simple. Must love books. Must NOT love hockey. Which is why I wil… read more

Similar categories in Jenny Proctor's Absolutely Not in Love (Sweater Weather, #7; Appies, #2) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
"My parents did a lot of things right, but they didn’t always talk to me like my thoughts were important, especially since they were so frequently different from their own. Josh got lucky. He loves ho…"

-Jenny Proctor, Absolutely Not in Love (Sweater Weather, #7; Appies, #2)

Cover of Fake Dating the Football Player (Most Likely To #4) by Sarah   Sutton

5. Fake Dating the Football Player (Most Likely To #4)

By: Sarah Sutton

4.30

Format: 458 pages, Kindle Edition

Ever since I was little, I’ve dreamt of being able to leave Brentwood in the rearview mirror. And a… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Sutton's Fake Dating the Football Player (Most Likely To #4) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Can't Help Falling (Sweater Weather, #3) by Courtney Walsh

6. Can't Help Falling (Sweater Weather, #3)

By: Courtney Walsh

4.17

Format: 360 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes all it takes to start a fire is a single match. . . Owen Larrabee is not my soulmate. … read more

Similar categories in Courtney Walsh's Can't Help Falling (Sweater Weather, #3) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
"This town has. . .uh. . .never been very high on me, Captain,"

-Courtney Walsh, Can't Help Falling (Sweater Weather, #3)

"Listen. I know it sounds crazy. But this stuff works, Larrabee,"

-Courtney Walsh, Can't Help Falling (Sweater Weather, #3)

"Peggy is all Rachel Lynde from Anne of Green Gables. She’s blunt and assuming and in everybody’s business."

-Courtney Walsh, Can't Help Falling (Sweater Weather, #3)

"Ooh, what about making you look like a 1950’s pinup girl? Because I actually think you could rock a red lip."

-Courtney Walsh, Can't Help Falling (Sweater Weather, #3)

Cover of Loving the Ladies' Man  (California Dreamin' #1) by Kristin Canary

7. Loving the Ladies' Man (California Dreamin' #1)

By: Kristin Canary

3.78

Format: 244 pages, Kindle Edition

Connor is the last guy in the world I should fall for. He's the resident office flirt. I'm the quir… read more

Similar categories in Kristin Canary's Loving the Ladies' Man (California Dreamin' #1) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Easy as Pie (Sweater Weather, #5) by Carina Taylor

8. Easy as Pie (Sweater Weather, #5)

By: Carina Taylor

3.93

Format: 242 pages, Kindle Edition

My best friend is back in town—and I refuse to let my pesky attraction to him ruin our friendship. … read more

Similar categories in Carina Taylor's Easy as Pie (Sweater Weather, #5) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of How to Kiss Your Best Friend (Hawthorne Brothers #1) by Jenny Proctor

9. How to Kiss Your Best Friend (Hawthorne Brothers #1)

By: Jenny Proctor

3.88

Format: 309 pages, Kindle Edition

He’s a hot high school chemistry teacher living in a small town. She’s a globetrotting journalist r… read more

Similar categories in Jenny Proctor's How to Kiss Your Best Friend (Hawthorne Brothers #1) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
"Tacos first, then diamonds"

-Jenny Proctor, How to Kiss Your Best Friend (Hawthorne Brothers #1)

Cover of A Not So Fictional Fall (Sweater Weather, #6) by Savannah Scott

10. A Not So Fictional Fall (Sweater Weather, #6)

By: Savannah Scott

4.18

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

I live for happily ever afters. And I'm finally meeting my favorite romance author in person! O… read more

Similar categories in Savannah Scott's A Not So Fictional Fall (Sweater Weather, #6) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
"You’ve known him, what? A week? Don’t tell me you’re considering this."

-Savannah Scott, A Not So Fictional Fall (Sweater Weather, #6)

"Tasha, my friend. You have become the one person I can count on to be honest with me here in the states. You support me without any hidden motives. You have made me laugh more than I thought I could.…"

-Savannah Scott, A Not So Fictional Fall (Sweater Weather, #6)

Cover of Anything That You Want (Anything #1) by Mary Carson

11. Anything That You Want (Anything #1)

By: Mary Carson

3.71

Format: 251 pages, Kindle Edition

He’s the hot owner of a home construction business who wants to build a family. I’m the Doctor o… read more

Similar categories in Mary Carson's Anything That You Want (Anything #1) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Falling for Prince Charming  (That Wilson Charm #1) by Sophie-Leigh Robbins

12. Falling for Prince Charming (That Wilson Charm #1)

By: Sophie-Leigh Robbins

3.51

Format: 237 pages, Kindle Edition

Falling for your best friend’s brother is tricky… unless you’re keeping it a secret. Elle I n… read more

Similar categories in Sophie-Leigh Robbins's Falling for Prince Charming (That Wilson Charm #1) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Falling in Line (Arcadia Creek, #2) by Kasey Stockton

13. Falling in Line (Arcadia Creek, #2)

By: Kasey Stockton

4.12

Format: 338 pages, Kindle Edition

Break my heart once, shame on you. Break my heart twice? Nope. Not gonna let that happen.Tucker’s h… read more

Similar categories in Kasey Stockton's Falling in Line (Arcadia Creek, #2) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Love on Deck (Arcadia Creek, #1) by Kasey Stockton

14. Love on Deck (Arcadia Creek, #1)

By: Kasey Stockton

3.91

Format: 314 pages, Paperback

He calls it fake dating, but she calls it being caught between the devil and the deep blue sea. Lau… read more

Similar categories in Kasey Stockton's Love on Deck (Arcadia Creek, #1) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Keep It Together (Sworn to Loathe You #4) by Rachel John

15. Keep It Together (Sworn to Loathe You #4)

By: Rachel John

4.17

Format: 239 pages, Kindle Edition

It's not awkward unless we make it awkward. Carmen... I’ve forgiven Isaac for being a jerk to m… read more

Similar categories in Rachel John's Keep It Together (Sworn to Loathe You #4) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary
Cover of No More Horrible Dates (High Tea #3) by Kate O'Keeffe

16. No More Horrible Dates (High Tea #3)

By: Kate O'Keeffe

4.12

Format: 247 pages, Kindle Edition

What do you do when you want to find your happily ever after, but you're stuck in a fake relationsh… read more

Similar categories in Kate O'Keeffe's No More Horrible Dates (High Tea #3) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of The Art of Falling in Love with Your Best Friend by Anne Kemp

17. The Art of Falling in Love with Your Best Friend

By: Anne Kemp

3.82

Format: 210 pages, Kindle Edition

All’s fair in love and war…until you set up the man you love with another woman. The realization … read more

Similar categories in Anne Kemp's The Art of Falling in Love with Your Best Friend book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Meeting at the Altar (Brothers of Lucky Seven Ranch, #3) by Kristine W. Joy

18. Meeting at the Altar (Brothers of Lucky Seven Ranch, #3)

By: Kristine W. Joy

3.90

Format: 205 pages, Kindle Edition

I signed up to marry a stranger on reality TV. Turns out, the bride is someone I know. And I'm pret… read more

Similar categories in Kristine W. Joy's Meeting at the Altar (Brothers of Lucky Seven Ranch, #3) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Coming Home (Highland Falls #1) by Kat  Ryan

19. Coming Home (Highland Falls #1)

By: Kat Ryan

3.51

Format: 392 pages, Kindle Edition

Now that her brother’s best friend has moved back to their quirky small town, will this shy librari… read more

Similar categories in Kat Ryan's Coming Home (Highland Falls #1) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of How to Find Love When You're Weird (How to Rom-com #5) by Camilla Evergreen

20. How to Find Love When You're Weird (How to Rom-com #5)

By: Camilla Evergreen

4.43

Format: 344 pages, Paperback

I am a perfectly functional adult. So why is it so hard to get a date? When my father decided la… read more

Similar categories in Camilla Evergreen's How to Find Love When You're Weird (How to Rom-com #5) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Best Friends Backups & Something More (LA Rays, #1) by Ranee S. Clark

21. Best Friends Backups & Something More (LA Rays, #1)

By: Ranee S. Clark

3.86

Format: 123 pages, Kindle Edition

A sweet sports romance inspired by Jane Austen’s Sense & Sensibility . If “best friends at firs… read more

Similar categories in Ranee S. Clark's Best Friends Backups & Something More (LA Rays, #1) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Two Last First Dates (Cozy Cottage Café, #2) by Kate O'Keeffe

22. Two Last First Dates (Cozy Cottage Café, #2)

By: Kate O'Keeffe

4.05

Format: 232 pages, Kindle Edition

To Paige Miller Two Last First Dates sounds like a disaster waiting to happen. Paige is having a… read more

Similar categories in Kate O'Keeffe's Two Last First Dates (Cozy Cottage Café, #2) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of It's Always Sonny (Sweet as Sugar Maple #3) by Kate  Watson

23. It's Always Sonny (Sweet as Sugar Maple #3)

By: Kate Watson

4.26

Format: 328 pages, Kindle Edition

Sunshine always melts ice eventually. And I’m starting to feel the burn. People may call me an “… read more

Similar categories in Kate Watson's It's Always Sonny (Sweet as Sugar Maple #3) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Baby Llama Drama (Sweet as Sugar Maple #2) by Kate  Watson

24. Baby Llama Drama (Sweet as Sugar Maple #2)

By: Kate Watson

3.96

Format: 306 pages, Kindle Edition

Embittered single dad Duke has sworn off love forever. Unfortunately, his daughter just met the mot… read more

Similar categories in Kate Watson's Baby Llama Drama (Sweet as Sugar Maple #2) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Strawberry Fields for Never (Sweet as Sugar Maple #1) by Kate  Watson

25. Strawberry Fields for Never (Sweet as Sugar Maple #1)

By: Kate Watson

4.15

Format: 282 pages, Kindle Edition

She’s the desperate CEO hired to rebrand a sleepy Southern orchard. He’s the stubborn heir determin… read more

Similar categories in Kate Watson's Strawberry Fields for Never (Sweet as Sugar Maple #1) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1) by Grace J. Croy

26. It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

By: Grace J. Croy

3.96

Format: 300 pages, Kindle Edition

She’s alone and pregnant. He’s been burned by relationships in the past. Pretending to date might b… read more

Similar categories in Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Runaway Bride and Prejudice (Appies, #5) by Emma St. Clair

27. Runaway Bride and Prejudice (Appies, #5)

By: Emma St. Clair

4.46

Format: 418 pages, Kindle Edition

There's one rule smart hockey players know not to break: never, and I mean, NEVER date the coach's … read more

Similar categories in Emma St. Clair's Runaway Bride and Prejudice (Appies, #5) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Don't Go Faking My Heart (Sweet as Sugar Maple #4) by Kate  Watson

28. Don't Go Faking My Heart (Sweet as Sugar Maple #4)

By: Kate Watson

4.57

Format: 348 pages, Kindle Edition

It should be a match made in heaven, except she’s only attracted to jerks, and he’s a cinnamon roll… read more

Similar categories in Kate Watson's Don't Go Faking My Heart (Sweet as Sugar Maple #4) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of The Parlor Game: A Regency Romance (Noble Charades Book 3) by Ashtyn Newbold

29. The Parlor Game: A Regency Romance (Noble Charades Book 3)

By: Ashtyn Newbold

4.59

Format: 309 pages, Kindle Edition

Love might be the most dangerous game of all.  After enduring a loveless marriage, Anne, the wid… read more

Similar categories in Ashtyn Newbold's The Parlor Game: A Regency Romance (Noble Charades Book 3) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
Cover of Raise the Bar by K.M. Gillis

30. Raise the Bar

By: K.M. Gillis

4.13

Format: 295 pages, ebook

Sometimes the reward is worth the risk. Maggie Morales is a woman on a mission. She’s ended a t… read more

Similar categories in K.M. Gillis's Raise the Bar book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Love Burns: Lake Hill Mini Series: A Second Chance Firefighter Short Small Town Romance (Second Chances Are Forever Book 3) by Ada Beck

31. Love Burns: Lake Hill Mini Series: A Second Chance Firefighter Short Small Town Romance (Second Chances Are Forever Book 3)

By: Ada Beck

2.89

Format: 39 pages, Kindle Edition

One small town, cinnamon roll firefighter + One former best friend back after moving away with a si… read more

Similar categories in Ada Beck's Love Burns: Lake Hill Mini Series: A Second Chance Firefighter Short Small Town Romance (Second Chances Are Forever Book 3) book and Grace J. Croy's It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1)

  • romance

28 must-read contemporary books like It's Not Like It's a Secret (It Must Be Love #1) by Grace J. Croy

Transform Your Habits

A Groom of One's Own (Appies, #3)

Emma St. Clair

4.23

Transform Your Habits

Betrothal or Breakaway (D.C. Eagles Hockey, #3)

Leah Brunner

4.16

Transform Your Habits

Absolutely Not in Love (Sweater Weather, #7; Appies, #2)

Jenny Proctor

4.26

Transform Your Habits

Fake Dating the Football Player (Most Likely To #4)

Sarah Sutton

4.30

View all the books

22 Top fiction books like Falling for Prince Charming (That Wilson Charm #1) by Sophie-Leigh Robbins

Transform Your Habits

All of Me (Starlight Hill, #1)

Heatherly Bell

4.20

Transform Your Habits

Turn Up the Heat (Pine Mountain, #1)

Kimberly Kincaid

3.85

Transform Your Habits

The Cupcake Cottage (Hockey Sweethearts, #1)

Jean Oram

3.47

Transform Your Habits

Driving the Billionaire (Sweet & Swoonworthy Billionaires, #1)

Laurie Baxter

4.09

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.