16 Top mystery books like Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England by Avree Kelly Clark

Cover of Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England by Avree Kelly Clark

Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

By: Avree Kelly Clark

4.38

Format: 420 pages, Paperback

2024 Eric Hoffer First Horizon Award winner for best debut novel. In the summer of 1874, a bel…

If you liked the mystery plot in Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England by Avree Kelly Clark , here is a list of 16 books like this:

Cover of Black Like Me by John Howard Griffin

1. Black Like Me

By: John Howard Griffin

4.11

Format: 208 pages, Paperback

In the Deep South of the 1950s, journalist John Howard Griffin decided to cross the color line. Usi… read more

Similar categories in John Howard Griffin's Black Like Me book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • nonfiction
  • history
"Now you go into oblivion."

-John Howard Griffin, Black Like Me

"We need a conversion of morals,"

-John Howard Griffin, Black Like Me

"Night coming tenderly Black like me."

-John Howard Griffin, Black Like Me

"In the context of today, this WAS heroism."

-John Howard Griffin, Black Like Me

2. Mrs. Poe

By: Lynn Cullen

3.79

Format: 160 pages, Hardcover

A vivid and compelling novel about a woman who becomes entangled in an affair with Edgar Allan Poe-… read more

Similar categories in Lynn Cullen's Mrs. Poe book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

3. The Physick Book of Deliverance Dane

By: Katherine Howe

4.00

Format: None pages, Hardcover

A spellbinding, beautifully written novel that moves between contemporary times and one of the most… read more

Similar categories in Katherine Howe's The Physick Book of Deliverance Dane book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

Cover of In the Midnight Rain by Barbara O'Neal

4. In the Midnight Rain

By: Barbara O'Neal

4.37

Format: 318 pages, Kindle Edition

Two converging mysteries compel a woman’s search for the truth in a captivating novel about loss, l… read more

Similar categories in Barbara O'Neal's In the Midnight Rain book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
Cover of The Princess of Las Vegas by Chris Bohjalian

5. The Princess of Las Vegas

By: Chris Bohjalian

3.53

Format: 400 pages, Hardcover

A Princess Diana impersonator and her estranged sister find themselves drawn into a dangerous game … read more

Similar categories in Chris Bohjalian's The Princess of Las Vegas book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
Cover of The Frozen River by Ariel Lawhon

6. The Frozen River

By: Ariel Lawhon

4.43

Format: 432 pages, Hardcover

A gripping historical mystery inspired by the life and diary of Martha Ballard, a renowned 18th-cen… read more

Similar categories in Ariel Lawhon's The Frozen River book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • historical
Cover of Extinction by Douglas Preston

7. Extinction

By: Douglas Preston

4.14

Format: 370 pages, Hardcover

Erebus Resort, occupying a magnificent, hundred-thousand–acre valley deep in the Colorado Rockies, … read more

Similar categories in Douglas Preston's Extinction book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
"If something can be done, it will be done-no matter how dangerous."

-Douglas Preston, Extinction

"Extinction is the rule. Survival is the exception." Carl Sagan, in Extinction by Douglas Preston"

-Douglas Preston, Extinction

"You actually think we want to be like you? You Sapiens, with your bleak and apocalyptic history? What a grim and self-loathing species you are! Look at what you worship as progress. The agricultural …"

-Douglas Preston, Extinction

Cover of The Main Character by Jaclyn Goldis

8. The Main Character

By: Jaclyn Goldis

3.37

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

A bestselling thriller author arranges a luxury train trip that is not what it appears to be in thi… read more

Similar categories in Jaclyn Goldis's The Main Character book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
Cover of The Sweet Blue Distance by Sara Donati

9. The Sweet Blue Distance

By: Sara Donati

4.31

Format: 800 pages, Hardcover

In 1857 a young midwife braves the perilous journey west from New York City to Santa Fe, New Mexico… read more

Similar categories in Sara Donati's The Sweet Blue Distance book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • historical
Cover of One Puzzling Afternoon by Emily   Critchley

10. One Puzzling Afternoon

By: Emily Critchley

3.86

Format: 350 pages, Paperback

A mystery she can't remember. A friend she can't forget. I kept your secret Lucy. I've kept it f… read more

Similar categories in Emily Critchley's One Puzzling Afternoon book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • historical
Cover of By Any Other Name by Jodi Picoult

11. By Any Other Name

By: Jodi Picoult

4.19

Format: 528 pages, Kindle Edition

From the New York Times bestselling co-author of Mad Honey comes an “inspiring” (Elle) novel about … read more

Similar categories in Jodi Picoult's By Any Other Name book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • historical
Cover of Scorpions (Never Tell Collection, #4) by Rachel Howzell Hall

12. Scorpions (Never Tell Collection, #4)

By: Rachel Howzell Hall

3.36

Format: 49 pages, Kindle Edition

A man’s lifetime of secrets and lies. A woman on the hunt for his hidden riches. But there’s a stin… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Howzell Hall's Scorpions (Never Tell Collection, #4) book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
Cover of An American Beauty by Shana Abe

13. An American Beauty

By: Shana Abe

4.15

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

This sweeping novel of historical fiction is inspired by the true rags-to-riches story of Arabella … read more

Similar categories in Shana Abe's An American Beauty book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • historical
Cover of Canary Girls by Jennifer Chiaverini

14. Canary Girls

By: Jennifer Chiaverini

4.04

Format: 417 pages, Paperback

Rosie the Riveter meets A League of Their Own in New York Times bestselling novelist Jennifer Chiav… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Chiaverini's Canary Girls book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • historical
Cover of Before and After by Judy Christie

15. Before and After

By: Judy Christie

3.98

Format: 320 pages, Hardcover

7 hours, 57 minutes The incredible, poignant true stories of victims of a notorious adoption sca… read more

Similar categories in Judy Christie's Before and After book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • historical
  • nonfiction
  • history
  • true crime
Cover of Not You It's Me (Boston Love, #1) by Julie   Johnson

16. Not You It's Me (Boston Love, #1)

By: Julie Johnson

3.89

Format: 428 pages, Kindle Edition

Gemma Summers is unlucky in love. She’s known it since third grade, when her first crush blew a … read more

Similar categories in Julie Johnson's Not You It's Me (Boston Love, #1) book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

"Take a risk on messy. Live Fearlessly. Love recklessly. Most of all, just love."

-Julie Johnson, Not You It's Me (Boston Love, #1)

"When you start to fall, don't try to talk yourself out of it. The right man will be there at the bottom, to catch you."

-Julie Johnson, Not You It's Me (Boston Love, #1)

"Of all the people in the world who could've won the seat next to mine at that playoff game... it was you, Gemma. You. The one person on the planet who might just understand me."

-Julie Johnson, Not You It's Me (Boston Love, #1)

"The way I see it, everyone’s been telling the story wrong. I mean, take Cinderella, for example. She never asked for a Prince, let alone waited around for one. Hell, all she ever wanted was a night o…"

-Julie Johnson, Not You It's Me (Boston Love, #1)

Cover of Dear Sister: A Memoir of Secrets, Survival, and Unbreakable Bonds by Michelle Horton

17. Dear Sister: A Memoir of Secrets, Survival, and Unbreakable Bonds

By: Michelle Horton

4.52

Format: 352 pages, Hardcover

A breathtaking memoir about two sisters and a high-profile Nikki Addimando, incarcerated for killi… read more

Similar categories in Michelle Horton's Dear Sister: A Memoir of Secrets, Survival, and Unbreakable Bonds book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • nonfiction
  • true crime
Cover of The Family Gathering (Sullivan's Crossing, #3) by Robyn Carr

18. The Family Gathering (Sullivan's Crossing, #3)

By: Robyn Carr

4.21

Format: 352 pages, Hardcover

An exceptional storyteller, #1 New York Times bestselling author Robyn Carr beautifully captures th… read more

Similar categories in Robyn Carr's The Family Gathering (Sullivan's Crossing, #3) book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

"It's not what you get in life that will make you whole, but what you give."

-Robyn Carr, The Family Gathering (Sullivan's Crossing, #3)

Cover of Our Woman in Moscow by Beatriz Williams

19. Our Woman in Moscow

By: Beatriz Williams

4.06

Format: 437 pages, Hardcover

The New York Times bestselling author of Her Last Flight returns with a gripping and profoundly hum… read more

Similar categories in Beatriz Williams's Our Woman in Moscow book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • historical
"Ruth, I spent most of my life just trying to be safe. Trying to hide from what scared me. Letting other people control what happened to me. Then I realized the idea of safety itself is just a delusio…"

-Beatriz Williams, Our Woman in Moscow

"...humans are corrupt. We are all of us selfish, ignorant beasts, loyal only to ourselves and our own kind, interested only in getting a leg up on others, whether it's money or status or moral virtue…"

-Beatriz Williams, Our Woman in Moscow

"A man had appeared out of nowhere—a thick-shouldered, square-jawed, cleft-chinned all- American of a type Iris hadn’t seen in years. He showed her some friendly white teeth and continued in a slow co…"

-Beatriz Williams, Our Woman in Moscow

"[In marriage you] go through stages, like acts in a play. Act One, you fall in love, and the birds twitter and the bees go buzz, and you'll never love somebody else as long as you both shall live, am…"

-Beatriz Williams, Our Woman in Moscow

Cover of The Last Beekeeper by Julie Carrick Dalton

20. The Last Beekeeper

By: Julie Carrick Dalton

3.95

Format: 384 pages, Hardcover

Julie Carrick Dalton's The Last Beekeeper is a celebration of found family, an exploration of truth… read more

Similar categories in Julie Carrick Dalton's The Last Beekeeper book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

Cover of Shelterwood by Lisa Wingate

21. Shelterwood

By: Lisa Wingate

3.88

Format: 368 pages, Hardcover

A sweeping novel inspired by the untold history of women pioneers who fought to protect children ca… read more

Similar categories in Lisa Wingate's Shelterwood book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • historical
"What lucky people we readers are that we live not just one life, but many, and diving into yet another is as easy as opening a book."

-Lisa Wingate, Shelterwood

"That was a perilous area. . .Graves could be anywhere and undoubtedly are. We walk over history, unaware, every day in all places. We sleep atop it. When we rest our heads at night, we've no way of k…"

-Lisa Wingate, Shelterwood

"The light between them outshines the November day. My heartstrings tug, and I want to call my mother and my grandmother, the women who built me - who implanted the idea that whatever path I chose for…"

-Lisa Wingate, Shelterwood

"I take a deep breath, lose myself in the healing power of feeling the world breathe, water over stones, wind against trees, last year's dry leaves tumbling along expanses of rock, in the play of clou…"

-Lisa Wingate, Shelterwood

Cover of Cross the Line (Boston Love, #2) by Julie   Johnson

22. Cross the Line (Boston Love, #2)

By: Julie Johnson

4.00

Format: 374 pages, Kindle Edition

Phoebe West has been head-over-heels in love with her brother’s best friend for as long as she can … read more

Similar categories in Julie Johnson's Cross the Line (Boston Love, #2) book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

"Nate and me... we aren't built for truces, for good times, for light jokes and giggles. We're meant for the shadows. For the dirty, ugly, secret parts of our souls, the parts we can't hide because we…"

-Julie Johnson, Cross the Line (Boston Love, #2)

Cover of Incidents Around the House by Josh Malerman

23. Incidents Around the House

By: Josh Malerman

3.82

Format: 371 pages, Hardcover

A chilling horror novel about a haunting told from the perspective of a young girl whose troubled f… read more

Similar categories in Josh Malerman's Incidents Around the House book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
Cover of All the Colors of the Dark by Chris  Whitaker

24. All the Colors of the Dark

By: Chris Whitaker

4.44

Format: 608 pages, Hardcover

From the New York Times bestselling author of We Begin at the End comes a soaring thriller and an e… read more

Similar categories in Chris Whitaker's All the Colors of the Dark book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
Cover of Killing Me by Michelle Gagnon

25. Killing Me

By: Michelle Gagnon

3.88

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

Amber Jamison cannot believe she's about to become the latest victim of a serial killer-she's savvy… read more

Similar categories in Michelle Gagnon's Killing Me book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
Cover of Pitch Dark (Mike Bowditch, #15) by Paul Doiron

26. Pitch Dark (Mike Bowditch, #15)

By: Paul Doiron

4.27

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

Game Warden Mike Bowditch must chase down a cunning and dangerous fugitive in the North Maine Woods… read more

Similar categories in Paul Doiron's Pitch Dark (Mike Bowditch, #15) book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
Cover of Paradise of the Damned: The True Story of an Obsessive Quest for El Dorado, the Legendary City of Gold by Keith Thomson

27. Paradise of the Damned: The True Story of an Obsessive Quest for El Dorado, the Legendary City of Gold

By: Keith Thomson

3.80

Format: 400 pages, Hardcover

The transporting account of an obsessive quest to find El Dorado, set against the backdrop of Eliza… read more

Similar categories in Keith Thomson's Paradise of the Damned: The True Story of an Obsessive Quest for El Dorado, the Legendary City of Gold book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • historical
  • nonfiction
  • history
Cover of The Briar Club by Kate Quinn

28. The Briar Club

By: Kate Quinn

4.35

Format: 432 pages, Hardcover

A haunting and powerful story of female friendships and secrets in a Washington, D.C. boardinghouse… read more

Similar categories in Kate Quinn's The Briar Club book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • historical
"You can't call yourself a proper home without the regular smell of good food..."

-Kate Quinn, The Briar Club

"And guilt roiled in his stomach because he wanted to love his mother, and sometimes what pulsed through him came horribly close to hate."

-Kate Quinn, The Briar Club

"Be selfish, stick to the plan Claire had clung to since she was 16. Look out for herself and no one else, because love was for suckers and happiness meant a well-stocked bank account and a house you …"

-Kate Quinn, The Briar Club

"Happiness is a choice as much as anything. Or you could choose to be angry, and if you stay angry long enough, it will become comfortable, like an old robe. But eventually you’ll realize that old rob…"

-Kate Quinn, The Briar Club

Cover of Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England by Avree Kelly Clark

29. Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

By: Avree Kelly Clark

4.38

Format: 420 pages, Paperback

2024 Eric Hoffer First Horizon Award winner for best debut novel. In the summer of 1874, a bel… read more

Similar categories in Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery thriller
  • history
  • true crime
  • historical
  • nonfiction
  • mystery
Cover of Memorials by Richard  Chizmar

30. Memorials

By: Richard Chizmar

4.51

Format: 480 pages, Hardcover

A group of students encounter a supernatural terror while on a road trip through Appalachia in this… read more

Similar categories in Richard Chizmar's Memorials book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

  • mystery
Cover of The Abduction: A Suspenseful Novella by T.O. Paine

31. The Abduction: A Suspenseful Novella

By: T.O. Paine

3.89

Format: 135 pages, Kindle Edition

She should never have gotten into his car.Marcus Crawford doesn't want to go back to jail. They sho… read more

Similar categories in T.O. Paine's The Abduction: A Suspenseful Novella book and Avree Kelly Clark's Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England

12 Top historical books like Malice Aforethought: A True Story of the Shocking Double Crime That Horrified Nineteenth-Century New England by Avree Kelly Clark

Transform Your Habits

The Frozen River

Ariel Lawhon

4.43

Transform Your Habits

The Sweet Blue Distance

Sara Donati

4.31

Transform Your Habits

One Puzzling Afternoon

Emily Critchley

3.86

Transform Your Habits

By Any Other Name

Jodi Picoult

4.19

View all the books

20 Best mystery books like Pitch Dark (Mike Bowditch, #15) by Paul Doiron

Transform Your Habits

Three-Inch Teeth (Joe Pickett #24)

C.J. Box

4.36

Transform Your Habits

First Frost (Walt Longmire, #20)

Craig Johnson

4.37

Transform Your Habits

Clete (Dave Robicheaux, #24)

James Lee Burke

4.07

Transform Your Habits

One Deadly Eye (Doc Ford #27)

Randy Wayne White

4.23

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.