22 Best christian books like Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1) by Susan G. Mathis

Cover of Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1) by Susan G. Mathis

Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

By: Susan G. Mathis

4.22

Format: 294 pages, Kindle Edition

Scandalous news just keeps begging to be told, and taming her tongue seems an insurmountable task. …

"A whole new world is waiting for us across this river."

-Susan G. Mathis, Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

"A whole new world is waiting for us across this river."

-Susan G. Mathis, Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

"This summer can be the adventure of a lifetime, if you let it."

-Susan G. Mathis, Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

"This summer can be the adventure of a lifetime, if you let it."

-Susan G. Mathis, Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

If you liked the christian plot in Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1) by Susan G. Mathis , here is a list of 22 books like this:

Cover of The Laws of Attraction (Wyoming Sunrise, #2) by Mary Connealy

1. The Laws of Attraction (Wyoming Sunrise, #2)

By: Mary Connealy

4.29

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

If widowed town seamstress Nell Armstrong has to make one more pair of boring chaps for the cowboys… read more

Similar categories in Mary Connealy's The Laws of Attraction (Wyoming Sunrise, #2) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • inspirational
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Marshaling Her Heart (Wyoming Sunrise #3) by Mary Connealy

2. Marshaling Her Heart (Wyoming Sunrise #3)

By: Mary Connealy

4.37

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

Becky Pruitt has always prided herself on knowing everything that's happening on her successful ran… read more

Similar categories in Mary Connealy's Marshaling Her Heart (Wyoming Sunrise #3) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • inspirational
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of In the Shelter of Hollythorne House (The Houses of Yorkshire #2) by Sarah E. Ladd

3. In the Shelter of Hollythorne House (The Houses of Yorkshire #2)

By: Sarah E. Ladd

4.00

Format: 338 pages, Paperback

A young widow faces an uncertain future . . . until an unexpected encounter with her first love giv… read more

Similar categories in Sarah E. Ladd's In the Shelter of Hollythorne House (The Houses of Yorkshire #2) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of If the Boot Fits (Texas Ever After, #2) by Karen Witemeyer

4. If the Boot Fits (Texas Ever After, #2)

By: Karen Witemeyer

4.40

Format: 350 pages, Paperback

Determined to prove that cattle king Eli Dearing has no justification for evicting his stepmother a… read more

Similar categories in Karen Witemeyer's If the Boot Fits (Texas Ever After, #2) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Redemption in the Wilderness (Frontier Hearts Book 2) by Andrea Byrd

5. Redemption in the Wilderness (Frontier Hearts Book 2)

By: Andrea Byrd

4.41

Format: 176 pages, Kindle Edition

Two sisters alone on the Kentucky frontier…love is the last thing they expect to find.After the dea… read more

Similar categories in Andrea Byrd's Redemption in the Wilderness (Frontier Hearts Book 2) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

Cover of Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2) by Michelle Griep

6. Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2)

By: Michelle Griep

4.43

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

“The world seems full of good men—even if there are monsters in it.” –Bram Stoker, Dracula Eng… read more

Similar categories in Michelle Griep's Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"People need you and you need people. That’s the way of humankind."

-Michelle Griep, Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2)

"Man is not meant to find hope in anything of this world, but rather to lose hope in all things worldly."

-Michelle Griep, Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2)

"God brings people into our lives to walk beside us through our troubles, yet we are the ones who must open the door and let them in."

-Michelle Griep, Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2)

"God is not so limited that He cannot act outside the boundaries of physical law, for it is He alone who decides where those boundaries lie."

-Michelle Griep, Man of Shadow and Mist (Of Monsters and Men, #2)

Cover of A Noble Inheritance (Castles & Courtship) by Kasey Stockton

7. A Noble Inheritance (Castles & Courtship)

By: Kasey Stockton

4.45

Format: 312 pages, Kindle Edition

They say reformed rakes make the best husbands... Lady Verity wants nothing more than to provide… read more

Similar categories in Kasey Stockton's A Noble Inheritance (Castles & Courtship) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of A Heart to Keep (Castles and Courtship) by Ashtyn Newbold

8. A Heart to Keep (Castles and Courtship)

By: Ashtyn Newbold

4.14

Format: 226 pages, Kindle Edition

Five gentlemen, one eligible young lady…and her reluctantly jealous best friend. Emma Eastwood c… read more

Similar categories in Ashtyn Newbold's A Heart to Keep (Castles and Courtship) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical fiction
  • historical romance
Cover of The Rules of Matchmaking (Castles and Courtship) by Rebecca Connolly

9. The Rules of Matchmaking (Castles and Courtship)

By: Rebecca Connolly

4.10

Format: 266 pages, Kindle Edition

Jane Richards is not interested in marriage at the moment, nor is she particularly concerned about … read more

Similar categories in Rebecca Connolly's The Rules of Matchmaking (Castles and Courtship) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical fiction
  • historical romance
Cover of A Beautiful Disguise (The Imposters, #1) by Roseanna M. White

10. A Beautiful Disguise (The Imposters, #1)

By: Roseanna M. White

4.26

Format: 400 pages, Paperback

Left with an estate on the brink of bankruptcy after their father's death, Lady Marigold Fairfax an… read more

Similar categories in Roseanna M. White's A Beautiful Disguise (The Imposters, #1) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • inspirational
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"I think the truth always changes us. I think it always should."

-Roseanna M. White, A Beautiful Disguise (The Imposters, #1)

"The truth isn't always pretty. But I like to think it's always beautiful."

-Roseanna M. White, A Beautiful Disguise (The Imposters, #1)

"The truth isn’t always pretty. But I like to think it’s always beautiful."

-Roseanna M. White, A Beautiful Disguise (The Imposters, #1)

"How very boring he'd painted his faceless future spouse. No wonder he'd never been inspired to search for her."

-Roseanna M. White, A Beautiful Disguise (The Imposters, #1)

Cover of The Juliet Code (A Freddie and Grace Mystery, #3) by Pepper Basham

11. The Juliet Code (A Freddie and Grace Mystery, #3)

By: Pepper Basham

4.41

Format: 323 pages, Kindle Edition

Newlyweds Lord and Lady Astley Finally Reach Their Honeymoon Destination Only to Encounter a New My… read more

Similar categories in Pepper Basham's The Juliet Code (A Freddie and Grace Mystery, #3) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Healing the Mountain Man's Heart (Brothers of Sapphire Ranch #1) by Misty M. Beller

12. Healing the Mountain Man's Heart (Brothers of Sapphire Ranch #1)

By: Misty M. Beller

4.56

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

In the wild mountains of the Montana Territory, the Coulter ranch is a place of family, loyalty…and… read more

Similar categories in Misty M. Beller's Healing the Mountain Man's Heart (Brothers of Sapphire Ranch #1) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of A Noble Scheme (The Imposters, #2) by Roseanna M. White

13. A Noble Scheme (The Imposters, #2)

By: Roseanna M. White

4.42

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

Gemma Parks is known throughout high society as G. M. Parker, a columnist renowned for her commenta… read more

Similar categories in Roseanna M. White's A Noble Scheme (The Imposters, #2) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"Perhaps she didn't need her own forgiveness. Perhaps she could rely on His."

-Roseanna M. White, A Noble Scheme (The Imposters, #2)

"Once upon a time, he’d have leaned in for a kiss, and she’d have counted it a victory to have distracted him for even a moment."

-Roseanna M. White, A Noble Scheme (The Imposters, #2)

"It wasn't the same, their mourning. The grief of a mother and the grief of a father - they weren't the same. But sharing them made them a little bit easier to bear."

-Roseanna M. White, A Noble Scheme (The Imposters, #2)

"But the thought of not forgiving him, of drifting away until she'd scarcely recognize him on the street, of living the rest of her life alone... that terrified her even more, lit an even deeper flame…"

-Roseanna M. White, A Noble Scheme (The Imposters, #2)

Cover of Garden of the Midnights by Hannah  Linder

14. Garden of the Midnights

By: Hannah Linder

4.30

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

The accidents are not a matter of chance. They are deliberate. As English gentleman William Kensley… read more

Similar categories in Hannah Linder's Garden of the Midnights book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"A man is not what he possesses but what he does with himself."

-Hannah Linder, Garden of the Midnights

"There are too many people who would offer the honorary seat to the rich and the stool in the corner to the poor."

-Hannah Linder, Garden of the Midnights

"She gave him her warmth, her affection, every tender thought and emotion of her soul. She spoke everything she felt for him without words."

-Hannah Linder, Garden of the Midnights

Cover of A Counterfeit Betrothal (Scouts of the Georgia Frontier #1) by Denise Weimer

15. A Counterfeit Betrothal (Scouts of the Georgia Frontier #1)

By: Denise Weimer

4.50

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

A frontier scout, a healing widow, and a desperate fight for peace. At the farthest Georgia outp… read more

Similar categories in Denise Weimer's A Counterfeit Betrothal (Scouts of the Georgia Frontier #1) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of A Courageous Betrothal (Scouts of the Georgia Frontier Book 2) by Denise Weimer

16. A Courageous Betrothal (Scouts of the Georgia Frontier Book 2)

By: Denise Weimer

4.35

Format: 111 pages, Kindle Edition

A wounded lieutenant, a woman fierce enough to protect her family, and an American Revolution with … read more

Similar categories in Denise Weimer's A Courageous Betrothal (Scouts of the Georgia Frontier Book 2) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • historical
Cover of Christmas Bells and Wedding Vows: A Marriage of Convenience Anthology by Jody Hedlund

17. Christmas Bells and Wedding Vows: A Marriage of Convenience Anthology

By: Jody Hedlund

4.50

Format: 332 pages, Paperback

From bestselling and award-winning authors, experience Christmas on the rugged western frontier wit… read more

Similar categories in Jody Hedlund's Christmas Bells and Wedding Vows: A Marriage of Convenience Anthology book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of The Sleuth of Blackfriars Lane (Blackfriars Lane, #3) by Michelle Griep

18. The Sleuth of Blackfriars Lane (Blackfriars Lane, #3)

By: Michelle Griep

4.36

Format: 384 pages, Kindle Edition

Wife. Mother. Homemaker. Detective. Kit Forge wears many hats, and if that’s not enough, she’s part… read more

Similar categories in Michelle Griep's The Sleuth of Blackfriars Lane (Blackfriars Lane, #3) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • historical
  • christian
  • inspirational
  • historical fiction
Cover of The Starlet Spy (Heroines of WWII) by Rachel Scott McDaniel

19. The Starlet Spy (Heroines of WWII)

By: Rachel Scott McDaniel

4.43

Format: 259 pages, Kindle Edition

Hollywood Star Turns SpyIn 1943, Movie producer Henrik Zoltan approaches Amelie Blake under the gui… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Scott McDaniel's The Starlet Spy (Heroines of WWII) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of A Winter at the White Queen (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts #1) by Denise Weimer

20. A Winter at the White Queen (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts #1)

By: Denise Weimer

4.22

Format: 152 pages, Kindle Edition

n the world of the wealthy, things are never quite as they appear. Ellie Hastings is tired of pl… read more

Similar categories in Denise Weimer's A Winter at the White Queen (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts #1) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Rebecca (Daughters of the Lost Colony, #3) by Shannon McNear

21. Rebecca (Daughters of the Lost Colony, #3)

By: Shannon McNear

4.18

Format: 323 pages, Kindle Edition

A Native Princess Follows Her Heart   Immerse yourself in the “what if” questions related to the Lo… read more

Similar categories in Shannon McNear's Rebecca (Daughters of the Lost Colony, #3) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • historical
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of A Mark of Grace (Secrets of the Canyon, #3) by Kimberley Woodhouse

22. A Mark of Grace (Secrets of the Canyon, #3)

By: Kimberley Woodhouse

4.43

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

Ruth Anniston survived an injury that left her physically scarred, broken, and angry at God. Now sh… read more

Similar categories in Kimberley Woodhouse's A Mark of Grace (Secrets of the Canyon, #3) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • inspirational
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • historical fiction
Cover of When Hope Sank (A Day to Remember, #3) by Denise Weimer

23. When Hope Sank (A Day to Remember, #3)

By: Denise Weimer

4.40

Format: 259 pages, Kindle Edition

Can Hope Resurface After Evil Tries to Drown It?  Introducing a new series of 6 exciting novels fea… read more

Similar categories in Denise Weimer's When Hope Sank (A Day to Remember, #3) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • inspirational
  • historical
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of When the Waters Came (A Day to Remember Book 1) by Candice Sue Patterson

24. When the Waters Came (A Day to Remember Book 1)

By: Candice Sue Patterson

4.26

Format: 306 pages, Kindle Edition

An act of greed or an act of God? Introducing a new series of 6 exciting novels featuring histor… read more

Similar categories in Candice Sue Patterson's When the Waters Came (A Day to Remember Book 1) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • christian
  • inspirational
  • historical
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of The Pursuit of Miss Parish  (Aprons & Veils, #2) by Grace Hitchcock

25. The Pursuit of Miss Parish (Aprons & Veils, #2)

By: Grace Hitchcock

4.57

Format: 275 pages, ebook

Love’s gentle promise becomes nothing more than a withered dream. With dreams of love and a hope… read more

Similar categories in Grace Hitchcock's The Pursuit of Miss Parish (Aprons & Veils, #2) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • inspirational
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of A Summer on Bellevue Avenue (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts Book 5) by Lorri Dudley

26. A Summer on Bellevue Avenue (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts Book 5)

By: Lorri Dudley

4.48

Format: 161 pages, Kindle Edition

In the world of the elite, reputation is everything...Wealthy heiress Amanda Mae Klein is set to ma… read more

Similar categories in Lorri Dudley's A Summer on Bellevue Avenue (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts Book 5) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • historical
Cover of Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1) by Susan G. Mathis

27. Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

By: Susan G. Mathis

4.22

Format: 294 pages, Kindle Edition

Scandalous news just keeps begging to be told, and taming her tongue seems an insurmountable task. … read more

Similar categories in Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • inspirational
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"A whole new world is waiting for us across this river."

-Susan G. Mathis, Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

"This summer can be the adventure of a lifetime, if you let it."

-Susan G. Mathis, Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

"She would be free like the gulls that sailed the summer breeze."

-Susan G. Mathis, Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

"A whole summer on this beautiful Pullman Island! What magic might transpire?"

-Susan G. Mathis, Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

Cover of A Summer at Sagamore (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts, #2) by Lisa M. Prysock

28. A Summer at Sagamore (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts, #2)

By: Lisa M. Prysock

4.34

Format: 191 pages, Paperback

Can summer love survive amid mystery and mayhem? When Abigail Greenwood and her cousins settle i… read more

Similar categories in Lisa M. Prysock's A Summer at Sagamore (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts, #2) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • christian
  • historical
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Christmas at the Jekyll Island Club (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts Book 9) by Blossom Turner

29. Christmas at the Jekyll Island Club (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts Book 9)

By: Blossom Turner

4.62

Format: 153 pages, Kindle Edition

She was born into privilege yet yearns for freedom. Dare she risk it all for love? Though spunky S… read more

Similar categories in Blossom Turner's Christmas at the Jekyll Island Club (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts Book 9) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Reclaiming the Spy (Agents of Espionage Book 2) by Lorri Dudley

30. Reclaiming the Spy (Agents of Espionage Book 2)

By: Lorri Dudley

4.64

Format: 382 pages, Kindle Edition

How can he protect her from himself when she keeps winding up in his arms?She never gave up hope. A… read more

Similar categories in Lorri Dudley's Reclaiming the Spy (Agents of Espionage Book 2) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • historical
  • christian
Cover of A Season at the Grand (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts Book 3) by Sherri Wilson Johnson

31. A Season at the Grand (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts Book 3)

By: Sherri Wilson Johnson

4.29

Format: 198 pages, Kindle Edition

Can the perfect picture reveal the truth before it’s too late? Photographer Amelia Harris has had … read more

Similar categories in Sherri Wilson Johnson's A Season at the Grand (Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts Book 3) book and Susan G. Mathis's Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1)

  • romance

22 best-selling fiction books like Katelyn's Choice (Thousand Islands Gilded Age #1) by Susan G. Mathis

Transform Your Habits

The Laws of Attraction (Wyoming Sunrise, #2)

Mary Connealy

4.29

Transform Your Habits

Marshaling Her Heart (Wyoming Sunrise #3)

Mary Connealy

4.37

Transform Your Habits

In the Shelter of Hollythorne House (The Houses of Yorkshire #2)

Sarah E. Ladd

4.00

Transform Your Habits

If the Boot Fits (Texas Ever After, #2)

Karen Witemeyer

4.40

View all the books

9 must-read fiction books like Healing the Mountain Man's Heart (Brothers of Sapphire Ranch #1) by Misty M. Beller

Transform Your Habits

A Trail So Lonesome (Wagon Train Matches #1)

Lacy Williams

4.48

Transform Your Habits

A Trail Untamed (Wagon Train Matches #3)

Lacy Williams

4.59

Transform Your Habits

Healing the Mountain Man's Heart (Brothers of Sapphire Ranch #1)

Misty M. Beller

4.56

Transform Your Habits

Finally His Bride (Bride Ships: New Voyages, #1)

Jody Hedlund

4.13

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.