9 must-read romance books like Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1) by Gayle Roper

Cover of Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1) by Gayle Roper

Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

By: Gayle Roper

3.86

Format: 256 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Amhearst, Pennsylvania was just the kind of place for new beginnings for brokenhearted reporter Mer…

If you liked the romance plot in Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1) by Gayle Roper , here is a list of 9 books like this:

Cover of Thin Ice (Men of Valor, #2) by Irene Hannon

1. Thin Ice (Men of Valor, #2)

By: Irene Hannon

4.26

Format: 394 pages, Paperback

After losing her parents in a car accident and her sister to a house fire, Christy Reed has been mi… read more

Similar categories in Irene Hannon's Thin Ice (Men of Valor, #2) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • romantic suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery

2. Die Again (Rizzoli & Isles, #11)

By: Tess Gerritsen

3.17

Format: 120 pages, Hardcover

The latest enthralling case in Tess Gerritsen's New York Times bestselling Rizzoli & Isles series, … read more

Similar categories in Tess Gerritsen's Die Again (Rizzoli & Isles, #11) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

3. Buried Secrets (Men of Valor #1)

By: Irene Hannon

2.50

Format: 260 pages, Paperback

After seven years as a Chicago homicide detective, Lisa Grant has hit a wall. Ready for a kinder, g… read more

Similar categories in Irene Hannon's Buried Secrets (Men of Valor #1) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

4. Tangled Webs (Men of Valor #3)

By: Irene Hannon

5.00

Format: 120 pages, Hardcover

Three-Time RITA Award Winner Delivers Another Heart-Stopping Thriller After a disastrous Middle Eas… read more

Similar categories in Irene Hannon's Tangled Webs (Men of Valor #3) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

5. Christmas Eve at Friday Harbor (Friday Harbor, #1)

By: Lisa Kleypas

3.00

Format: None pages, Hardcover

New York Times bestselling author Lisa Kleypas's new series begins during the most magical time of … read more

Similar categories in Lisa Kleypas's Christmas Eve at Friday Harbor (Friday Harbor, #1) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

Cover of The Puppet Show (Washington Poe, #1) by M.W. Craven

6. The Puppet Show (Washington Poe, #1)

By: M.W. Craven

4.33

Format: 352 pages, Hardcover

A serial killer is burning people alive in the Lake District's prehistoric stone circles. He leaves… read more

Similar categories in M.W. Craven's The Puppet Show (Washington Poe, #1) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • mystery
  • fiction
Cover of Forever My Own (Ladies of the Lake, #2) by Tracie Peterson

7. Forever My Own (Ladies of the Lake, #2)

By: Tracie Peterson

4.23

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

In 1871, Kirstin Hallberg arrives in Duluth, Minnesota, to find the city council intent on building… read more

Similar categories in Tracie Peterson's Forever My Own (Ladies of the Lake, #2) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
Cover of Destined for You (Ladies of the Lake, #1) by Tracie Peterson

8. Destined for You (Ladies of the Lake, #1)

By: Tracie Peterson

4.21

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

In 1869, Gloriana Womack's family is much smaller since smallpox killed her mother and two of her s… read more

Similar categories in Tracie Peterson's Destined for You (Ladies of the Lake, #1) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
Cover of Life Flight (Extreme Measures, #1) by Lynette Eason

9. Life Flight (Extreme Measures, #1)

By: Lynette Eason

4.20

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

EMS helicopter pilot Penny Carlton is used to high stress situations, but being forced to land on a… read more

Similar categories in Lynette Eason's Life Flight (Extreme Measures, #1) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • romantic suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
Cover of All My Knotted-Up Life: A Memoir by Beth Moore

10. All My Knotted-Up Life: A Memoir

By: Beth Moore

4.47

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

New York Times, Publishers Weekly, and Wall Street Journal bestseller! An incredibly thoughtful,… read more

Similar categories in Beth Moore's All My Knotted-Up Life: A Memoir book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • christian
"Once you've broken to pieces, the luxury of imagining yourself unbreakable evaporates."

-Beth Moore, All My Knotted-Up Life: A Memoir

"You want to know how to love me? Love my children. You want to be good to me? Be good to my children."

-Beth Moore, All My Knotted-Up Life: A Memoir

"A teenager doesn't know she's still a child. A teenager feels like an adult, I suppose primarily because her outside, her flesh and her face, her body, her size, her width and height, look like - and…"

-Beth Moore, All My Knotted-Up Life: A Memoir

Cover of Come Back to Me (Waters of Time, #1) by Jody Hedlund

11. Come Back to Me (Waters of Time, #1)

By: Jody Hedlund

4.10

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

The ultimate cure that could heal any disease? Crazy. That's exactly what research scientist Mar… read more

Similar categories in Jody Hedlund's Come Back to Me (Waters of Time, #1) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
"If he was nothing more than a vision, then why did he seem so real?"

-Jody Hedlund, Come Back to Me (Waters of Time, #1)

"Living in the starkness of the Middle Ages had taught her there was something special about needing others and being needed in return. She'd learned it took courage to open her heart and allow people…"

-Jody Hedlund, Come Back to Me (Waters of Time, #1)

"Maybe that's why God had placed the angel at the Garden of Eden—to keep people away from the Tree of Life? Not to prevent them from having something good, but to protect them from something that had …"

-Jody Hedlund, Come Back to Me (Waters of Time, #1)

Cover of You Make It Feel Like Christmas by Toni Shiloh

12. You Make It Feel Like Christmas

By: Toni Shiloh

3.38

Format: 208 pages, ebook

Starr Lewis reluctantly returns home for the holidays jobless, single, and not at all prepared to b… read more

Similar categories in Toni Shiloh's You Make It Feel Like Christmas book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
"I really want to kiss you."

-Toni Shiloh, You Make It Feel Like Christmas

"It was time to let the hurt go, even if Angel never said she was sorry."

-Toni Shiloh, You Make It Feel Like Christmas

"Starr’s voice had gotten quiet. Waylon couldn’t sit by and let her get railroaded by her obnoxious sister."

-Toni Shiloh, You Make It Feel Like Christmas

"Starr wanted to roll her eyes at his political grin. How had she ever thought him to be sincere and trustworthy?"

-Toni Shiloh, You Make It Feel Like Christmas

Cover of Before She Disappeared (Frankie Elkin, #1) by Lisa Gardner

13. Before She Disappeared (Frankie Elkin, #1)

By: Lisa Gardner

3.97

Format: 400 pages, Hardcover

From #1 New York Times bestselling author Lisa Gardner, a propulsive thriller featuring an ordinary… read more

Similar categories in Lisa Gardner's Before She Disappeared (Frankie Elkin, #1) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • mystery
  • fiction
Cover of The Christmas Swap by Melody Carlson

14. The Christmas Swap

By: Melody Carlson

3.67

Format: 176 pages, Hardcover

All Emma Daley wants this holiday season is a white Christmas. But the young teacher and struggling… read more

Similar categories in Melody Carlson's The Christmas Swap book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
Cover of The Escape (US Marshals, #1) by Lisa          Harris

15. The Escape (US Marshals, #1)

By: Lisa Harris

4.30

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

US Marshals Madison James and Jonas Quinn are thrust into a high-profile case when they are called … read more

Similar categories in Lisa Harris's The Escape (US Marshals, #1) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • romantic suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
Cover of Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1) by Gayle Roper

16. Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

By: Gayle Roper

3.86

Format: 256 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Amhearst, Pennsylvania was just the kind of place for new beginnings for brokenhearted reporter Mer… read more

Similar categories in Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1) book and Gayle Roper's Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1)

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • love inspired suspense
  • love inspired
  • romantic suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery

11 Best fiction books like Caught in the Middle (Amhearst Mystery Series #1) by Gayle Roper

Transform Your Habits

Thin Ice (Men of Valor, #2)

Irene Hannon

4.26

Transform Your Habits

The Puppet Show (Washington Poe, #1)

M.W. Craven

4.33

Transform Your Habits

Forever My Own (Ladies of the Lake, #2)

Tracie Peterson

4.23

Transform Your Habits

Destined for You (Ladies of the Lake, #1)

Tracie Peterson

4.21

View all the books

20 Top fiction books like You Make It Feel Like Christmas by Toni Shiloh

Transform Your Habits

Rocky Road (Sons of Scandal, #2)

Becky Wade

4.21

Transform Your Habits

Love in Winter Wonderland

Abiola Bello

3.72

Transform Your Habits

Loyally, Luke

Pepper Basham

4.07

Transform Your Habits

You Make It Feel Like Christmas

Toni Shiloh

3.38

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.