13 must-read amish books like Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9) by Marlene Chase

Cover of Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9) by Marlene Chase

Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

By: Marlene Chase

3.97

Format: None pages, None

Valentine's Day is fast approaching, and with it comes a new cast of intriguing characters to Pleas…

If you liked the amish plot in Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9) by Marlene Chase , here is a list of 13 books like this:

Cover of The Beloved Christmas Quilt by Wanda E. Brunstetter, Jean Brunstetter, Richelle Brunstetter

1. The Beloved Christmas Quilt

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter , Jean Brunstetter , Richelle Brunstetter

4.22

Format: 400 pages, Paperback

One quilt binds three generations of Amish women in these three stories of family, romance, and Ami… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's The Beloved Christmas Quilt book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • amish fiction
  • amish

2. The Kennel Caper

By: Jan Fields

4.30

Format: 543 pages, Hardcover

read more

Similar categories in Jan Fields's The Kennel Caper book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

3. Due or Die (Library Lover's Mystery, #2)

By: JM

3.76

Format: 205 pages, Paperback

Answering tricky reference questions is more than enough excitement for library director Lindsey No… read more

Similar categories in JM's Due or Die (Library Lover's Mystery, #2) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

4. A Patchwork Murder

By: Jan Fields

3.94

Format: 450 pages, Hardcover

read more

Similar categories in Jan Fields's A Patchwork Murder book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

5. Assaulted Caramel (Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #1)

By: Amanda Flower

3.96

Format: None pages, Mass Market Paperback

read more

Similar categories in Amanda Flower's Assaulted Caramel (Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #1) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

6. A Novel Murder (Secrets of the Castleton Manor Library #1)

By: Elizabeth Penney

3.76

Format: 85 pages, Hardcover

read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Penney's A Novel Murder (Secrets of the Castleton Manor Library #1) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

7. Down a Dark Road (Kate Burkholder, #9)

By: Linda Castillo

4.45

Format: 864 pages, Hardcover

In this electrifying new thriller in the New York Times bestselling series, a convicted murderer is… read more

Similar categories in Linda Castillo's Down a Dark Road (Kate Burkholder, #9) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

Cover of Murder on the Poet's Walk (Book Retreat Mysteries, #8) by Ellery Adams

8. Murder on the Poet's Walk (Book Retreat Mysteries, #8)

By: Ellery Adams

4.29

Format: 315 pages, Paperback

When corpses clutching poems begin turning up around Storyton Hall, resort manager Jane Steward is … read more

Similar categories in Ellery Adams's Murder on the Poet's Walk (Book Retreat Mysteries, #8) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Scottish Ladies' Detective Agency (The Scottish Ladies' Detective Agency, #1) by Lydia Travers

9. The Scottish Ladies' Detective Agency (The Scottish Ladies' Detective Agency, #1)

By: Lydia Travers

3.97

Format: 340 pages, Kindle Edition

When Maud McIntyre sets up her own private detective agency, she never imagines her first case will… read more

Similar categories in Lydia Travers's The Scottish Ladies' Detective Agency (The Scottish Ladies' Detective Agency, #1) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Peanut Butter Panic (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #7) by Amanda Flower

10. Peanut Butter Panic (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #7)

By: Amanda Flower

4.20

Format: 304 pages, Kindle Edition

Thanksgiving is Bailey King’s busiest holiday weekend. This year promises to be even more hectic, s… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Flower's Peanut Butter Panic (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #7) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
  • cozy mystery
  • amish
Cover of Blueberry Blunder (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery Book 8) by Amanda Flower

11. Blueberry Blunder (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery Book 8)

By: Amanda Flower

4.27

Format: 289 pages, Kindle Edition

Amanda Flower's USA Today bestselling Amish Candy Shop Mysteries combines a fascinating look at Ami… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Flower's Blueberry Blunder (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery Book 8) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
  • cozy mystery
  • amish
Cover of Premeditated Peppermint (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #3) by Amanda Flower

12. Premeditated Peppermint (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #3)

By: Amanda Flower

4.07

Format: 332 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Someone's sweet on revenge . . . Christmas is Bailey King's favorite time of year. For her first Y… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Flower's Premeditated Peppermint (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #3) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
  • cozy mystery
  • amish
Cover of A Gathering of Secrets (Kate Burkholder, #10) by Linda  Castillo

13. A Gathering of Secrets (Kate Burkholder, #10)

By: Linda Castillo

4.19

Format: 308 pages, Hardcover

A deadly fire exposes the dark side of Amish life in this harrowing new thriller in the New York Ti… read more

Similar categories in Linda Castillo's A Gathering of Secrets (Kate Burkholder, #10) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • amish
Cover of Toxic Toffee (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #4) by Amanda Flower

14. Toxic Toffee (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #4)

By: Amanda Flower

4.13

Format: 292 pages, Kindle Edition

A sweet tooth for murder . . . Bailey King's in New York wrapping up a six-week shoot on her first … read more

Similar categories in Amanda Flower's Toxic Toffee (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #4) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
  • cozy mystery
  • amish
Cover of Fallen (Kate Burkholder, #13) by Linda  Castillo

15. Fallen (Kate Burkholder, #13)

By: Linda Castillo

4.25

Format: 320 pages, Hardcover

In New York Times bestselling author Linda Castillo’s new thriller Fallen , a rebellious Amish woma… read more

Similar categories in Linda Castillo's Fallen (Kate Burkholder, #13) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • amish
Cover of Lethal Licorice (Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #2) by Amanda Flower

16. Lethal Licorice (Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #2)

By: Amanda Flower

4.04

Format: 336 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Too many sweets spoil the murder . . . Harvest, Ohio, is a long way from New York City, where B… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Flower's Lethal Licorice (Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #2) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
  • cozy mystery
  • amish
Cover of Shamed (Kate Burkholder, #11) by Linda  Castillo

17. Shamed (Kate Burkholder, #11)

By: Linda Castillo

4.13

Format: 294 pages, Hardcover

In this gripping thriller from New York Times bestselling author Linda Castillo, a devastating murd… read more

Similar categories in Linda Castillo's Shamed (Kate Burkholder, #11) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • amish
Cover of Criminally Cocoa (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #3.5) by Amanda Flower

18. Criminally Cocoa (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #3.5)

By: Amanda Flower

3.88

Format: 86 pages, Kindle Edition

A taste for trouble . . .      As if being in New York City for Easter isn’t exciting enough, Charl… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Flower's Criminally Cocoa (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #3.5) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
  • cozy mystery
  • amish
Cover of I've Got My Eyes on You by Mary Higgins Clark

19. I've Got My Eyes on You

By: Mary Higgins Clark

3.76

Format: 256 pages, Hardcover

After a party when her parents are away, eighteen-year-old Kerry Dowling is found fully dressed at … read more

Similar categories in Mary Higgins Clark's I've Got My Eyes on You book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
Cover of Lemon Drop Dead (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #6) by Amanda Flower

20. Lemon Drop Dead (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #6)

By: Amanda Flower

4.23

Format: 320 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Murder always leaves a sour taste . . . Although baby showers aren’t an Amish tradition, Bailey… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Flower's Lemon Drop Dead (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #6) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • amish
"She gave out advice like Amish Kettle Corn."

-Amanda Flower, Lemon Drop Dead (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #6)

Cover of To the Moon and Back (The Baxter Family, #3) by Karen Kingsbury

21. To the Moon and Back (The Baxter Family, #3)

By: Karen Kingsbury

4.28

Format: 362 pages, Hardcover

Dear Jenna, Like I do every year, I wrote you a letter. In case you come to the memorial today. In… read more

Similar categories in Karen Kingsbury's To the Moon and Back (The Baxter Family, #3) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

"He might’ve only been seventeen, but he knew he wanted Jenna in his life as long as he lived."

-Karen Kingsbury, To the Moon and Back (The Baxter Family, #3)

"She felt like she’d slipped into another world. For the first time someone knew exactly what the hurt felt like."

-Karen Kingsbury, To the Moon and Back (The Baxter Family, #3)

Cover of Bitter Words (Secrets of the Castleton Manor Library, #2) by Jan Fields

22. Bitter Words (Secrets of the Castleton Manor Library, #2)

By: Jan Fields

3.91

Format: 205 pages, Hardcover

Join Faith Newberry and her cat, Watson, in the quaint town of Lighthouse Bay on Cape Cod in Massac… read more

Similar categories in Jan Fields's Bitter Words (Secrets of the Castleton Manor Library, #2) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Grim Reader (Secrets of the Castleton Manor Library, #3) by Margaret Welch

23. The Grim Reader (Secrets of the Castleton Manor Library, #3)

By: Margaret Welch

3.91

Format: 217 pages, Hardcover

It's simmering Suspense week at the Castleton Manor literary retreat in Lighthouse Bay, MA. Faith h… read more

Similar categories in Margaret Welch's The Grim Reader (Secrets of the Castleton Manor Library, #3) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Hems and Homicide (Apron Shop #1) by Elizabeth Penney

24. Hems and Homicide (Apron Shop #1)

By: Elizabeth Penney

4.01

Format: 264 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Welcome to the quaint village of Blueberry Cove, Maine, where an expert seamstress turned amateur s… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Penney's Hems and Homicide (Apron Shop #1) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Bodies and Bows (Apron Shop, #3) by Elizabeth Penney

25. Bodies and Bows (Apron Shop, #3)

By: Elizabeth Penney

4.16

Format: 288 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Bodies & Bows is the third in the charming cozy Iris Buckley mystery series set in an apron shop in… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Penney's Bodies and Bows (Apron Shop, #3) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of A Murder Unscripted by Elizabeth Penney

26. A Murder Unscripted

By: Elizabeth Penney

4.01

Format: 205 pages, Hardcover

It's lights, camera, action at Castleton Manor, the exclusive literary retreat in Lighthouse Bay, M… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Penney's A Murder Unscripted book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9) by Marlene Chase

27. Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

By: Marlene Chase

3.97

Format: None pages, None

Valentine's Day is fast approaching, and with it comes a new cast of intriguing characters to Pleas… read more

Similar categories in Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
  • cozy mystery
  • amish
Cover of For Letter or Worse by Margaret Welch

28. For Letter or Worse

By: Margaret Welch

3.97

Format: 208 pages, Hardcover

The Nancy Drew Clue Colloquium converges on the manor. Fans and scholars are dressed as their favor… read more

Similar categories in Margaret Welch's For Letter or Worse book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Designs To Die For (Annie's Mysteries Unraveled, #1) by Jan Fields

29. Designs To Die For (Annie's Mysteries Unraveled, #1)

By: Jan Fields

3.84

Format: 205 pages, Hardcover

Mystery always finds its way to Kate Steven's door. Kate, a dynamic crochet designer and author in … read more

Similar categories in Jan Fields's Designs To Die For (Annie's Mysteries Unraveled, #1) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery

30. Grave Inheritance (Amish Inn Mysteries, #11)

By: Rachael O. Phillips

3.93

Format: None pages, None

None read more

Similar categories in Rachael O. Phillips's Grave Inheritance (Amish Inn Mysteries, #11) book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • amish
Cover of Grave Inheritance by Rachael O. Phillips

31. Grave Inheritance

By: Rachael O. Phillips

4.40

Format: None pages, Hardcover

Amish Inn Mysteries #11 It's a scorching hot summer in Pleasant Creek, Indiana, but the temperature… read more

Similar categories in Rachael O. Phillips's Grave Inheritance book and Marlene Chase's Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9)

22 must-read mystery books like Deceptive Hearts (Amish Inn Mysteries #9) by Marlene Chase

Transform Your Habits

Murder on the Poet's Walk (Book Retreat Mysteries, #8)

Ellery Adams

4.29

Transform Your Habits

The Scottish Ladies' Detective Agency (The Scottish Ladies' Detective Agency, #1)

Lydia Travers

3.97

Transform Your Habits

Peanut Butter Panic (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #7)

Amanda Flower

4.20

Transform Your Habits

Blueberry Blunder (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery Book 8)

Amanda Flower

4.27

View all the books

12 must-read mystery thriller books like I've Got My Eyes on You by Mary Higgins Clark

Transform Your Habits

The Body in the Wardrobe (Faith Fairchild Mysteries, #23)

Katherine Hall Page

3.56

Transform Your Habits

Let Me Whisper In Your Ear (KEY News #3)

Mary Jane Clark

3.95

Transform Your Habits

Treacherous Estate (Jack Ludefance, #1)

Behcet Kaya

4.25

Transform Your Habits

She's Not Sorry

Mary Kubica

3.81

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.