10 Top mystery books like Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13) by Cara C. Putman

Cover of Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13) by Cara C. Putman

Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

By: Cara C. Putman

3.98

Format: 262 pages, Hardcover

As the annual Martha’s Vineyard International Film Festival is set to begin, Priscilla accompanies …

If you liked the mystery plot in Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13) by Cara C. Putman , here is a list of 10 books like this:

Cover of The Valentine Visitor (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #12) by Emily Thomas

1. The Valentine Visitor (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #12)

By: Emily Thomas

4.15

Format: 277 pages, Hardcover

It's early February in Blue Hill, and Anne Gibson is surprised to receive a Valentine's Day postcar… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's The Valentine Visitor (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #12) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Theft and Thanksgiving (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #4) by Emily Thomas

2. Theft and Thanksgiving (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #4)

By: Emily Thomas

4.03

Format: 283 pages, Hardcover

Anne Gibson is alarmed when identity thefts leave elderly Blue Hill citizens with bank accounts dra… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Theft and Thanksgiving (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #4) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6) by Emily Thomas

3. Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6)

By: Emily Thomas

4.40

Format: 277 pages, Hardcover

When the mayor of Blue Hill visits Anne to talk about a new tax proposal that will soon go before t… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3) by Emily Thomas

4. Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3)

By: Emily Thomas

4.57

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When an unmarked envelope arrives at the library, containing a mock-up of a newspaper article, Anne… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Shadows of the Past (Secrets of Blue Hill Library, #2) by Emily Thomas

5. Shadows of the Past (Secrets of Blue Hill Library, #2)

By: Emily Thomas

4.00

Format: 321 pages, Hardcover

While cataloging books at the library, Anne stumbles on an old, yellowed map of Pennsylvania tucked… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Shadows of the Past (Secrets of Blue Hill Library, #2) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of If walls could talk by Emily Thomas

6. If walls could talk

By: Emily Thomas

3.33

Format: 288 pages, Hardcover

After a heavy rain, Anne discovers that one of the walls in the library basement is crumbling. She … read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's If walls could talk book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Peace Like a River (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #7) by Olivia Newport

7. Peace Like a River (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #7)

By: Olivia Newport

4.33

Format: None pages, Hardcover

Though Cheryl Cooper wrestles with her own mixed feelings about Valentine's Day, she wants to make … read more

Similar categories in Olivia Newport's Peace Like a River (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #7) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Without a trace by Emily Thomas

8. Without a trace

By: Emily Thomas

4.00

Format: None pages,

Following a meeting of the Blue Hill Library's writing group. Lucas Miller disappears. His teenage … read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Without a trace book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Cracking the code by Emily Thomas

9. Cracking the code

By: Emily Thomas

4.11

Format: 15 pages, Hardcover

Anne and Wendy are preparing for a new adult literacy class when Ben races inside the library to te… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Cracking the code book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • mystery

10. Mum's the Word (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library #17)

By: Emily Thomas

3.29

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When Anne finds an ancient Egyptian clay pot in the attic, which Aunt Edie excavated at an archaeol… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Mum's the Word (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library #17) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

11. A Stitch in Time (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #9)

By: Elizabeth Ludwig

4.52

Format: None pages, Hardcover

Cheryl Cooper loves helping out a friend, so when Naomi Miller asks for a ride to visit a sick rela… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Ludwig's A Stitch in Time (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #9) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

12. The Rightful Owner (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library Book #10)

By: Emily Thomas

3.75

Format: 40 pages, Hardcover

Anne and Wendy decide to organize a used books sale to raise money for the library. As Anne is sort… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's The Rightful Owner (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library Book #10) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

13. Sidetracked suspicions

By: Emily Thomas

3.98

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

Bill Hill is celebrating its first-ever Railroad Days Festival, and the main event is an antiques a… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Sidetracked suspicions book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

14. Shoo Fly Shoo (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #12)

By: Amy Lillard

4.45

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When Albert Yoder is arrested for illegally transporting and selling raw milk across county lines, … read more

Similar categories in Amy Lillard's Shoo Fly Shoo (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #12) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

15. Stagestruck

By: Emily Thomas

3.60

Format: 224 pages, Hardcover

Anne is thrilled when her old high school friend Tami Bates returns to Blue Hill for a visit. Tami … read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Stagestruck book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

16. Earthly Treasures (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #13)

By: Annalisa Daughety

4.20

Format: 172 pages, ebook

A treasure hunt is set to begin in Sugarcreek and the surrounding countryside, and Cheryl Cooper is… read more

Similar categories in Annalisa Daughety's Earthly Treasures (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #13) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

17. Nowhere to be found (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #1)

By: Emily Thomas

4.23

Format: 528 pages, Hardcover

While converting the Victorian home left by her great-aunt Edie into a library, Anne Gibson stumble… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Nowhere to be found (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #1) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

18. No Time for Trouble (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #14)

By: Olivia Newport

3.89

Format: 272 pages, Hardcover

With a history of more than sixty years, Sugarcreek's Ohio Swiss Festival is a highlight of the sea… read more

Similar categories in Olivia Newport's No Time for Trouble (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #14) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

19. Christmas key (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #5)

By: Emily Thomas

4.00

Format: None pages, Hardcover

Anne is busy preparing for Christmas when she finds a delicate key among Aunt Edie's holiday decora… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Christmas key (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #5) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

20. All sewn up

By: Emily Thomas

4.60

Format: 200 pages, Hardcover

While scouring Aunt Edie's attic for supplies to help Wendy with her latest project, Anne discovers… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's All sewn up book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

21. Simply Vanished (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #8)

By: Nancy Mehl

3.67

Format: 208 pages, Hardcover

As Cheryl Cooper's birthday approaches, she believes her new life in Sugarcreek, Ohio, is the best … read more

Similar categories in Nancy Mehl's Simply Vanished (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #8) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

22. Gone in a flash

By: Emily Thomas

3.33

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When Anne finds a roll of undeveloped film in an old camera of her great-aunt Edie's and has it pro… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Gone in a flash book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

Cover of All That Glitters (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #15) by Emily Thomas

23. All That Glitters (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #15)

By: Emily Thomas

4.30

Format: 277 pages, Hardcover

When a powerful storm blows through Blue Hill, Anne's children are rescued by a drifter named Jack … read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's All That Glitters (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #15) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Hidden Gate (Savannah Secrets #1) by Marlene Chase

24. The Hidden Gate (Savannah Secrets #1)

By: Marlene Chase

4.06

Format: 257 pages, Hardcover

Meredith Bellefontaine has recently reopened her late husband's investigation agency with her best … read more

Similar categories in Marlene Chase's The Hidden Gate (Savannah Secrets #1) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Double Trouble (Savannah Secrets #3) by Gabrielle  Meyer

25. Double Trouble (Savannah Secrets #3)

By: Gabrielle Meyer

4.14

Format: 268 pages, Hardcover

Double Trouble is the 3rd book in the Savannah Secrets cozy-mystery series. Meredith catches sig… read more

Similar categories in Gabrielle Meyer's Double Trouble (Savannah Secrets #3) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

Cover of Lights! Camera! Action! (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #16) by Emily Thomas

26. Lights! Camera! Action! (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #16)

By: Emily Thomas

4.36

Format: 278 pages, Hardcover

After a fire in an empty warehouse damages the historic Blue Hill Theater, Anne is shocked to learn… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Lights! Camera! Action! (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #16) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

Cover of Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13) by Cara C. Putman

27. Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

By: Cara C. Putman

3.98

Format: 262 pages, Hardcover

As the annual Martha’s Vineyard International Film Festival is set to begin, Priscilla accompanies … read more

Similar categories in Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Do You See What I See? by Vera Dodge

28. Do You See What I See?

By: Vera Dodge

4.46

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

January arrives in Lancaster, and the whole town is fascinated by a serialized mystery story runnin… read more

Similar categories in Vera Dodge's Do You See What I See? book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

Cover of Tea and Promises by Susan Page Davis

29. Tea and Promises

By: Susan Page Davis

4.46

Format: 238 pages, Kindle Edition

Even as Jan puts the final touches on her wedding plans, mystery still swirls around the tearoom. W… read more

Similar categories in Susan Page Davis's Tea and Promises book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of A Fallen Petal (Savannah Secrets #2) by Ruth Logan Herne

30. A Fallen Petal (Savannah Secrets #2)

By: Ruth Logan Herne

4.29

Format: 239 pages, Hardcover

A Fallen Petal is the 2nd book in the Savannah Secrets cozy-mystery series When an acclaimed aut… read more

Similar categories in Ruth Logan Herne's A Fallen Petal (Savannah Secrets #2) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

Cover of Whispering Bells (Savannah Secrets #4) by Shirley Raye Redmond

31. Whispering Bells (Savannah Secrets #4)

By: Shirley Raye Redmond

4.09

Format: 249 pages, Hardcover

Whispering Bells is the 4th book in the Savannah Secrets cozy-mystery series. Pastor Ed Markham… read more

Similar categories in Shirley Raye Redmond's Whispering Bells (Savannah Secrets #4) book and Cara C. Putman's Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13)

12 Top cozy mystery books like Shark Bait (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #13) by Cara C. Putman

Transform Your Habits

The Valentine Visitor (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #12)

Emily Thomas

4.15

Transform Your Habits

Theft and Thanksgiving (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #4)

Emily Thomas

4.03

Transform Your Habits

Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6)

Emily Thomas

4.40

Transform Your Habits

Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3)

Emily Thomas

4.57

View all the books

5 Best cozy mystery books like All That Glitters (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #15) by Emily Thomas

Transform Your Habits

Nobody's Safe (Mysteries of Silver Peak #2)

Carole Jefferson

4.37

Transform Your Habits

Pieces of the Past (Patchwork, #6)

Susan Page Davis

3.79

Transform Your Habits

All That Glitters (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #15)

Emily Thomas

4.30

Transform Your Habits

A Code of Honor

Carole Jefferson

4.06

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.