25 Top cozy mystery books like Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1) by Mara Webb

Cover of Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1) by Mara Webb

Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

By: Mara Webb

4.61

Format: 203 pages, Kindle Edition

Life can take a wicked turn in the blink of an eye! In a single fateful day, Sage Rivers loses h…

If you liked the cozy mystery plot in Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1) by Mara Webb , here is a list of 25 books like this:

Cover of Chilled to the Crone (Spell's Angels, #11) by Amanda M. Lee

1. Chilled to the Crone (Spell's Angels, #11)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.59

Format: 288 pages, Kindle Edition

Winter has descended on Hawthorne Hollow like a chilly blanket, and all Scout Randall wants to do w… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Chilled to the Crone (Spell's Angels, #11) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of All Quiet On the Witchy Front (Wicked Witches of the Midwest #24) by Amanda M. Lee

2. All Quiet On the Witchy Front (Wicked Witches of the Midwest #24)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.70

Format: 268 pages, Kindle Edition

Christmas is in the past and the new year is shining bright for Bay Winchester…right up until a loc… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's All Quiet On the Witchy Front (Wicked Witches of the Midwest #24) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Witching on the Job (Moonstone Bay #13) by Amanda M. Lee

3. Witching on the Job (Moonstone Bay #13)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.59

Format: 303 pages, Kindle Edition

Hadley Hunter came to Moonstone Bay to find herself. That included finding her passion in life. She… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Witching on the Job (Moonstone Bay #13) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Hexcess Baggage (Supernatural Speakeasy, #14) by Lily Harper Hart

4. Hexcess Baggage (Supernatural Speakeasy, #14)

By: Lily Harper Hart

4.69

Format: 230 pages, Kindle Edition

The French Quarter is quiet for a change. Christmas is just around the corner, and the off-season i… read more

Similar categories in Lily Harper Hart's Hexcess Baggage (Supernatural Speakeasy, #14) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Cold as a Witch's Tequila Sunrise (Witch on the Rocks, #7) by Lily Harper Hart

5. Cold as a Witch's Tequila Sunrise (Witch on the Rocks, #7)

By: Lily Harper Hart

4.68

Format: 228 pages, Kindle Edition

The big day has arrived. Hali Waverly is finally getting the surgery she so desperately needs. Her … read more

Similar categories in Lily Harper Hart's Cold as a Witch's Tequila Sunrise (Witch on the Rocks, #7) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Undead Urges (Luna Thorn #3) by Amanda M. Lee

6. Undead Urges (Luna Thorn #3)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.70

Format: 302 pages, Kindle Edition

Luna Thorn is a witch about town. She likes to fancy herself a loner, but the truth is, she has the… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Undead Urges (Luna Thorn #3) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Freaky Wedding (Mystic Caravan, #17) by Amanda M. Lee

7. Freaky Wedding (Mystic Caravan, #17)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.71

Format: 294 pages, Kindle Edition

Wedding bells are about to ring for Poet Parker and Kade Denton. They just have to knock a few thin… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Freaky Wedding (Mystic Caravan, #17) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of White Witchmas (Wicked Witches of the Midwest, #23) by Amanda M. Lee

8. White Witchmas (Wicked Witches of the Midwest, #23)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.67

Format: 309 pages, Kindle Edition

Chestnuts are roasting. Jingle bells are rocking. The halls are about to be decked.In other words, … read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's White Witchmas (Wicked Witches of the Midwest, #23) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Grim Reaper Gaffe (Charlie Rhodes, #15) by Amanda M. Lee

9. The Grim Reaper Gaffe (Charlie Rhodes, #15)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.73

Format: 313 pages, Kindle Edition

Charlie Rhodes has fought witches, ghosts, chupacabras, and killer clowns. Now she must face her… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's The Grim Reaper Gaffe (Charlie Rhodes, #15) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Don't Be Afraid of the Spark (Return to Magic, #6) by Lily Harper Hart

10. Don't Be Afraid of the Spark (Return to Magic, #6)

By: Lily Harper Hart

4.69

Format: 240 pages, Kindle Edition

What happens when Michigan’s most famous ghost hunter can’t see a ghost but her daughter can? Harpe… read more

Similar categories in Lily Harper Hart's Don't Be Afraid of the Spark (Return to Magic, #6) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

Cover of Witches in the Kitchen (Magic Inn Paranormal Mysteries #1) by Danielle Garrett

11. Witches in the Kitchen (Magic Inn Paranormal Mysteries #1)

By: Danielle Garrett

4.31

Format: 308 pages, Kindle Edition

A magical inn bursting with paranormal delight. A picture-perfect seaside town filled with humans w… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Garrett's Witches in the Kitchen (Magic Inn Paranormal Mysteries #1) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Masters of Hex (Supernatural Speakeasy, #13) by Lily Harper Hart

12. Masters of Hex (Supernatural Speakeasy, #13)

By: Lily Harper Hart

4.69

Format: 231 pages, Kindle Edition

Life in the French Quarter is about to calm down for the off-season, so of course things in Ofelia … read more

Similar categories in Lily Harper Hart's Masters of Hex (Supernatural Speakeasy, #13) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Hextraordinary Circumstances (Supernatural Speakeasy, #12) by Lily Harper Hart

13. Hextraordinary Circumstances (Supernatural Speakeasy, #12)

By: Lily Harper Hart

4.74

Format: 231 pages, Kindle Edition

Vampires are taking over the French Quarter. Ofelia Archer was hoping for a break, a stretch of qu… read more

Similar categories in Lily Harper Hart's Hextraordinary Circumstances (Supernatural Speakeasy, #12) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Haunted Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 2) by Jenna St. James

14. Haunted Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 2)

By: Jenna St. James

4.69

Format: 148 pages, Kindle Edition

A Midlife Sea Witch Used to Working Alone A Handsome Demigod with a Penchant for Trouble An Islan… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Haunted Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 2) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Fairies in the Foyer (Magic Inn Paranormal Mysteries #2) by Danielle Garrett

15. Fairies in the Foyer (Magic Inn Paranormal Mysteries #2)

By: Danielle Garrett

4.40

Format: 266 pages, Kindle Edition

Fairy godmothers who mean business! The Beechwood Inn for paranormal beings is opening its doors… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Garrett's Fairies in the Foyer (Magic Inn Paranormal Mysteries #2) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Jelly Bean Jiggery-Pokery (A Candy & Chaos Cozy Mystery, #1) by Sara Bourgeois

16. Jelly Bean Jiggery-Pokery (A Candy & Chaos Cozy Mystery, #1)

By: Sara Bourgeois

4.11

Format: 232 pages, Kindle Edition

Welcome to Hemlock Hollow, where witchcraft bubbles beneath the surface. Blue Bell has spent years… read more

Similar categories in Sara Bourgeois's Jelly Bean Jiggery-Pokery (A Candy & Chaos Cozy Mystery, #1) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

Cover of Deadly Souls (Witch in the Woods, #18) by Jenna St. James

17. Deadly Souls (Witch in the Woods, #18)

By: Jenna St. James

4.66

Format: 139 pages, Kindle Edition

A 40-year-old Witch with a New Career... A Gargoyle Sheriff Raising a Teenaged Daughter... An… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Deadly Souls (Witch in the Woods, #18) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Ghosts in the Garden (Magic Inn Paranormal Mysteries #3) by Danielle Garrett

18. Ghosts in the Garden (Magic Inn Paranormal Mysteries #3)

By: Danielle Garrett

4.45

Format: 200 pages, Kindle Edition

When specters speak, secrets unravel. Adjusting to life at Beechwood Inn, with its magical quirk… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Garrett's Ghosts in the Garden (Magic Inn Paranormal Mysteries #3) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Tangled Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 1) by Jenna St. James

19. Tangled Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 1)

By: Jenna St. James

4.52

Format: 152 pages, Kindle Edition

A Midlife Sea Witch Used to Working Alone A Handsome Demigod with a Penchant for Trouble An Island … read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Tangled Waters (An Enchanted Waters Mystery Book 1) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of All Witches on Deck (Moonstone Bay #14) by Amanda M. Lee

20. All Witches on Deck (Moonstone Bay #14)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.66

Format: 280 pages, Kindle Edition

Hadley Hunter is the new mayor about town...and she's about of find trouble. She won't be alone for… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's All Witches on Deck (Moonstone Bay #14) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Witches Get Stitches (Witch on the Rocks, #8) by Lily Harper Hart

21. Witches Get Stitches (Witch on the Rocks, #8)

By: Lily Harper Hart

4.64

Format: 232 pages, Kindle Edition

Hali Waverly is in a holding pattern following hip surgery. She’s getting better, but she still has… read more

Similar categories in Lily Harper Hart's Witches Get Stitches (Witch on the Rocks, #8) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of An Unlucky Murder (Kara Hilder, #6) by Jenna St. James

22. An Unlucky Murder (Kara Hilder, #6)

By: Jenna St. James

4.64

Format: 162 pages, Kindle Edition

A Valkyrie with Haphazard Magic A Fallen Angel Seeking Redemption An Unlikely Crime-Solving Duo Whe… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's An Unlucky Murder (Kara Hilder, #6) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

Cover of Murder on Winter Island  (Kara Hilder, #8) by Jenna St. James

23. Murder on Winter Island (Kara Hilder, #8)

By: Jenna St. James

4.66

Format: 144 pages, Kindle Edition

A Valkyrie with Haphazard Magic A Fallen Angel Seeking Redemption An Unlikely Crime-Solving D… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Murder on Winter Island (Kara Hilder, #8) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Deadly Storm (Witch in the Woods, #22) by Jenna St. James

24. Deadly Storm (Witch in the Woods, #22)

By: Jenna St. James

4.65

Format: 151 pages, Kindle Edition

A 40-year-old Witch with a New Career A Gargoyle Sheriff Raising a Teenaged Daughter And an Enchant… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Deadly Storm (Witch in the Woods, #22) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Deadly Secrets (Witch in the Woods, #19) by Jenna St. James

25. Deadly Secrets (Witch in the Woods, #19)

By: Jenna St. James

4.65

Format: 135 pages, Kindle Edition

As Shayla, Alex, and Needles prepare for Zoie's big graduation day from high school during the busy… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Deadly Secrets (Witch in the Woods, #19) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Murder at Mystic Market (Kara Hilder, #7) by Jenna St. James

26. Murder at Mystic Market (Kara Hilder, #7)

By: Jenna St. James

4.66

Format: 155 pages, Kindle Edition

A Valkyrie with Haphazard MagicA Fallen Angel Seeking RedemptionAn Unlikely Crime-Solving DuoWith M… read more

Similar categories in Jenna St. James's Murder at Mystic Market (Kara Hilder, #7) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1) by Mara Webb

27. Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

By: Mara Webb

4.61

Format: 203 pages, Kindle Edition

Life can take a wicked turn in the blink of an eye! In a single fateful day, Sage Rivers loses h… read more

Similar categories in Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Freaky Ways (Mystic Caravan, #18) by Amanda M. Lee

28. Freaky Ways (Mystic Caravan, #18)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.69

Format: 312 pages, Kindle Edition

The honeymoon is over for Poet and Kade. After a blissful week off from the day-to-day grind of the… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Freaky Ways (Mystic Caravan, #18) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

Cover of Taming of the Brew (Supernatural Speakeasy, #15) by Lily Harper Hart

29. Taming of the Brew (Supernatural Speakeasy, #15)

By: Lily Harper Hart

4.70

Format: 239 pages, Kindle Edition

Life in the French Quarter is quiet…which is exactly how Ofeila Archer likes it. She’s making plans… read more

Similar categories in Lily Harper Hart's Taming of the Brew (Supernatural Speakeasy, #15) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Two Birds, One Crone (Spell's Angels #12) by Amanda M. Lee

30. Two Birds, One Crone (Spell's Angels #12)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.69

Format: 338 pages, Kindle Edition

Scout Randall thought she had things well in hand. Then a loa landed in her lap and life exploded.B… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Two Birds, One Crone (Spell's Angels #12) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

Cover of Hexy Hijinks (Luna Thorn #4) by Amanda M. Lee

31. Hexy Hijinks (Luna Thorn #4)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.65

Format: 341 pages, Kindle Edition

Luna, Jesse, the Grimlocks, and the rest of the gang are back for more fun...and more trouble.Full … read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Hexy Hijinks (Luna Thorn #4) book and Mara Webb's Potions and Peril (Wicked Witches of Spellcaster Creek, #1)

22 best-selling paranormal books like An Unlucky Murder (Kara Hilder, #6) by Jenna St. James

Transform Your Habits

Chilled to the Crone (Spell's Angels, #11)

Amanda M. Lee

4.59

Transform Your Habits

All Quiet On the Witchy Front (Wicked Witches of the Midwest #24)

Amanda M. Lee

4.70

Transform Your Habits

Witching on the Job (Moonstone Bay #13)

Amanda M. Lee

4.59

Transform Your Habits

Hexcess Baggage (Supernatural Speakeasy, #14)

Lily Harper Hart

4.69

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.