12 Top suspense books like Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1) by Jennifer Rebecca

Cover of Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1) by Jennifer Rebecca

Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

By: Jennifer Rebecca

3.68

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

George Washington Township, New Jersey has seen its fair share of crime and tragedy. Most recently,…

If you liked the suspense plot in Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1) by Jennifer Rebecca , here is a list of 12 books like this:

Cover of Dreams for Stones by Ann Warner

1. Dreams for Stones

By: Ann Warner

4.39

Format: None pages, ebook

A man holding fast to grief and a woman who lets go of love too easily. It will take all the magic … read more

Similar categories in Ann Warner's Dreams for Stones book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary
"I know from our talks, you worry about making the right choices in your life. I cannot nor should anyone, tell you what to do. For that, my dear, you must listen to your own heart. And, never fear, i…"

-Ann Warner, Dreams for Stones

Cover of The Last Call (Bill Travis Mysteries, #1) by George Wier

2. The Last Call (Bill Travis Mysteries, #1)

By: George Wier

3.53

Format: 231 pages, Kindle Edition

The Last Call is the first of six completed novels in The Bill Travis Mysteries. Bill Travis, an… read more

Similar categories in George Wier's The Last Call (Bill Travis Mysteries, #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of Someone Else's Fairytale (Someone Else's Fairytale, #1) by E.M. Tippetts

3. Someone Else's Fairytale (Someone Else's Fairytale, #1)

By: E.M. Tippetts

3.55

Format: 199 pages, Kindle Edition

Alternate cover edition for ASIN B006JD115K Jason Vanderholt, Hollywood's hottest actor, falls head… read more

Similar categories in E.M. Tippetts's Someone Else's Fairytale (Someone Else's Fairytale, #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary

4. A Hero to Keep (Hawkins Brothers #1)

By: Susan Gable

4.24

Format: 384 pages,

Sometimes you have to fight for what - for who- you love. Shannon Vanderhoff's childhood taught her… read more

Similar categories in Susan Gable's A Hero to Keep (Hawkins Brothers #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary

5. Eleven Days: An Unexpected Love (Days Trilogy, #1)

By: Lora Lindy

3.42

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

After the death of her beloved cousin, Lana Andrews has to get away to be alone, to grieve. Little … read more

Similar categories in Lora Lindy's Eleven Days: An Unexpected Love (Days Trilogy, #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

Cover of Beyond Reason (Reese Link, #1) by Molly Black

6. Beyond Reason (Reese Link, #1)

By: Molly Black

4.12

Format: 201 pages, Kindle Edition

In a small harbor town in Maine, police officer Reese Link’s first day on the force begins with a … read more

Similar categories in Molly Black's Beyond Reason (Reese Link, #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of Shadow Falls (Detective Madison Harper, #1) by Wendy Dranfield

7. Shadow Falls (Detective Madison Harper, #1)

By: Wendy Dranfield

4.36

Format: 364 pages, Kindle Edition

You thought your little girl was safe at summer camp. You were wrong… The little girl drags her … read more

Similar categories in Wendy Dranfield's Shadow Falls (Detective Madison Harper, #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of The Girl from Silent Lake (Detective Kay Sharp #1) by Leslie Wolfe

8. The Girl from Silent Lake (Detective Kay Sharp #1)

By: Leslie Wolfe

4.32

Format: 356 pages, Kindle Edition

Her daughter, with emerald eyes and the sweetest smile, is everything to her. Her whole world. “Mom… read more

Similar categories in Leslie Wolfe's The Girl from Silent Lake (Detective Kay Sharp #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of Let Her Go (Fiona Red #1) by Blake Pierce

9. Let Her Go (Fiona Red #1)

By: Blake Pierce

3.73

Format: 163 pages, Kindle Edition

When a new serial killer strikes, the FBI, stumped, turns to its brilliant forensic examiner and en… read more

Similar categories in Blake Pierce's Let Her Go (Fiona Red #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of The Little Grave (Detective Amanda Steele #1) by Carolyn Arnold

10. The Little Grave (Detective Amanda Steele #1)

By: Carolyn Arnold

4.16

Format: 324 pages, Kindle Edition

Detective Amanda Steele stops just inside the doorway, recognizing the victim’s face instantly. He … read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Arnold's The Little Grave (Detective Amanda Steele #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
"Lead sank in Amanda’s gut, a premonition setting that everything was about to come crumbling down on top of her."

-Carolyn Arnold, The Little Grave (Detective Amanda Steele #1)

"In that moment there was an unmistakable bond between the two women made of pain that no one should ever need endure."

-Carolyn Arnold, The Little Grave (Detective Amanda Steele #1)

"Law enforcement might still mostly be a man’s world, but the women who did the job weren’t ones you wanted to mess with."

-Carolyn Arnold, The Little Grave (Detective Amanda Steele #1)

"Once you saw an image of that, there was no going back, and the one Amanda had just seen would be burned on her brain for life."

-Carolyn Arnold, The Little Grave (Detective Amanda Steele #1)

Cover of The Fallen Girls (Detective Clara Jefferies, #1) by Kathryn Casey

11. The Fallen Girls (Detective Clara Jefferies, #1)

By: Kathryn Casey

4.17

Format: 326 pages, Kindle Edition

She didn’t notice the corn stalks shiver a few feet to her right. By the time she looked up, the ma… read more

Similar categories in Kathryn Casey's The Fallen Girls (Detective Clara Jefferies, #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of Face of Death (Zoe Prime #1) by Stella Gold

12. Face of Death (Zoe Prime #1)

By: Stella Gold

4.09

Format: 226 pages, Kindle Edition

FBI Special Agent Zoe Prime suffers from a rare condition which also gives her a unique talent—she … read more

Similar categories in Stella Gold's Face of Death (Zoe Prime #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of Hiding from the Sheriff (A Southern Kind of Love, #1) by Palmer Jones

13. Hiding from the Sheriff (A Southern Kind of Love, #1)

By: Palmer Jones

4.07

Format: 248 pages, Kindle Edition

An alternative cover edition for this ASIN can be found here. It was an uncomplicated favor: Go… read more

Similar categories in Palmer Jones's Hiding from the Sheriff (A Southern Kind of Love, #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Still Alive (A Lily Dawn FBI Suspense Thriller, #1) by Ava Strong

14. Still Alive (A Lily Dawn FBI Suspense Thriller, #1)

By: Ava Strong

3.83

Format: 187 pages, Kindle Edition

FBI BAU Special Agent Lily Dawn, half Dutch, half Hispanic, raised in the Caribbean, knows the isle… read more

Similar categories in Ava Strong's Still Alive (A Lily Dawn FBI Suspense Thriller, #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of Summer at Blue Sands Cove (Glorious Summer Book 1) by C.P. Ward

15. Summer at Blue Sands Cove (Glorious Summer Book 1)

By: C.P. Ward

3.75

Format: 254 pages, Kindle Edition

The first book in the sparkling Glorious Summer series from CP Ward, author of Christmas at the Mar… read more

Similar categories in C.P. Ward's Summer at Blue Sands Cove (Glorious Summer Book 1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Need You (Daisy Fortune Private Investigator #1) by Blake Pierce

16. Need You (Daisy Fortune Private Investigator #1)

By: Blake Pierce

4.09

Format: 203 pages, Kindle Edition

When private investigator Daisy Fortune is approached by an uber-wealthy, mysterious woman to disco… read more

Similar categories in Blake Pierce's Need You (Daisy Fortune Private Investigator #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • crime
  • thriller
Cover of Knock Knock (Detectives Lockhart and Green, #1) by Chris Merritt

17. Knock Knock (Detectives Lockhart and Green, #1)

By: Chris Merritt

4.16

Format: 392 pages, Kindle Edition

Natasha Mayston wasn’t expecting anyone to knock on her door so late at night. And she has no idea … read more

Similar categories in Chris Merritt's Knock Knock (Detectives Lockhart and Green, #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime
Cover of Tangled Web (The Carters Book 1) by Wendy Saunders

18. Tangled Web (The Carters Book 1)

By: Wendy Saunders

4.56

Format: 498 pages, Kindle Edition

Cassandra Grayson leads a quiet life managing a library in Queens, NY. There’s only one thing missi… read more

Similar categories in Wendy Saunders's Tangled Web (The Carters Book 1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery
  • suspense
Cover of The Girls on Chalk Hill (Detective Lexi Bennett #1) by Alison Belsham

19. The Girls on Chalk Hill (Detective Lexi Bennett #1)

By: Alison Belsham

4.33

Format: 400 pages, Kindle Edition

They lie on the hillside, wearing matching white dresses, tiaras in their blonde hair. Each of them… read more

Similar categories in Alison Belsham's The Girls on Chalk Hill (Detective Lexi Bennett #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • crime
  • thriller
Cover of Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1) by Jennifer Rebecca

20. Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

By: Jennifer Rebecca

3.68

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

George Washington Township, New Jersey has seen its fair share of crime and tragedy. Most recently,… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1) book and Jennifer Rebecca's Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1)

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • romantic suspense
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • crime

10 must-read contemporary books like Tell Me a Story (Claire Goodnite #1) by Jennifer Rebecca

Transform Your Habits

Dreams for Stones

Ann Warner

4.39

Transform Your Habits

Someone Else's Fairytale (Someone Else's Fairytale, #1)

E.M. Tippetts

3.55

A Hero to Keep (Hawkins Brothers #1)

Susan Gable

4.24

Transform Your Habits

The Girl from Silent Lake (Detective Kay Sharp #1)

Leslie Wolfe

4.32

View all the books

20 Top fiction books like The Fallen Girls (Detective Clara Jefferies, #1) by Kathryn Casey

Transform Your Habits

All Good Deeds (Lucy Kendall, #1)

Stacy Green

4.04

Transform Your Habits

The Girls In The Water (Detectives King and Lane, #1)

Victoria Jenkins

4.06

Transform Your Habits

The Birthday (Detective Natalie Ward, #1)

Carol Wyer

4.08

Transform Your Habits

Girl Without a Chance (A Tara Strong Mystery #1)

Rylie Dark

3.92

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.