15 best-selling mystery thriller books like The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1) by Kelly Utt

Cover of The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1) by Kelly Utt

The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

By: Kelly Utt

3.39

Format: 210 pages, Kindle Edition

A terrible accident, a sister's betrayal, and the bonds that keep families together against all odd…

If you liked the mystery thriller plot in The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1) by Kelly Utt , here is a list of 15 books like this:

Cover of No Kiss Goodbye by Janelle Harris

1. No Kiss Goodbye

By: Janelle Harris

2.67

Format: 166 pages,

Kids change your life, they said. Things will never be the same again, they said. Isn't it wonderfu… read more

Similar categories in Janelle Harris's No Kiss Goodbye book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • thriller
  • fiction

2. Itsy Bitsy Spider (Emma Frost #1)

By: Willow Rose

4.46

Format: 192 pages,

Emma Frost inherits a house on Fanoe Island when her grandmother dies. She decides to move there wi… read more

Similar categories in Willow Rose's Itsy Bitsy Spider (Emma Frost #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

Cover of Redemption by Phil M. Williams

3. Redemption

By: Phil M. Williams

4.38

Format: 408 pages, Kindle Edition

Do you really trust your husband? That’s what I had to decide. I had it all. At least that’s wha… read more

Similar categories in Phil M. Williams's Redemption book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Lakehouse Promises (Laurel Cove #1) by Jodi Allen Brice

4. Lakehouse Promises (Laurel Cove #1)

By: Jodi Allen Brice

4.48

Format: 432 pages, Kindle Edition

Carolina Johnson had the life everyone wanted. A solid marriage of twenty years. A gorgeous house i… read more

Similar categories in Jodi Allen Brice's Lakehouse Promises (Laurel Cove #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Little Lost Secrets (Georgiana Germaine #2) by Cheryl Bradshaw

5. Little Lost Secrets (Georgiana Germaine #2)

By: Cheryl Bradshaw

4.33

Format: 239 pages, Kindle Edition

When a dead body is found in the walls during a home renovation, detective Georgiana Germaine gets … read more

Similar categories in Cheryl Bradshaw's Little Lost Secrets (Georgiana Germaine #2) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Advocate's Labyrinth (The Advocate, #12) by Teresa Burrell

6. The Advocate's Labyrinth (The Advocate, #12)

By: Teresa Burrell

4.52

Format: 328 pages, Kindle Edition

When Attorney Sabre Brown’s eccentric Aunt Goldie dies, leaving a series of cryptic notes, Sabre la… read more

Similar categories in Teresa Burrell's The Advocate's Labyrinth (The Advocate, #12) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Til Death Do Us Part by Daniel Hurst

7. Til Death Do Us Part

By: Daniel Hurst

4.13

Format: 325 pages, Kindle Edition

Megan thinks that she has the perfect husband and the perfect life. Craig works so that she doesn't… read more

Similar categories in Daniel Hurst's Til Death Do Us Part book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • audiobook
Cover of The Castaway (Shipwreck Key, #1) by Stephanie Taylor

8. The Castaway (Shipwreck Key, #1)

By: Stephanie Taylor

4.49

Format: 214 pages, Kindle Edition

A President dies under mysterious circumstances, leaving a secret mistress and their twelve-year-ol… read more

Similar categories in Stephanie Taylor's The Castaway (Shipwreck Key, #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Lucy's Coming For You by Ashley Beegan

9. Lucy's Coming For You

By: Ashley Beegan

3.85

Format: 300 pages, Kindle Edition

Summer Thomas questions her own sanity when violent patient, Lucy Clark, disappears from a locked h… read more

Similar categories in Ashley Beegan's Lucy's Coming For You book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Widow (Serenity's Plain Secrets, #9) by Karen Ann Hopkins

10. The Widow (Serenity's Plain Secrets, #9)

By: Karen Ann Hopkins

4.33

Format: 233 pages, Kindle Edition

Some Amish communities aren’t so cozy. The Widow is the next installment to the Serenity’s Plain… read more

Similar categories in Karen Ann Hopkins's The Widow (Serenity's Plain Secrets, #9) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Let Me In (Morgan Young, #1) by Adam Nicholls

11. Let Me In (Morgan Young, #1)

By: Adam Nicholls

3.77

Format: 298 pages, Kindle Edition

All he wanted was to stop a killer. He never knew what it would cost. Morgan Young only took the sm… read more

Similar categories in Adam Nicholls's Let Me In (Morgan Young, #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of The First Time I Died (Garnet McGee, #1) by Jo Macgregor

12. The First Time I Died (Garnet McGee, #1)

By: Jo Macgregor

4.27

Format: 422 pages, Kindle Edition

The first time I died, I didn’t come back alone. When Garnet McGee returns to her small Vermo… read more

Similar categories in Jo Macgregor's The First Time I Died (Garnet McGee, #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • audiobook
Cover of Night Song (Serenity's Plain Secrets, #14) by Karen Ann Hopkins

13. Night Song (Serenity's Plain Secrets, #14)

By: Karen Ann Hopkins

4.28

Format: 269 pages, Kindle Edition

After the bishop’s younger sister, Martha Mast, makes a plea for help, the holy man asks a favor of… read more

Similar categories in Karen Ann Hopkins's Night Song (Serenity's Plain Secrets, #14) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Dark Hollow Road (Possum Gap, #2) by Karen Ann Hopkins

14. Dark Hollow Road (Possum Gap, #2)

By: Karen Ann Hopkins

4.43

Format: 288 pages, Paperback

Surrounded by wilderness is Possum Gap, the isolated town in Kentucky where dark secrets and violen… read more

Similar categories in Karen Ann Hopkins's Dark Hollow Road (Possum Gap, #2) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of My Husband's Fiancée (My Husband's Fiancée, #1) by Wendy Owens

15. My Husband's Fiancée (My Husband's Fiancée, #1)

By: Wendy Owens

4.11

Format: 242 pages, Kindle Edition

When my husband’s mistress was found brutally murdered, I was the one imprisoned for the crime. … read more

Similar categories in Wendy Owens's My Husband's Fiancée (My Husband's Fiancée, #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of Dead Upon Arrival (Maddie Swallows #2) by Kat Bellemore

16. Dead Upon Arrival (Maddie Swallows #2)

By: Kat Bellemore

4.12

Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition

Flying high in the New Mexican sky has never been more lethal. The biggest hot air balloon festi… read more

Similar categories in Kat Bellemore's Dead Upon Arrival (Maddie Swallows #2) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Once a Wife (A Mother's Heart #2) by Patricia Keelyn

17. Once a Wife (A Mother's Heart #2)

By: Patricia Keelyn

4.22

Format: 300 pages, Kindle Edition

At seventeen, Sarah Colby had been scared and desperate. Her marriage to Reece Colby was falter… read more

Similar categories in Patricia Keelyn's Once a Wife (A Mother's Heart #2) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of The Seaside House (Marina Cove Book 1) by Sophie Kenna

18. The Seaside House (Marina Cove Book 1)

By: Sophie Kenna

4.33

Format: 382 pages, Kindle Edition

A shattered family. A long-lost love. And devastating secrets that could tear her life apart. Dec… read more

Similar categories in Sophie Kenna's The Seaside House (Marina Cove Book 1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

Cover of The Silent Boy (Sloane & Maddie, Peril Awaits #1) by Cheryl Bradshaw

19. The Silent Boy (Sloane & Maddie, Peril Awaits #1)

By: Cheryl Bradshaw

4.10

Format: 176 pages, Kindle Edition

Private Investigator Sloane Monroe is about to face the most challenging case of her life, and this… read more

Similar categories in Cheryl Bradshaw's The Silent Boy (Sloane & Maddie, Peril Awaits #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of May and Ted: A story of love and perspective by J.D.  Robertson

20. May and Ted: A story of love and perspective

By: J.D. Robertson

4.03

Format: 360 pages, Kindle Edition

May isn’t your average child. Neither is Ted. May is controlling and manipulative. Ted is brilliant… read more

Similar categories in J.D. Robertson's May and Ted: A story of love and perspective book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • thriller
  • contemporary
Cover of The Guest Bedroom (Standalone Psychological Thrillers) by A.J.  Carter

21. The Guest Bedroom (Standalone Psychological Thrillers)

By: A.J. Carter

4.03

Format: 328 pages, Kindle Edition

An utterly addictive psychological thriller with a shocking twist What if a psychopath was in yo… read more

Similar categories in A.J. Carter's The Guest Bedroom (Standalone Psychological Thrillers) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

Cover of Cemetery View: A Novel by A.M. Caplan

22. Cemetery View: A Novel

By: A.M. Caplan

4.19

Format: 281 pages, Kindle Edition

When a shocking discovery unearths an old secret, can Stella expose a killer?Abandoned by her mothe… read more

Similar categories in A.M. Caplan's Cemetery View: A Novel book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
Cover of A Lie Worth Living (Grace Miller, #1) by Simon    King

23. A Lie Worth Living (Grace Miller, #1)

By: Simon King

4.21

Format: 284 pages, Kindle Edition

An island paradise with all the trimmings. Gossip, lies, and murder. With the tragic passing of … read more

Similar categories in Simon King's A Lie Worth Living (Grace Miller, #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Killer on the Run (DI Kayli Bright Trilogy, #2) by M.A. Comley

24. Killer on the Run (DI Kayli Bright Trilogy, #2)

By: M.A. Comley

4.34

Format: 175 pages, Kindle Edition

DI Kayli Bright is called to the scene of a terrible accident that appears to be a case of careless… read more

Similar categories in M.A. Comley's Killer on the Run (DI Kayli Bright Trilogy, #2) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Blue Blooded (Lord & Lady Hetheridge #5) by Emma Jameson

25. Blue Blooded (Lord & Lady Hetheridge #5)

By: Emma Jameson

4.38

Format: 291 pages, Kindle Edition

Tony Hetheridge is stepping into a new career—private detective. As a Chief Superintendent for New … read more

Similar categories in Emma Jameson's Blue Blooded (Lord & Lady Hetheridge #5) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • audiobook
Cover of The Cottage at Hope Cove (Hope Cove, #1) by Hannah Ellis

26. The Cottage at Hope Cove (Hope Cove, #1)

By: Hannah Ellis

4.34

Format: 337 pages, Kindle Edition

The summer that changed everything... Lizzie Beaumont has it all: a great career, a wealthy fiancé… read more

Similar categories in Hannah Ellis's The Cottage at Hope Cove (Hope Cove, #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Let Me Love You (Whisper Lake, #3) by Melanie Shawn

27. Let Me Love You (Whisper Lake, #3)

By: Melanie Shawn

4.39

Format: None pages, None

Stand-alone Whisper Lake romance, complete with HEA--and plenty of heat and heart along the way!Si… read more

Similar categories in Melanie Shawn's Let Me Love You (Whisper Lake, #3) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • romance
  • contemporary
Cover of The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1) by Kelly Utt

28. The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

By: Kelly Utt

3.39

Format: 210 pages, Kindle Edition

A terrible accident, a sister's betrayal, and the bonds that keep families together against all odd… read more

Similar categories in Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • audiobook
Cover of Color of Blood (Dennis Cunningham, #1) by Keith Yocum

29. Color of Blood (Dennis Cunningham, #1)

By: Keith Yocum

4.23

Format: 387 pages, Kindle Edition

Dennis is glad to be back at work. His wife’s death left him devastated but he’ll do anything to lo… read more

Similar categories in Keith Yocum's Color of Blood (Dennis Cunningham, #1) book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

  • romance
  • thriller
  • fiction
  • mystery
Cover of Little Boy Lost: A Story of Hope and Redemption, Set Amidst the Backdrop of a Mother's Suicide by David Peters

30. Little Boy Lost: A Story of Hope and Redemption, Set Amidst the Backdrop of a Mother's Suicide

By: David Peters

4.49

Format: 255 pages, Kindle Edition

Little Boy Lost – the true story of one boy’s heartache and hope while coming of age in small-town … read more

Similar categories in David Peters's Little Boy Lost: A Story of Hope and Redemption, Set Amidst the Backdrop of a Mother's Suicide book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

Cover of Bridgewater by Charlie Wood

31. Bridgewater

By: Charlie Wood

4.05

Format: 292 pages, Kindle Edition

Bridgewater is a sleepy little town on the outskirts of West Virginia. This is the story of a visit… read more

Similar categories in Charlie Wood's Bridgewater book and Kelly Utt's The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1)

21 Top fiction books like The Sisters of Kestrel Cay (Hideaway Isle, #1) by Kelly Utt

Transform Your Habits

No Kiss Goodbye

Janelle Harris

2.67

Transform Your Habits

Redemption

Phil M. Williams

4.38

Transform Your Habits

Lakehouse Promises (Laurel Cove #1)

Jodi Allen Brice

4.48

Transform Your Habits

Little Lost Secrets (Georgiana Germaine #2)

Cheryl Bradshaw

4.33

View all the books

11 Best fiction books like The Silent Boy (Sloane & Maddie, Peril Awaits #1) by Cheryl Bradshaw

Transform Your Habits

Buried (Twisted Cedar Mysteries, #1)

C.J. Carmichael

3.50

Transform Your Habits

Not Now (Camille Grace, #2)

Kate Bold

4.15

Transform Your Habits

Broken (Casey Bolt #1)

Molly Black

3.64

Transform Your Habits

The Silent Boy (Sloane & Maddie, Peril Awaits #1)

Cheryl Bradshaw

4.10

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.