15 must-read cozy mystery books like Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11) by Kelly Ann Riley

Cover of Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11) by Kelly Ann Riley

Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

By: Kelly Ann Riley

4.05

Format: 273 pages, Hardcover

It’s baseball season in Ivy Bay, and the entire town is cheering for its team, the Blue Jays. Mary …

If you liked the cozy mystery plot in Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11) by Kelly Ann Riley , here is a list of 15 books like this:

Cover of The Valentine Visitor (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #12) by Emily Thomas

1. The Valentine Visitor (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #12)

By: Emily Thomas

4.15

Format: 277 pages, Hardcover

It's early February in Blue Hill, and Anne Gibson is surprised to receive a Valentine's Day postcar… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's The Valentine Visitor (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #12) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Isle of the Lost (Descendants #1) by Melissa de la Cruz

2. The Isle of the Lost (Descendants #1)

By: Melissa de la Cruz

3.81

Format: 320 pages, Kindle Edition

Twenty years ago, all the evil villains were banished from the kingdom of Auradon and made to live … read more

Similar categories in Melissa de la Cruz's The Isle of the Lost (Descendants #1) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

"It was the truth, and like any truth, it was powerful."

-Melissa de la Cruz, The Isle of the Lost (Descendants #1)

"It was hopeless. Their journey was ended before it had truly begun."

-Melissa de la Cruz, The Isle of the Lost (Descendants #1)

"What Mal wanted, more than anything, was to be just like her mother. Exactly like her."

-Melissa de la Cruz, The Isle of the Lost (Descendants #1)

"We've been wicked for such a very long time, you know. It does get tiresome after a while."

-Melissa de la Cruz, The Isle of the Lost (Descendants #1)

Cover of Theft and Thanksgiving (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #4) by Emily Thomas

3. Theft and Thanksgiving (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #4)

By: Emily Thomas

4.03

Format: 283 pages, Hardcover

Anne Gibson is alarmed when identity thefts leave elderly Blue Hill citizens with bank accounts dra… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Theft and Thanksgiving (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #4) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6) by Emily Thomas

4. Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6)

By: Emily Thomas

4.40

Format: 277 pages, Hardcover

When the mayor of Blue Hill visits Anne to talk about a new tax proposal that will soon go before t… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3) by Emily Thomas

5. Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3)

By: Emily Thomas

4.57

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When an unmarked envelope arrives at the library, containing a mock-up of a newspaper article, Anne… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Shadows of the Past (Secrets of Blue Hill Library, #2) by Emily Thomas

6. Shadows of the Past (Secrets of Blue Hill Library, #2)

By: Emily Thomas

4.00

Format: 321 pages, Hardcover

While cataloging books at the library, Anne stumbles on an old, yellowed map of Pennsylvania tucked… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Shadows of the Past (Secrets of Blue Hill Library, #2) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
  • cozy mystery
Cover of If walls could talk by Emily Thomas

7. If walls could talk

By: Emily Thomas

3.33

Format: 288 pages, Hardcover

After a heavy rain, Anne discovers that one of the walls in the library basement is crumbling. She … read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's If walls could talk book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Without a trace by Emily Thomas

8. Without a trace

By: Emily Thomas

4.00

Format: None pages,

Following a meeting of the Blue Hill Library's writing group. Lucas Miller disappears. His teenage … read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Without a trace book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Cracking the code by Emily Thomas

9. Cracking the code

By: Emily Thomas

4.11

Format: 15 pages, Hardcover

Anne and Wendy are preparing for a new adult literacy class when Ben races inside the library to te… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Cracking the code book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction

10. Mum's the Word (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library #17)

By: Emily Thomas

3.29

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When Anne finds an ancient Egyptian clay pot in the attic, which Aunt Edie excavated at an archaeol… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Mum's the Word (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library #17) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

11. The Rightful Owner (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library Book #10)

By: Emily Thomas

3.75

Format: 40 pages, Hardcover

Anne and Wendy decide to organize a used books sale to raise money for the library. As Anne is sort… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's The Rightful Owner (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library Book #10) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

12. Dewey: The Small-Town Library Cat Who Touched the World

By: Vicki Myron , Bret Witter

3.69

Format: 384 pages, Hardcover

How much of an impact can an animal have? How many lives can one cat touch? How is it possible for … read more

Similar categories in Vicki Myron's Dewey: The Small-Town Library Cat Who Touched the World book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

13. Stagestruck

By: Emily Thomas

3.60

Format: 224 pages, Hardcover

Anne is thrilled when her old high school friend Tami Bates returns to Blue Hill for a visit. Tami … read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Stagestruck book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

14. Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet

By: Jamie Ford

3.71

Format: 224 pages, Hardcover

Set during one of the most conflicted and volatile times in American history - the internment of Am… read more

Similar categories in Jamie Ford's Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

15. Nowhere to be found (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #1)

By: Emily Thomas

4.23

Format: 528 pages, Hardcover

While converting the Victorian home left by her great-aunt Edie into a library, Anne Gibson stumble… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Nowhere to be found (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #1) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

16. Christmas key (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #5)

By: Emily Thomas

4.00

Format: None pages, Hardcover

Anne is busy preparing for Christmas when she finds a delicate key among Aunt Edie's holiday decora… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Christmas key (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #5) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

17. All sewn up

By: Emily Thomas

4.60

Format: 200 pages, Hardcover

While scouring Aunt Edie's attic for supplies to help Wendy with her latest project, Anne discovers… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's All sewn up book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

18. Gone in a flash

By: Emily Thomas

3.33

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When Anne finds a roll of undeveloped film in an old camera of her great-aunt Edie's and has it pro… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Gone in a flash book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

Cover of Pink Lemonade Cake Murder (Hannah Swensen, #29) by Joanne Fluke

19. Pink Lemonade Cake Murder (Hannah Swensen, #29)

By: Joanne Fluke

3.38

Format: 290 pages, Hardcover

In this irresistible mystery from New York Times and USA Today bestselling author Joanne Fluke, Han… read more

Similar categories in Joanne Fluke's Pink Lemonade Cake Murder (Hannah Swensen, #29) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of All That Glitters (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #15) by Emily Thomas

20. All That Glitters (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #15)

By: Emily Thomas

4.30

Format: 277 pages, Hardcover

When a powerful storm blows through Blue Hill, Anne's children are rescued by a drifter named Jack … read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's All That Glitters (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #15) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Cottage on Nantucket (Nantucket Point, #1) by Jessie Newton

21. The Cottage on Nantucket (Nantucket Point, #1)

By: Jessie Newton

4.29

Format: 514 pages, Kindle Edition

After their mother dies, two sisters return to the cottage where they spent their summers growing u… read more

Similar categories in Jessie Newton's The Cottage on Nantucket (Nantucket Point, #1) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
Cover of Time Will Tell by Carole Jefferson

22. Time Will Tell

By: Carole Jefferson

4.11

Format: 225 pages, Hardcover

When Silver Peak reopens an abandoned rail line as the Mountain Crest Railroad, it kicks off a week… read more

Similar categories in Carole Jefferson's Time Will Tell book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

Cover of Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11) by Kelly Ann Riley

23. Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

By: Kelly Ann Riley

4.05

Format: 273 pages, Hardcover

It’s baseball season in Ivy Bay, and the entire town is cheering for its team, the Blue Jays. Mary … read more

Similar categories in Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Lights! Camera! Action! (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #16) by Emily Thomas

24. Lights! Camera! Action! (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #16)

By: Emily Thomas

4.36

Format: 278 pages, Hardcover

After a fire in an empty warehouse damages the historic Blue Hill Theater, Anne is shocked to learn… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Lights! Camera! Action! (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #16) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

Cover of Sail Away Home (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #21) by Cara C. Putman

25. Sail Away Home (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #21)

By: Cara C. Putman

3.94

Format: 268 pages, Hardcover

Priscilla and her cousins solve all kinds of mysteries on the island of Martha's Vineyard. read more

Similar categories in Cara C. Putman's Sail Away Home (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #21) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Sheeps Passing in the Night (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #20) by Elizabeth Ludwig

26. Sheeps Passing in the Night (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #20)

By: Elizabeth Ludwig

3.84

Format: None pages, Hardcover

It’s springtime in Martha’s Vineyard, and Priscilla attends the annual Lambapalooza festival going … read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Ludwig's Sheeps Passing in the Night (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #20) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Beyond the Sea (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #18) by Janice  Thompson

27. Beyond the Sea (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #18)

By: Janice Thompson

4.06

Format: 280 pages, Hardcover

Priscilla is thrilled when her friend Eliza Jamison solicits her help with a special surprise weddi… read more

Similar categories in Janice Thompson's Beyond the Sea (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #18) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Storm Tide (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard) by Elizabeth Penney

28. Storm Tide (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard)

By: Elizabeth Penney

4.00

Format: None pages, Hardcover

Another entry in this series from Guideposts. Priscilla Latham Grant, and her cousin discover a wom… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Penney's Storm Tide (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Waves of Doubt by Nancy Mehl

29. Waves of Doubt

By: Nancy Mehl

4.40

Format: None pages, None

Prickly Virginia Lawrence, a preeminent scholar of Vineyard history, is also a notorious recluse. T… read more

Similar categories in Nancy Mehl's Waves of Doubt book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Lifeline (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard) by Elizabeth Penney

30. Lifeline (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard)

By: Elizabeth Penney

4.11

Format: None pages, Hardcover

In this entry in the Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard series, Priscilla Latham Grant volunteers to he… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Penney's Lifeline (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard) book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

Cover of Flotsam & Jetsam  (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #24 by DeAnna Julie Dodson

31. Flotsam & Jetsam (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #24

By: DeAnna Julie Dodson

4.00

Format: 263 pages, Hardcover

Priscilla and Gerald’s preparations for their upcoming nuptials are interrupted when Gerald’s heirl… read more

Similar categories in DeAnna Julie Dodson's Flotsam & Jetsam (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard #24 book and Kelly Ann Riley's Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11)

11 Best mystery books like Disappearing Acts (Secrets of Mary's Bookshop, #11) by Kelly Ann Riley

Transform Your Habits

Theft and Thanksgiving (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #4)

Emily Thomas

4.03

Transform Your Habits

Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6)

Emily Thomas

4.40

Transform Your Habits

Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3)

Emily Thomas

4.57

Transform Your Habits

Shadows of the Past (Secrets of Blue Hill Library, #2)

Emily Thomas

4.00

View all the books

17 Top fiction books like The Cottage on Nantucket (Nantucket Point, #1) by Jessie Newton

Transform Your Habits

Lakehouse Promises (Laurel Cove #1)

Jodi Allen Brice

4.48

Transform Your Habits

A Chance Love (The Inn at Dune Island, #1)

Fiona Grace

4.09

Transform Your Habits

The Lilac House (Lake Summers, #1)

Barbara Josselsohn

4.13

Transform Your Habits

Sunrise at Crystal Bay (Crystal Bay, #1)

Mia Kent

4.24

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.