25 best-selling fiction books like It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3) by Saranna DeWylde

Cover of It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3) by Saranna DeWylde

It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

By: Saranna DeWylde

3.64

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

Fans of The Ex Hex and Payback’s a Witch won’t want to miss this delightful and entertaining novel …

If you liked the fiction plot in It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3) by Saranna DeWylde , here is a list of 25 books like this:

Cover of Vampire Most Wanted (Argeneau, #20) by Lynsay Sands

1. Vampire Most Wanted (Argeneau, #20)

By: Lynsay Sands

4.17

Format: 358 pages, Mass Market Paperback

For Basha Argeneau, anything is better than facing her estranged family. Even hiding out in swelter… read more

Similar categories in Lynsay Sands's Vampire Most Wanted (Argeneau, #20) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Merhorses and Bubbles by Marion Lindsay, Asia Citro

2. Merhorses and Bubbles

By: Marion Lindsay , Asia Citro

2.00

Format: None pages,

With magical animals, science, mystery, and adventure -- the brand new series Zoey and Sassafras ha… read more

Similar categories in Marion Lindsay's Merhorses and Bubbles book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • fantasy
  • magic
  • fiction
Cover of If Walls Could Talk (Haunted Home Renovation Mystery, #1) by Juliet Blackwell

3. If Walls Could Talk (Haunted Home Renovation Mystery, #1)

By: Juliet Blackwell

3.92

Format: 290 pages, Paperback

Melanie Turner has made quite a name for herself remodeling historic houses in the San Francisco Ba… read more

Similar categories in Juliet Blackwell's If Walls Could Talk (Haunted Home Renovation Mystery, #1) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • fiction
Cover of Murder on the House (Haunted Home Renovation Mystery, #3) by Juliet Blackwell

4. Murder on the House (Haunted Home Renovation Mystery, #3)

By: Juliet Blackwell

4.03

Format: 166 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Since word has spread that contractor Mel Turner can communicate with the spirits of the dead, it's… read more

Similar categories in Juliet Blackwell's Murder on the House (Haunted Home Renovation Mystery, #3) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • fiction
Cover of This Old Homicide (A Fixer-Upper Mystery, #2) by Kate Carlisle

5. This Old Homicide (A Fixer-Upper Mystery, #2)

By: Kate Carlisle

3.70

Format: 264 pages, Paperback

From the New York Times bestselling author of the Bibliophile Mysteries and A High-End Finish comes… read more

Similar categories in Kate Carlisle's This Old Homicide (A Fixer-Upper Mystery, #2) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary

6. One Lucky Vampire (Argeneau, #19)

By: Lynsay Sands

5.00

Format: 500 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Luck be a vampire tonight . . . When Nicole Phillips agreed to hire a housekeeper, she pictured som… read more

Similar categories in Lynsay Sands's One Lucky Vampire (Argeneau, #19) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

7. Immortal Ever After (Argeneau, #18)

By: Lynsay Sands

3.89

Format: 384 pages, Mass Market Paperback

New York Times bestselling author Lynsay Sands delivers a wickedly fun Argeneau novel featuring a v… read more

Similar categories in Lynsay Sands's Immortal Ever After (Argeneau, #18) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

8. Dead Bolt (Haunted Home Renovation Mystery, #2)

By: Juliet Blackwell

3.19

Format: 292 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Turner Construction's latest restoration project is a historic Queen Anne Victorian in San Francisc… read more

Similar categories in Juliet Blackwell's Dead Bolt (Haunted Home Renovation Mystery, #2) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

9. The Immortal Who Loved Me (Argeneau #21)

By: Lynsay Sands

2.83

Format: 64 pages, ebook

A few hours ago, Sherry Carne would have sworn that vampires didn't exist. That's before rogue immo… read more

Similar categories in Lynsay Sands's The Immortal Who Loved Me (Argeneau #21) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

Cover of Witch Please (Fix-It Witches, #1) by Ann Aguirre

10. Witch Please (Fix-It Witches, #1)

By: Ann Aguirre

3.39

Format: 363 pages, Paperback

Practical Magic meets Gilmore Girls in this adorable witchy rom-com with: • A bisexual virgin ba… read more

Similar categories in Ann Aguirre's Witch Please (Fix-It Witches, #1) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • contemporary romance
  • paranormal
Cover of The Only Purple House in Town (Fix-It Witches, #4) by Ann Aguirre

11. The Only Purple House in Town (Fix-It Witches, #4)

By: Ann Aguirre

3.44

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

Iris Collins is the messy one in her family. The "chaos bunny." Her sisters are all wildly successf… read more

Similar categories in Ann Aguirre's The Only Purple House in Town (Fix-It Witches, #4) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Extra Witchy (Fix-It Witches, #3) by Ann Aguirre

12. Extra Witchy (Fix-It Witches, #3)

By: Ann Aguirre

3.76

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

After two failed marriages, Leanne Vanderpol is here for a good time, not for a long time. She only… read more

Similar categories in Ann Aguirre's Extra Witchy (Fix-It Witches, #3) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Once Upon a Royal Summer by Teri Wilson

13. Once Upon a Royal Summer

By: Teri Wilson

3.98

Format: 288 pages, Paperback

A USA TODAY BESTSELLER!!! A theme park “princess” meets a single dad…who turns out to be a real pr… read more

Similar categories in Teri Wilson's Once Upon a Royal Summer book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
Cover of Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5) by Danielle Garrett

14. Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5)

By: Danielle Garrett

4.06

Format: 60 pages, Kindle Edition

Shamrocks, rainbows, pots of gold, and … one irate leprechaun. Spring has sprung, and I’m finall… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Garrett's Leprechauns and Lemon Bars (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries #3.5) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • magic
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Hexes and Honey Buns (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries, #3) by Danielle Garrett

15. Hexes and Honey Buns (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries, #3)

By: Danielle Garrett

4.24

Format: 268 pages, Kindle Edition

The pen is mightier than the sword—but what’s a witch to do when she has writer’s block? After land… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Garrett's Hexes and Honey Buns (Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries, #3) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of A Demon's Guide to Wooing a Witch (Glimmer Falls, #2) by Sarah  Hawley

16. A Demon's Guide to Wooing a Witch (Glimmer Falls, #2)

By: Sarah Hawley

3.78

Format: 432 pages, Paperback

Calladia Cunnington curses the day she met Astaroth the demon, but when he shows up memoryless, why… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Hawley's A Demon's Guide to Wooing a Witch (Glimmer Falls, #2) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Not Your Ex's Hexes (Supernatural Singles, #2) by April Asher

17. Not Your Ex's Hexes (Supernatural Singles, #2)

By: April Asher

3.84

Format: 343 pages, Paperback

In April Asher’s next Supernatural Singles novel, a one-night-stand between a willful witch and a b… read more

Similar categories in April Asher's Not Your Ex's Hexes (Supernatural Singles, #2) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Boss Witch (Fix-It Witches, #2) by Ann Aguirre

18. Boss Witch (Fix-It Witches, #2)

By: Ann Aguirre

3.58

Format: 364 pages, Paperback

The second in an adorable witchy rom-com series by New York Times bestselling author Ann Aguirre, p… read more

Similar categories in Ann Aguirre's Boss Witch (Fix-It Witches, #2) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
"Please stop being yourself, your personality is atrocious"

-Ann Aguirre, Boss Witch (Fix-It Witches, #2)

"I was a real son of a bitch, and I'll die knowing that I was, but I do my best not to be anymore. It's all we can do."

-Ann Aguirre, Boss Witch (Fix-It Witches, #2)

"Fine, you're angry. But I don't care if you pray mad, stay mad, and die mad. That's your choice. Or you could choose to be different.... How this turns out is up to you."

-Ann Aguirre, Boss Witch (Fix-It Witches, #2)

"Clem had her own conflicted feelings about monogamy, but she did know one couldn't simply decide fidelity was for chumps without having a conversation with their partner first. If a relationship stop…"

-Ann Aguirre, Boss Witch (Fix-It Witches, #2)

Cover of Monsters and Mold (Zoey and Sassafras, #2) by Asia Citro

19. Monsters and Mold (Zoey and Sassafras, #2)

By: Asia Citro

4.46

Format: 96 pages, Paperback

A Mighty Girl Book of the Year With magical animals, science, mystery, and adventure -- the brand n… read more

Similar categories in Asia Citro's Monsters and Mold (Zoey and Sassafras, #2) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • fantasy
  • fiction
Cover of The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1) by Sophie H. Morgan

20. The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1)

By: Sophie H. Morgan

3.57

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

Love is a hex of a thing. Former childhood sweethearts fake a relationship in this charming, witchy… read more

Similar categories in Sophie H. Morgan's The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
"Bastian cleared his throat. Looked off to the distance. "Moot point. Look, I get why she did what she did. But it's that she didn't tell me, even after we..." He stopped. "Made sweet, sweet love?" Et…"

-Sophie H. Morgan, The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1)

Cover of Not Your Crush's Cauldron (Supernatural Singles, #3) by April Asher

21. Not Your Crush's Cauldron (Supernatural Singles, #3)

By: April Asher

3.81

Format: 327 pages, Paperback

In April Asher's new Supernatural Singles novel, a witch takes a stroll on the wild-ish side, spark… read more

Similar categories in April Asher's Not Your Crush's Cauldron (Supernatural Singles, #3) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of A Daughter of Fair Verona (Daughter of Montague, #1) by Christina Dodd

22. A Daughter of Fair Verona (Daughter of Montague, #1)

By: Christina Dodd

3.86

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

Knives Out meets Bridgerton in Fair Verona, as New York Times bestselling author Christina Dodd kic… read more

Similar categories in Christina Dodd's A Daughter of Fair Verona (Daughter of Montague, #1) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
Cover of An Intrigue of Witches (Secret Society Mystery, #1) by Esme  Addison

23. An Intrigue of Witches (Secret Society Mystery, #1)

By: Esme Addison

3.61

Format: 288 pages, Kindle Edition

Introducing the Secret Society mystery series, and kick-ass red-headed heroine Sidney, a Black his… read more

Similar categories in Esme Addison's An Intrigue of Witches (Secret Society Mystery, #1) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • magic
  • fiction
  • paranormal
  • adult
  • fantasy
Cover of It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3) by Saranna DeWylde

24. It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

By: Saranna DeWylde

3.64

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

Fans of The Ex Hex and Payback’s a Witch won’t want to miss this delightful and entertaining novel … read more

Similar categories in Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • fantasy
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of A Werewolf’s Guide to Seducing a Vampire (Glimmer Falls, #3) by Sarah  Hawley

25. A Werewolf’s Guide to Seducing a Vampire (Glimmer Falls, #3)

By: Sarah Hawley

3.99

Format: 444 pages, ebook

Ben Rosewood never meant to be bound to a vampire succubus, especially one as sexy-yet-terrifying a… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Hawley's A Werewolf’s Guide to Seducing a Vampire (Glimmer Falls, #3) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Runaway Bride and Prejudice (Appies, #5) by Emma St. Clair

26. Runaway Bride and Prejudice (Appies, #5)

By: Emma St. Clair

4.46

Format: 418 pages, Kindle Edition

There's one rule smart hockey players know not to break: never, and I mean, NEVER date the coach's … read more

Similar categories in Emma St. Clair's Runaway Bride and Prejudice (Appies, #5) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of The Bookshop of Hidden Dreams (Dove Pond, #4) by Karen Hawkins

27. The Bookshop of Hidden Dreams (Dove Pond, #4)

By: Karen Hawkins

4.17

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

A brand new novel in the “sometimes whimsical, often insightful, always absorbing” ( Shelf Awarenes… read more

Similar categories in Karen Hawkins's The Bookshop of Hidden Dreams (Dove Pond, #4) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Murder at Vinland (Gilded Newport Mysteries, #12) by Alyssa Maxwell

28. Murder at Vinland (Gilded Newport Mysteries, #12)

By: Alyssa Maxwell

4.33

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

Reporter and sleuth Emma Cross Andrews must stop a bold poisoner who is targeting the society wives… read more

Similar categories in Alyssa Maxwell's Murder at Vinland (Gilded Newport Mysteries, #12) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • fiction
Cover of The Crescent Moon Tearoom by Stacy Sivinski

29. The Crescent Moon Tearoom

By: Stacy Sivinski

3.98

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

A cozy and uplifting debut novel about three clairvoyant sisters who face an unexpected twist of Fa… read more

Similar categories in Stacy Sivinski's The Crescent Moon Tearoom book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • adult
  • fantasy
Cover of Best Hex Ever by Nadia El-Fassi

30. Best Hex Ever

By: Nadia El-Fassi

3.81

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

A kitchen witch with a penchant for baking and a (literally) cursed love life meets someone who's w… read more

Similar categories in Nadia El-Fassi's Best Hex Ever book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • paranormal romance
  • magic
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Just One Chance (Just One... #1) by Brenna Jacobs

31. Just One Chance (Just One... #1)

By: Brenna Jacobs

4.11

Format: 189 pages, Kindle Edition

Can the new doctor next door save Avery from a broken heart? ER doctor David Daniels thinks his … read more

Similar categories in Brenna Jacobs's Just One Chance (Just One... #1) book and Saranna DeWylde's It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • chick lit
  • contemporary romance

17 must-read contemporary books like It Happened One Midnight (Fairy Godmothers, Inc., #3) by Saranna DeWylde

Transform Your Habits

Vampire Most Wanted (Argeneau, #20)

Lynsay Sands

4.17

Transform Your Habits

This Old Homicide (A Fixer-Upper Mystery, #2)

Kate Carlisle

3.70

Transform Your Habits

Witch Please (Fix-It Witches, #1)

Ann Aguirre

3.39

Transform Your Habits

The Only Purple House in Town (Fix-It Witches, #4)

Ann Aguirre

3.44

View all the books

9 must-read fiction books like Just One Chance (Just One... #1) by Brenna Jacobs

Transform Your Habits

Love Off-Limits (Some Kind of Love, #3)

Jenny Proctor

4.12

Transform Your Habits

A Little in Love With You (A Love at First Note Novella)

Jenny Proctor

3.66

Transform Your Habits

Love Unexpected (Some Kind of Love)

Jenny Proctor

4.13

Transform Your Habits

(Not So) Alone for Christmas

Jenny Proctor

3.91

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.