6 Top christmas books like The Hearts of New Cheltenham by Chautona Havig

Cover of The Hearts of New Cheltenham by Chautona Havig

The Hearts of New Cheltenham

By: Chautona Havig

4.30

Format: None pages, Paperback

The only way not to break her best friend’s heart is to get someone else to steal it. It wasn’t …

If you liked the christmas plot in The Hearts of New Cheltenham by Chautona Havig , here is a list of 6 books like this:

Cover of Love, Mary Elisabeth by Christy Martenson

1. Love, Mary Elisabeth

By: Christy Martenson

4.65

Format: 230 pages, Paperback

Eleven-year-old Mary Elisabeth’s life will never be the same. It’s 1924 and her mother has contract… read more

Similar categories in Christy Martenson's Love, Mary Elisabeth book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of The Blackout Book Club by Amy Lynn Green

2. The Blackout Book Club

By: Amy Lynn Green

3.93

Format: 400 pages, Paperback

An impulsive promise to her brother before he goes off to the European Front puts Avis Montgomery i… read more

Similar categories in Amy Lynn Green's The Blackout Book Club book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

"I have found that books make fine friends--but fellow readers even better."

-Amy Lynn Green, The Blackout Book Club

"Wasn't that one purpose of stories? The best ones might be about good and evil in fictional lands, but they were meant to help people recognize them in the real world. And maybe even teach them how t…"

-Amy Lynn Green, The Blackout Book Club

Cover of Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1) by Pepper Basham

3. Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1)

By: Pepper Basham

3.89

Format: 432 pages, Paperback

“Dear Izzy—I feel certain there’s a book-loving man living relatively nearby waiting to speak booki… read more

Similar categories in Pepper Basham's Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

"The place where they lived within my heart is still being held for them, like a bookmark of sorts - waiting to see them again."

-Pepper Basham, Authentically, Izzy (Skymar, #1)

Cover of All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2) by Nicole Deese

4. All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2)

By: Nicole Deese

4.46

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

When the ever-cautious Val Locklier moves cross-country with her son for a secure job, everything s… read more

Similar categories in Nicole Deese's All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

"Nothing is easy without practice."

-Nicole Deese, All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2)

"Listen. Feel. Create. Always in that order."

-Nicole Deese, All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2)

"Of all the curveballs I'd been thrown, Val was the one I'd reach to catch over and over again."

-Nicole Deese, All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2)

"I'd much rather my life be defined by a thousand little moments of faithfulness than by one big moment of fame."

-Nicole Deese, All That It Takes (McKenzie Family Romance, #2)

Cover of The Berlin Letters by Katherine Reay

5. The Berlin Letters

By: Katherine Reay

4.21

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

Near the end of the Cold War, a CIA code breaker discovers a symbol she recognizes from her childho… read more

Similar categories in Katherine Reay's The Berlin Letters book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of The Sweet Life (Cape Cod Creamery #1) by Suzanne Woods Fisher

6. The Sweet Life (Cape Cod Creamery #1)

By: Suzanne Woods Fisher

4.12

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Dawn Dixon can hardly believe she's on a groomless honeymoon on beautiful Cape Cod . . . with her m… read more

Similar categories in Suzanne Woods Fisher's The Sweet Life (Cape Cod Creamery #1) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Once Upon Nantucket (Lighthouse Lane #1) by Irene Hannon

7. Once Upon Nantucket (Lighthouse Lane #1)

By: Irene Hannon

4.31

Format: 220 pages, Kindle Edition

They’ve loved and lost… but does a new beginning await on magical Nantucket? After fifteen year… read more

Similar categories in Irene Hannon's Once Upon Nantucket (Lighthouse Lane #1) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Positively, Penelope (Skymar, #2) by Pepper Basham

8. Positively, Penelope (Skymar, #2)

By: Pepper Basham

4.21

Format: 396 pages, Paperback

Told mostly through letters, texts, and email, this contemporary romance will charm its way into he… read more

Similar categories in Pepper Basham's Positively, Penelope (Skymar, #2) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

"But don’t let all those big dreams in your head stop you from seeing that sometimes the best adventures can still be in the simplest things. Like home and family."

-Pepper Basham, Positively, Penelope (Skymar, #2)

"He’d never met anyone who wore sunshine quite like Penelope Edgewood. At first, it had been too much. Too overpowering and seemingly inauthentic, but then, over the weeks, her vibrancy melded into th…"

-Pepper Basham, Positively, Penelope (Skymar, #2)

Cover of What Happens Next by Christina Suzann Nelson

9. What Happens Next

By: Christina Suzann Nelson

4.22

Format: 342 pages, Paperback

Popular podcaster and ex-reporter Faith Byrne has made a name for herself telling stories of greatn… read more

Similar categories in Christina Suzann Nelson's What Happens Next book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Love on Ice (Original Six Hockey #2) by Carolyn   Miller

10. Love on Ice (Original Six Hockey #2)

By: Carolyn Miller

4.43

Format: 404 pages, Kindle Edition

She’s focused on winning gold. He wants to lose the player tag. Can a fake relationship become some… read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Miller's Love on Ice (Original Six Hockey #2) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Potential Threat (Black Tower Security #1) by Tara Grace Ericson

11. Potential Threat (Black Tower Security #1)

By: Tara Grace Ericson

4.48

Format: 207 pages, Kindle Edition

Can this bad-boy bodyguard protect America's sweetheart without losing his heart? Fiona Raven is… read more

Similar categories in Tara Grace Ericson's Potential Threat (Black Tower Security #1) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of The Unlikely Yarn of the Dragon Lady  (Purls and Prayers) by Sharon J. Mondragón

12. The Unlikely Yarn of the Dragon Lady (Purls and Prayers)

By: Sharon J. Mondragón

4.42

Format: 264 pages, Paperback

"Mondragon debuts with this charming tale of knitting, faith, and change. . . . Inspirational fans … read more

Similar categories in Sharon J. Mondragón's The Unlikely Yarn of the Dragon Lady (Purls and Prayers) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

  • christmas
Cover of To Win a Prince (In Search of a Prince, #2) by Toni Shiloh

13. To Win a Prince (In Search of a Prince, #2)

By: Toni Shiloh

4.47

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

As a fashion aficionado and best friend of the queen of the African island country Oloro Ilé, Iris … read more

Similar categories in Toni Shiloh's To Win a Prince (In Search of a Prince, #2) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

"Oh."

-Toni Shiloh, To Win a Prince (In Search of a Prince, #2)

"The only thing I could hope for was to show them I was no longer the same man. I did not know how I could change, but something different had to happen. I could not live in this limbo."

-Toni Shiloh, To Win a Prince (In Search of a Prince, #2)

Cover of Not Until Now  (Hope Springs #8) by Valerie M. Bodden

14. Not Until Now (Hope Springs #8)

By: Valerie M. Bodden

4.71

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

“My heart went pitter patter.… A sweet story about forgiveness, redemption and letting go of what y… read more

Similar categories in Valerie M. Bodden's Not Until Now (Hope Springs #8) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of I'll Always Choose You (Trinity Lakes Romance, #3) by Lisa  Renee

15. I'll Always Choose You (Trinity Lakes Romance, #3)

By: Lisa Renee

4.48

Format: 166 pages, Kindle Edition

Leah Thompson is the Sheriff's daughter of Trinity Lakes, Washington state. No one is good enough f… read more

Similar categories in Lisa Renee's I'll Always Choose You (Trinity Lakes Romance, #3) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of The One Who Got Away  (Second Chance Fire Station #1) by Tara Grace Ericson

16. The One Who Got Away (Second Chance Fire Station #1)

By: Tara Grace Ericson

4.50

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

The relationship is fake. But the sparks are real. Can these best friends rekindle a second chance… read more

Similar categories in Tara Grace Ericson's The One Who Got Away (Second Chance Fire Station #1) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Clean Slate (Black Tower Security) by Tara Grace Ericson

17. Clean Slate (Black Tower Security)

By: Tara Grace Ericson

4.31

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

The only person who can help her is the one man she never wants to see again. Personal trainer Jes… read more

Similar categories in Tara Grace Ericson's Clean Slate (Black Tower Security) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Imminent Danger (Black Tower Security) by Tara Grace Ericson

18. Imminent Danger (Black Tower Security)

By: Tara Grace Ericson

4.56

Format: 348 pages, Paperback

None read more

Similar categories in Tara Grace Ericson's Imminent Danger (Black Tower Security) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of A Thousand Words (Unfailing Love, #0) by Mandi Blake

19. A Thousand Words (Unfailing Love, #0)

By: Mandi Blake

4.43

Format: None pages, ebook

Tyler’s last year of residency is all work and no play, just the way he likes it. His life would be… read more

Similar categories in Mandi Blake's A Thousand Words (Unfailing Love, #0) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of The Ocean Between Us (Trinity Lakes Romance, #2) by Meredith Resce

20. The Ocean Between Us (Trinity Lakes Romance, #2)

By: Meredith Resce

4.45

Format: 222 pages, Kindle Edition

Small town romance Second chance romance Alanah, has set off on a trip of a lifetime. Her best frie… read more

Similar categories in Meredith Resce's The Ocean Between Us (Trinity Lakes Romance, #2) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Her Best Friend (Love Off Limits) by Hannah Jo Abbott

21. Her Best Friend (Love Off Limits)

By: Hannah Jo Abbott

4.17

Format: 122 pages, Kindle Edition

What if her best friend turned out to be her soulmate? Julie Hughes had a plan for her life. But… read more

Similar categories in Hannah Jo Abbott's Her Best Friend (Love Off Limits) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Whole Latte Love by Kari Trumbo

22. Whole Latte Love

By: Kari Trumbo

4.21

Format: 156 pages, Paperback

Addi Merrick is a matchmaker with no match. Her past is riddled with friends who married and left … read more

Similar categories in Kari Trumbo's Whole Latte Love book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of The Hearts of New Cheltenham by Chautona Havig

23. The Hearts of New Cheltenham

By: Chautona Havig

4.30

Format: None pages, Paperback

The only way not to break her best friend’s heart is to get someone else to steal it. It wasn’t … read more

Similar categories in Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

  • christmas
Cover of Love Somebody Like You (Trinity Lakes Romance, #5) by Carolyn   Miller

24. Love Somebody Like You (Trinity Lakes Romance, #5)

By: Carolyn Miller

4.42

Format: 222 pages, Kindle Edition

For Lexi Franklin, returning to Trinity Lakes feels a little like running home with her tail betwee… read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Miller's Love Somebody Like You (Trinity Lakes Romance, #5) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Second Chance Sweethearts by Liwen Y. Ho

25. Second Chance Sweethearts

By: Liwen Y. Ho

4.55

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

Two former high school sweethearts and their surprising second chance at love. Missy Clark left … read more

Similar categories in Liwen Y. Ho's Second Chance Sweethearts book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Always and Forever (The Glory Quilts, #1) by Cathe Swanson

26. Always and Forever (The Glory Quilts, #1)

By: Cathe Swanson

4.44

Format: 327 pages, Kindle Edition

Scrap quilts, bridal gowns, an old Swedish farmhouse and a hidden family heirloom. What more you co… read more

Similar categories in Cathe Swanson's Always and Forever (The Glory Quilts, #1) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

  • christmas
Cover of Not Another Christmas (Sinclair Sisters Trilogy Book 3) by Jaycee Weaver

27. Not Another Christmas (Sinclair Sisters Trilogy Book 3)

By: Jaycee Weaver

4.48

Format: 116 pages, Paperback

Childhood neighbors, rivals, enemies. This Christmas, will love have a fighting chance? The palm… read more

Similar categories in Jaycee Weaver's Not Another Christmas (Sinclair Sisters Trilogy Book 3) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

  • christmas
Cover of Big Apple Atonement (Original Six Hockey #5) by Carolyn   Miller

28. Big Apple Atonement (Original Six Hockey #5)

By: Carolyn Miller

4.62

Format: 364 pages, Kindle Edition

She’s the saint with a secret. He’s the sinner with a heart of gold. For Emma Moritello, giving … read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Miller's Big Apple Atonement (Original Six Hockey #5) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

Cover of Kiss Me on Christmas by Sarah Monzon

29. Kiss Me on Christmas

By: Sarah Monzon

4.38

Format: 174 pages, Paperback

Single mom Kaitlyn Stafford has never considered Christmas a balancing act, but when her sister cal… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Monzon's Kiss Me on Christmas book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

  • christmas
Cover of Christmas Camp by Cathe Swanson

30. Christmas Camp

By: Cathe Swanson

4.31

Format: 185 pages, Paperback

What's so special about a white Christmas? Julia expected her first job for the family’s charita… read more

Similar categories in Cathe Swanson's Christmas Camp book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

  • christmas
Cover of Hearts and Goals (Original Six Hockey #4) by Carolyn   Miller

31. Hearts and Goals (Original Six Hockey #4)

By: Carolyn Miller

4.41

Format: 354 pages, Kindle Edition

He’s a goalie with a big heart, while she’s afraid to trust again. After a series of tragedies, … read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Miller's Hearts and Goals (Original Six Hockey #4) book and Chautona Havig's The Hearts of New Cheltenham

31 Top fiction books like To Win a Prince (In Search of a Prince, #2) by Toni Shiloh

Transform Your Habits

Rocky Road (Sons of Scandal, #2)

Becky Wade

4.21

Transform Your Habits

Dear Henry, Love Edith

Becca Kinzer

3.70

Transform Your Habits

The Roads We Follow (Fog Harbor, #2)

Nicole Deese

4.39

Transform Your Habits

For a Lifetime (Timeless, #3)

Gabrielle Meyer

4.55

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.