10 must-read mystery books like The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1) by Eldritch Black

Cover of The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1) by Eldritch Black

The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

By: Eldritch Black

4.08

Format: 226 pages, Kindle Edition

A lost Pirate’s Treasure. A Mysterious Secret Society. A Summer Adventure like no other.Dylan Wylde…

If you liked the mystery plot in The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1) by Eldritch Black , here is a list of 10 books like this:

Cover of The Knight at Dawn (Magic Tree House, #2) by Mary Pope Osborne, Salvatore Murdocca

1. The Knight at Dawn (Magic Tree House, #2)

By: Mary Pope Osborne , Salvatore Murdocca

3.91

Format: 66 pages, Paperback

Peacocks for dinner and boys in skirts? That's what Jack and Annie find when the Magic Tree Hous… read more

Similar categories in Mary Pope Osborne's The Knight at Dawn (Magic Tree House, #2) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • fantasy
  • middle grade
  • childrens
  • fiction
Cover of The Improbable Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Barbara Hambly, Stephen        King, John Joseph Adams, Stephen Baxter, Anne Perry, Neil Gaiman, Geoffrey A. Landis, H. Paul Jeffers, Tanith Lee, Laurie R. King, Michael Moorcock, Chris Roberson, Robert J. Sawyer, Naomi Novik, Tim Lebbon, Mary Robinette Kowal, Sharyn McCrumb, Peter Tremayne, Darrell Schweitzer, Anthony Burgess, Barbara Roden, Dominic Green, Bradley H. Sinor, Rob Rogers, Vonda N. McIntyre, Tony Pi, Mark Valentine, Edward D. Hoch, Amy Myers

2. The Improbable Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

By: Barbara Hambly , Stephen King , John Joseph Adams , Stephen Baxter , Anne Perry , Neil Gaiman , Geoffrey A. Landis , H. Paul Jeffers , Tanith Lee , Laurie R. King , Michael Moorcock , Chris Roberson , Robert J. Sawyer , Naomi Novik , Tim Lebbon , Mary Robinette Kowal , Sharyn McCrumb , Peter Tremayne , Darrell Schweitzer , Anthony Burgess , Barbara Roden , Dominic Green , Bradley H. Sinor , Rob Rogers , Vonda N. McIntyre , Tony Pi , Mark Valentine , Edward D. Hoch , Amy Myers

3.81

Format: 4 pages, Paperback

The game is afoot! Night Shade Books is proud to present the fantastic adventures of the world's gr… read more

Similar categories in Barbara Hambly's The Improbable Adventures of Sherlock Holmes book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • fiction
Cover of Mummies in the Morning (Magic Tree House, #3) by Mary Pope Osborne, Salvatore Murdocca

3. Mummies in the Morning (Magic Tree House, #3)

By: Mary Pope Osborne , Salvatore Murdocca

5.00

Format: 303 pages,

Jack and Annie don't need another mummy.But that's what they get when the Magic Tree House whisks t… read more

Similar categories in Mary Pope Osborne's Mummies in the Morning (Magic Tree House, #3) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • fantasy
  • middle grade
  • childrens
  • fiction

4. Afternoon on the Amazon (Magic Tree House, #6)

By: Mary Pope Osborne , Salvatore Murdocca

4.21

Format: None pages, Paperback

Jack and Annie are ready for their next fantasy adventure in the bestselling middle-grade series--t… read more

Similar categories in Mary Pope Osborne's Afternoon on the Amazon (Magic Tree House, #6) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • fantasy
  • middle grade
  • childrens
  • fiction

5. Night of the Ninjas (Magic Tree House, #5)

By: Mary Pope Osborne , Salvatore Murdocca

5.00

Format: None pages,

Philipp und Anne konnen es kaum glauben: Dunkel vermummte Gestalten klettern zum magischen Baumhaus… read more

Similar categories in Mary Pope Osborne's Night of the Ninjas (Magic Tree House, #5) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

6. Pirates Past Noon (Magic Tree House, #4)

By: Mary Pope Osborne , Salvatore Murdocca

3.80

Format: 25 pages, Paperback

Jack and Annie are ready for their next fantasy adventure in the bestselling middle-grade series--t… read more

Similar categories in Mary Pope Osborne's Pirates Past Noon (Magic Tree House, #4) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

7. The Jumbies (The Jumbies #1)

By: Tracey Baptiste

4.00

Format: 592 pages, Hardcover

A spine-tingling tale rooted in Caribbean folklore that will have readers holding their breath as t… read more

Similar categories in Tracey Baptiste's The Jumbies (The Jumbies #1) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

8. A Hard Day's Night (The Lonely Hearts Club, #1.1)

By: Elizabeth Eulberg

3.67

Format: 220 pages, ebook

Penny Lane Bloom, founder of The Lonely Hearts Club, has never loved Halloween. Her dad's a dentist… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Eulberg's A Hard Day's Night (The Lonely Hearts Club, #1.1) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

Cover of The Swifts: A Dictionary of Scoundrels by Beth Lincoln

9. The Swifts: A Dictionary of Scoundrels

By: Beth Lincoln

4.06

Format: 338 pages, Hardcover

In her family, Shenanigan Swift has always been synonymous with mischief. As Arch-Aunt Schadenfreud… read more

Similar categories in Beth Lincoln's The Swifts: A Dictionary of Scoundrels book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • childrens
  • middle grade
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • audiobook
"According to Arch-Aunt Schadenfreude, a funeral ought to look like a wedding upside down."

-Beth Lincoln, The Swifts: A Dictionary of Scoundrels

"A funeral is supposed to be a way to say goodbye. You look inside yourself and find a place to put your grief, not somewhere hidden, not the top shelf or the back of a cupboard, but maybe by a window…"

-Beth Lincoln, The Swifts: A Dictionary of Scoundrels

"A collective term is a special name given to a group of animals, like a herd of cows. Many animals have their own strange terms. She knew the collective term for starlings was a murmuration, and the …"

-Beth Lincoln, The Swifts: A Dictionary of Scoundrels

"Family was exhausting, and complicated, and everyone was their own person, which meant you had just as much chance of getting along with them as you did any stranger off the street. Just sharing bloo…"

-Beth Lincoln, The Swifts: A Dictionary of Scoundrels

Cover of The House That Horror Built by Christina Henry

10. The House That Horror Built

By: Christina Henry

3.22

Format: 317 pages, Paperback

A single mother working in the gothic mansion of a reclusive horror director stumbles upon terrifyi… read more

Similar categories in Christina Henry's The House That Horror Built book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • fiction
  • audiobook
Cover of The House with Chicken Legs by Sophie   Anderson

11. The House with Chicken Legs

By: Sophie Anderson

4.10

Format: 337 pages, Paperback

All 12-year-old Marinka wants is a friend. A real friend. Not like her house with chicken legs. Sur… read more

Similar categories in Sophie Anderson's The House with Chicken Legs book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • fantasy
  • middle grade
  • childrens
  • fiction
"But it’s our duty as Yaga, living in this Yaga house, to talk to them and give them one last wonderful evening reliving their memories and celebrating their lives, before they pass through The Gate a…"

-Sophie Anderson, The House with Chicken Legs

Cover of Freaky Wedding (Mystic Caravan, #17) by Amanda M. Lee

12. Freaky Wedding (Mystic Caravan, #17)

By: Amanda M. Lee

4.71

Format: 294 pages, Kindle Edition

Wedding bells are about to ring for Poet Parker and Kade Denton. They just have to knock a few thin… read more

Similar categories in Amanda M. Lee's Freaky Wedding (Mystic Caravan, #17) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • mystery
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of The Devil's Dust (Sherlock Holmes) by James Lovegrove

13. The Devil's Dust (Sherlock Holmes)

By: James Lovegrove

3.74

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

It is 1884, and when a fellow landlady finds her lodger poisoned, Mrs Hudson turns to Sherlock Holm… read more

Similar categories in James Lovegrove's The Devil's Dust (Sherlock Holmes) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • fiction
  • audiobook
Cover of What Stays Buried by Suzanne Young

14. What Stays Buried

By: Suzanne Young

4.09

Format: 272 pages, Hardcover

Twelve-year-old Calista Wynn will lose her ability to speak with the dead on her thirteenth birthda… read more

Similar categories in Suzanne Young's What Stays Buried book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • childrens
  • middle grade
  • fiction
  • fantasy
  • mystery
  • paranormal
  • audiobook
"The same love that bound people together could sometimes be a barrier when it turned to grief."

-Suzanne Young, What Stays Buried

"All the love you’ve been holding in—the kind that’s mixed with grief and hurt, you let it out and set us free."

-Suzanne Young, What Stays Buried

"Sometimes, Calista could feel the grief as if it seeped down from the previous generation — sadness as a hereditary condition."

-Suzanne Young, What Stays Buried

Cover of Sabrina the Teenage Witch (Sabrina, #1) by Kelly Thompson

15. Sabrina the Teenage Witch (Sabrina, #1)

By: Kelly Thompson

4.08

Format: 144 pages, Paperback

Kelly Thompson (Uncanny X-Men) and artist Veronica Fish (Spider-Woman, Archie) team-up to tell the … read more

Similar categories in Kelly Thompson's Sabrina the Teenage Witch (Sabrina, #1) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • fiction
  • fantasy
  • young adult
Cover of Fins (Sharks Incorporated #1) by Randy Wayne White

16. Fins (Sharks Incorporated #1)

By: Randy Wayne White

3.98

Format: 320 pages, Hardcover

From Randy Wayne White, the New York Times bestselling author of the Doc Ford series for adults, co… read more

Similar categories in Randy Wayne White's Fins (Sharks Incorporated #1) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • childrens
  • middle grade
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • audiobook
Cover of The Witch's Hand (The Montague Twins, #1) by Nathan  Page

17. The Witch's Hand (The Montague Twins, #1)

By: Nathan Page

4.00

Format: 352 pages, None

Brothers. Detectives. Witches? Meet Pete and Alastair Montague in the first installment of a new gr… read more

Similar categories in Nathan Page's The Witch's Hand (The Montague Twins, #1) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • young adult
Cover of The Black Girl Survives in This One by Desiree S. Evans

18. The Black Girl Survives in This One

By: Desiree S. Evans

4.06

Format: 368 pages, Hardcover

Be warned, dear reader: The Black girls survive in this one. Celebrating a new generation of bes… read more

Similar categories in Desiree S. Evans's The Black Girl Survives in This One book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • fiction
  • fantasy
  • young adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Snafu At The Zoo and More Zanytown Tales! : A Funny Interactive Rhyming Book for Kids by Jeff Eisenbaum

19. Snafu At The Zoo and More Zanytown Tales! : A Funny Interactive Rhyming Book for Kids

By: Jeff Eisenbaum

4.59

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

Oodles of noodles and a treasure chest... Extremely long legs and a lemon quest. A thrilling battle… read more

Similar categories in Jeff Eisenbaum's Snafu At The Zoo and More Zanytown Tales! : A Funny Interactive Rhyming Book for Kids book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • childrens
Cover of Extra Normal by Kate Alice Marshall

20. Extra Normal

By: Kate Alice Marshall

4.25

Format: 239 pages, Kindle Edition

It's hard to fight the supernatural when you're naturally "un-super." This chilling middle grade is… read more

Similar categories in Kate Alice Marshall's Extra Normal book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • childrens
  • middle grade
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • audiobook
Cover of The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1) by Eldritch Black

21. The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

By: Eldritch Black

4.08

Format: 226 pages, Kindle Edition

A lost Pirate’s Treasure. A Mysterious Secret Society. A Summer Adventure like no other.Dylan Wylde… read more

Similar categories in Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1) book and Eldritch Black's The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1)

  • childrens
  • middle grade
  • pirates
  • young adult
  • amazon
  • fiction
  • fantasy
  • mystery
  • paranormal
  • audiobook

13 Best fiction books like The Pirates of Penn Cove (Weirdbey Island #1) by Eldritch Black

Transform Your Habits

The Knight at Dawn (Magic Tree House, #2)

Mary Pope Osborne , Salvatore Murdocca

3.91

Transform Your Habits

The Improbable Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Barbara Hambly , Stephen King , John Joseph Adams , Stephen Baxter , Anne Perry , Neil Gaiman , Geoffrey A. Landis , H. Paul Jeffers , Tanith Lee , Laurie R. King , Michael Moorcock , Chris Roberson , Robert J. Sawyer , Naomi Novik , Tim Lebbon , Mary Robinette Kowal , Sharyn McCrumb , Peter Tremayne , Darrell Schweitzer , Anthony Burgess , Barbara Roden , Dominic Green , Bradley H. Sinor , Rob Rogers , Vonda N. McIntyre , Tony Pi , Mark Valentine , Edward D. Hoch , Amy Myers

3.81

Transform Your Habits

Mummies in the Morning (Magic Tree House, #3)

Mary Pope Osborne , Salvatore Murdocca

5.00

Afternoon on the Amazon (Magic Tree House, #6)

Mary Pope Osborne , Salvatore Murdocca

4.21

View all the books

17 Top fantasy books like The Witch's Hand (The Montague Twins, #1) by Nathan Page

Transform Your Habits

Crumbs

Danie Stirling

3.94

Transform Your Habits

Lightfall: The Dark Times (Lightfall, #3)

Tim Probert

4.38

Transform Your Habits

Squad

Maggie Tokuda-Hall

3.79

Transform Your Habits

Rainbow! Vol. 1 (Rainbow!, #1)

Sunny .

3.87

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.