7 Best suspense books like Shouldn't Want You by Brooke Cumberland

Cover of Shouldn't Want You by Brooke Cumberland

Shouldn't Want You

By: Brooke Cumberland

3.87

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

I shouldn’t want him—my older fiancé’s son. He’s arrogant, unapologetic, and annoying as hell. …

"Seasons come and go, but our love will always continue to grow."

-Brooke Cumberland, Shouldn't Want You

If you liked the suspense plot in Shouldn't Want You by Brooke Cumberland , here is a list of 7 books like this:

Cover of Call Me Daddy by Jade West

1. Call Me Daddy

By: Jade West

3.15

Format: None pages,

I want him to be my first. I want him to be the one. I want him to be my everything. I didn't expec… read more

Similar categories in Jade West's Call Me Daddy book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • erotica
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of Black Swan Affair by K.L. Kreig

2. Black Swan Affair

By: K.L. Kreig

4.09

Format: 370 pages, ebook

I’ve loved him as long as I can remember. The gangly boy with big brown eyes and unruly hair who… read more

Similar categories in K.L. Kreig's Black Swan Affair book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • suspense
  • erotica
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
"While he was the sun that lit your world, you were the darkness that shadowed mine."

-K.L. Kreig, Black Swan Affair

"She has a carpet rake, for God’s sake. A. Carpet. Rake. Who rakes their fucking carpet? It’s carpet."

-K.L. Kreig, Black Swan Affair

"When life gives you lemons, you don't make lemonade. That's for pantywaisters. No. You pucker up, suck them dry, then throw the used rinds back in life's face with a giant fuck-you and a gesture for …"

-K.L. Kreig, Black Swan Affair

"There are different kinds of love. There's the dreamy kind you always thought you wanted and then there's the steady one you never understood but the second you let yourself feel it...it's nothing li…"

-K.L. Kreig, Black Swan Affair

Cover of The Golden Boys (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #1) by Rachel Jonas

3. The Golden Boys (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #1)

By: Rachel Jonas

4.14

Format: 350 pages, Kindle Edition

West Golden--easy to hate, yet so hard to resist. Don’t let that pretty face of his fool you. He… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Jonas's The Golden Boys (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #1) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Never His Girl (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #2) by Rachel Jonas

4. Never His Girl (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #2)

By: Rachel Jonas

4.11

Format: 308 pages, Kindle Edition

West Golden--Football star. Playboy. Dead to me. Nothing puts the final bullet in a girl’s rep l… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Jonas's Never His Girl (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #2) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Forever Golden (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #3) by Rachel Jonas

5. Forever Golden (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #3)

By: Rachel Jonas

4.20

Format: 340 pages, Kindle Edition

West Golden—Fierce protector. The one. The cocky jock I once wanted to kill with my bare hands i… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Jonas's Forever Golden (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #3) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • suspense
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of The Aristocrat by Penelope Ward

6. The Aristocrat

By: Penelope Ward

4.06

Format: 303 pages, Kindle Edition

From New York Times bestselling author Penelope Ward, comes a new standalone novel. The one that… read more

Similar categories in Penelope Ward's The Aristocrat book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • amazon
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Stepbrothers' Darling by K.A. Knight

7. Stepbrothers' Darling

By: K.A. Knight

4.00

Format: 563 pages, Kindle Edition

Life is never what you expect it to be. I never thought I would end up here, moving halfway acr… read more

Similar categories in K.A. Knight's Stepbrothers' Darling book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • erotica
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of The Rules of Dating My Best Friend's Sister (The Law of Opposites Attract, #2) by Vi Keeland

8. The Rules of Dating My Best Friend's Sister (The Law of Opposites Attract, #2)

By: Vi Keeland

4.03

Format: 400 pages, Paperback

From New York Times bestselling authors Vi Keeland and Penelope Ward comes a new standalone romance… read more

Similar categories in Vi Keeland's The Rules of Dating My Best Friend's Sister (The Law of Opposites Attract, #2) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Dark Obsession (Whiskey Men: Wounded Heroes, #2) by Hope Ford

9. Dark Obsession (Whiskey Men: Wounded Heroes, #2)

By: Hope Ford

4.06

Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition

Curvy Divorcee and the Wounded Hero. Together in an against all odds romance. When you’re on a date… read more

Similar categories in Hope Ford's Dark Obsession (Whiskey Men: Wounded Heroes, #2) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • m f romance
  • adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Unforgettable by Tayla Louise

10. Unforgettable

By: Tayla Louise

4.12

Format: 407 pages, Kindle Edition

From USA Today & Wall Street Journal bestselling author Michelle Heard and debut author Tayla Louis… read more

Similar categories in Tayla Louise's Unforgettable book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Stay With Me (Sugarland Creek, #2) by Brooke Montgomery

11. Stay With Me (Sugarland Creek, #2)

By: Brooke Montgomery

4.00

Format: 434 pages, Kindle Edition

A best friend’s brother stand-alone from small-town romance author Brooke Montgomery about a girl w… read more

Similar categories in Brooke Montgomery's Stay With Me (Sugarland Creek, #2) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • suspense
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Dancing with Sin by Alexandria  Lee

12. Dancing with Sin

By: Alexandria Lee

4.04

Format: None pages, None

Alice Monroe is a good person who is about to do a very bad thing. A professional dancer at twen… read more

Similar categories in Alexandria Lee's Dancing with Sin book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • erotica
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
Cover of Tangled Innocence (Egorov Bratva #1) by Nicole Fox

13. Tangled Innocence (Egorov Bratva #1)

By: Nicole Fox

4.37

Format: 575 pages, Kindle Edition

“What do you mean, ‘You gave me the wrong sperm sample’?!”But the doctor says he isn’t joking.Inste… read more

Similar categories in Nicole Fox's Tangled Innocence (Egorov Bratva #1) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • suspense
  • contemporary
Cover of Boss’s Secret Baby (Bosses and Babies #1) by Crystal Monroe

14. Boss’s Secret Baby (Bosses and Babies #1)

By: Crystal Monroe

4.04

Format: 238 pages, Kindle Edition

My new boss is my baby's daddy... He just doesn't know it yet. But when he sees my son for the … read more

Similar categories in Crystal Monroe's Boss’s Secret Baby (Bosses and Babies #1) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • adult
  • amazon
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • m f romance
Cover of Cruel Idols by Sorcha Black

15. Cruel Idols

By: Sorcha Black

4.03

Format: 328 pages, Kindle Edition

How can my favorite author be such a suspicious alphahole? All I wanted was an autograph, but Va… read more

Similar categories in Sorcha Black's Cruel Idols book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • erotica
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Come With Me (Sugarland Creek, #0) by Brooke Montgomery

16. Come With Me (Sugarland Creek, #0)

By: Brooke Montgomery

3.77

Format: 216 pages, Kindle Edition

A second chance prequel from small-town romance author Brooke Montgomery about high school sweethea… read more

Similar categories in Brooke Montgomery's Come With Me (Sugarland Creek, #0) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • suspense
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Bless Your Heart (Valentine Texas, #1) by Lyra Parish

17. Bless Your Heart (Valentine Texas, #1)

By: Lyra Parish

4.07

Format: 350 pages, ebook

I have three simple wishes:
 1. Keep my houseplants alive.
 2. Open a charming bed-and-breakfast … read more

Similar categories in Lyra Parish's Bless Your Heart (Valentine Texas, #1) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • amazon
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Contract with the Mafia Boss (D’Angelo Brothers Mafia Reign) by Ashlie Silas

18. Contract with the Mafia Boss (D’Angelo Brothers Mafia Reign)

By: Ashlie Silas

4.19

Format: 226 pages, Kindle Edition

A chance encounter led to a dating contract... with a mafia boss.I was desperate and needed a prete… read more

Similar categories in Ashlie Silas's Contract with the Mafia Boss (D’Angelo Brothers Mafia Reign) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Fake It 'Til You Break It by Meagan Brandy

19. Fake It 'Til You Break It

By: Meagan Brandy

4.10

Format: 399 pages, Paperback

Fake. That’s what we are. That’s what we agreed to be. I thought it would be harder, convinc… read more

Similar categories in Meagan Brandy's Fake It 'Til You Break It book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
"What'd I miss?" he asks. "Oh, you know, Macy being Macy, and advising I jump into the water before I ... jump on you." His frown is instant. "That's some shitty advice."

-Meagan Brandy, Fake It 'Til You Break It

Cover of Fall With Me (Sugarland Creek, #3) by Brooke Montgomery

20. Fall With Me (Sugarland Creek, #3)

By: Brooke Montgomery

3.98

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

A dislike to lovers stand-alone from small-town romance author Brooke Montgomery about a barrel rac… read more

Similar categories in Brooke Montgomery's Fall With Me (Sugarland Creek, #3) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
  • contemporary
Cover of The Canary Cowards by Jescie Hall

21. The Canary Cowards

By: Jescie Hall

4.43

Format: 538 pages, Paperback

From Author Jescie Hall comes a compelling and angst-filled love story that will pull at your heart… read more

Similar categories in Jescie Hall's The Canary Cowards book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • new adult
Cover of Rule (Power Brothers, #2) by Cassandra Robbins

22. Rule (Power Brothers, #2)

By: Cassandra Robbins

3.93

Format: 330 pages, Kindle Edition

From USA Today bestselling author Cassandra Robbins comes a scorching Professor/Student, age-gap, c… read more

Similar categories in Cassandra Robbins's Rule (Power Brothers, #2) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • erotica
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • m f romance
  • new adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Secret Baby with my Brother's Best Friend by Brooklyn Cox

23. Secret Baby with my Brother's Best Friend

By: Brooklyn Cox

4.03

Format: 293 pages, Kindle Edition

Losing my v-card to my brother’s billionaire best friend and lifelong crush - a fantasy come true. … read more

Similar categories in Brooklyn Cox's Secret Baby with my Brother's Best Friend book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
Cover of A Little Twist by Tia Louise

24. A Little Twist

By: Tia Louise

4.12

Format: 316 pages, Kindle Edition

I never said I was engaged to Alex Stone (a.k.a., the richest man in Eureka)… My douchey ex just a… read more

Similar categories in Tia Louise's A Little Twist book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • audiobook
  • contemporary
Cover of Here With Me (Sugarland Creek, #1) by Brooke Montgomery

25. Here With Me (Sugarland Creek, #1)

By: Brooke Montgomery

3.96

Format: 394 pages, Kindle Edition

A forbidden age gap stand-alone from small-town romance author Brooke Montgomery about a daring hor… read more

Similar categories in Brooke Montgomery's Here With Me (Sugarland Creek, #1) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • suspense
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Spill the Sweet Tea (Valentine Texas, #2) by Lyra Parish

26. Spill the Sweet Tea (Valentine Texas, #2)

By: Lyra Parish

4.28

Format: 246 pages, Paperback

Some describe me as a quirky, free-spirited journalist who charges her crystals by moonlight. They… read more

Similar categories in Lyra Parish's Spill the Sweet Tea (Valentine Texas, #2) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
  • audiobook
Cover of Butter My Biscuit (Valentine Texas, #3) by Lyra Parish

27. Butter My Biscuit (Valentine Texas, #3)

By: Lyra Parish

4.31

Format: 404 pages, Paperback

My bestie was off-limits until he kissed me and changed everything… Harrison Valentine is my bes… read more

Similar categories in Lyra Parish's Butter My Biscuit (Valentine Texas, #3) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Baby for the Single Dad by A.J. Summers

28. Baby for the Single Dad

By: A.J. Summers

4.17

Format: 212 pages, Kindle Edition

Swap a cheating boyfriend for a hot night with a gorgeous billionaire?Best. Swap. Ever.But morning … read more

Similar categories in A.J. Summers's Baby for the Single Dad book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

Cover of Handsome Devil (Cocky Hero Club) by Sara Cate

29. Handsome Devil (Cocky Hero Club)

By: Sara Cate

3.86

Format: 170 pages, Kindle Edition

There are exactly 2,716 miles between my home in Boston and my best friend in Las Vegas. When she c… read more

Similar categories in Sara Cate's Handsome Devil (Cocky Hero Club) book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • erotica
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Shouldn't Want You by Brooke Cumberland

30. Shouldn't Want You

By: Brooke Cumberland

3.87

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

I shouldn’t want him—my older fiancé’s son. He’s arrogant, unapologetic, and annoying as hell. … read more

Similar categories in Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • adult
  • suspense
  • erotica
  • amazon
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • m f romance
  • new adult
  • audiobook
"Seasons come and go, but our love will always continue to grow."

-Brooke Cumberland, Shouldn't Want You

Cover of Out of Sight by Cleo White

31. Out of Sight

By: Cleo White

4.05

Format: 162 pages, Kindle Edition

A Forbidden, Age Gap, Forced Proximity Romance ISOBEL I know a bad idea when I see one, and … read more

Similar categories in Cleo White's Out of Sight book and Brooke Cumberland's Shouldn't Want You

  • romance
  • adult
  • erotica
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • m f romance

29 must-read contemporary books like Shouldn't Want You by Brooke Cumberland

Transform Your Habits

Call Me Daddy

Jade West

3.15

Transform Your Habits

Black Swan Affair

K.L. Kreig

4.09

Transform Your Habits

The Golden Boys (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #1)

Rachel Jonas

4.14

Transform Your Habits

Never His Girl (Kings of Cypress Pointe, #2)

Rachel Jonas

4.11

View all the books

20 Top contemporary books like The Canary Cowards by Jescie Hall

Transform Your Habits

Older

Jennifer Hartmann

4.13

Transform Your Habits

When We Lied (Fairview Hockey, #2)

Claire Contreras

4.14

Transform Your Habits

Carnage (L.O.R.D.S., #5)

Shantel Tessier

4.31

Transform Your Habits

Little Stranger (The Web of Silence Duet, #1)

Leigh Rivers

3.81

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.