21 must-read historical books like Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3) by Jo Goodman

Cover of Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3) by Jo Goodman

Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

By: Jo Goodman

4.20

Format: 453 pages, Kindle Edition

Injured and lost, Mary Margaret "Maggie" Dennehy stumbles into a seedy New York City neighborhood. …

If you liked the historical plot in Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3) by Jo Goodman , here is a list of 21 books like this:

Cover of The Dangerous Lord (Lord Trilogy, #3) by Sabrina Jeffries

1. The Dangerous Lord (Lord Trilogy, #3)

By: Sabrina Jeffries

4.00

Format: 370 pages, Mass Market Paperback

To prevent a dear friend from wedding Ian Lennard, the notorious Viscount St. Clair, Felicity Taylo… read more

Similar categories in Sabrina Jeffries's The Dangerous Lord (Lord Trilogy, #3) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Sometimes a Rogue (Lost Lords, #5) by Mary Jo Putney

2. Sometimes a Rogue (Lost Lords, #5)

By: Mary Jo Putney

3.90

Format: 415 pages, Mass Market Paperback

"Putney's reputation as one of the finest writers of Regency romance is well deserved. She never sh… read more

Similar categories in Mary Jo Putney's Sometimes a Rogue (Lost Lords, #5) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Once a Soldier (Rogues Redeemed, #1) by Mary Jo Putney

3. Once a Soldier (Rogues Redeemed, #1)

By: Mary Jo Putney

3.82

Format: 343 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Rogues Redeemed As heir to a title and great wealth, Will Masterson should have stayed home and … read more

Similar categories in Mary Jo Putney's Once a Soldier (Rogues Redeemed, #1) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Duke of Sin (Maiden Lane, #10) by Elizabeth Hoyt

4. Duke of Sin (Maiden Lane, #10)

By: Elizabeth Hoyt

3.98

Format: 347 pages, Kindle Edition

A MAN OF SIN Devastatingly handsome. Vain. Unscrupulous. Valentine Napier, the Duke of Montgomer… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Hoyt's Duke of Sin (Maiden Lane, #10) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"Perhaps the wine had mingled with the blood in his veins, and now he was part grape."

-Elizabeth Hoyt, Duke of Sin (Maiden Lane, #10)

"For a moment she stared at him, panting, breathless and wordless, it seemed, with rage. He'd had no idea she would respond to his capture of her queen so violently. It was rather arousing."

-Elizabeth Hoyt, Duke of Sin (Maiden Lane, #10)

"Val's upper lip curled as he wondered if Mrs. Crumb knew the meaning of the word fun . Most likely she dismissed it as something vaguely shameful and leading to sin - which, at the best of times, it …"

-Elizabeth Hoyt, Duke of Sin (Maiden Lane, #10)

"No more shall you go bookless, Mrs. Crumb. From this day henceforth you have free run of my library with my compliments." She stared. "I-" He grinned, looking not a little wicked. "Have you looked at…"

-Elizabeth Hoyt, Duke of Sin (Maiden Lane, #10)

Cover of Ask For It (Georgian, #1) by Sylvia Day

5. Ask For It (Georgian, #1)

By: Sylvia Day

3.72

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Length: 9 hrs and 31 mins Nothing incites Marcus more than the primal hunger roused by his forme… read more

Similar categories in Sylvia Day's Ask For It (Georgian, #1) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Never Less Than a Lady (Lost Lords, #2) by Mary Jo Putney

6. Never Less Than a Lady (Lost Lords, #2)

By: Mary Jo Putney

3.65

Format: None pages, Mass Market Paperback

New York Times bestselling author Mary Jo Putney continues her stunning Lost Lords series with this… read more

Similar categories in Mary Jo Putney's Never Less Than a Lady (Lost Lords, #2) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Sister of the Bride (Fool's Gold, #2.5) by Susan Mallery

7. Sister of the Bride (Fool's Gold, #2.5)

By: Susan Mallery

4.15

Format: None pages, ebook

When Katie McCormick finds out that her sister is marrying her ex, she finally agrees to a setup fo… read more

Similar categories in Susan Mallery's Sister of the Bride (Fool's Gold, #2.5) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
Cover of Saving Grace by Julie Garwood

8. Saving Grace

By: Julie Garwood

3.79

Format: None pages, Paperback

When Lady Johanna learned that she was a widow, she vowed she would never marry again. Only sixteen… read more

Similar categories in Julie Garwood's Saving Grace book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of No Longer a Gentleman (Lost Lords, #4) by Mary Jo Putney

9. No Longer a Gentleman (Lost Lords, #4)

By: Mary Jo Putney

3.69

Format: 98 pages, Paperback

Grey Sommers, Lord Wyndham, never met a predicament he couldn't charm his way out of. Then a tryst … read more

Similar categories in Mary Jo Putney's No Longer a Gentleman (Lost Lords, #4) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Make Me Love You by Johanna Lindsey

10. Make Me Love You

By: Johanna Lindsey

3.54

Format: None pages, ebook

#1 New York Times bestselling author Johanna Lindsey delivers "first rate romance" (Daily News) in … read more

Similar categories in Johanna Lindsey's Make Me Love You book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Not Quite a Wife (Lost Lords, #6) by Mary Jo Putney

11. Not Quite a Wife (Lost Lords, #6)

By: Mary Jo Putney

3.66

Format: None pages, Mass Market Paperback

Marry in haste, repent at leisure. James, Lord Kirkland, owns a shipping fleet, half a London gamin… read more

Similar categories in Mary Jo Putney's Not Quite a Wife (Lost Lords, #6) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction

12. One Heart to Win (Callahan-Warren, #1)

By: Johanna Lindsey

3.73

Format: 32 pages, ebook

Some young ladies marry for money and social standing, a few lucky ones marry for love, but Tiffany… read more

Similar categories in Johanna Lindsey's One Heart to Win (Callahan-Warren, #1) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

13. Once a Rebel (Rogues Redeemed #2)

By: Mary Jo Putney

4.57

Format: 201 pages, Mass Market Paperback

As Washington burns, Callista Brooke is trapped in the battle between her native England and her ad… read more

Similar categories in Mary Jo Putney's Once a Rebel (Rogues Redeemed #2) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

14. The Wives of Bowie Stone

By: Maggie Osborne

4.21

Format: 256 pages, Paperback

Knowing that she can save the life of a condemned man by offering to marry him, Rosie Mulvehey opts… read more

Similar categories in Maggie Osborne's The Wives of Bowie Stone book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

15. Stormy Persuasion (Malory-Anderson Family, #11)

By: Johanna Lindsey

3.49

Format: 465 pages, Hardcover

James Malory sets sail for America to honor a promise he made to his in-laws: His and Georgina's da… read more

Similar categories in Johanna Lindsey's Stormy Persuasion (Malory-Anderson Family, #11) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

Cover of Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1) by Ellen O'Connell

16. Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1)

By: Ellen O'Connell

4.11

Format: 316 pages, Kindle Edition

In 1866 on the empty Kansas prairie, two children shared a few desperate moments that changed their… read more

Similar categories in Ellen O'Connell's Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • western historical romance
  • westerns
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • western romance
  • historical fiction
"He parked the wagon beside the church and left Norah there with Early and orders to stay, no matter what she heard. He had more faith in Early obeying — he tied the dog to the wagon."

-Ellen O'Connell, Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1)

"What she'd done was give him a glimpse of something that scared the bejesus out of him, something never meant for men like him that could start a hunger that would eat away what little was left insid…"

-Ellen O'Connell, Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1)

"...she was honest enough to admit she married him because actions other men would not conceive of to start with or carry out to finish with were ordinary for [him]... not that she ever wanted or need…"

-Ellen O'Connell, Beautiful Bad Man (Sutton Family, #1)

17. Loving a Lost Lord (Lost Lords #1)

By: Mary Jo Putney

4.04

Format: None pages, Mass Market Paperback

In the first of a dazzling series, Mary Jo Putney introduces the Lost Lords--maverick childhood fri… read more

Similar categories in Mary Jo Putney's Loving a Lost Lord (Lost Lords #1) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

18. The Texan's Wager (Wife Lottery, #1)

By: Jodi Thomas

4.09

Format: 256 pages,

Thrown off a wagon train with two other women and trying to avoid jail for a murder they committed,… read more

Similar categories in Jodi Thomas's The Texan's Wager (Wife Lottery, #1) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

19. Beautiful Tempest (Malory Family, #12)

By: Johanna Lindsey

3.60

Format: None pages, Hardcover

#1 New York Timesbestselling author Johanna Lindsey now reveals the tempestuous story of Jacqueline… read more

Similar categories in Johanna Lindsey's Beautiful Tempest (Malory Family, #12) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

Cover of The Lost Letter by Mimi Matthews

20. The Lost Letter

By: Mimi Matthews

4.03

Format: 244 pages, ebook

Alternative cover edition for ASIN B07777L5NP. A PROUD BEAUTY Society beauty Sylvia Stafford… read more

Similar categories in Mimi Matthews's The Lost Letter book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
"She briefly closed her eyes as a fiery blush crept into her face. "The first letter," she repeated. "Of course it would be." "Milsom bought it from her for fifty pounds. He brought it back to Pershin…"

-Mimi Matthews, The Lost Letter

Cover of Once a Scoundrel (Rogues Redeemed, #3) by Mary Jo Putney

21. Once a Scoundrel (Rogues Redeemed, #3)

By: Mary Jo Putney

3.87

Format: 336 pages, Mass Market Paperback

An outcast on the high seas . . . The son of a proud naval dynasty, Gabriel Hawkins was born to … read more

Similar categories in Mary Jo Putney's Once a Scoundrel (Rogues Redeemed, #3) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of The Prospector's Only Prospect by Dani Collins

22. The Prospector's Only Prospect

By: Dani Collins

4.20

Format: 352 pages, Mass Market Paperback

After eight days in a cramped stagecoach, divorcée Marigold Davis already regrets her decision to c… read more

Similar categories in Dani Collins's The Prospector's Only Prospect book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • western historical romance
  • westerns
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • western romance
  • historical fiction
Cover of Hell Hath No Fury (Devilish Debutantes, #1) by Annabelle Anders

23. Hell Hath No Fury (Devilish Debutantes, #1)

By: Annabelle Anders

4.16

Format: 315 pages, ebook

To keep the money, he has to keep her as well… Cecily Nottingham has made a huge mistake.  The … read more

Similar categories in Annabelle Anders's Hell Hath No Fury (Devilish Debutantes, #1) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of Come Back by Melissa Maygrove

24. Come Back

By: Melissa Maygrove

4.18

Format: 432 pages, Kindle Edition

Left behind by everyone she loves... Rebecca Garvey had the promise of a California future dreams … read more

Similar categories in Melissa Maygrove's Come Back book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • westerns
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • western romance
Cover of Swear by Moonlight (The Reluctant Brides Series, Book 2) by Shirlee Busbee

25. Swear by Moonlight (The Reluctant Brides Series, Book 2)

By: Shirlee Busbee

3.93

Format: 383 pages, Kindle Edition

London's loveliest and wealthiest social pariah, Thea Garrett guards her wounded heart by refusing … read more

Similar categories in Shirlee Busbee's Swear by Moonlight (The Reluctant Brides Series, Book 2) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical fiction
  • historical romance
Cover of The Hired Man by Lynna Banning

26. The Hired Man

By: Lynna Banning

4.23

Format: 288 pages, Mass Market Paperback

A home for the drifter Cordell Winterman is haunted by his mistakes--and the years spent paying… read more

Similar categories in Lynna Banning's The Hired Man book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical romance
  • westerns
  • historical fiction
Cover of An Unexpected Gentleman (Haverston Family, #2) by Alissa Johnson

27. An Unexpected Gentleman (Haverston Family, #2)

By: Alissa Johnson

3.96

Format: 373 pages, Kindle Edition

Adelaide Ward has but one goal-to obtain an offer of marriage from the respectable, if unappealing,… read more

Similar categories in Alissa Johnson's An Unexpected Gentleman (Haverston Family, #2) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
Cover of A Guy Like Him by Amanda Gambill

28. A Guy Like Him

By: Amanda Gambill

4.17

Format: 326 pages, Kindle Edition

Skylar is the kind of girl who knows exactly how many seconds it takes to read this summary. She kn… read more

Similar categories in Amanda Gambill's A Guy Like Him book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • fiction
Cover of The Captain's Woman (The Thompsons of Locust Street #4) by Holly  Bush

29. The Captain's Woman (The Thompsons of Locust Street #4)

By: Holly Bush

4.12

Format: 230 pages, Kindle Edition

Meet the Thompsons of Locust Street, an unconventional family taking Philadelphia high society by s… read more

Similar categories in Holly Bush's The Captain's Woman (The Thompsons of Locust Street #4) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical fiction
  • historical romance
Cover of Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3) by Jo Goodman

30. Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

By: Jo Goodman

4.20

Format: 453 pages, Kindle Edition

Injured and lost, Mary Margaret "Maggie" Dennehy stumbles into a seedy New York City neighborhood. … read more

Similar categories in Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • new york
  • american
  • western historical romance
  • westerns
  • historical
  • historical romance
  • fiction
  • western romance
  • historical fiction
Cover of A Foolish Flirtation (Victorian Reversal of Fortune, #1) by Alice Coldbreath

31. A Foolish Flirtation (Victorian Reversal of Fortune, #1)

By: Alice Coldbreath

4.17

Format: None pages, ebook

At eighteen, Emmeline Ballentine’s father splashed out on one London season to introduce his daught… read more

Similar categories in Alice Coldbreath's A Foolish Flirtation (Victorian Reversal of Fortune, #1) book and Jo Goodman's Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3)

  • romance
  • historical
  • historical fiction
  • historical romance

18 best-selling fiction books like Forever in My Heart (The Dennehy Sisters Series #3) by Jo Goodman

Transform Your Habits

The Dangerous Lord (Lord Trilogy, #3)

Sabrina Jeffries

4.00

Transform Your Habits

Sometimes a Rogue (Lost Lords, #5)

Mary Jo Putney

3.90

Transform Your Habits

Once a Soldier (Rogues Redeemed, #1)

Mary Jo Putney

3.82

Transform Your Habits

Duke of Sin (Maiden Lane, #10)

Elizabeth Hoyt

3.98

View all the books

13 Top romance books like The Hired Man by Lynna Banning

Transform Your Habits

The Gunslinger's Bride (Montana Mavericks: Historicals #1)

Cheryl St. John

3.80

Transform Your Habits

The Major's Wife

Lauri Robinson

4.04

Transform Your Habits

One in a Million (Rivalries)

Janet Dailey

4.27

Transform Your Habits

Sweet Mountain Magic

Rosanne Bittner

4.40

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.