22 best-selling mystery books like That Night by Cyn Balog

Cover of That Night by Cyn Balog

That Night

By: Cyn Balog

3.61

Format: 298 pages, Paperback

Hailey wants to know the truth, but there are some secrets that are best left buried… Hailey is…

If you liked the mystery plot in That Night by Cyn Balog , here is a list of 22 books like this:

Cover of None of the Above by I.W. Gregorio

1. None of the Above

By: I.W. Gregorio

3.85

Format: 328 pages, Hardcover

A groundbreaking story about a teenage girl who discovers she was born intersex... and what happens… read more

Similar categories in I.W. Gregorio's None of the Above book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • teen
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
"I could still feel the echo of his hand on mine."

-I.W. Gregorio, None of the Above

"Love isn’t a choice. You fall for the person, not their chromosomes."

-I.W. Gregorio, None of the Above

"The biggest difference between boy and girls is how people treat them"

-I.W. Gregorio, None of the Above

"As long as we had ground under our feet and the wind at our backs, things were going to be okay."

-I.W. Gregorio, None of the Above

Cover of Awake by Natasha Preston

2. Awake

By: Natasha Preston

3.71

Format: 314 pages, Paperback

Scarlett Garner doesn’t remember anything before the age of four—but a car accident changes everyth… read more

Similar categories in Natasha Preston's Awake book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • horror
Cover of The Chaos of Standing Still by Jessica Brody

3. The Chaos of Standing Still

By: Jessica Brody

4.48

Format: 448 pages, Hardcover

Over the course of one chaotic night stranded at the Denver airport, Ryn confronts her shattered pa… read more

Similar categories in Jessica Brody's The Chaos of Standing Still book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Just as Long as We're Together by Judy Blume

4. Just as Long as We're Together

By: Judy Blume

4.05

Format: 144 pages, Paperback

Rachel is Stephanie's best friend. Since second grade, they've shared secrets, good and bad. Now in… read more

Similar categories in Judy Blume's Just as Long as We're Together book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Summer I Wasn't Me by Jessica Verdi

5. The Summer I Wasn't Me

By: Jessica Verdi

3.24

Format: 0 pages, Paperback

Lexi has a secret. She never meant for her mom to find out. And now she's afraid that what's left o… read more

Similar categories in Jessica Verdi's The Summer I Wasn't Me book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary

6. The Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall

By: Katie Alender

3.63

Format: 56 pages, Hardcover

In this asylum, your mind plays tricks on you all the time... Delia's new house isn't just a house.… read more

Similar categories in Katie Alender's The Dead Girls of Hysteria Hall book and Cyn Balog's That Night

7. One Breath Away

By: Heather Gudenkauf

4.75

Format: 14 pages, Paperback

In her most emotionally charged novel to date, New York Timesbestselling author Heather Gudenkauf e… read more

Similar categories in Heather Gudenkauf's One Breath Away book and Cyn Balog's That Night

Cover of No Way Home by Jody Feldman

8. No Way Home

By: Jody Feldman

3.28

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

How can you save your parents when you are an ocean away? A propulsive international thriller from … read more

Similar categories in Jody Feldman's No Way Home book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • horror
Cover of The Other Lola by Ripley Jones

9. The Other Lola

By: Ripley Jones

3.59

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

What happens when the people you love the most are the people you can trust the least? In the mo… read more

Similar categories in Ripley Jones's The Other Lola book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Dare by Natasha Preston

10. The Dare

By: Natasha Preston

3.85

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

I triple dog dare you . . . As senior year comes to an end, senior pranks are just beginning. It… read more

Similar categories in Natasha Preston's The Dare book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery thriller
  • teen
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of That Weekend by Kara Thomas

11. That Weekend

By: Kara Thomas

3.78

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

Three best friends, a lake house, a secret trip - what could go wrong? It was supposed to be the… read more

Similar categories in Kara Thomas's That Weekend book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
"How am I supposed to accept that the worst thing to ever happen to me has no meaning?"

-Kara Thomas, That Weekend

"I wish you'd killed me, I tried to say with my eyes. Then maybe someone would finally stop you."

-Kara Thomas, That Weekend

"Maybe, like me, it's even more than the absence. The silence, maybe - the waiting for the phone call that never comes."

-Kara Thomas, That Weekend

"Recently, she dyed her short blond bob a sassy red, a decision my mother and I discussed at length back when my friends weren't missing and we consumed other peoples' tragedies for entertainment."

-Kara Thomas, That Weekend

Cover of A Year to the Day by Robin Benway

12. A Year to the Day

By: Robin Benway

3.49

Format: 352 pages, Hardcover

It’s been a year—a year of missing Nina. A year of milestones—holidays, birthdays, everything witho… read more

Similar categories in Robin Benway's A Year to the Day book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • teen
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of The Lost by Natasha Preston

13. The Lost

By: Natasha Preston

3.92

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

In the small town of Aurora, teens go missing all the time. But when one of Piper and Hazel's class… read more

Similar categories in Natasha Preston's The Lost book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • horror
Cover of The Game (Underlined Paperbacks) by Linsey Miller

14. The Game (Underlined Paperbacks)

By: Linsey Miller

3.14

Format: 240 pages, Paperback

If you loved American Horror Story 1984, you'll die for this paperback original thriller mashup of … read more

Similar categories in Linsey Miller's The Game (Underlined Paperbacks) book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • horror
Cover of Secrets Never Die by Vincent Ralph

15. Secrets Never Die

By: Vincent Ralph

3.46

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

We call it the Dark Place. I don’t know who built it or when but, for us, it’s special. Every ye… read more

Similar categories in Vincent Ralph's Secrets Never Die book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • horror
"Was he okay with you staying over? Wasnt worried about you two bumping uglies in the night?" Haran is dicking around. He knows that my uglies and Elisha's have never officially met."

-Vincent Ralph, Secrets Never Die

Cover of The Only Girl in Town by Ally Condie

16. The Only Girl in Town

By: Ally Condie

3.23

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

What would you do if everyone you love disappeared? What if it was your fault? For July Fielding… read more

Similar categories in Ally Condie's The Only Girl in Town book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Monarchs (The Ravens, #2) by Kass Morgan

17. The Monarchs (The Ravens, #2)

By: Kass Morgan

3.70

Format: 448 pages, Hardcover

In this thrilling conclusion to New York Times best-selling authors Kass Morgan and Danielle Paige’… read more

Similar categories in Kass Morgan's The Monarchs (The Ravens, #2) book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery
  • fiction
  • young adult
Cover of The New Girl by Jesse Q. Sutanto

18. The New Girl

By: Jesse Q. Sutanto

3.43

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

Lia Setiawan has never really fit in. When she wins a full ride to the prestigious Draycott Academy… read more

Similar categories in Jesse Q. Sutanto's The New Girl book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • horror
"You pretended you had to go get your laptop because you couldn't afford to buy dinner for yourself after swiping me through?"

-Jesse Q. Sutanto, The New Girl

Cover of The Impossible Story of Hannah Kemp by Leonie Agnew

19. The Impossible Story of Hannah Kemp

By: Leonie Agnew

3.30

Format: 257 pages, Kindle Edition

The unpublished manuscript was the winner of the 2022 Tessa Duder a powerful exploration of guilt,… read more

Similar categories in Leonie Agnew's The Impossible Story of Hannah Kemp book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Murder Game by Carrie Doyle

20. The Murder Game

By: Carrie Doyle

3.65

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

What if your best friend and roommate killed a teacher at your prep school? Or what if he didn’t do… read more

Similar categories in Carrie Doyle's The Murder Game book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • horror
Cover of You Owe Me a Murder by Eileen Cook

21. You Owe Me a Murder

By: Eileen Cook

3.53

Format: 368 pages, Hardcover

Seventeen-year-old Kim gets more than she bargained for when she is set up for murder. Perfect for … read more

Similar categories in Eileen Cook's You Owe Me a Murder book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Headmaster's List by Melissa de la Cruz

22. The Headmaster's List

By: Melissa de la Cruz

3.50

Format: 400 pages, Hardcover

One of them was driving. One of them was high. One of them screamed. And one of them died. When fif… read more

Similar categories in Melissa de la Cruz's The Headmaster's List book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Girl in the Headlines by Hannah Jayne

23. The Girl in the Headlines

By: Hannah Jayne

3.46

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

The headlines say she killed her family. The truth? She doesn't remember. Andrea McNulty goes to… read more

Similar categories in Hannah Jayne's The Girl in the Headlines book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Obsession by Jesse Q. Sutanto

24. The Obsession

By: Jesse Q. Sutanto

3.73

Format: 309 pages, Paperback

A classic sort of love story... except somebody might wind up dead. Nobody knows Delilah like Lo… read more

Similar categories in Jesse Q. Sutanto's The Obsession book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
"Erotomania"

-Jesse Q. Sutanto, The Obsession

Cover of What You Hide by Natalie D. Richards

25. What You Hide

By: Natalie D. Richards

3.77

Format: 369 pages, Paperback

A new pulse-pounding romantic thriller from the author of We All Fall Down and Six Months Later … read more

Similar categories in Natalie D. Richards's What You Hide book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • teen
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • horror
"Maybe there’s a book in here that will tell me what to do when all the smart choices feel wrong."

-Natalie D. Richards, What You Hide

Cover of Someone I Used to Know by Patty Blount

26. Someone I Used to Know

By: Patty Blount

4.24

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

It's been two years since the night that changed Ashley's life. Two years since she was raped by he… read more

Similar categories in Patty Blount's Someone I Used to Know book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary
"Every time there’s a terrorist attack, everybody starts screaming for border closings and tighter security at airports. Does anybody ever shrug it off and say, ‘Oh, it’s just extremists being extremi…"

-Patty Blount, Someone I Used to Know

Cover of Fright Night by Maren Stoffels

27. Fright Night

By: Maren Stoffels

3.46

Format: 167 pages, Paperback

Wat is je grootste angst? Ik weet het antwoord nu. Een groepje vrienden geeft zich op voor een Fr… read more

Similar categories in Maren Stoffels's Fright Night book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery thriller
  • teen
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • horror
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of Every Single Lie by Rachel Vincent

28. Every Single Lie

By: Rachel Vincent

3.97

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

In this gripping YA novel about social media bullying and half-truths, one girl's discovery of a de… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Vincent's Every Single Lie book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Year They Fell by David Kreizman

29. The Year They Fell

By: David Kreizman

3.66

Format: 384 pages, Hardcover

When a horrible tragedy unites five very different high school seniors, they discover the worst mom… read more

Similar categories in David Kreizman's The Year They Fell book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of When the Light Went Out by Bridget Morrissey

30. When the Light Went Out

By: Bridget Morrissey

3.26

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Five years after the accidental shooting of Marley Bricket, her friends, who were there the day she… read more

Similar categories in Bridget Morrissey's When the Light Went Out book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of That Night by Cyn Balog

31. That Night

By: Cyn Balog

3.61

Format: 298 pages, Paperback

Hailey wants to know the truth, but there are some secrets that are best left buried… Hailey is… read more

Similar categories in Cyn Balog's That Night book and Cyn Balog's That Night

  • romance
  • mystery thriller
  • teen
  • young adult
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • horror

28 Top fiction books like That Night by Cyn Balog

Transform Your Habits

None of the Above

I.W. Gregorio

3.85

Transform Your Habits

Awake

Natasha Preston

3.71

Transform Your Habits

The Chaos of Standing Still

Jessica Brody

4.48

Transform Your Habits

Just as Long as We're Together

Judy Blume

4.05

View all the books

9 Best realistic fiction books like The Year They Fell by David Kreizman

Transform Your Habits

Phantom Limbs

Paula Garner

3.93

Transform Your Habits

The Last Thing You Said

Sara Biren

3.57

The F- It List

Julie Halpern

3.98

Transform Your Habits

Something Happened to Ali Greenleaf (Something Happened to Ali Greenleaf, #1)

Hayley Krischer

3.93

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.