Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
By: Polly Holmes
3.94
Format: 366 pages, Kindle Edition
Witches, cats, pumpkin pies and murder! I’m Evelyn Grayson and if you’d told me by the time I wa…
Want to Read $ 4.99If you liked the cozy mystery plot in Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1) by Polly Holmes , here is a list of 18 books like this:
1. Witch Way to Murder & Mayhem (Witch Way #1)
By: Jane Hinchey
4.33
Format: 191 pages, Kindle Edition
To call Gran eccentric is somewhat of an understatement. She has questionable fashion sense, cough,… read more
Want to ReadSimilar categories in Jane Hinchey's Witch Way to Murder & Mayhem (Witch Way #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- magic
- amazon
- fiction
- paranormal
- witches
- fantasy
- mystery
2. Shifting and Shenanigans: Magical Mystery Book Club #1
By: Elizabeth Pantley
4.33
Format: 210 pages, Kindle Edition
2022 Cozy Mystery Tribe Awards - BOOK OF THE YEAR finalist! THIS IS NO ORDINARY BOOK CLUB! Paig… read more
Want to Read $ 2.99Similar categories in Elizabeth Pantley's Shifting and Shenanigans: Magical Mystery Book Club #1 book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- magic
- fiction
- paranormal
- mystery
- fantasy
3. Awakening the Witch (Hollywood Lakes Magical Midlife #1)
By: Christina Garner
4.50
Format: 230 pages, Kindle Edition
A paranormal women's fiction novel with Gen X attitude and a heart of gold.Welcome to Hollywood Lak… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Christina Garner's Awakening the Witch (Hollywood Lakes Magical Midlife #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- witches
- fantasy
- paranormal
4. Cookie Calamity (Cookie Corner Paranormal Cozy Mysteries, #1)
By: Cindy Stark
4.49
Format: 172 pages, Kindle Edition
When Evie St. Claire learns she’s the heir to a long-lost aunt’s entire estate, she momentarily bel… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Cindy Stark's Cookie Calamity (Cookie Corner Paranormal Cozy Mysteries, #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- fiction
- fantasy
- witches
- paranormal
- mystery
5. New Witch on the Block (Midlife in Mosswood, #1)
By: Louisa West
3.69
Format: 169 pages, Kindle Edition
(Alternate cover edition of ASIN B087KYLF3N.) She thought she was running away from her past, n… read more
Want to Read $ 3.99Similar categories in Louisa West's New Witch on the Block (Midlife in Mosswood, #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- magic
- fiction
- paranormal
- witches
- fantasy
- mystery
6. Lifestyles of the Witch and Ageless (Season of the Witch #1)
By: Shéa MacLeod
4.33
Format: 148 pages, Kindle Edition
A paranormal women’s fiction cozy mystery – because midlife can be a real witch! There are a lot… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Shéa MacLeod's Lifestyles of the Witch and Ageless (Season of the Witch #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- fiction
- fantasy
- witches
- paranormal
- mystery
7. Bust a Witch (Holiday Hills Witch #7)
By: Carolyn Ridder Aspenson
4.57
Format: 180 pages, Kindle Edition
Two can keep a secret if one of them is dead. The thing magicals fear the most has happened. Ou… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Carolyn Ridder Aspenson's Bust a Witch (Holiday Hills Witch #7) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- paranormal
8. There's a New Witch in Town Christmas Edition (The Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery, #1-2) )
By: Carolyn Ridder Aspenson
4.25
Format: 222 pages, Kindle Edition
USA TODAY BESTSELLING AUTHOR Carolyn Ridder Aspenson’s Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery Series… read more
Want to Read $ 0.99Similar categories in Carolyn Ridder Aspenson's There's a New Witch in Town Christmas Edition (The Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery, #1-2) ) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- fiction
- paranormal
- witches
- fantasy
- mystery
9. Spells and Spooks (Witch Haven #1)
By: K.E. O'Connor
4.29
Format: 178 pages, Kindle Edition
Welcome to Witch Haven. Where nothing is quite what it seems. I’m back in the last place I want … read more
Want to Read $ 0.99Similar categories in K.E. O'Connor's Spells and Spooks (Witch Haven #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- halloween
- amazon
- fiction
- fantasy
- witches
- paranormal
- mystery
10. Bookshop Witch (Seashell Cove Paranormal Mystery, #1)
By: T. Thorn Coyle
4.01
Format: 192 pages, Kindle Edition
My name is Sarah Braxton, and I'm a witch. You might think that's unusual, but trust me, I am no… read more
Want to ReadSimilar categories in T. Thorn Coyle's Bookshop Witch (Seashell Cove Paranormal Mystery, #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- magic
- fiction
- paranormal
- witches
- fantasy
- mystery
11. Magic Hidden, Magic Found (Wyrd Words & Witchcraft #1; Baking Up a Magical Midlife)
By: Jessica Rosenberg
4.30
Format: 283 pages, Kindle Edition
She’s always been a bookworm, but when surprising magical powers emerge, will she find the courage … read more
Want to Read $ 0.99Similar categories in Jessica Rosenberg's Magic Hidden, Magic Found (Wyrd Words & Witchcraft #1; Baking Up a Magical Midlife) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- magic
- fiction
- paranormal
- witches
- fantasy
- mystery
12. Haunted Halloween: A Mia Watson Cruise Ship Cozy Mystery (Mia Watson Cruise Ship Mysteries Book 3)
By: Gwen Taylor
3.88
Format: 242 pages, Kindle Edition
The haunt is on… It’s Halloween and Mia and the gang are leaving the Bella for a rare opportunity.… read more
Want to Read $ 3.99Similar categories in Gwen Taylor's Haunted Halloween: A Mia Watson Cruise Ship Cozy Mystery (Mia Watson Cruise Ship Mysteries Book 3) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- mystery
- holiday
- cozy mystery
- halloween
13. Witch or Without You (Holiday Hills Witch #6)
By: Carolyn Ridder Aspenson
4.55
Format: 190 pages, Kindle Edition
Grab your coffee and sit a spell. USA TODAY BESTSELLING AUTHOR Carolyn Ridder Aspenson brings back … read more
Want to Read $ 3.99Similar categories in Carolyn Ridder Aspenson's Witch or Without You (Holiday Hills Witch #6) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- fiction
- paranormal
- mystery
- fantasy
14. Another Witch Bites the Dust (The Witches of Holiday Hills #4)
By: Carolyn Ridder Aspenson
4.49
Format: 194 pages, Kindle Edition
Being a witch can be complicated. We have powers, but with limitations. In a perfect witchy world… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Carolyn Ridder Aspenson's Another Witch Bites the Dust (The Witches of Holiday Hills #4) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- paranormal
- witches
- fantasy
- mystery
15. Who's that Witch? (Holiday Hills Witch #3)
By: Carolyn Ridder Aspenson
4.42
Format: 167 pages, Kindle Edition
My name is Abby Odell, and I’m leading a double life. Don’t get me wrong, I love it! But being a… read more
Want to ReadSimilar categories in Carolyn Ridder Aspenson's Who's that Witch? (Holiday Hills Witch #3) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- mystery
- amazon
- cozy mystery
- paranormal
16. Witch this Way (Holiday Hills Witch #3)
By: Carolyn Ridder Aspenson
4.51
Format: 196 pages, Kindle Edition
USA TODAY BESTSELLING AUTHOR Carolyn Ridder Aspenson is back with Witch This Way, book two in the W… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Carolyn Ridder Aspenson's Witch this Way (Holiday Hills Witch #3) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- mystery
- cozy mystery
- fantasy
- paranormal
17. Hopeless Pocus (Hex Falls #1)
By: Rachel Rivers
4.08
Format: 368 pages, Kindle Edition
A failed crime investigator turned interior decorator. A strange new client with an age-old secret… read more
Want to ReadSimilar categories in Rachel Rivers's Hopeless Pocus (Hex Falls #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- cozy mystery
- halloween
- fiction
- paranormal
- witches
- fantasy
- mystery
18. Pebble Cove: A Cozy Mystery Box Set: Books 1-3 (Pebble Cove Teahouse #1-3)
By: Eryn Scott
4.61
Format: 661 pages, Kindle Edition
“A ghost mystery for readers who don’t usually enjoy the paranormal.” Book 1 - Steeped in Suspic… read more
Want to Read $ 9.99Similar categories in Eryn Scott's Pebble Cove: A Cozy Mystery Box Set: Books 1-3 (Pebble Cove Teahouse #1-3) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- mystery
- amazon
- cozy mystery
19. Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
By: Polly Holmes
3.94
Format: 366 pages, Kindle Edition
Witches, cats, pumpkin pies and murder! I’m Evelyn Grayson and if you’d told me by the time I wa… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- holiday
- cozy mystery
- magic
- halloween
- amazon
- fiction
- paranormal
- witches
- fantasy
- mystery
20. A Spirited Swindler (Midlife is Murder #1)
By: Clare Lockhart
4.29
Format: None pages, Kindle Edition
Empty nested and excited to start a new chapter in life, Quinn is almost ready to open her new lake… read more
Want to Read $ 2.99Similar categories in Clare Lockhart's A Spirited Swindler (Midlife is Murder #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- mystery
- cozy mystery
- fiction
- paranormal
21. Living in Bliss (Lyssa Jones #1)
By: Sara Isabelle
4.30
Format: 226 pages, Kindle Edition
Welcome to Bliss, where the streets are lined with endless charm, every storefront has a story, and… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Sara Isabelle's Living in Bliss (Lyssa Jones #1) book and Polly Holmes's Pumpkin Pies & Potions (Melting Pot Cafe #1)
- mystery
- cozy mystery
