18 Top queer books like Gay the Pray Away by Natalie Naudus

Cover of Gay the Pray Away by Natalie Naudus

Gay the Pray Away

By: Natalie Naudus

4.46

Format: 245 pages, Kindle Edition

Valerie Danners is in a cult. She just doesn't know it yet. When she finds a queer book at the libr…

If you liked the queer plot in Gay the Pray Away by Natalie Naudus , here is a list of 18 books like this:

Cover of Dear Wendy by Ann Zhao

1. Dear Wendy

By: Ann Zhao

4.01

Format: 368 pages, Hardcover

Dear Wendy's Sophie and Jo, two aromantic and asexual students at Wellesley College, engage in an o… read more

Similar categories in Ann Zhao's Dear Wendy book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
"Nobody talks about breaking up with your friends. It sucks. Especially when that friend ditches you to be with whoever they think is The One."

-Ann Zhao, Dear Wendy

"And still, it's hard to find people like me. The asexual community is small enough as it is; there are fewer aromantic people and even fewer people who are both."

-Ann Zhao, Dear Wendy

"And that really made me think for the first time about how this could happen with any friend who's not also aroace. Like, my person, my closest confidant, will probably always have someone else - a r…"

-Ann Zhao, Dear Wendy

Cover of Second Night Stand by Karelia Stetz-Waters

2. Second Night Stand

By: Karelia Stetz-Waters

3.95

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

A burlesque performer and a professional ballerina fall in love while competing on a reality TV tal… read more

Similar categories in Karelia Stetz-Waters's Second Night Stand book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of The Summer Love Strategy by Ray Stoeve

3. The Summer Love Strategy

By: Ray Stoeve

3.42

Format: 288 pages, Hardcover

A sweet and swoony YA rom-com about two friends making a pact to find summer romance like they’ve s… read more

Similar categories in Ray Stoeve's The Summer Love Strategy book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of Here We Go Again by Alison Cochrun

4. Here We Go Again

By: Alison Cochrun

4.17

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

The author of Kiss Her Once for Me returns with a new queer rom-com following once childhood best f… read more

Similar categories in Alison Cochrun's Here We Go Again book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of Late Bloomer by Mazey Eddings

5. Late Bloomer

By: Mazey Eddings

3.73

Format: 400 pages, Paperback

A sapphic opposites-attract romance with Mazey Edding's signature sparkling voice! Winning the l… read more

Similar categories in Mazey Eddings's Late Bloomer book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
"Fuck anything and anyone that made you have to survive instead of live. You deserve a life so peaceful it feels deliciously boring. A life filled with flowers and sunny days and people who show you a…"

-Mazey Eddings, Late Bloomer

Cover of How You Get the Girl (Love & Other Disasters, #3) by Anita Kelly

6. How You Get the Girl (Love & Other Disasters, #3)

By: Anita Kelly

4.17

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

Chemistry sizzles in this workplace rom-com set in the world of high school basketball from the aut… read more

Similar categories in Anita Kelly's How You Get the Girl (Love & Other Disasters, #3) book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of The Ride of Her Life by Jennifer Dugan

7. The Ride of Her Life

By: Jennifer Dugan

3.68

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

From the author of Love at First Set, a new irresistible enemies-to-lovers, grumpy/sunshine queer r… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Dugan's The Ride of Her Life book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
"She's coming undone right in front of me and it's turning me on. It should not be turning me on."

-Jennifer Dugan, The Ride of Her Life

Cover of Here for the Wrong Reasons by Annabel Paulsen

8. Here for the Wrong Reasons

By: Annabel Paulsen

3.73

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

In this swoon-filled lesbian romcom, two dating show contestants vying for the affection of the lea… read more

Similar categories in Annabel Paulsen's Here for the Wrong Reasons book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of Triple Sec by T.J.   Alexander

9. Triple Sec

By: T.J. Alexander

3.95

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

A jaded bartender is wooed by a charmingly quirky couple in this fresh and sizzling polyamorous rom… read more

Similar categories in T.J. Alexander's Triple Sec book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of Houseswap 101 by Jaime Clevenger

10. Houseswap 101

By: Jaime Clevenger

4.21

Format: 290 pages, Paperback

Working remote on a houseboat in Seattle sounds amazing—until it rains for four months straight. No… read more

Similar categories in Jaime Clevenger's Houseswap 101 book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • lesbian
  • lgbt
Cover of Playing for Keeps by Jennifer Dugan

11. Playing for Keeps

By: Jennifer Dugan

3.52

Format: 320 pages, Hardcover

From the author of Some Girls Do comes another heartfelt YA sapphic romance—starring a baseball pit… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Dugan's Playing for Keeps book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of Gay the Pray Away by Natalie Naudus

12. Gay the Pray Away

By: Natalie Naudus

4.46

Format: 245 pages, Kindle Edition

Valerie Danners is in a cult. She just doesn't know it yet. When she finds a queer book at the libr… read more

Similar categories in Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • realistic fiction
  • young adult
  • religion
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of The Pairing by Casey McQuiston

13. The Pairing

By: Casey McQuiston

3.90

Format: 432 pages, Paperback

In #1 New York Times bestselling author Casey McQuiston's latest romantic comedy, two bisexual exes… read more

Similar categories in Casey McQuiston's The Pairing book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
"Some people dye their hair when they go through a breakup. I got a bus."

-Casey McQuiston, The Pairing

"This is what I get for assuming all women in safari hats can be trusted."

-Casey McQuiston, The Pairing

"He was the first great thing I ever let myself want. This time, I’m keeping him."

-Casey McQuiston, The Pairing

"A love that’s ended is the only kind I can have, because I can’t possibly lose it."

-Casey McQuiston, The Pairing

Cover of Loser of the Year by Carrie  Byrd

14. Loser of the Year

By: Carrie Byrd

4.63

Format: None pages, ebook

Mattie Belman’s life has gone from dismal to desperate. After the loss of her acting career, her ma… read more

Similar categories in Carrie Byrd's Loser of the Year book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • lgbt
Cover of Wish You Weren't Here by Erin Baldwin

15. Wish You Weren't Here

By: Erin Baldwin

4.03

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

Juliette doesn’t hate Priya Pendley. At least, not in the way teen movies say she should hate th… read more

Similar categories in Erin Baldwin's Wish You Weren't Here book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of True Love and Other Impossible Odds by Christina  Li

16. True Love and Other Impossible Odds

By: Christina Li

4.18

Format: 400 pages, Hardcover

Pitched as Nina LaCour meets The Half of It, the story follows a first-year college student Grace T… read more

Similar categories in Christina Li's True Love and Other Impossible Odds book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of Cash Delgado Is Living the Dream by Tehlor Kay Mejia

17. Cash Delgado Is Living the Dream

By: Tehlor Kay Mejia

3.94

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

A small-town bartender juggles motherhood and a sexual awakening in this heartwarming queer friends… read more

Similar categories in Tehlor Kay Mejia's Cash Delgado Is Living the Dream book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of Nothing Heals Me Like You Do by Harper Bliss

18. Nothing Heals Me Like You Do

By: Harper Bliss

4.23

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

When two worlds collide, a love story beginsJustine Blackburn has dedicated her life to the Rainbow… read more

Similar categories in Harper Bliss's Nothing Heals Me Like You Do book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • contemporary
  • lesbian
  • lgbt
Cover of A Bánh Mì for Two by Trinity  Nguyen

19. A Bánh Mì for Two

By: Trinity Nguyen

4.02

Format: 224 pages, Paperback

In this sweet sapphic romance about two foodies in love, Vivi meets Lan while studying abroad in Vi… read more

Similar categories in Trinity Nguyen's A Bánh Mì for Two book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of Time and Time Again by Chatham Greenfield

20. Time and Time Again

By: Chatham Greenfield

4.21

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

Phoebe Mendel's day is never ending—literally. On August 6th, she woke up to find herself stuck … read more

Similar categories in Chatham Greenfield's Time and Time Again book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • lgbt
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of I'll Get Back to You by Becca Grischow

21. I'll Get Back to You

By: Becca Grischow

3.81

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

A charming homerun of a queer holiday romance where two former classmates’ plan to fake-date their … read more

Similar categories in Becca Grischow's I'll Get Back to You book and Natalie Naudus's Gay the Pray Away

  • romance
  • lesbian
  • audiobook
  • lgbt
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • queer

18 Best fiction books like Gay the Pray Away by Natalie Naudus

Transform Your Habits

Dear Wendy

Ann Zhao

4.01

Transform Your Habits

Second Night Stand

Karelia Stetz-Waters

3.95

Transform Your Habits

The Summer Love Strategy

Ray Stoeve

3.42

Transform Your Habits

Here We Go Again

Alison Cochrun

4.17

View all the books

21 Best fiction books like Here We Go Again by Alison Cochrun

Transform Your Habits

Don't Want You Like a Best Friend (Mischief & Matchmaking, #1)

Emma R. Alban

3.82

Transform Your Habits

Iris Kelly Doesn't Date (Bright Falls, #3)

Ashley Herring Blake

4.14

Transform Your Habits

At Her Service (Out in Hollywood, #2)

Amy Spalding

3.86

Transform Your Habits

You Should Be So Lucky

Cat Sebastian

4.39

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.