21 must-read mystery books like A Sorrow Called Sarah by Charlotte Roddy

Cover of A Sorrow Called Sarah by Charlotte Roddy

A Sorrow Called Sarah

By: Charlotte Roddy

4.26

Format: 360 pages, Kindle Edition

The oldest secrets are the deadliest. Sarah Hopewell had it all—popular student, loving sister, …

If you liked the mystery plot in A Sorrow Called Sarah by Charlotte Roddy , here is a list of 21 books like this:

1. 52 Steps To Murder (Dekker Cozy Mystery #1)

By: Steve Demaree

4.17

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

An elderly woman is found poisoned in the upstairs bedroom of her home whose from door stands 52 st… read more

Similar categories in Steve Demaree's 52 Steps To Murder (Dekker Cozy Mystery #1) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
Cover of The Private Tutor by A.J.  Carter

2. The Private Tutor

By: A.J. Carter

4.14

Format: 368 pages, Kindle Edition

The perfect job, or a deadly trap?It seemed like the perfect job at first. The doctor and his wife … read more

Similar categories in A.J. Carter's The Private Tutor book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • mystery thriller
Cover of Vanishing Day (Logan McKenna #4) by Valerie Davisson

3. Vanishing Day (Logan McKenna #4)

By: Valerie Davisson

4.30

Format: 280 pages, Kindle Edition

Viciously attacked by an unknown assailant, Logan's new neighbor, a young mother, clings to life in… read more

Similar categories in Valerie Davisson's Vanishing Day (Logan McKenna #4) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Throwaway Jane (Karen Pantelli, #1) by Scott William Carter

4. Throwaway Jane (Karen Pantelli, #1)

By: Scott William Carter

4.33

Format: 314 pages, Kindle Edition

Former FBI agent Karen Pantelli lives by a simple philosophy: never, ever care. Three years after a… read more

Similar categories in Scott William Carter's Throwaway Jane (Karen Pantelli, #1) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • fiction
  • suspense
Cover of The Sister-in-Law by A.J.  Carter

5. The Sister-in-Law

By: A.J. Carter

4.05

Format: 218 pages, Kindle Edition

Living with family can be murder. I’ve never met my husband’s sister, because she’s been in pris… read more

Similar categories in A.J. Carter's The Sister-in-Law book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
  • mystery thriller
Cover of Eleven (Brandon Fisher FBI, #1) by Carolyn Arnold

6. Eleven (Brandon Fisher FBI, #1)

By: Carolyn Arnold

3.95

Format: 384 pages, Kindle Edition

Eleven Rooms. Ten Bodies. One Empty Grave. In this international bestseller, rookie FBI Agent Br… read more

Similar categories in Carolyn Arnold's Eleven (Brandon Fisher FBI, #1) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of One Last Bite by Leah Cupps

7. One Last Bite

By: Leah Cupps

4.06

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

Sadie’s dream job is about to become her nightmare.Chef Sadie Jackson is ready to escape a troubled… read more

Similar categories in Leah Cupps's One Last Bite book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Body at Blackwell Lake: An Amateur Sleuth Paranormal Mystery by A.M. Caplan

8. The Body at Blackwell Lake: An Amateur Sleuth Paranormal Mystery

By: A.M. Caplan

4.25

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

She hates her power to detect missing things. When it leads her to a dead woman, can she smoke out … read more

Similar categories in A.M. Caplan's The Body at Blackwell Lake: An Amateur Sleuth Paranormal Mystery book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Breach of Trust (The Madeline Dawkins Mystery Series Book 8) by Cynthia Hamilton

9. Breach of Trust (The Madeline Dawkins Mystery Series Book 8)

By: Cynthia Hamilton

4.53

Format: 320 pages, Kindle Edition

A page-turner that will keep you guessing until the end, Breach of Trust is the thrilling eighth bo… read more

Similar categories in Cynthia Hamilton's Breach of Trust (The Madeline Dawkins Mystery Series Book 8) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

Cover of Spouse Trap (Madeline Dawkins, #1) by Cynthia Hamilton

10. Spouse Trap (Madeline Dawkins, #1)

By: Cynthia Hamilton

4.28

Format: 436 pages, Kindle Edition

Madeline Ridley had all she’d ever dreamed of: a handsome, successful husband, a place at the top o… read more

Similar categories in Cynthia Hamilton's Spouse Trap (Madeline Dawkins, #1) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of Victim 14 (Detective Emily Tizzano #3) by K.J. Kalis

11. Victim 14 (Detective Emily Tizzano #3)

By: K.J. Kalis

4.41

Format: 312 pages, Kindle Edition

The people of Tifton, Louisiana, count their population by the clock. Every six months, someone … read more

Similar categories in K.J. Kalis's Victim 14 (Detective Emily Tizzano #3) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Wicked Sharp (Born Bad, Book 1) by Meghan O'Flynn

12. Wicked Sharp (Born Bad, Book 1)

By: Meghan O'Flynn

3.72

Format: 165 pages, Kindle Edition

Fast-paced, electric, and barbed with nerve-shredding thrills, Wicked Sharp is exquisitely addictiv… read more

Similar categories in Meghan O'Flynn's Wicked Sharp (Born Bad, Book 1) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • psychological thriller
Cover of Shore Lodge (The Millersville series) by Susan Specht Oram

13. Shore Lodge (The Millersville series)

By: Susan Specht Oram

3.87

Format: 298 pages, Kindle Edition

A high-stakes psychological thriller Her grief threatened to swallow her whole. When a seed of bet… read more

Similar categories in Susan Specht Oram's Shore Lodge (The Millersville series) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • psychological thriller
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of Off The Grid by John                  Hunt

14. Off The Grid

By: John Hunt

4.26

Format: 253 pages, Kindle Edition

Graham Richards was shopping with his family at an outlet mall when an active shooter began indiscr… read more

Similar categories in John Hunt's Off The Grid book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Murder at Aspen Creek: An Inspector Hilary Casgrain Murder Mystery (An Elk Ridge Murder Mystery) by Anne Shillolo

15. Murder at Aspen Creek: An Inspector Hilary Casgrain Murder Mystery (An Elk Ridge Murder Mystery)

By: Anne Shillolo

3.99

Format: 74 pages, Kindle Edition

A random overnight visit to a quiet prairie town turns deadly for Inspector Hilary Casgrain. Inste… read more

Similar categories in Anne Shillolo's Murder at Aspen Creek: An Inspector Hilary Casgrain Murder Mystery (An Elk Ridge Murder Mystery) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery thriller
Cover of Who Cares If They Die (Dean Matheson #1) by Wendy Dranfield

16. Who Cares If They Die (Dean Matheson #1)

By: Wendy Dranfield

4.26

Format: 344 pages, Kindle Edition

A Jane Doe hanging in Maple Valley’s woods. Officer Dean Matheson stands shivering against the c… read more

Similar categories in Wendy Dranfield's Who Cares If They Die (Dean Matheson #1) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of A Knock at the Door by Peter  Rowlands

17. A Knock at the Door

By: Peter Rowlands

4.31

Format: 409 pages, Kindle Edition

A brain-teasing mystery that grabs you right from the start – and then delivers A bedraggled wom… read more

Similar categories in Peter Rowlands's A Knock at the Door book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • fiction
Cover of Cemetery View: A Novel by A.M. Caplan

18. Cemetery View: A Novel

By: A.M. Caplan

4.19

Format: 281 pages, Kindle Edition

When a shocking discovery unearths an old secret, can Stella expose a killer?Abandoned by her mothe… read more

Similar categories in A.M. Caplan's Cemetery View: A Novel book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
Cover of Last Place Seen by Alessandra Harris

19. Last Place Seen

By: Alessandra Harris

3.95

Format: 303 pages, Kindle Edition

In the aftermath of her husband’s life-altering mistake, Tiana Williams grapples with lingering res… read more

Similar categories in Alessandra Harris's Last Place Seen book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • thriller
  • fiction
  • suspense
Cover of Web of Secrets (Vital Secrets #3) by D.F. Hart

20. Web of Secrets (Vital Secrets #3)

By: D.F. Hart

4.18

Format: 317 pages, Kindle Edition

An alternative cover edition for this ASIN can be found here So many to choose from… Someone’… read more

Similar categories in D.F. Hart's Web of Secrets (Vital Secrets #3) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
  • suspense
Cover of The Fear of Winter (The Fear Of, #1) by S.C. Sterling

21. The Fear of Winter (The Fear Of, #1)

By: S.C. Sterling

3.93

Format: 233 pages, Paperback

On a frigid December night, Megan Floyd vanishes from the mountain town of Fraser, Colorado. The ex… read more

Similar categories in S.C. Sterling's The Fear of Winter (The Fear Of, #1) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
  • suspense
Cover of A Sorrow Called Sarah by Charlotte Roddy

22. A Sorrow Called Sarah

By: Charlotte Roddy

4.26

Format: 360 pages, Kindle Edition

The oldest secrets are the deadliest. Sarah Hopewell had it all—popular student, loving sister, … read more

Similar categories in Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery thriller
  • suspense
  • psychological thriller
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The New Friend by S.L. Harker

23. The New Friend

By: S.L. Harker

4.01

Format: 222 pages, Kindle Edition

You saved her life. You gave her a home. You know nothing about her… Divorcee Claire is learning… read more

Similar categories in S.L. Harker's The New Friend book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery thriller
  • thriller
  • fiction
Cover of Stable: Someone is Taking Them... (A Tyler Zahn Novel Book 1) by Cam Torrens

24. Stable: Someone is Taking Them... (A Tyler Zahn Novel Book 1)

By: Cam Torrens

4.42

Format: 359 pages, Kindle Edition

A kidnapper hiding in plain sight. A rural town with tons of suspects. From debut author Cam Torren… read more

Similar categories in Cam Torrens's Stable: Someone is Taking Them... (A Tyler Zahn Novel Book 1) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • thriller
  • suspense
Cover of Five Cold Bodies (Detective Max Grady #3) by K.J. Kalis

25. Five Cold Bodies (Detective Max Grady #3)

By: K.J. Kalis

4.26

Format: 334 pages, Kindle Edition

Detective Max Grady couldn’t be more irritated…Sent out to an abandoned barn with his partner, Cass… read more

Similar categories in K.J. Kalis's Five Cold Bodies (Detective Max Grady #3) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • fiction
Cover of Under the Willows by Pamela   McCord

26. Under the Willows

By: Pamela McCord

4.23

Format: 302 pages, Kindle Edition

After her husband is killed by a drunk driver, Kelly Harris and her son TJ move into a sprawling Vi… read more

Similar categories in Pamela McCord's Under the Willows book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • fiction
Cover of You Are Not Alone by Leah Cupps

27. You Are Not Alone

By: Leah Cupps

3.97

Format: 261 pages, Kindle Edition

They thought they were alone on the island. They were wrong. Natalie and boyfriend Hudson have b… read more

Similar categories in Leah Cupps's You Are Not Alone book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
  • suspense
Cover of Her Last Request (Alex Harper #1) by Mark Ayre

28. Her Last Request (Alex Harper #1)

By: Mark Ayre

4.13

Format: 369 pages, Kindle Edition

Get Alex Harper... A gripping thriller packed with twists and turns, perfect for fans of Harlan Cob… read more

Similar categories in Mark Ayre's Her Last Request (Alex Harper #1) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

Cover of Behind Her Lies (Elise Close, #1) by Molly Black

29. Behind Her Lies (Elise Close, #1)

By: Molly Black

3.85

Format: 193 pages, Kindle Edition

Celebrity therapist Elise Close is no stranger to families with skeletons in their closets.But when… read more

Similar categories in Molly Black's Behind Her Lies (Elise Close, #1) book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • psychological thriller
  • mystery thriller
Cover of Plum Springs by Dan Lawton

30. Plum Springs

By: Dan Lawton

4.25

Format: 276 pages, Paperback

Winner of the 2019 New Hampshire Writers' Project Readers' Choice Award for Fiction Faced with t… read more

Similar categories in Dan Lawton's Plum Springs book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

Cover of The Poison Garden by Mary  Oldham

31. The Poison Garden

By: Mary Oldham

4.07

Format: 240 pages, Kindle Edition

If Amber/Jane/Kelan chooses your neighborhood, it is because there is work to do. She will rent a h… read more

Similar categories in Mary Oldham's The Poison Garden book and Charlotte Roddy's A Sorrow Called Sarah

20 best-selling fiction books like A Sorrow Called Sarah by Charlotte Roddy

52 Steps To Murder (Dekker Cozy Mystery #1)

Steve Demaree

4.17

Transform Your Habits

Vanishing Day (Logan McKenna #4)

Valerie Davisson

4.30

Transform Your Habits

Throwaway Jane (Karen Pantelli, #1)

Scott William Carter

4.33

Transform Your Habits

The Sister-in-Law

A.J. Carter

4.05

View all the books

24 must-read fiction books like Last Place Seen by Alessandra Harris

Transform Your Habits

So Long (Faith Bold #1)

Blake Pierce

4.27

Transform Your Habits

Shred of Doubt

Darren Sugrue

4.37

Transform Your Habits

The Last Night

Harvey Church

3.85

Transform Your Habits

It Should Have Been Me

Susan Wilkins

3.99

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.