20 best-selling romance books like P.S. I'm Still Yours by Eliah Greenwood

P.S. I'm Still Yours

By: Eliah Greenwood

4.11

Format: None pages, None

It all started with the worst day of my life. He waltzed into that church like it hadn’t been fi…

If you liked the romance plot in P.S. I'm Still Yours by Eliah Greenwood , here is a list of 20 books like this:

Cover of Pine River by Tijan

1. Pine River

By: Tijan

4.18

Format: 554 pages, Kindle Edition

Pine River was supposed to be a new start for me. And it was, especially attending school with my … read more

Similar categories in Tijan's Pine River book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Tell Me Pretty Lies by Charleigh Rose

2. Tell Me Pretty Lies

By: Charleigh Rose

3.89

Format: 312 pages, Kindle Edition

Three things my mother acquired when she became engaged: 1. A brand new Tiffany's ring. 2. A l… read more

Similar categories in Charleigh Rose's Tell Me Pretty Lies book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of Not Made to Last by Jay McLean

3. Not Made to Last

By: Jay McLean

4.15

Format: 364 pages, Kindle Edition

Two simple words hold the truth of our love: wait and hope. Olivia Rhys Garrett—recent high sch… read more

Similar categories in Jay McLean's Not Made to Last book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of Ice Bet (Bexley U) by S.J. Sylvis

4. Ice Bet (Bexley U)

By: S.J. Sylvis

4.05

Format: 356 pages, Kindle Edition

She’s the coach’s daughter and his rival’s newest target. Aasher Matthews is everything I detest… read more

Similar categories in S.J. Sylvis's Ice Bet (Bexley U) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Moon and Back by Ginger Scott

5. The Moon and Back

By: Ginger Scott

4.14

Format: 444 pages, Kindle Edition

Johnny Bishop crashed into my life like a hurricane. Not once, but twice. The first time, we wer… read more

Similar categories in Ginger Scott's The Moon and Back book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • music
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of You Beautiful Thing, You (Bad Boys of Bardstown, #1) by Saffron A. Kent

6. You Beautiful Thing, You (Bad Boys of Bardstown, #1)

By: Saffron A. Kent

3.49

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

Nineteen-year-old Tempest Jackson wants a baby. No, her biological clock isn’t ticking, but sh… read more

Similar categories in Saffron A. Kent's You Beautiful Thing, You (Bad Boys of Bardstown, #1) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of Sticks and Stones by S. Massery

7. Sticks and Stones

By: S. Massery

3.95

Format: 301 pages, Kindle Edition

Sticks and stones may break our bones… Hockey is my life. After Wren Davis puts my dreams o… read more

Similar categories in S. Massery's Sticks and Stones book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • new adult
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of You Promised Me Forever by L.A. Cotton

8. You Promised Me Forever

By: L.A. Cotton

3.77

Format: 396 pages, Kindle Edition

From bestselling author L A Cotton comes an emotional and angsty coming-of-age story about loss, lo… read more

Similar categories in L.A. Cotton's You Promised Me Forever book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Tuesday Night Truths (Truth and Lies Book 2) by C.W. Farnsworth

9. Tuesday Night Truths (Truth and Lies Book 2)

By: C.W. Farnsworth

3.73

Format: 347 pages, Kindle Edition

Are first loves meant to last? Or do we outgrow our pasts...She’s been part of my life since we wer… read more

Similar categories in C.W. Farnsworth's Tuesday Night Truths (Truth and Lies Book 2) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of I Wish I Would've Told You (Forbidden Wishes #1) by Whitney G.

10. I Wish I Would've Told You (Forbidden Wishes #1)

By: Whitney G.

3.81

Format: 264 pages, Kindle Edition

She lied to me. Not once, not twice. This entire time. To her, I was the "cliche Mr. Popular,"… read more

Similar categories in Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would've Told You (Forbidden Wishes #1) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Come Break My Heart Again by C.W. Farnsworth

11. Come Break My Heart Again

By: C.W. Farnsworth

4.03

Format: 446 pages, Paperback

An angsty, opposites attract, forced proximity standalone romance from bestselling author C.W. Farn… read more

Similar categories in C.W. Farnsworth's Come Break My Heart Again book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Boy I Once Hated (Love & Hate Duet, #1) by C.R. Jane

12. The Boy I Once Hated (Love & Hate Duet, #1)

By: C.R. Jane

4.16

Format: 422 pages, Kindle Edition

I've always heard there's a fine line between love and hate. No one told me that line could destr… read more

Similar categories in C.R. Jane's The Boy I Once Hated (Love & Hate Duet, #1) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of The Girl I Once Loved (Love & Hate Duet, #2) by C.R. Jane

13. The Girl I Once Loved (Love & Hate Duet, #2)

By: C.R. Jane

4.23

Format: 373 pages, Kindle Edition

Someone once told me that there's a fine line between love and hate. They forgot to mention how … read more

Similar categories in C.R. Jane's The Girl I Once Loved (Love & Hate Duet, #2) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • dark
  • contemporary

14. Break Your Little Heart (Heartbreak Hill, #2)

By: Charleigh Rose

4.18

Format: None pages, None

He thinks he can break my heart, but you have to have a heart in order for it to break… It was s… read more

Similar categories in Charleigh Rose's Break Your Little Heart (Heartbreak Hill, #2) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Cruel Crypts (Gods of Hatherley Hall, #1) by Becca Steele

15. Cruel Crypts (Gods of Hatherley Hall, #1)

By: Becca Steele

3.95

Format: 350 pages, Kindle Edition

From USA Today and Wall Street Journal bestselling author, Becca Steele, comes an all-new standalon… read more

Similar categories in Becca Steele's Cruel Crypts (Gods of Hatherley Hall, #1) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of He Loves Me (He Loves Me Not/He Loves Me Duet #2) by Carmen Rosales

16. He Loves Me (He Loves Me Not/He Loves Me Duet #2)

By: Carmen Rosales

4.00

Format: 232 pages, Kindle Edition

All good things that come to an end make way for new beginnings. Even in the shadow of past dece… read more

Similar categories in Carmen Rosales's He Loves Me (He Loves Me Not/He Loves Me Duet #2) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
"But sometimes we make mistakes to learn what matters most."

-Carmen Rosales, He Loves Me (He Loves Me Not/He Loves Me Duet #2)

"When I stare his black eyes, it's like he has lived a thousand lives, and I'm every one of them."

-Carmen Rosales, He Loves Me (He Loves Me Not/He Loves Me Duet #2)

"it's difficult to let go of the person you care about the most. But now I find him, it's even harder to hold the memory of a person who doesn't care about you in the way you hopped."

-Carmen Rosales, He Loves Me (He Loves Me Not/He Loves Me Duet #2)

Cover of You Broke Me First by Michaela   Sawyer

17. You Broke Me First

By: Michaela Sawyer

4.02

Format: 392 pages, Kindle Edition

He's everything I'm not. He's into sports, and I'm into books and art. He's popular with girls fa… read more

Similar categories in Michaela Sawyer's You Broke Me First book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

Cover of These Two Wrongs (Savage Academy, #2) by Julia  Wolf

18. These Two Wrongs (Savage Academy, #2)

By: Julia Wolf

4.24

Format: 334 pages, Kindle Edition

The universe must really hate me. Rhys Astor, the guy with a deadly smirk and devil-may-care att… read more

Similar categories in Julia Wolf's These Two Wrongs (Savage Academy, #2) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of You Said I Was Your Favorite (Lancaster Prep, #5) by Monica  Murphy

19. You Said I Was Your Favorite (Lancaster Prep, #5)

By: Monica Murphy

3.99

Format: 462 pages, Kindle Edition

Daisy Albright. Incredibly beautiful. Painfully shy. Nobody in our class pays attention to the g… read more

Similar categories in Monica Murphy's You Said I Was Your Favorite (Lancaster Prep, #5) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
"Because if you were into her, you wouldn’t want it to be just hanging out and fucking around. You’d want to be with her all the time. Your thoughts would be consumed with her. You’d see things, or so…"

-Monica Murphy, You Said I Was Your Favorite (Lancaster Prep, #5)

20. P.S. I'm Still Yours

By: Eliah Greenwood

4.11

Format: None pages, None

It all started with the worst day of my life. He waltzed into that church like it hadn’t been fi… read more

Similar categories in Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance
  • music
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of Bitter Enemies (Hurtful Love, Book 2) by Vera Hollins

21. Bitter Enemies (Hurtful Love, Book 2)

By: Vera Hollins

3.84

Format: 335 pages, Kindle Edition

Three weeks ago, Carter and I had managed to find each other again. We’d managed to conquer hate an… read more

Similar categories in Vera Hollins's Bitter Enemies (Hurtful Love, Book 2) book and Eliah Greenwood's P.S. I'm Still Yours

  • romance

18 Top contemporary books like P.S. I'm Still Yours by Eliah Greenwood

Transform Your Habits

Pine River

Tijan

4.18

Transform Your Habits

Tell Me Pretty Lies

Charleigh Rose

3.89

Transform Your Habits

Not Made to Last

Jay McLean

4.15

Transform Your Habits

Ice Bet (Bexley U)

S.J. Sylvis

4.05

View all the books

19 best-selling contemporary books like The Boy I Once Hated (Love & Hate Duet, #1) by C.R. Jane

Transform Your Habits

Pine River

Tijan

4.18

Transform Your Habits

Tell Me Pretty Lies

Charleigh Rose

3.89

Transform Your Habits

Playing with Fire

Michaela Sawyer

3.99

Transform Your Habits

Bad Intentions (Hellions of Hade Harbor #1)

Mila Kane

4.15

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.