21 best-selling romance books like That First Date (Firsts in the City #2) by Jenn McMahon

Cover of That First Date (Firsts in the City #2) by Jenn McMahon

That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

By: Jenn McMahon

4.20

Format: 344 pages, Kindle Edition

My new boss has lost his mind. Marc Ford is everything that I’m not. He wants a long term relati…

If you liked the romance plot in That First Date (Firsts in the City #2) by Jenn McMahon , here is a list of 21 books like this:

Cover of Just This Once (King Family, #1) by Lena Hendrix

1. Just This Once (King Family, #1)

By: Lena Hendrix

4.08

Format: 329 pages, Kindle Edition

Whip King cannot be the man for me. Cocky, pierced firefighters are perfect for late-night rom-c… read more

Similar categories in Lena Hendrix's Just This Once (King Family, #1) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
"How did I make you feel?"

-Lena Hendrix, Just This Once (King Family, #1)

"I was calling your name, but it looked like you were in a different world."

-Lena Hendrix, Just This Once (King Family, #1)

Cover of One Chance (The Sullivan Family, #3) by Lena Hendrix

2. One Chance (The Sullivan Family, #3)

By: Lena Hendrix

4.12

Format: 392 pages, Kindle Edition

Fake dating my best friend? Total disaster. With his cocky grin and devilish charm, firefighter … read more

Similar categories in Lena Hendrix's One Chance (The Sullivan Family, #3) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Learn Your Lesson (Kings of the Ice, #3) by Kandi Steiner

3. Learn Your Lesson (Kings of the Ice, #3)

By: Kandi Steiner

4.13

Format: 470 pages, Kindle Edition

My mother only wanted me to learn one lesson growing up… Men are trash. Her father left her, a… read more

Similar categories in Kandi Steiner's Learn Your Lesson (Kings of the Ice, #3) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Pretty Rings & Broken Things (Black Tie Billionaires, #2) by Kat Singleton

4. Pretty Rings & Broken Things (Black Tie Billionaires, #2)

By: Kat Singleton

3.98

Format: 364 pages, Kindle Edition

Pretty rings can’t always fix broken things. Unfortunately, that doesn’t stop powerful men from … read more

Similar categories in Kat Singleton's Pretty Rings & Broken Things (Black Tie Billionaires, #2) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Homerun Proposal (Orleans University, #1) by Maren Moore

5. Homerun Proposal (Orleans University, #1)

By: Maren Moore

3.78

Format: 364 pages, Kindle Edition

The proposal was Score a homerun and take my virginity. Except, my proposal went to the wrong bro… read more

Similar categories in Maren Moore's Homerun Proposal (Orleans University, #1) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of In the Game (Lakes Hockey, #3) by Sloane St. James

6. In the Game (Lakes Hockey, #3)

By: Sloane St. James

4.18

Format: 424 pages, Kindle Edition

Raleigh Being a “puck bunny” isn’t a term I enjoy, but it’s what they call me. And I’m okay with… read more

Similar categories in Sloane St. James's In the Game (Lakes Hockey, #3) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
"Her gaze meets mine, and it's so full of love. Because that's what Raleigh is, she's love."

-Sloane St. James, In the Game (Lakes Hockey, #3)

"...But as soon as I slid inside you, it was like a switch flipped in my brain. Like, that was it. My vision was perfectly clear and you were all I wanted. My heart was at peace. My soul was on fire. …"

-Sloane St. James, In the Game (Lakes Hockey, #3)

Cover of Bright Lights & Summer Nights (Black Tie Billionaires, #3) by Kat Singleton

7. Bright Lights & Summer Nights (Black Tie Billionaires, #3)

By: Kat Singleton

4.22

Format: 356 pages, Kindle Edition

Summer nights can be full of surprises. As a single, unemployed, and unapologetic twenty-five ye… read more

Similar categories in Kat Singleton's Bright Lights & Summer Nights (Black Tie Billionaires, #3) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of If You Give a Single Dad a Nanny (Aspen Grove, #1) by Ann Einerson

8. If You Give a Single Dad a Nanny (Aspen Grove, #1)

By: Ann Einerson

3.88

Format: 312 pages, Kindle Edition

I, Marlow Taylor, need to stop fantasizing about the hot, single dad next door. Should I have ag… read more

Similar categories in Ann Einerson's If You Give a Single Dad a Nanny (Aspen Grove, #1) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Strong and Wild (Lakes Hockey, #2) by Sloane St. James

9. Strong and Wild (Lakes Hockey, #2)

By: Sloane St. James

4.10

Format: 346 pages, Kindle Edition

FreyaThings are looking up for me in my new Minnesota home. My bestie’s husband hooked me up with a… read more

Similar categories in Sloane St. James's Strong and Wild (Lakes Hockey, #2) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
"And that same heady buzz I felt on the ice before my goal is the same one I feel when I look at her."

-Sloane St. James, Strong and Wild (Lakes Hockey, #2)

Cover of Stand and Defend (Lakes Hockey, #4) by Sloane St. James

10. Stand and Defend (Lakes Hockey, #4)

By: Sloane St. James

4.29

Format: 458 pages, Kindle Edition

Jordana I live my life head over heart and never rock the boat. Which is how I wound up engaged … read more

Similar categories in Sloane St. James's Stand and Defend (Lakes Hockey, #4) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Line of Scrimmage (Out of Bounds, #1) by Erin MacKenzie

11. Line of Scrimmage (Out of Bounds, #1)

By: Erin MacKenzie

3.84

Format: 326 pages, Kindle Edition

Football has been the only constant thing in my life for the last twenty years. Everything I've wor… read more

Similar categories in Erin MacKenzie's Line of Scrimmage (Out of Bounds, #1) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Tempt Our Fate (Sutten Mountain, #2) by Kat Singleton

12. Tempt Our Fate (Sutten Mountain, #2)

By: Kat Singleton

4.16

Format: 398 pages, Kindle Edition

Camden Hunter doesn't belong here. I've spent my entire life in the small town of Sutten Mountai… read more

Similar categories in Kat Singleton's Tempt Our Fate (Sutten Mountain, #2) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of That First Date (Firsts in the City #2) by Jenn McMahon

13. That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

By: Jenn McMahon

4.20

Format: 344 pages, Kindle Edition

My new boss has lost his mind. Marc Ford is everything that I’m not. He wants a long term relati… read more

Similar categories in Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Catching Feelings (Orleans University, #2) by Maren Moore

14. Catching Feelings (Orleans University, #2)

By: Maren Moore

4.12

Format: 370 pages, Kindle Edition

I accidentally hooked up with the guy I despise. A mistake I’d love to forget…except now he’s my ne… read more

Similar categories in Maren Moore's Catching Feelings (Orleans University, #2) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Play Along (Windy City, #4) by Liz Tomforde

15. Play Along (Windy City, #4)

By: Liz Tomforde

4.52

Format: 384 pages, Kindle Edition

Kennedy I’m the only woman on staff for the Windy City Warriors, and after years of putting up w… read more

Similar categories in Liz Tomforde's Play Along (Windy City, #4) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Walkoff Wedding (Orleans University, #3) by Maren Moore

16. Walkoff Wedding (Orleans University, #3)

By: Maren Moore

4.01

Format: 428 pages, Kindle Edition

I fell for my secret pen pal believing we would never meet but now.. he’s my husband. Grant Berg… read more

Similar categories in Maren Moore's Walkoff Wedding (Orleans University, #3) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of If You Give a Billionaire a Bride (Aspen Grove, #2) by Ann Einerson

17. If You Give a Billionaire a Bride (Aspen Grove, #2)

By: Ann Einerson

4.03

Format: 437 pages, Kindle Edition

I, Everly Townstead, need to stop fantasizing about my brother’s billionaire best friend. Should… read more

Similar categories in Ann Einerson's If You Give a Billionaire a Bride (Aspen Grove, #2) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Just My Luck (King Family, #2) by Lena Hendrix

18. Just My Luck (King Family, #2)

By: Lena Hendrix

4.21

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

You might think it’s reckless for a single mom to enter into a marriage of convenience with her bos… read more

Similar categories in Lena Hendrix's Just My Luck (King Family, #2) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Fall with Me (Playing for Keeps, #4) by Becka Mack

19. Fall with Me (Playing for Keeps, #4)

By: Becka Mack

4.39

Format: 510 pages, Kindle Edition

It was supposed to be a one-night stand. But what if they can’t leave it in the past? Jaxon Ril… read more

Similar categories in Becka Mack's Fall with Me (Playing for Keeps, #4) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
"Stop worrying about being enough for other people. Be enough for yourself"

-Becka Mack, Fall with Me (Playing for Keeps, #4)

Cover of The End Zone (Out of Bounds, #2) by Erin MacKenzie

20. The End Zone (Out of Bounds, #2)

By: Erin MacKenzie

3.99

Format: 313 pages, Kindle Edition

Super Bowl Champion. All Pro running back. Leading rusher in the NFL. All titles I've strived fo… read more

Similar categories in Erin MacKenzie's The End Zone (Out of Bounds, #2) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
Cover of The Playbook (Out of Bounds, #3) by Erin MacKenzie

21. The Playbook (Out of Bounds, #3)

By: Erin MacKenzie

4.05

Format: 324 pages, Kindle Edition

I’m a father first, football player second and everything else third. I’ve worked hard the last … read more

Similar categories in Erin MacKenzie's The Playbook (Out of Bounds, #3) book and Jenn McMahon's That First Date (Firsts in the City #2)

  • romance

19 must-read contemporary books like That First Date (Firsts in the City #2) by Jenn McMahon

Transform Your Habits

Just This Once (King Family, #1)

Lena Hendrix

4.08

Transform Your Habits

One Chance (The Sullivan Family, #3)

Lena Hendrix

4.12

Transform Your Habits

Learn Your Lesson (Kings of the Ice, #3)

Kandi Steiner

4.13

Transform Your Habits

Pretty Rings & Broken Things (Black Tie Billionaires, #2)

Kat Singleton

3.98

View all the books

26 must-read fiction books like Play Along (Windy City, #4) by Liz Tomforde

Transform Your Habits

King of Sloth (Kings of Sin, #4)

Ana Huang

4.00

Transform Your Habits

Wild Love (Rose Hill, #1)

Elsie Silver

4.10

Transform Your Habits

The Dixon Rule (Campus Diaries, #2)

Elle Kennedy

4.20

Transform Your Habits

Forbidden King (Magnolia Falls, #3)

Laura Pavlov

4.26

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.