12 best-selling mystery books like To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24) by Tricia Goyer

Cover of To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24) by Tricia Goyer

To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

By: Tricia Goyer

4.59

Format: 240 pages, Hardcover

Cheryl Cooper & Levi Miller will be wed in just a few days. But one thing after another crops up t…

If you liked the mystery plot in To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24) by Tricia Goyer , here is a list of 12 books like this:

Cover of Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6) by Emily Thomas

1. Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6)

By: Emily Thomas

4.40

Format: 277 pages, Hardcover

When the mayor of Blue Hill visits Anne to talk about a new tax proposal that will soon go before t… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Off the Shelf (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #6) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
Cover of Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3) by Emily Thomas

2. Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3)

By: Emily Thomas

4.57

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When an unmarked envelope arrives at the library, containing a mock-up of a newspaper article, Anne… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Unlocking the Truth (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #3) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery

3. Nowhere to be found (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #1)

By: Emily Thomas

4.23

Format: 528 pages, Hardcover

While converting the Victorian home left by her great-aunt Edie into a library, Anne Gibson stumble… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Nowhere to be found (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #1) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

4. Goodbye to Yesterday (Discovery, #1)

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.06

Format: 32 pages, Paperback

Join Meredith and Luke Stoltzfus, an Amish couple who are faced with the greatest challenge of thei… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's Goodbye to Yesterday (Discovery, #1) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

5. Christmas key (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #5)

By: Emily Thomas

4.00

Format: None pages, Hardcover

Anne is busy preparing for Christmas when she finds a delicate key among Aunt Edie's holiday decora… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Christmas key (Secrets of the Blue Hill Library, #5) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

6. Gone in a flash

By: Emily Thomas

3.33

Format: None pages, Hardcover

When Anne finds a roll of undeveloped film in an old camera of her great-aunt Edie's and has it pro… read more

Similar categories in Emily Thomas's Gone in a flash book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

Cover of If I Live (If I Run, #3) by Terri Blackstock

7. If I Live (If I Run, #3)

By: Terri Blackstock

4.36

Format: 352 pages, Kindle Edition

Casey is hiding again—in Memphis this time—but it’s different now. She knows without a doubt that D… read more

Similar categories in Terri Blackstock's If I Live (If I Run, #3) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
Cover of The Teacher's Bride (Amish Brides of Birch Creek #1) by Kathleen Fuller

8. The Teacher's Bride (Amish Brides of Birch Creek #1)

By: Kathleen Fuller

4.31

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

Beloved and bestselling author of Amish romance Kathleen Fuller reminds us that sometimes opposites… read more

Similar categories in Kathleen Fuller's The Teacher's Bride (Amish Brides of Birch Creek #1) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • amish fiction
Cover of Christmas in the Crosshairs: An Elite Guardians Christmas Anthology (Elite Guardians Collection Book 4) by Lynette Eason

9. Christmas in the Crosshairs: An Elite Guardians Christmas Anthology (Elite Guardians Collection Book 4)

By: Lynette Eason

4.52

Format: 283 pages, Paperback

It’s Christmastime and love is in the air. But when these three Elite Guardians walk into the cross… read more

Similar categories in Lynette Eason's Christmas in the Crosshairs: An Elite Guardians Christmas Anthology (Elite Guardians Collection Book 4) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
Cover of Another's Treasure (Mysteries of Lancaster County, #1) by Nancy Mehl

10. Another's Treasure (Mysteries of Lancaster County, #1)

By: Nancy Mehl

3.93

Format: None pages, None

Nestled among Pennsylvania’s rolling hills is Bird-in-Hand, a tiny village where Amish, Mennonites,… read more

Similar categories in Nancy Mehl's Another's Treasure (Mysteries of Lancaster County, #1) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
Cover of Fatal Witness (Pearl River, #2) by Patricia  Bradley

11. Fatal Witness (Pearl River, #2)

By: Patricia Bradley

4.49

Format: 400 pages, Paperback

As a child, artist and potter Dani Bennett witnessed the brutal murder of her parents. With no memo… read more

Similar categories in Patricia Bradley's Fatal Witness (Pearl River, #2) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
Cover of Nursing Her Amish Neighbor (Brides of Lost Creek #6) by Marta Perry

12. Nursing Her Amish Neighbor (Brides of Lost Creek #6)

By: Marta Perry

4.62

Format: 221 pages, Kindle Edition

Healing his physical wounds is just the beginning... Seeking a break from her nursing duties, Miri… read more

Similar categories in Marta Perry's Nursing Her Amish Neighbor (Brides of Lost Creek #6) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • amish fiction
Cover of Secrets of the Amish Diary (Amish Inn Mysteries, #1) by Rachael O. Phillips

13. Secrets of the Amish Diary (Amish Inn Mysteries, #1)

By: Rachael O. Phillips

3.95

Format: 221 pages, Hardcover

The people of Pleasant Creek are delighted to welcome Liz Eckardt to their picturesque country town… read more

Similar categories in Rachael O. Phillips's Secrets of the Amish Diary (Amish Inn Mysteries, #1) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
Cover of The Mysterious Amish Bachelor (Indiana Amish Market, #4) by Vannetta Chapman

14. The Mysterious Amish Bachelor (Indiana Amish Market, #4)

By: Vannetta Chapman

4.47

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

He has a secret. She’s set on discovering it. After paying the price for a crime he committed… read more

Similar categories in Vannetta Chapman's The Mysterious Amish Bachelor (Indiana Amish Market, #4) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

Cover of Hidden in the Night (Missing in Alaska, #3) by Elizabeth Goddard

15. Hidden in the Night (Missing in Alaska, #3)

By: Elizabeth Goddard

4.27

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

At the behest of her ailing mother, former FBI special agent turned rare-book collector Ivy Elliott… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Goddard's Hidden in the Night (Missing in Alaska, #3) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
Cover of Plain Deception (Amish Inn Mysteries, # 2) by Tara Randel

16. Plain Deception (Amish Inn Mysteries, # 2)

By: Tara Randel

4.04

Format: 204 pages, None

Liz Eckardt, new owner of the Olde Mansion Inn, located in the idyllic town of Pleasant Creek, Indi… read more

Similar categories in Tara Randel's Plain Deception (Amish Inn Mysteries, # 2) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
Cover of Letters of Wisdom (Friendship Letters, #3) by Wanda E. Brunstetter

17. Letters of Wisdom (Friendship Letters, #3)

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.46

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

Friendship Letters Series — Doretta Schwartz has always enjoyed writing letters and feels her lette… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's Letters of Wisdom (Friendship Letters, #3) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • amish fiction
Cover of A Is for Amish (Amish ABCs, #1) by Shelley Shepard Gray

18. A Is for Amish (Amish ABCs, #1)

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.21

Format: 288 pages, Paperback

In a heartwarming new series from New York Times bestselling author Shelley Shepard Gray, four sibl… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's A Is for Amish (Amish ABCs, #1) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • amish fiction
Cover of To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24) by Tricia Goyer

19. To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

By: Tricia Goyer

4.59

Format: 240 pages, Hardcover

Cheryl Cooper & Levi Miller will be wed in just a few days. But one thing after another crops up t… read more

Similar categories in Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
Cover of Tea Leaves & Legacies (Tearoom Mysteries, #27) by Susan Page Davis

20. Tea Leaves & Legacies (Tearoom Mysteries, #27)

By: Susan Page Davis

4.50

Format: 257 pages, Hardcover

Elaine gets word she is about to receive a small fortune, from her ex husband's aunt. She contacts … read more

Similar categories in Susan Page Davis's Tea Leaves & Legacies (Tearoom Mysteries, #27) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

Cover of When Angels Whisper (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #31) by Nancy Mehl

21. When Angels Whisper (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #31)

By: Nancy Mehl

4.31

Format: None pages, Paperback

It’s Christmastime in Sugarcreek and Cheryl Miller has a lot left to accomplish if she is going to … read more

Similar categories in Nancy Mehl's When Angels Whisper (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #31) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • amish fiction
Cover of In the Fullness of Time (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries) by Nancy Mehl

22. In the Fullness of Time (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries)

By: Nancy Mehl

4.58

Format: 236 pages, Kindle Edition

With each passing season in their first year of married life, Cheryl and Levi Miller find a fresh s… read more

Similar categories in Nancy Mehl's In the Fullness of Time (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

Cover of Cold Vengeance (Ryland & St. Clair, #3) by Nancy Mehl

23. Cold Vengeance (Ryland & St. Clair, #3)

By: Nancy Mehl

4.43

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

When a renowned crime podcaster vanishes without a trace, former FBI behavioral analysts turned pri… read more

Similar categories in Nancy Mehl's Cold Vengeance (Ryland & St. Clair, #3) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
Cover of The Protector (Mifflin County Mystery, #1) by Wanda E. Brunstetter

24. The Protector (Mifflin County Mystery, #1)

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.37

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

A Mysterious Disappearance Shakes an Amish Family’s Faith In book one of A Mifflin County Mystery s… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's The Protector (Mifflin County Mystery, #1) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

  • mystery
  • amish fiction
Cover of Tea and Promises by Susan Page Davis

25. Tea and Promises

By: Susan Page Davis

4.46

Format: 238 pages, Kindle Edition

Even as Jan puts the final touches on her wedding plans, mystery still swirls around the tearoom. W… read more

Similar categories in Susan Page Davis's Tea and Promises book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

Cover of In Too Deep (Tearoom Mysteries, #22) by Elizabeth Adams

26. In Too Deep (Tearoom Mysteries, #22)

By: Elizabeth Adams

4.53

Format: 262 pages, Hardcover

Jan agrees to chaperone the church youth groups overnight camping trip. The trip includes her grand… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Adams's In Too Deep (Tearoom Mysteries, #22) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

Cover of A Cup of Grace by Leslie Gould

27. A Cup of Grace

By: Leslie Gould

4.52

Format: 233 pages, Kindle Edition

Nathan is surprised by news that he has inherited a shuttered roadside attraction, the World’s Larg… read more

Similar categories in Leslie Gould's A Cup of Grace book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

Cover of A Dawn with the Wolf Knight by Elise Kova

28. A Dawn with the Wolf Knight

By: Elise Kova

3.88

Format: 398 pages, Hardcover

To enter the woods as a human means death… But I am no mere human. They call me, “witch." As on… read more

Similar categories in Elise Kova's A Dawn with the Wolf Knight book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

Cover of A Bitter Brew (Tearoom Mysteries, #26) by Elizabeth Ludwig

29. A Bitter Brew (Tearoom Mysteries, #26)

By: Elizabeth Ludwig

4.17

Format: 279 pages, Hardcover

"Jan and Elaine are thrilled when Jan is chosen to compete in the Traveling Baking Challenge. Not o… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Ludwig's A Bitter Brew (Tearoom Mysteries, #26) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

Cover of Turning the Tables (Tearoom Mysteries, #21) by Anne Marie Rodgers

30. Turning the Tables (Tearoom Mysteries, #21)

By: Anne Marie Rodgers

4.46

Format: 273 pages, Hardcover

State trooper Dan asks Elaine and Jan's help with a case. Dan's friend has been accused of embezzle… read more

Similar categories in Anne Marie Rodgers's Turning the Tables (Tearoom Mysteries, #21) book and Tricia Goyer's To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24)

9 Best amish fiction books like To Have and To Hold (Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries, #24) by Tricia Goyer

Transform Your Habits

The Teacher's Bride (Amish Brides of Birch Creek #1)

Kathleen Fuller

4.31

Transform Your Habits

Nursing Her Amish Neighbor (Brides of Lost Creek #6)

Marta Perry

4.62

Transform Your Habits

Secrets of the Amish Diary (Amish Inn Mysteries, #1)

Rachael O. Phillips

3.95

Transform Your Habits

Plain Deception (Amish Inn Mysteries, # 2)

Tara Randel

4.04

View all the books

15 must-read romance books like Nursing Her Amish Neighbor (Brides of Lost Creek #6) by Marta Perry

Transform Your Habits

An Amish Mother for His Twins (North Country Amish #6)

Patricia Davids

4.54

Transform Your Habits

Happily Ever Amish (The Amish of Apple Creek #1)

Shelley Shepard Gray

4.42

Transform Your Habits

Mistaken for His Amish Bride (North Country Amish #7)

Patricia Davids

4.56

Transform Your Habits

Foundation of Love (An Amish Legacy #1)

Amy Clipston

4.43

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.