16 best-selling fantasy books like Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1) by Gretchen Rue

Cover of Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1) by Gretchen Rue

Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

By: Gretchen Rue

3.49

Format: 304 pages, Kindle Edition

Recipe for a potion to demolish life as you know it: Step one: pack up your life and move to you…

If you liked the fantasy plot in Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1) by Gretchen Rue , here is a list of 16 books like this:

Cover of The Pumpkin Spice Café (Dream Harbor, #1) by Laurie Gilmore

1. The Pumpkin Spice Café (Dream Harbor, #1)

By: Laurie Gilmore

3.46

Format: 286 pages, Kindle Edition

A spicy small-town romance and TikTok phenomenon, perfect for fans of Hannah Grace and Stephanie Ar… read more

Similar categories in Laurie Gilmore's The Pumpkin Spice Café (Dream Harbor, #1) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • cozy mystery
  • halloween
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
"I've loved you since I saw how many tiny pumpkins you could carry in your arms."

-Laurie Gilmore, The Pumpkin Spice Café (Dream Harbor, #1)

Cover of The Spare Room by Laura Starkey

2. The Spare Room

By: Laura Starkey

3.61

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

Two unexpected flatmates. One shared space. Will they cross the line into love? Rosie had the pe… read more

Similar categories in Laura Starkey's The Spare Room book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Like a Charm  (Could It Be Magic #1) by Kerry  Barrett

3. Like a Charm (Could It Be Magic #1)

By: Kerry Barrett

3.19

Format: 215 pages, Paperback

Esme McLeod is a high-flying lawyer in London, but her life isn't as perfect as it might seem. She … read more

Similar categories in Kerry Barrett's Like a Charm (Could It Be Magic #1) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • halloween
  • fantasy
  • witches
  • paranormal
  • mystery
Cover of Spookily Yours (Witches of Pleasant Grove, #1) by Jennifer Chipman

4. Spookily Yours (Witches of Pleasant Grove, #1)

By: Jennifer Chipman

3.51

Format: 246 pages, Kindle Edition

My cat is a demon. No, that's not a joke. An actual, real life demon. And he needs my help to brea… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Chipman's Spookily Yours (Witches of Pleasant Grove, #1) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • halloween
  • fantasy
  • witches
  • paranormal
Cover of How to Fake-Date a Vampire (Charming Cove, #2) by Linsey Hall

5. How to Fake-Date a Vampire (Charming Cove, #2)

By: Linsey Hall

3.96

Format: 302 pages, Kindle Edition

Faking it with a vampire duke should be easy, right? I’ve got one chance to prove to my coven th… read more

Similar categories in Linsey Hall's How to Fake-Date a Vampire (Charming Cove, #2) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of My Roommate Is a Vampire by Jenna Levine

6. My Roommate Is a Vampire

By: Jenna Levine

3.47

Format: 341 pages, Paperback

True love is at stake in this charming, debut romantic comedy. Cassie Greenberg loves being an a… read more

Similar categories in Jenna Levine's My Roommate Is a Vampire book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • adult
  • paranormal
"My pots and pans are in the shop. Being repaired."

-Jenna Levine, My Roommate Is a Vampire

"And, yes, okay, he was a vampire. That did present some legitimate challenges. But that didn't change how good he was or the fact that I wanted him more than I'd ever wanted anyone in my life."

-Jenna Levine, My Roommate Is a Vampire

"I don't think there's anything particularly special about me at all." His jaw clenched. "Then please," he began, his voice hoarse and dripping with promise, " please allow me to show you how wrong yo…"

-Jenna Levine, My Roommate Is a Vampire

"Some vampires have impressive abilities like turning wine into blood, or being able to fly, or turning back time, he continued ruefully. Unfortunately, all I can do is somewhat involuntarily conjure …"

-Jenna Levine, My Roommate Is a Vampire

Cover of The Modern Girl's Guide to Magic (Charming Cove, #1) by Linsey Hall

7. The Modern Girl's Guide to Magic (Charming Cove, #1)

By: Linsey Hall

3.79

Format: 327 pages, Kindle Edition

So here’s the deal—I’m a magical disaster. A witch from a family of witches, and the only one whose… read more

Similar categories in Linsey Hall's The Modern Girl's Guide to Magic (Charming Cove, #1) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • halloween
  • fantasy
  • witches
  • adult
  • paranormal
"Callan?" Her voice was raspy as she looked up at my face. "What are you thinking?" "That you look like a sunrise after a decade of darkness."

-Linsey Hall, The Modern Girl's Guide to Magic (Charming Cove, #1)

Cover of A Demon's Guide to Wooing a Witch (Glimmer Falls, #2) by Sarah  Hawley

8. A Demon's Guide to Wooing a Witch (Glimmer Falls, #2)

By: Sarah Hawley

3.78

Format: 432 pages, Paperback

Calladia Cunnington curses the day she met Astaroth the demon, but when he shows up memoryless, why… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Hawley's A Demon's Guide to Wooing a Witch (Glimmer Falls, #2) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of The Kiss Curse (The Ex Hex, #2) by Erin Sterling

9. The Kiss Curse (The Ex Hex, #2)

By: Erin Sterling

3.78

Format: 309 pages, Paperback

Welcome to Spooky Season!! The follow-up to Erin Sterling’s New York Times bestselling hit The Ex H… read more

Similar categories in Erin Sterling's The Kiss Curse (The Ex Hex, #2) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • halloween
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • adult
  • paranormal
"Instead, Gwyn gestured around them and said, “Do you think we’re just picking up on bad vibes from this stuff? Because the vibes in here are definitely bad. Vibe check thoroughly failed."

-Erin Sterling, The Kiss Curse (The Ex Hex, #2)

"So Glinda was telling us how you’re trying to find out about someone getting kicked out of Penhaven, and I was telling her that I dated this girl who works in the records department. Her name was Sar…"

-Erin Sterling, The Kiss Curse (The Ex Hex, #2)

"I want all of you, too.' he told her. 'The powerful witch and the woman who loves nothing better than to take the piss out of me when I deserve it. The woman who inspires loyalty in talking cats and …"

-Erin Sterling, The Kiss Curse (The Ex Hex, #2)

"He wondered if he should share with her his suspicions about Morgan, but Gwyn and Morgan were clearly old friends. She’d probably just roll her eyes at him again and tell him he was being an idiot. A…"

-Erin Sterling, The Kiss Curse (The Ex Hex, #2)

Cover of The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1) by Sophie H. Morgan

10. The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1)

By: Sophie H. Morgan

3.57

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

Love is a hex of a thing. Former childhood sweethearts fake a relationship in this charming, witchy… read more

Similar categories in Sophie H. Morgan's The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • adult
  • paranormal
"Bastian cleared his throat. Looked off to the distance. "Moot point. Look, I get why she did what she did. But it's that she didn't tell me, even after we..." He stopped. "Made sweet, sweet love?" Et…"

-Sophie H. Morgan, The Witch Is Back (Toil and Trouble, #1)

Cover of Romance Rules for Werewolves (Charming Cove, #3) by Linsey Hall

11. Romance Rules for Werewolves (Charming Cove, #3)

By: Linsey Hall

4.17

Format: 276 pages, Kindle Edition

Autumn is a time of snuggly sweaters, crisp breezes, and…. sexy, broody werewolves?When I inherit a… read more

Similar categories in Linsey Hall's Romance Rules for Werewolves (Charming Cove, #3) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • witches
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Hex Appeal by Kate Johnson

12. Hex Appeal

By: Kate Johnson

3.49

Format: 318 pages, Kindle Edition

Encanto meets Hocus Pocus in this perfect witchy romcom. An absolute must-read if you love Erin Ste… read more

Similar categories in Kate Johnson's Hex Appeal book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • halloween
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • paranormal
Cover of Hex and the City by Kate Johnson

13. Hex and the City

By: Kate Johnson

3.54

Format: 385 pages, Kindle Edition

Things you should know about Poppy: 1. She’s a witch 2. She has magical hair like Rapunzel fr… read more

Similar categories in Kate Johnson's Hex and the City book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • halloween
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • paranormal
Cover of Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1) by Gretchen Rue

14. Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

By: Gretchen Rue

3.49

Format: 304 pages, Kindle Edition

Recipe for a potion to demolish life as you know it: Step one: pack up your life and move to you… read more

Similar categories in Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • adult
  • cozy mystery
  • halloween
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • supernatural
  • paranormal
  • mystery
Cover of Witch You Weren't Here by Emma  Jackson

15. Witch You Weren't Here

By: Emma Jackson

3.69

Format: 342 pages, Kindle Edition

One hurricane. Two stranded witches. Sparks are bound to fly... Kay knows three things to be a… read more

Similar categories in Emma Jackson's Witch You Weren't Here book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • witches
  • fantasy
Cover of Haunt Your Heart Out by Amber Roberts

16. Haunt Your Heart Out

By: Amber Roberts

3.61

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

A dashing ghost hunter and the bookseller who made up the ghosts he’s chasing wind up entangled in … read more

Similar categories in Amber Roberts's Haunt Your Heart Out book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • halloween
  • contemporary
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of The Midnight Village by Holly Martin

17. The Midnight Village

By: Holly Martin

4.16

Format: None pages, Paperback

A scoop of second chances and a dash of destiny are about to become the recipe for this year's most… read more

Similar categories in Holly Martin's The Midnight Village book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • paranormal
Cover of Rewitched by Lucy Jane Wood

18. Rewitched

By: Lucy Jane Wood

4.15

Format: 384 pages, Paperback

Belladonna Blackthorn hasn’t lost her magical spark . . . but she hasn’t seen it in a while, either… read more

Similar categories in Lucy Jane Wood's Rewitched book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • cozy mystery
  • halloween
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • adult
  • paranormal
  • mystery
Cover of The Cinnamon Bun Bookstore (Dream Harbor, #2) by Laurie Gilmore

19. The Cinnamon Bun Bookstore (Dream Harbor, #2)

By: Laurie Gilmore

3.93

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

From the author of the Sunday Times bestseller and viral TikTok phenomenon, The Pumpkin Spice Café,… read more

Similar categories in Laurie Gilmore's The Cinnamon Bun Bookstore (Dream Harbor, #2) book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • cozy mystery
  • halloween
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
Cover of Impractical Magic by Emily Grimoire

20. Impractical Magic

By: Emily Grimoire

3.11

Format: 335 pages, Kindle Edition

The perfect autumn read where Gilmore Girls meets Charmed in a cosy second-chance romance with a sp… read more

Similar categories in Emily Grimoire's Impractical Magic book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance
  • halloween
  • fantasy
  • contemporary
  • witches
  • paranormal
Cover of A Blend Of Magic by Kate Kenzie

21. A Blend Of Magic

By: Kate Kenzie

4.26

Format: 388 pages, Kindle Edition

A witch cannot exist on potions and tea alone. Hiding in the shadows, staunch singleton Willow A… read more

Similar categories in Kate Kenzie's A Blend Of Magic book and Gretchen Rue's Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1)

  • romance

15 Top contemporary books like Something Wicked (Phoebe Winchester Mystery, #1) by Gretchen Rue

Transform Your Habits

The Pumpkin Spice Café (Dream Harbor, #1)

Laurie Gilmore

3.46

Transform Your Habits

The Spare Room

Laura Starkey

3.61

Transform Your Habits

How to Fake-Date a Vampire (Charming Cove, #2)

Linsey Hall

3.96

Transform Your Habits

My Roommate Is a Vampire

Jenna Levine

3.47

View all the books

8 Best adult books like Romance Rules for Werewolves (Charming Cove, #3) by Linsey Hall

Transform Your Habits

Resting Witch Face (Stay a Spell, #5)

Juliette Cross

4.23

Transform Your Habits

Grim and Bear It (Stay a Spell, #6)

Juliette Cross

4.18

Transform Your Habits

Don't Hex and Drive (Stay a Spell, #2)

Juliette Cross

4.10

Transform Your Habits

Wolf Gone Wild (Stay a Spell, #1)

Juliette Cross

3.96

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.