10 Top paranormal books like Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2) by Nicole McKeon

Cover of Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2) by Nicole McKeon

Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

By: Nicole McKeon

4.47

Format: 341 pages, Kindle Edition

Gwenevere St. James may be a lady, but she’s never been interested in playing by the rules. Instead…

If you liked the paranormal plot in Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2) by Nicole McKeon , here is a list of 10 books like this:

Cover of The Fire in the Glass (The Charismatics, #1) by Jacquelyn Benson

1. The Fire in the Glass (The Charismatics, #1)

By: Jacquelyn Benson

4.26

Format: 498 pages, ebook

London, 1914. Lily’s visions could stop a killer… if she’ll trust a reclusive aristocrat with her d… read more

Similar categories in Jacquelyn Benson's The Fire in the Glass (The Charismatics, #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • historical
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Chosen (The Grey Gates, #5) by Vanessa  Nelson

2. Chosen (The Grey Gates, #5)

By: Vanessa Nelson

4.46

Format: 305 pages, Kindle Edition

Demons on the loose. Ritual murders. An ancient vampire breathing down her neck. Some days Max j… read more

Similar categories in Vanessa Nelson's Chosen (The Grey Gates, #5) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • magic
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of The Order of Blood and Ruin (Magic on Main Street #3) by K.M. Shea

3. The Order of Blood and Ruin (Magic on Main Street #3)

By: K.M. Shea

4.53

Format: 495 pages, Kindle Edition

They used to be enemies. Now they’re partners. I never imagined Considine Maledictus—one of the … read more

Similar categories in K.M. Shea's The Order of Blood and Ruin (Magic on Main Street #3) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • fae
  • magic
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Fair Market Value (The Body Shop, #1) by Hailey Edwards

4. Fair Market Value (The Body Shop, #1)

By: Hailey Edwards

4.39

Format: 266 pages, Kindle Edition

Forgot to feed your goldfish before your untimely demise? Need to jot down a will? Say a goodbye? S… read more

Similar categories in Hailey Edwards's Fair Market Value (The Body Shop, #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • magic
  • fantasy
Cover of Wormwood Abbey (The Secrets of Ormdale, #1) by Christina Baehr

5. Wormwood Abbey (The Secrets of Ormdale, #1)

By: Christina Baehr

4.28

Format: 208 pages, Kindle Edition

As a Victorian clergyman’s daughter, Edith Worms has seen everything — until a mythical salamander … read more

Similar categories in Christina Baehr's Wormwood Abbey (The Secrets of Ormdale, #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • historical
  • fantasy
Cover of Drake Hall (The Secrets of Ormdale, #2) by Christina Baehr

6. Drake Hall (The Secrets of Ormdale, #2)

By: Christina Baehr

4.42

Format: 203 pages, Kindle Edition

Edith’s ancient home is full of secrets…and dragons are the least of them. As the new dragon kee… read more

Similar categories in Christina Baehr's Drake Hall (The Secrets of Ormdale, #2) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • historical
  • fantasy
Cover of Lady Avely's Guide to Truth and Magic (Matronly Misadventures #1) by Rosalie Oaks

7. Lady Avely's Guide to Truth and Magic (Matronly Misadventures #1)

By: Rosalie Oaks

4.13

Format: 367 pages, Kindle Edition

A Regency widow shouldn’t be hunting spectres all night. Lady Judith Avely’s magical gift for d… read more

Similar categories in Rosalie Oaks's Lady Avely's Guide to Truth and Magic (Matronly Misadventures #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • historical
  • magic
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • fantasy
"Silence was often the best interrogation technique; something she had learned as a mother."

-Rosalie Oaks, Lady Avely's Guide to Truth and Magic (Matronly Misadventures #1)

Cover of Drinks and Sinkholes (The Weary Dragon Inn, #1) by S. Usher Evans

8. Drinks and Sinkholes (The Weary Dragon Inn, #1)

By: S. Usher Evans

3.80

Format: None pages, ebook

Bev may not know who she was before she showed up in the quaint village of Pigsend five years ago, … read more

Similar categories in S. Usher Evans's Drinks and Sinkholes (The Weary Dragon Inn, #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • magic
  • fantasy
Cover of Murder by Lamplight (Dr. Julia Lewis, #1) by Patrice McDonough

9. Murder by Lamplight (Dr. Julia Lewis, #1)

By: Patrice McDonough

4.08

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

In the twilight streets of Victorian London, a gruesome series of murders unfolds, and Dr. Julia Le… read more

Similar categories in Patrice McDonough's Murder by Lamplight (Dr. Julia Lewis, #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • historical
Cover of The Ward Witch (Unholy Island #1) by Sarah Painter

10. The Ward Witch (Unholy Island #1)

By: Sarah Painter

4.18

Format: 292 pages, Kindle Edition

Mysterious, magical, and a little bit deadly… Welcome to Unholy Island. Esme Gray runs the guest… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Painter's The Ward Witch (Unholy Island #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • magic
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Wrighting Old Wrongs (World Wrights Book 1) by Maria Grace

11. Wrighting Old Wrongs (World Wrights Book 1)

By: Maria Grace

4.44

Format: 361 pages, Kindle Edition

Controlling Fire, Earth, Water, and Air with a simple touch would have been much more impressive if… read more

Similar categories in Maria Grace's Wrighting Old Wrongs (World Wrights Book 1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • historical
  • magic
  • fantasy
Cover of A Matter of Secrets and Spies (The Case Files of Henri Davenforth, #10) by Honor Raconteur

12. A Matter of Secrets and Spies (The Case Files of Henri Davenforth, #10)

By: Honor Raconteur

4.36

Format: 223 pages, Kindle Edition

How many ways can a marriage proposal go wrong? One: the ring gets stolen Two: a storm destroys… read more

Similar categories in Honor Raconteur's A Matter of Secrets and Spies (The Case Files of Henri Davenforth, #10) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • steampunk
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2) by Sarah Painter

13. The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2)

By: Sarah Painter

4.43

Format: 292 pages, Kindle Edition

Mysterious, magical, and a little bit deadly... Welcome to Unholy Island. Luke Taylor was search… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Painter's The Book Keeper (Unholy Island, #2) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • magic
  • fantasy
Cover of The Witchwood Knot (Victorian Faerie Tales, #1) by Olivia Atwater

14. The Witchwood Knot (Victorian Faerie Tales, #1)

By: Olivia Atwater

4.16

Format: 330 pages, Kindle Edition

Olivia Atwater returns to the world of Half a Soul. Dive into The Witchwood Knot, and enjoy a dark … read more

Similar categories in Olivia Atwater's The Witchwood Knot (Victorian Faerie Tales, #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • historical
  • fantasy
  • fae
Cover of The Moria Pearls (Lady Diviner, #2) by Rosalie Oaks

15. The Moria Pearls (Lady Diviner, #2)

By: Rosalie Oaks

4.02

Format: 268 pages, Kindle Edition

A missing necklace, a murder, and an extra helping of plum pie... The magical Moria Pearls are … read more

Similar categories in Rosalie Oaks's The Moria Pearls (Lady Diviner, #2) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • historical
  • magic
  • fantasy
Cover of The Burning Witch 3 by Delemhach

16. The Burning Witch 3

By: Delemhach

4.64

Format: 475 pages, Kindle Edition

A young witch takes on burning new passions, simmering ancient grudges, and timeless magical mayhem… read more

Similar categories in Delemhach's The Burning Witch 3 book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • magic
  • fantasy
Cover of The Book of Secrets (The Last Oracle, #1) by Melissa McShane

17. The Book of Secrets (The Last Oracle, #1)

By: Melissa McShane

4.09

Format: 192 pages, Paperback

Helena Davies just wants a job that will get her out of her parents’ basement. Abernathy’s Bookstor… read more

Similar categories in Melissa McShane's The Book of Secrets (The Last Oracle, #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • magic
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Castle of the Winds (The Secrets of Ormdale, #3) by Christina Baehr

18. Castle of the Winds (The Secrets of Ormdale, #3)

By: Christina Baehr

4.50

Format: 260 pages, Kindle Edition

At Midsummer’s Eve, the Red Dragon will choose his bride. Following this mysterious invitation, … read more

Similar categories in Christina Baehr's Castle of the Winds (The Secrets of Ormdale, #3) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • historical
  • fantasy
Cover of Subversive (Clandestine Magic, #1) by Colleen Cowley

19. Subversive (Clandestine Magic, #1)

By: Colleen Cowley

4.08

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

In an America controlled by wizards and 100 years behind on women’s rights, Beatrix Harper counts h… read more

Similar categories in Colleen Cowley's Subversive (Clandestine Magic, #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • historical
  • magic
  • fantasy
Cover of Skullduggery (Thrill of the Hunt, #3) by Helen Harper

20. Skullduggery (Thrill of the Hunt, #3)

By: Helen Harper

4.44

Format: 296 pages, Kindle Edition

Okay. I’ll admit I’ve got problems. But surrender is word wholly absent from my vocabulary. My gra… read more

Similar categories in Helen Harper's Skullduggery (Thrill of the Hunt, #3) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • fae
  • magic
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Veils and Villains (The Weary Dragon Inn, #6) by S. Usher Evans

21. Veils and Villains (The Weary Dragon Inn, #6)

By: S. Usher Evans

4.21

Format: 298 pages, Kindle Edition

It's the wedding of the year in Pigsend, at least if you talk to Vicky Hamblin. The bride-to-be is … read more

Similar categories in S. Usher Evans's Veils and Villains (The Weary Dragon Inn, #6) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • fantasy
Cover of Beasts and Baking (The Weary Dragon Inn, #4) by S. Usher Evans

22. Beasts and Baking (The Weary Dragon Inn, #4)

By: S. Usher Evans

4.24

Format: 305 pages, Kindle Edition

Spring is on the horizon, and the Weary Dragon Inn is getting its annual deep clean. But before Bev… read more

Similar categories in S. Usher Evans's Beasts and Baking (The Weary Dragon Inn, #4) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • magic
  • fantasy
Cover of Magic and Molemen (The Weary Dragon Inn #5) by S. Usher Evans

23. Magic and Molemen (The Weary Dragon Inn #5)

By: S. Usher Evans

4.28

Format: 297 pages, Kindle Edition

Bev's on the hunt to understand her mysterious past, and that means a visit to her dear friend Merv… read more

Similar categories in S. Usher Evans's Magic and Molemen (The Weary Dragon Inn #5) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • fantasy
Cover of Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2) by Nicole McKeon

24. Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

By: Nicole McKeon

4.47

Format: 341 pages, Kindle Edition

Gwenevere St. James may be a lady, but she’s never been interested in playing by the rules. Instead… read more

Similar categories in Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • historical
  • magic
  • steampunk
  • paranormal
  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • fae
Cover of The Shadow of Water (The Charismatics, #2) by Jacquelyn Benson

25. The Shadow of Water (The Charismatics, #2)

By: Jacquelyn Benson

4.37

Format: 348 pages, Kindle Edition

Lily Albright can see the future, and it looks like hell. In an England on the brink of war, Li… read more

Similar categories in Jacquelyn Benson's The Shadow of Water (The Charismatics, #2) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • historical
  • fantasy
Cover of Empire of Shadows (Raiders of the Arcana, #1) by Jacquelyn Benson

26. Empire of Shadows (Raiders of the Arcana, #1)

By: Jacquelyn Benson

4.29

Format: 478 pages, Kindle Edition

Nice Victorian ladies don’t run off to find legendary lost cities. One trifling little arrest sh… read more

Similar categories in Jacquelyn Benson's Empire of Shadows (Raiders of the Arcana, #1) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • historical
  • fantasy
Cover of Fiends and Festivals (The Weary Dragon Inn, #2) by S. Usher Evans

27. Fiends and Festivals (The Weary Dragon Inn, #2)

By: S. Usher Evans

4.10

Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition

A cozy fantasy novel The Harvest Festival is the most-anticipated event in the quaint village of… read more

Similar categories in S. Usher Evans's Fiends and Festivals (The Weary Dragon Inn, #2) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • magic
  • fantasy
Cover of Bridge of Ash (The Charismatics, #3) by Jacquelyn Benson

28. Bridge of Ash (The Charismatics, #3)

By: Jacquelyn Benson

4.45

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

England's deadliest secrets are at risk—and so is the man Lily is about to marry. As World War I… read more

Similar categories in Jacquelyn Benson's Bridge of Ash (The Charismatics, #3) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • mystery
  • historical
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of What the Ravens Sing (The Charismatics #4) by Jacquelyn Benson

29. What the Ravens Sing (The Charismatics #4)

By: Jacquelyn Benson

4.51

Format: 482 pages, Kindle Edition

An arcane horror emerges from battle and blood. To stop it, Lily must risk becoming everything she … read more

Similar categories in Jacquelyn Benson's What the Ravens Sing (The Charismatics #4) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • historical
  • fantasy
Cover of City of Serpents (The Secrets of Ormdale, #4) by Christina Baehr

30. City of Serpents (The Secrets of Ormdale, #4)

By: Christina Baehr

4.49

Format: 308 pages, Kindle Edition

Edith is ready for the mad scientist and the snake-infested laboratory, but is she ready to admit s… read more

Similar categories in Christina Baehr's City of Serpents (The Secrets of Ormdale, #4) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • fantasy
Cover of Miss Percy's Definitive Guide to the Restoration of Dragons (Miss Percy Guide #3) by Quenby Olson

31. Miss Percy's Definitive Guide to the Restoration of Dragons (Miss Percy Guide #3)

By: Quenby Olson

4.61

Format: 445 pages, Kindle Edition

Miss Mildred Percy has no wish to go to London. Unfortunately, her niece, Belinda, has recently … read more

Similar categories in Quenby Olson's Miss Percy's Definitive Guide to the Restoration of Dragons (Miss Percy Guide #3) book and Nicole McKeon's Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2)

  • historical
  • fantasy

30 must-read fantasy books like Moonstruck (The Gwen St. James Affair #2) by Nicole McKeon

Transform Your Habits

The Fire in the Glass (The Charismatics, #1)

Jacquelyn Benson

4.26

Transform Your Habits

Chosen (The Grey Gates, #5)

Vanessa Nelson

4.46

Transform Your Habits

The Order of Blood and Ruin (Magic on Main Street #3)

K.M. Shea

4.53

Transform Your Habits

Fair Market Value (The Body Shop, #1)

Hailey Edwards

4.39

View all the books

21 must-read fantasy books like Chosen (The Grey Gates, #5) by Vanessa Nelson

Transform Your Habits

Chosen (The Grey Gates, #5)

Vanessa Nelson

4.46

Transform Your Habits

The Games of Enemies and Allies (Magic on Main Street, #2)

K.M. Shea

4.56

Transform Your Habits

The Lies of Vampires and Slayers (Magic on Main Street, #1)

K.M. Shea

4.39

Transform Your Habits

Vicious Creatures (The Waif in the Wilds, #1)

Lauretta Hignett

4.39

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.