31 best-selling romance books like If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3) by Sarah Sutton

Cover of If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3) by Sarah   Sutton

If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

By: Sarah Sutton

3.94

Format: 180 pages, Kindle Edition

HOW DO YOU MOVE ON FROM SOMEONE YOU NEVER FELL OUT OF LOVE WITH? I swear, I've got to be the onl…

If you liked the romance plot in If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3) by Sarah Sutton , here is a list of 31 books like this:

Cover of Adorkable by Cookie O'Gorman

1. Adorkable

By: Cookie O'Gorman

3.58

Format: 24 pages,

Adorkable (ah-dor-kuh-bul): Descriptive term meaning to be equal parts dorky and adorable. For refe… read more

Similar categories in Cookie O'Gorman's Adorkable book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Bookworm by Cookie O'Gorman

2. Bookworm

By: Cookie O'Gorman

4.12

Format: 395 pages, Kindle Edition

Bookworm (buk-werm): Someone who loves books, reading, and/or studying. For reference, see Charlott… read more

Similar categories in Cookie O'Gorman's Bookworm book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Sweetheart by Cookie O'Gorman

3. Sweetheart

By: Cookie O'Gorman

4.21

Format: 258 pages, Kindle Edition

Sweetheart (suh-weet-hart): Someone who is kind, friendly, and/or lovable. For reference, see Scar… read more

Similar categories in Cookie O'Gorman's Sweetheart book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Wallflower by Cookie O'Gorman

4. Wallflower

By: Cookie O'Gorman

4.09

Format: 197 pages, Kindle Edition

Wallflower (wohl-flou-erh): Identifier for someone who is shy and/or awkward. For reference, see V… read more

Similar categories in Cookie O'Gorman's Wallflower book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Fauxmance by Cookie O'Gorman

5. Fauxmance

By: Cookie O'Gorman

4.19

Format: 283 pages, Kindle Edition

Fauxmance (foh-mans): Term for a romantic relationship that is fake. Real feelings, like love, are… read more

Similar categories in Cookie O'Gorman's Fauxmance book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of The Only Boy Off Limits (Hallisburg Prep #3) by Emily Lowry

6. The Only Boy Off Limits (Hallisburg Prep #3)

By: Emily Lowry

4.13

Format: 221 pages, Kindle Edition

Get ready for Hallisburg Prep Book 3, Cruz and Avery's story, coming in 2022. read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's The Only Boy Off Limits (Hallisburg Prep #3) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult
Cover of Chase Jones Is My Fake Boyfriend (Rumors and Lies at Evermore High #1) by Emily Lowry

7. Chase Jones Is My Fake Boyfriend (Rumors and Lies at Evermore High #1)

By: Emily Lowry

3.95

Format: 214 pages, Kindle Edition

The All-Star Quarterback. A Fake Relationship. A Sweet and Unexpected Love. Abby Murrow is an in… read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's Chase Jones Is My Fake Boyfriend (Rumors and Lies at Evermore High #1) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of It Had to be Mason (Beachbreak High, #1) by Emily Lowry

8. It Had to be Mason (Beachbreak High, #1)

By: Emily Lowry

4.03

Format: 206 pages, Kindle Edition

Ask your brother’s best friend nicely, and he’ll teach you how to date. He might even teach you how… read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's It Had to be Mason (Beachbreak High, #1) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Dear McKinnon (Love Notes, #1) by Danielle Keil

9. Dear McKinnon (Love Notes, #1)

By: Danielle Keil

4.06

Format: 129 pages, Kindle Edition

Everyone knows what it means to have a teal envelope taped to their locker on the first day of the … read more

Similar categories in Danielle Keil's Dear McKinnon (Love Notes, #1) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Bad Boys Don’t Fall For Shy Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #3) by Emma  Dalton

10. Bad Boys Don’t Fall For Shy Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #3)

By: Emma Dalton

4.06

Format: 334 pages, Kindle Edition

Every shy girl deserves to be heard. I’m the Shy Girl and I’m obsessed with romance. I dream of … read more

Similar categories in Emma Dalton's Bad Boys Don’t Fall For Shy Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #3) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Quarterbacks Don’t Fall For Invisible Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #1) by Emma  Dalton

11. Quarterbacks Don’t Fall For Invisible Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #1)

By: Emma Dalton

3.68

Format: 271 pages, Kindle Edition

Every invisible girl deserves to be seen. I’m the Invisible Girl. No one at school knows I exist… read more

Similar categories in Emma Dalton's Quarterbacks Don’t Fall For Invisible Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #1) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Love Notes (Lakeview Prep #4) by Gracie Graham

12. Love Notes (Lakeview Prep #4)

By: Gracie Graham

3.87

Format: 235 pages, Kindle Edition

Spending time with my nemesis never felt so good. Carson Brooks has been my enemy since the day … read more

Similar categories in Gracie Graham's Love Notes (Lakeview Prep #4) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Boy I Love to Hate (Hallisburg Prep #1) by Emily Lowry

13. The Boy I Love to Hate (Hallisburg Prep #1)

By: Emily Lowry

3.94

Format: 246 pages, Kindle Edition

Everyone at Hallisburg Prep worships the ground Sutton Reilly walks on. Everyone except me. I ha… read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's The Boy I Love to Hate (Hallisburg Prep #1) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Charade (Eden Falls Academy #1) by Judy Corry

14. The Charade (Eden Falls Academy #1)

By: Judy Corry

3.74

Format: 402 pages, Kindle Edition

My math tutor has one rule: he doesn’t date the girls he tutors at our private school. But a fak… read more

Similar categories in Judy Corry's The Charade (Eden Falls Academy #1) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of The Ruse by Judy Corry

15. The Ruse

By: Judy Corry

4.13

Format: 424 pages, Paperback

What’s the first rule of getting the lead in the school musical? Don’t fall for your bad-boy co-sta… read more

Similar categories in Judy Corry's The Ruse book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Billionaires Don’t Fall For Awkward Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #2) by Emma  Dalton

16. Billionaires Don’t Fall For Awkward Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #2)

By: Emma Dalton

3.91

Format: 361 pages, Kindle Edition

Every awkward girl deserves a happily ever after. I’m the Awkward Girl, dirt-poor with an uncoor… read more

Similar categories in Emma Dalton's Billionaires Don’t Fall For Awkward Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #2) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Rebels Don’t Fall for Tomboys (Invisible Girls Club #5) by Emma  Dalton

17. Rebels Don’t Fall for Tomboys (Invisible Girls Club #5)

By: Emma Dalton

4.22

Format: 348 pages, Kindle Edition

Every tomboy deserves to score the guy of her dreams. Bailey: I’m the Tomboy. I’ve dreamed of p… read more

Similar categories in Emma Dalton's Rebels Don’t Fall for Tomboys (Invisible Girls Club #5) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult
Cover of The Boy Who Steals Hearts (Hallisburg Prep #2) by Emily Lowry

18. The Boy Who Steals Hearts (Hallisburg Prep #2)

By: Emily Lowry

4.24

Format: 252 pages, Kindle Edition

Every girl at Hallisburg Prep has a crush on Arie Jensen. But no one has a bigger crush than me.… read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's The Boy Who Steals Hearts (Hallisburg Prep #2) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Dear Kerri (Love Notes, #2) by Danielle Keil

19. Dear Kerri (Love Notes, #2)

By: Danielle Keil

4.14

Format: 135 pages, Kindle Edition

Everyone at Ryder High knows what it means to have a teal envelope taped to their locker on the fir… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Keil's Dear Kerri (Love Notes, #2) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3) by Sarah   Sutton

20. If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

By: Sarah Sutton

3.94

Format: 180 pages, Kindle Edition

HOW DO YOU MOVE ON FROM SOMEONE YOU NEVER FELL OUT OF LOVE WITH? I swear, I've got to be the onl… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult contemporary
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • holiday
  • young adult
  • halloween
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of The Tomboy (Covington Prep: The Girls We Love #1) by Kylie Key

21. The Tomboy (Covington Prep: The Girls We Love #1)

By: Kylie Key

4.14

Format: 222 pages, Kindle Edition

He wants to win her heart...but she's not looking for love MAX I have a major crush on...the … read more

Similar categories in Kylie Key's The Tomboy (Covington Prep: The Girls We Love #1) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
Cover of It Could Only Be Tyler (Beachbreak High #2) by Emily Lowry

22. It Could Only Be Tyler (Beachbreak High #2)

By: Emily Lowry

4.12

Format: 200 pages, Kindle Edition

Ask your best friend’s brother nicely, and he might agree to be your fake boyfriend. He might even … read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's It Could Only Be Tyler (Beachbreak High #2) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of My Fake Relationship With the Popular Boy (Bayshore Academy, #1) by Clara Nielsen

23. My Fake Relationship With the Popular Boy (Bayshore Academy, #1)

By: Clara Nielsen

3.83

Format: 330 pages, Paperback

WHO’S THE BEST PERSON TO FAKE DATE? THE ONE YOU KNOW YOU WILL NEVER FALL FOR… I feel like my l… read more

Similar categories in Clara Nielsen's My Fake Relationship With the Popular Boy (Bayshore Academy, #1) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
Cover of Best Friends Don’t Fall For Best Friends (Invisible Girls Club, #8) by Emma  Dalton

24. Best Friends Don’t Fall For Best Friends (Invisible Girls Club, #8)

By: Emma Dalton

4.19

Format: 394 pages, Kindle Edition

Chloe: I’m in love with my best friend Liam, but he just sees me as his buddy. I spend my days hop… read more

Similar categories in Emma Dalton's Best Friends Don’t Fall For Best Friends (Invisible Girls Club, #8) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult
Cover of Movie Stars Don’t Fall for Nerdy Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #4) by Emma  Dalton

25. Movie Stars Don’t Fall for Nerdy Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #4)

By: Emma Dalton

4.17

Format: 360 pages, Kindle Edition

Every nerdy girl deserves to be loved. I’m the Nerdy Girl and I don’t believe in romance. Everyo… read more

Similar categories in Emma Dalton's Movie Stars Don’t Fall for Nerdy Girls (Invisible Girls Club, #4) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Chemistry of a Kiss (Sweet Water High, #5) by Kimberly Krey

26. Chemistry of a Kiss (Sweet Water High, #5)

By: Kimberly Krey

4.04

Format: 180 pages, Kindle Edition

How did I end up in a fake relationship with the gorgeous captain of the basketball team, Jett Brya… read more

Similar categories in Kimberly Krey's Chemistry of a Kiss (Sweet Water High, #5) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Rich Girls Don’t Fall for Poor Boys (Invisible Girls Club, #7) by Emma  Dalton

27. Rich Girls Don’t Fall for Poor Boys (Invisible Girls Club, #7)

By: Emma Dalton

4.28

Format: 369 pages, Kindle Edition

Every rich girl deserves to follow her heart. I’m the Rich Girl and my life is practically perfe… read more

Similar categories in Emma Dalton's Rich Girls Don’t Fall for Poor Boys (Invisible Girls Club, #7) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of It Was Always Jace (Beachbreak High #3) by Emily Lowry

28. It Was Always Jace (Beachbreak High #3)

By: Emily Lowry

4.25

Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition

Ask your best friend nicely, and he might become your personal tutor. He might even turn into somet… read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's It Was Always Jace (Beachbreak High #3) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • clean romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of It Was Still Asher (Beachbreak High #4) by Emily Lowry

29. It Was Still Asher (Beachbreak High #4)

By: Emily Lowry

4.24

Format: 222 pages, Kindle Edition

Ask your ex-boyfriend nicely, and he’ll help you chase your dreams. He might even convince you he d… read more

Similar categories in Emily Lowry's It Was Still Asher (Beachbreak High #4) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Dear Spencer (Love Notes, #4) by Danielle Keil

30. Dear Spencer (Love Notes, #4)

By: Danielle Keil

4.11

Format: 143 pages, Kindle Edition

Everyone at Ryder High knows what it means to have a teal envelope taped to their locker on the fir… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Keil's Dear Spencer (Love Notes, #4) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult
Cover of Enemies Don't Fall For Enemies (Invisible Girls Club, #10) by Emma  Dalton

31. Enemies Don't Fall For Enemies (Invisible Girls Club, #10)

By: Emma Dalton

4.20

Format: 395 pages, Kindle Edition

Even sworn enemies can fall in love. Noah Barrington is the most irritating guy on the planet. He… read more

Similar categories in Emma Dalton's Enemies Don't Fall For Enemies (Invisible Girls Club, #10) book and Sarah Sutton's If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3)

  • romance
  • young adult

7 Top fiction books like If the Broom Fits (Love in Fenton County, #3) by Sarah Sutton

Transform Your Habits

Bookworm

Cookie O'Gorman

4.12

Transform Your Habits

Sweetheart

Cookie O'Gorman

4.21

Transform Your Habits

Fauxmance

Cookie O'Gorman

4.19

Transform Your Habits

Dear McKinnon (Love Notes, #1)

Danielle Keil

4.06

View all the books

12 must-read fiction books like Sweetheart by Cookie O'Gorman

Transform Your Habits

Dreaming About the Boy Next Door (Most Likely To #2)

Sarah Sutton

4.15

Transform Your Habits

Sweetheart

Cookie O'Gorman

4.21

Transform Your Habits

Lonely Hearts Day

Kasie West

4.01

Transform Your Habits

The Tomboy and The Captain (The Final Score #1)

Ginger Scott

3.94

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.