8 must-read cozy mystery books like Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5) by Elizabeth Pantley

Cover of Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5) by Elizabeth Pantley

Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

By: Elizabeth Pantley

4.41

Format: 225 pages, Kindle Edition

Would you join a book club that gets sucked into their cozy mysteries? These people did, and now th…

If you liked the cozy mystery plot in Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5) by Elizabeth Pantley , here is a list of 8 books like this:

Cover of Love at First Blizzard (Rough & Ready Country #1) by Engrid Eaves

1. Love at First Blizzard (Rough & Ready Country #1)

By: Engrid Eaves

4.28

Format: 100 pages, Kindle Edition

This grumpy mountain man is her savior … until he demands complete surrender! Maksim During a f… read more

Similar categories in Engrid Eaves's Love at First Blizzard (Rough & Ready Country #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of A Smoking Bun (A Bakeshop Mystery, #18) by Ellie Alexander

2. A Smoking Bun (A Bakeshop Mystery, #18)

By: Ellie Alexander

4.05

Format: 336 pages, ebook

Another delicious installment in the Bakeshop Series set in Ashland, OR!The mountains are calling i… read more

Similar categories in Ellie Alexander's A Smoking Bun (A Bakeshop Mystery, #18) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Madame Pommery, Creator of Brut Champagne by Rebecca Rosenberg

3. Madame Pommery, Creator of Brut Champagne

By: Rebecca Rosenberg

4.43

Format: 368 pages, Kindle Edition

Champagne, France, 1860. Madame Pommery, an etiquette teacher and orphanage founder, loses her husb… read more

Similar categories in Rebecca Rosenberg's Madame Pommery, Creator of Brut Champagne book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of Bound in Crimson (Blood Oath #1) by J.A.  Carter

4. Bound in Crimson (Blood Oath #1)

By: J.A. Carter

3.71

Format: 220 pages, Kindle Edition

I should hate them, yet there’s no denying my body reacts to their every touch. When my ancestor… read more

Similar categories in J.A. Carter's Bound in Crimson (Blood Oath #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • paranormal
Cover of Not Your Child by Lis Angus

5. Not Your Child

By: Lis Angus

4.08

Format: None pages, Nook

Ottawa psychologist and single mother Susan Koss discovers that a strange man has been following he… read more

Similar categories in Lis Angus's Not Your Child book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
Cover of The Executed Executive (Nosy Parkers Mysteries Book 4) by Gena Webb

6. The Executed Executive (Nosy Parkers Mysteries Book 4)

By: Gena Webb

4.25

Format: 294 pages, Kindle Edition

Mary Wright is living a predictable life as a secretary in San Antonio, Texas. But when her boss is… read more

Similar categories in Gena Webb's The Executed Executive (Nosy Parkers Mysteries Book 4) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
Cover of Hour is Come (A Dotty Sayers Antique Mystery, #0.5) by Victoria Tait

7. Hour is Come (A Dotty Sayers Antique Mystery, #0.5)

By: Victoria Tait

4.14

Format: 240 pages, ebook

HOUR IS COME IS ONLY AVAILABLE TO READERS WHO JOIN MY MAILING LIST. Visit VictoriaTait.com A de… read more

Similar categories in Victoria Tait's Hour is Come (A Dotty Sayers Antique Mystery, #0.5) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Demi Mondaine: Volume One by N.R. Mayfield

8. Demi Mondaine: Volume One

By: N.R. Mayfield

3.63

Format: 290 pages, Kindle Edition

Life at the fringe of society was all Demi had hoped for after her years of military service yielde… read more

Similar categories in N.R. Mayfield's Demi Mondaine: Volume One book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of The Prism Society: A Spicy Friends to Lovers Novel (Prism Society, #1) by Gabi Salas

9. The Prism Society: A Spicy Friends to Lovers Novel (Prism Society, #1)

By: Gabi Salas

3.87

Format: 330 pages, Kindle Edition

The boy next door is about to up-end my life. Fresh off the college graduation stage, Emma Sincl… read more

Similar categories in Gabi Salas's The Prism Society: A Spicy Friends to Lovers Novel (Prism Society, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of The Misery House (The House on the Hill, #1) by David Duane Kummer

10. The Misery House (The House on the Hill, #1)

By: David Duane Kummer

4.11

Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes the quietest little towns are haunted by the darkest secrets. A psychological thriller a… read more

Similar categories in David Duane Kummer's The Misery House (The House on the Hill, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5) by Elizabeth Pantley

11. Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

By: Elizabeth Pantley

4.41

Format: 225 pages, Kindle Edition

Would you join a book club that gets sucked into their cozy mysteries? These people did, and now th… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of Extinction of All Children by L.J. Epps

12. Extinction of All Children

By: L.J. Epps

3.65

Format: None pages, ebook

A young adult, fantasy novel about a teenager who is the last eighteen-year-old in her territory. T… read more

Similar categories in L.J. Epps's Extinction of All Children book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of What Used to be Texas (What Used to Be, #1) by Maira Dawn

13. What Used to be Texas (What Used to Be, #1)

By: Maira Dawn

4.43

Format: 257 pages, Kindle Edition

Every day is a battle to survive. It’s been five years since The Fall. During that time, sixteen… read more

Similar categories in Maira Dawn's What Used to be Texas (What Used to Be, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of Fighting Her Touch (Healing Hearts Book 2) by M.T. Cassen

14. Fighting Her Touch (Healing Hearts Book 2)

By: M.T. Cassen

4.04

Format: 234 pages, Kindle Edition

ASIN B0B5B6RVWM moved to the more recent edition The future is fully mapped for a young new nurs… read more

Similar categories in M.T. Cassen's Fighting Her Touch (Healing Hearts Book 2) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of Fez Up (Kasey McCormick Mysteries, #1) by Bonnie Cavaliere

15. Fez Up (Kasey McCormick Mysteries, #1)

By: Bonnie Cavaliere

4.30

Format: 139 pages, Paperback

A valuable script is missing… and with it a lot of hopes and dreams. People’s #1 fear is public … read more

Similar categories in Bonnie Cavaliere's Fez Up (Kasey McCormick Mysteries, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of A Year in the Life of Leah Brand by Lucinda E. Clarke

16. A Year in the Life of Leah Brand

By: Lucinda E. Clarke

3.80

Format: 313 pages, Kindle Edition

Leah’s nightmare began the day the dog died. A few years earlier a fatal car crash took the lives … read more

Similar categories in Lucinda E. Clarke's A Year in the Life of Leah Brand book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of One Inner Voice (Alamo City Mystery Book 1) by Kay Wyont

17. One Inner Voice (Alamo City Mystery Book 1)

By: Kay Wyont

3.93

Format: 262 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes, the High and Mighty need to be taken down a peg or two. Everyone should have a purpose, … read more

Similar categories in Kay Wyont's One Inner Voice (Alamo City Mystery Book 1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
Cover of The Witch Club (Scottish Witches Mysteries #1) by Felicity  Green

18. The Witch Club (Scottish Witches Mysteries #1)

By: Felicity Green

4.35

Format: 251 pages, Kindle Edition

A creepy inn. Missing men. When only her new employee believes her, can she foil a pagan plot befor… read more

Similar categories in Felicity Green's The Witch Club (Scottish Witches Mysteries #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • paranormal
Cover of Gunther (My Pet Werewolf) by James  Kaine

19. Gunther (My Pet Werewolf)

By: James Kaine

4.39

Format: 128 pages, Kindle Edition

When a man sworn to save lives is transformed into a murderous monster, will he be able to stop him… read more

Similar categories in James Kaine's Gunther (My Pet Werewolf) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of Dead Lake (Tricky's Tales, #1) by Miranda Kate

20. Dead Lake (Tricky's Tales, #1)

By: Miranda Kate

4.25

Format: 189 pages, Paperback

Sometimes it pays to be tricky Damn and blast! That rancid piece of excrement, Carter, has had h… read more

Similar categories in Miranda Kate's Dead Lake (Tricky's Tales, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of Iced (Resort to Murder Mystery, #1) by Avery Daniels

21. Iced (Resort to Murder Mystery, #1)

By: Avery Daniels

4.06

Format: 236 pages, Kindle Edition

***NEWLY EDITED*** Julienne has her ideal job as an event planner at a prestigious resort. During a… read more

Similar categories in Avery Daniels's Iced (Resort to Murder Mystery, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of From Death to Dawn (Hallowed Ground, #1) by Chele Cooke

22. From Death to Dawn (Hallowed Ground, #1)

By: Chele Cooke

4.09

Format: 492 pages, Kindle Edition

Strange powers. Mysterious creatures. Necromancers with a deadly vendetta. Can she survive the worl… read more

Similar categories in Chele Cooke's From Death to Dawn (Hallowed Ground, #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of A Very Woodsy Murder by Ellen Byron

23. A Very Woodsy Murder

By: Ellen Byron

3.95

Format: 288 pages, Hardcover

New motel owner Dee Stern has checked out of the familiar comforts in the San Fernando Valley and c… read more

Similar categories in Ellen Byron's A Very Woodsy Murder book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Moon Kissed (Alpha Seeker #1) by Lela Grayce

24. Moon Kissed (Alpha Seeker #1)

By: Lela Grayce

3.91

Format: 226 pages, Kindle Edition

Can she find her mate and save her people from extinction? PearlChosen in secret to be the Alpha Se… read more

Similar categories in Lela Grayce's Moon Kissed (Alpha Seeker #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • paranormal
Cover of Reading Between the Lies (Survivor's Book Club Mystery, #4) by Lynn Cahoon

25. Reading Between the Lies (Survivor's Book Club Mystery, #4)

By: Lynn Cahoon

4.12

Format: 201 pages, Paperback

Bookshop owner Rarity Cole is living her best life after surviving cancer—hosting book clubs, class… read more

Similar categories in Lynn Cahoon's Reading Between the Lies (Survivor's Book Club Mystery, #4) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Mystery in the Margins (Havenwood #1) by L.L. Gray

26. The Mystery in the Margins (Havenwood #1)

By: L.L. Gray

4.55

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

A quaint bookshop, a sprinkle of magic, and a dash of mystery.Harper Sullivan yearns for a place to… read more

Similar categories in L.L. Gray's The Mystery in the Margins (Havenwood #1) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Twisted Fates: Unearthly Lessons in Darkness by J.P. Alters

27. The Twisted Fates: Unearthly Lessons in Darkness

By: J.P. Alters

3.70

Format: 118 pages, Kindle Edition

The Twisted Unearthly Lessons in Darkness Venture into the realm of the mysterious and macabre,… read more

Similar categories in J.P. Alters's The Twisted Fates: Unearthly Lessons in Darkness book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of I Am: Legends Chronicles Reverse Harem Book One by Sophia Florenza

28. I Am: Legends Chronicles Reverse Harem Book One

By: Sophia Florenza

3.59

Format: 216 pages, Kindle Edition

This story is a mashup with the book and movies "The Last Unicorn" and "Legend" (The one with Tom C… read more

Similar categories in Sophia Florenza's I Am: Legends Chronicles Reverse Harem Book One book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of They Will Kill You Next: A gripping thriller that keeps you guessing until the end (a box set) (Detective David Hudson Thrillers Book 3) by Tim Kizer

29. They Will Kill You Next: A gripping thriller that keeps you guessing until the end (a box set) (Detective David Hudson Thrillers Book 3)

By: Tim Kizer

3.62

Format: 575 pages, Kindle Edition

Four years ago, a plane disappeared without a trace. Now someone is killing those who know what hap… read more

Similar categories in Tim Kizer's They Will Kill You Next: A gripping thriller that keeps you guessing until the end (a box set) (Detective David Hudson Thrillers Book 3) book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of A Rose in Winter: Mail Order Mountain Brides Book One by Penny Kate

30. A Rose in Winter: Mail Order Mountain Brides Book One

By: Penny Kate

4.27

Format: 125 pages, Kindle Edition

This Beauty and the Beast retelling spins a new tale in the rustic mountains of the Old West. A … read more

Similar categories in Penny Kate's A Rose in Winter: Mail Order Mountain Brides Book One book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

Cover of Crimson Reign by Victor S. Deane

31. Crimson Reign

By: Victor S. Deane

3.91

Format: 265 pages, Kindle Edition

The Light Can't Save You...The abduction was the first sign. He didn't believe. Now he has the gods… read more

Similar categories in Victor S. Deane's Crimson Reign book and Elizabeth Pantley's Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5)

11 Best mystery books like Hexes and Hooligans (Magical Mystery Book Club #6.5) by Elizabeth Pantley

Transform Your Habits

A Smoking Bun (A Bakeshop Mystery, #18)

Ellie Alexander

4.05

Transform Your Habits

Not Your Child

Lis Angus

4.08

Transform Your Habits

The Executed Executive (Nosy Parkers Mysteries Book 4)

Gena Webb

4.25

Transform Your Habits

Hour is Come (A Dotty Sayers Antique Mystery, #0.5)

Victoria Tait

4.14

View all the books

27 Best fiction books like A Very Woodsy Murder by Ellen Byron

Transform Your Habits

The Diva Goes Overboard (A Domestic Diva Mystery, #17)

Krista Davis

4.33

Transform Your Habits

Between a Flock and a Hard Place (Meg Langslow, #35)

Donna Andrews

4.41

Transform Your Habits

The Witless Protection Program (Catering Hall Mystery #5)

Maria DiRico

4.11

Transform Your Habits

Olive You to Death (A Tourist Trap Mystery, #16)

Lynn Cahoon

4.27

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.