26 must-read amish books like Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3) by Rebecca Kertz

Cover of Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3) by Rebecca Kertz

Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

By: Rebecca Kertz

4.17

Format: 224 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Can she forgive and forget--and fall in love?A Women of Lancaster County StoryLeah Stoltzfus hasn't…

If you liked the amish plot in Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3) by Rebecca Kertz , here is a list of 26 books like this:

Cover of Wonderful Lonesome (Amish Turns of Time #1) by Olivia Newport

1. Wonderful Lonesome (Amish Turns of Time #1)

By: Olivia Newport

3.97

Format: 323 pages, Kindle Edition

In a struggling Amish settlement on the harsh Colorado plain, Abbie Weaver refuses to concede defea… read more

Similar categories in Olivia Newport's Wonderful Lonesome (Amish Turns of Time #1) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of Meek and Mild (Amish Turns of Time #2) by Olivia Newport

2. Meek and Mild (Amish Turns of Time #2)

By: Olivia Newport

4.23

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

The leadership in an Old Order Amish community requires shunning friends and family whose only offe… read more

Similar categories in Olivia Newport's Meek and Mild (Amish Turns of Time #2) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of Brightest and Best (Amish Turns of Time #3) by Olivia Newport

3. Brightest and Best (Amish Turns of Time #3)

By: Olivia Newport

3.16

Format: 288 pages, Paperback

The collapse of a schoolhouse puts pressure on Amish families and their long-held educational value… read more

Similar categories in Olivia Newport's Brightest and Best (Amish Turns of Time #3) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of Snowfall (Days of Redemption #3.5) by Shelley Shepard Gray

4. Snowfall (Days of Redemption #3.5)

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.04

Format: 368 pages, ebook

New York Timesbestselling author Shelley Shepard Gray spins a beautiful holiday tale of finding lov… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's Snowfall (Days of Redemption #3.5) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish

5. Summerhill Secrets, Volume 1 (Summerhill Secrets, #1-5)

By: Beverly Lewis

4.06

Format: 340 pages, Paperback

Set in rural Pennsylvania's Amish country, SummerHill Secrets follows the true-to-life struggles an… read more

Similar categories in Beverly Lewis's Summerhill Secrets, Volume 1 (Summerhill Secrets, #1-5) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

Cover of Just Once by Karen Kingsbury

6. Just Once

By: Karen Kingsbury

4.40

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

The #1 New York Times bestselling author “known for her deeply heartfelt novels” (Woman’s World) wr… read more

Similar categories in Karen Kingsbury's Just Once book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

Cover of Fairest of Heart (Texas Ever After, #1) by Karen Witemeyer

7. Fairest of Heart (Texas Ever After, #1)

By: Karen Witemeyer

4.29

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

Beauty has been nothing but a curse to Penelope Snow. When she becomes a personal maid for a famous… read more

Similar categories in Karen Witemeyer's Fairest of Heart (Texas Ever After, #1) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

"You don't have to earn your place here, Penelope," he'd said. "This is your home now. You're one of us, and we take care of our own."

-Karen Witemeyer, Fairest of Heart (Texas Ever After, #1)

"She cold dance with butterflies all she liked. That wouldn't stop him from clipping her wings if that's what it took to see justice done."

-Karen Witemeyer, Fairest of Heart (Texas Ever After, #1)

"She could dance with butterflies all she liked. That wouldn't stop him from clipping her wings if that's what it took to see justice done."

-Karen Witemeyer, Fairest of Heart (Texas Ever After, #1)

"In all the daydreams she’d woven about her and Titus sharing intimate conversations, never once did they entail discussing corset burglary."

-Karen Witemeyer, Fairest of Heart (Texas Ever After, #1)

Cover of Piecing It All Together (Plain Patterns, #1) by Leslie Gould

8. Piecing It All Together (Plain Patterns, #1)

By: Leslie Gould

4.28

Format: 365 pages, Paperback

When Savannah Mast's fiance dumps her a week before their wedding, she flees California for the saf… read more

Similar categories in Leslie Gould's Piecing It All Together (Plain Patterns, #1) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of Shelter from the Storm (North Country Amish #2) by Patricia Davids

9. Shelter from the Storm (North Country Amish #2)

By: Patricia Davids

4.45

Format: 179 pages, Kindle Edition

An Amish marriage of convenienceA new North Country Amish novelSecretly pregnant and unwed, Gemma L… read more

Similar categories in Patricia Davids's Shelter from the Storm (North Country Amish #2) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of An Amish Christmas Star by Shelley Shepard Gray

10. An Amish Christmas Star

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.34

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

The crisp fragrance of pine trees and the warm spice of fresh cookies aren’t the only blessings tha… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's An Amish Christmas Star book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of Sisters by the Sea by Wanda E. Brunstetter

11. Sisters by the Sea

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.27

Format: 401 pages, Kindle Edition

Four Amish Sisters Develop New Beginnings in Sarasota, Florida   Journey with the bestselling Bru… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's Sisters by the Sea book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of Amish Outsider (River Haven, #1) by Marta Perry

12. Amish Outsider (River Haven, #1)

By: Marta Perry

4.32

Format: 316 pages, Kindle Edition

The Amish of River Haven offer sanctuary and solace…even to those with a dangerous past.In the wake… read more

Similar categories in Marta Perry's Amish Outsider (River Haven, #1) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of Hiding Her Amish Secret (The Amish of New Hope #1) by Carrie Lighte

13. Hiding Her Amish Secret (The Amish of New Hope #1)

By: Carrie Lighte

4.34

Format: 208 pages, Kindle Edition

Forgiveness for her past could change her future… The guilt of her past weighs heavy… Can love s… read more

Similar categories in Carrie Lighte's Hiding Her Amish Secret (The Amish of New Hope #1) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of The Amish Suitor (Amish Spinster Club #1) by Jo Ann Brown

14. The Amish Suitor (Amish Spinster Club #1)

By: Jo Ann Brown

4.14

Format: 288 pages, Mass Market Paperback

A Family Comes Courting… The Amish Spinster Club series begins! With his orphaned nephew depe… read more

Similar categories in Jo Ann Brown's The Amish Suitor (Amish Spinster Club #1) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of A Secret Amish Crush (Brides of Lost Creek #5) by Marta Perry

15. A Secret Amish Crush (Brides of Lost Creek #5)

By: Marta Perry

4.38

Format: 202 pages, Kindle Edition

A second chance at her first love?A man from her past. A heartbroken child.Could she be their answe… read more

Similar categories in Marta Perry's A Secret Amish Crush (Brides of Lost Creek #5) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of The Wedding Quilt Bride (Brides of Lost Creek #2) by Marta Perry

16. The Wedding Quilt Bride (Brides of Lost Creek #2)

By: Marta Perry

4.41

Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition

It’s a single mom’s second chance to become a bride in this heartwarming romance by bestselling aut… read more

Similar categories in Marta Perry's The Wedding Quilt Bride (Brides of Lost Creek #2) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of Courting His Amish Wife by Emma  Miller

17. Courting His Amish Wife

By: Emma Miller

4.48

Format: 207 pages, Kindle Edition

He offers her his hand, but will she ever take his heart? When Levi Miller learns Eve Summy w… read more

Similar categories in Emma Miller's Courting His Amish Wife book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of A Nanny for the Rancher's Twins by Heidi Main

18. A Nanny for the Rancher's Twins

By: Heidi Main

4.34

Format: 224 pages, ebook

Returning to small-town Texas was her fresh start. She never expected a ready-made family. What cou… read more

Similar categories in Heidi Main's A Nanny for the Rancher's Twins book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • love inspired
Cover of Second Chance Christmas by Betsy St. Amant

19. Second Chance Christmas

By: Betsy St. Amant

4.36

Format: 224 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Holiday wishes can come true… If they work together. Charlie Bussey is ready to fight the corpora… read more

Similar categories in Betsy St. Amant's Second Chance Christmas book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

Cover of Strength in the Storm (Johns Mill Amish Romance #2) by Laurel Blount

20. Strength in the Storm (Johns Mill Amish Romance #2)

By: Laurel Blount

4.64

Format: 326 pages, Mass Market Paperback

In this touching Amish romance, a brokenhearted woman and a steadfast man discover that the safest … read more

Similar categories in Laurel Blount's Strength in the Storm (Johns Mill Amish Romance #2) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of Their Make-Believe Match by Jackie Stef

21. Their Make-Believe Match

By: Jackie Stef

4.52

Format: 224 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Their pretend relationship… Is becoming all too real Irrepressible Sadie Stolzfus refuses to wed s… read more

Similar categories in Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of An Amish Wife for Christmas (North Country Amish #1) by Patricia Davids

22. An Amish Wife for Christmas (North Country Amish #1)

By: Patricia Davids

4.32

Format: 192 pages, Kindle Edition

Will marriage save her family?Christmas with the North Country AmishBethany Martin has until Christ… read more

Similar categories in Patricia Davids's An Amish Wife for Christmas (North Country Amish #1) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of The Amish Teacher's Dilemma (North Country Amish #3) by Patricia Davids

23. The Amish Teacher's Dilemma (North Country Amish #3)

By: Patricia Davids

4.47

Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition

The teacher next door could be the mother they need…Will she return to her old life…or risk everyth… read more

Similar categories in Patricia Davids's The Amish Teacher's Dilemma (North Country Amish #3) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of Shelter in the Storm (Johns Mill Amish Romance #1) by Laurel Blount

24. Shelter in the Storm (Johns Mill Amish Romance #1)

By: Laurel Blount

4.62

Format: 336 pages, Mass Market Paperback

In this moving Amish romance, two broken hearts find hope in each other after a terrible loss. U… read more

Similar categories in Laurel Blount's Shelter in the Storm (Johns Mill Amish Romance #1) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3) by Rebecca Kertz

25. Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

By: Rebecca Kertz

4.17

Format: 224 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Can she forgive and forget--and fall in love?A Women of Lancaster County StoryLeah Stoltzfus hasn't… read more

Similar categories in Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of Romancing Nadine (Wells Landing #10) by Amy Lillard

26. Romancing Nadine (Wells Landing #10)

By: Amy Lillard

4.39

Format: 305 pages, Kindle Edition

In this heartwarming series from Amy Lillard, three generations of women find the Oklahoma Amish co… read more

Similar categories in Amy Lillard's Romancing Nadine (Wells Landing #10) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of The Brides of the Big Valley by Wanda E. Brunstetter

27. The Brides of the Big Valley

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.26

Format: 448 pages, Paperback

3 Short Stories of Love in a Unique Amish Community--Now a #1 Publishers Weekly Bestseller!   In an… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's The Brides of the Big Valley book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
Cover of Amish Triplets for Christmas (Love Inspired) by Carrie Lighte

28. Amish Triplets for Christmas (Love Inspired)

By: Carrie Lighte

4.20

Format: 288 pages, Mass Market Paperback

The Widower’s Christmas Gift Widowed father of triplets Sawyer Plank knows he has his hands full… read more

Similar categories in Carrie Lighte's Amish Triplets for Christmas (Love Inspired) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of Her New Amish Family (Amish Country Courtships #4) by Carrie Lighte

29. Her New Amish Family (Amish Country Courtships #4)

By: Carrie Lighte

4.26

Format: 224 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Neighbors who are worlds apart… Opposites attract in Amish Country Courtships Widower Seth Helmut… read more

Similar categories in Carrie Lighte's Her New Amish Family (Amish Country Courtships #4) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of Courting Her Amish Heart (Prodigal Daughters #1) by Mary   Davis

30. Courting Her Amish Heart (Prodigal Daughters #1)

By: Mary Davis

4.28

Format: 224 pages, Mass Market Paperback

A doctor or an Amish wife? She can choose to be only one… In this first book of the Prodigal Dau… read more

Similar categories in Mary Davis's Courting Her Amish Heart (Prodigal Daughters #1) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish
  • love inspired
Cover of Gift from Above (Sisters & Friends #3) by Rachel J. Good

31. Gift from Above (Sisters & Friends #3)

By: Rachel J. Good

4.47

Format: 242 pages, Kindle Edition

Sarah Esh's peaceful life turns upside down one afternoon when a parachutist crash-lands on her fam… read more

Similar categories in Rachel J. Good's Gift from Above (Sisters & Friends #3) book and Rebecca Kertz's Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3)

  • amish fiction
  • amish

14 best-selling love inspired books like Her Forgiving Amish Heart (Women of Lancaster County #3) by Rebecca Kertz

Transform Your Habits

Shelter from the Storm (North Country Amish #2)

Patricia Davids

4.45

Transform Your Habits

Hiding Her Amish Secret (The Amish of New Hope #1)

Carrie Lighte

4.34

Transform Your Habits

The Amish Suitor (Amish Spinster Club #1)

Jo Ann Brown

4.14

Transform Your Habits

A Secret Amish Crush (Brides of Lost Creek #5)

Marta Perry

4.38

View all the books

26 Best romance books like Shelter in the Storm (Johns Mill Amish Romance #1) by Laurel Blount

Transform Your Habits

A Winter by the Sea (On Devonshire Shores, #2)

Julie Klassen

4.21

Transform Your Habits

Orchard

Lewis

4.38

Transform Your Habits

The Heirloom

Beverly Lewis

4.37

Transform Your Habits

Once Upon a Buggy (The Amish of Apple Creek #2)

Shelley Shepard Gray

4.30

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.