28 must-read amish books like Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers) by Jennifer Beckstrand

Cover of Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers) by Jennifer Beckstrand

Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

By: Jennifer Beckstrand

4.48

Format: 296 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Known as “The Peanut Butter Brothers” for their Wisconsin family business, hardworking Andrew, Abra…

If you liked the amish plot in Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers) by Jennifer Beckstrand , here is a list of 28 books like this:

Cover of His Love Endures Forever (Land of Canaan #3) by Beth Wiseman

1. His Love Endures Forever (Land of Canaan #3)

By: Beth Wiseman

4.40

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

An unplanned pregnancy. An absent father. Can love really endure all things? Danielle Kent is a… read more

Similar categories in Beth Wiseman's His Love Endures Forever (Land of Canaan #3) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of The Decision (Prairie State Friends, #1) by Wanda E. Brunstetter

2. The Decision (Prairie State Friends, #1)

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.20

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

Discover along with Jonah Miller how life can begin anew in the prairie state of Illinois. Moving f… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's The Decision (Prairie State Friends, #1) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of The Wonder of Your Love (Land of Canaan #2) by Beth Wiseman

3. The Wonder of Your Love (Land of Canaan #2)

By: Beth Wiseman

3.92

Format: 98 pages, Paperback

Katie Ann lost the love of her life. Then God offers her a new beginning in Colorado. Katie Ann Sto… read more

Similar categories in Beth Wiseman's The Wonder of Your Love (Land of Canaan #2) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction

4. The Seekers

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.06

Format: 368 pages,

Join a class of unlikely Ohioans who take cooking lessons at Lyle and Heidi Troyer's Amish farm. A … read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's The Seekers book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

5. A Sister's Test (Sisters of Holmes County, #2)

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

3.77

Format: None pages, Paperback

read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's A Sister's Test (Sisters of Holmes County, #2) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

Cover of A Picture of Love (Amish Inn #1) by Beth Wiseman

6. A Picture of Love (Amish Inn #1)

By: Beth Wiseman

4.45

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

  Both of them have vowed from the bottom of their broken hearts never to love again.   Sw… read more

Similar categories in Beth Wiseman's A Picture of Love (Amish Inn #1) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of The Proposal Plot by Kathleen Fuller

7. The Proposal Plot

By: Kathleen Fuller

4.24

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

A headstrong young businesswoman. An unlucky-in-love bachelor. And the chaperoning assignment that … read more

Similar categories in Kathleen Fuller's The Proposal Plot book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • clean romance
  • amish
  • contemporary
Cover of Happily Ever Amish (The Amish of Apple Creek #1) by Shelley Shepard Gray

8. Happily Ever Amish (The Amish of Apple Creek #1)

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.42

Format: 304 pages, Kindle Edition

Combining the appeal of a small-town Amish setting and favorite romance tropes, New York Times best… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's Happily Ever Amish (The Amish of Apple Creek #1) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of The Amish Christmas Candle by Kelly Long

9. The Amish Christmas Candle

By: Kelly Long

3.79

Format: 336 pages, Mass Market Paperback

“The love and warmth of the holiday season shines brightly in this charming trio.” —Booklist   At t… read more

Similar categories in Kelly Long's The Amish Christmas Candle book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of All's Fair in Love and Christmas by Sarah Monzon

10. All's Fair in Love and Christmas

By: Sarah Monzon

3.52

Format: 256 pages, Kindle Edition

Every December two things are guaranteed for graphic designer Mackenzie Graham--Christmas celebrati… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Monzon's All's Fair in Love and Christmas book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • fiction
  • contemporary
"Memories are precious things. Not to be taken for granted. They have the power to bring comfort, to make us smile and feel warm inside. Everyone should take the time to cherish the memories they have…"

-Sarah Monzon, All's Fair in Love and Christmas

Cover of The Bookseller's Promise (The Amish Bookstore #1) by Beth Wiseman

11. The Bookseller's Promise (The Amish Bookstore #1)

By: Beth Wiseman

4.33

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

In the first novel of Beth Wiseman’s new Amish Bookstore series, a rare, old book may hold answers … read more

Similar categories in Beth Wiseman's The Bookseller's Promise (The Amish Bookstore #1) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of Letters of Trust (Friendship Letters #1) by Wanda E. Brunstetter

12. Letters of Trust (Friendship Letters #1)

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.29

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

Friendship Letters Series — Doretta Schwartz has always enjoyed writing letters and feels her lette… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's Letters of Trust (Friendship Letters #1) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of Foundation of Love (An Amish Legacy #1) by Amy Clipston

13. Foundation of Love (An Amish Legacy #1)

By: Amy Clipston

4.43

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

They were “only friends” . . . but they wanted so much more. Crystal Glick is grateful to live w… read more

Similar categories in Amy Clipston's Foundation of Love (An Amish Legacy #1) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of Building a Future (An Amish Legacy, #2) by Amy Clipston

14. Building a Future (An Amish Legacy, #2)

By: Amy Clipston

4.42

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

They both had different plans for their futures . . . until their hearts led them to each other. … read more

Similar categories in Amy Clipston's Building a Future (An Amish Legacy, #2) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of Her Secret Hope by Shelley Shepard Gray

15. Her Secret Hope

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.32

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

Almost two years after Lilly Kurtz first traveled to Pinecraft, Florida, with friends, she's decide… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's Her Secret Hope book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of An Amish Second Christmas by Shelley Shepard Gray

16. An Amish Second Christmas

By: Shelley Shepard Gray

4.36

Format: 309 pages, Paperback

For the Amish, the day after Christmas is for family, feasting, and exchanging simple gifts. And fo… read more

Similar categories in Shelley Shepard Gray's An Amish Second Christmas book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • amish
Cover of The Mockingbird's Song (Amish Greenhouse Mystery #2) by Wanda E. Brunstetter

17. The Mockingbird's Song (Amish Greenhouse Mystery #2)

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.29

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

Where Is the Hope in Grief for a Young Amish Widow? Sylvia has been nearly paralyzed with grief and… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's The Mockingbird's Song (Amish Greenhouse Mystery #2) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of An Amish Marriage of Convenience (Surprised by Love #4) by Rachel J. Good

18. An Amish Marriage of Convenience (Surprised by Love #4)

By: Rachel J. Good

4.32

Format: 352 pages, Kindle Edition

In Rachel J. Good’s sweetly romantic inspirational series, a bustling Green Valley Farmer’s Market … read more

Similar categories in Rachel J. Good's An Amish Marriage of Convenience (Surprised by Love #4) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • clean romance
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of An Unexpected Amish Courtship (Surprised by Love #2) by Rachel J. Good

19. An Unexpected Amish Courtship (Surprised by Love #2)

By: Rachel J. Good

4.58

Format: 331 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes love, guided by the Grace of God, is found in the most unexpected places or in unexpected… read more

Similar categories in Rachel J. Good's An Unexpected Amish Courtship (Surprised by Love #2) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of Letters of Comfort (Friendship Letters Book 2) by Wanda E. Brunstetter

20. Letters of Comfort (Friendship Letters Book 2)

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.41

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

Friendship Letters Series — Doretta Schwartz has always enjoyed writing letters and feels her lette… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's Letters of Comfort (Friendship Letters Book 2) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of Hopefully Ever After (The Amish Bookstore #3) by Beth Wiseman

21. Hopefully Ever After (The Amish Bookstore #3)

By: Beth Wiseman

4.48

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

To become who they’re meant to be, Eden and Samuel must find the courage to defy expectations. … read more

Similar categories in Beth Wiseman's Hopefully Ever After (The Amish Bookstore #3) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • contemporary
Cover of Breaking New Ground (An Amish Legacy #3) by Amy Clipston

22. Breaking New Ground (An Amish Legacy #3)

By: Amy Clipston

4.44

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

Korey Bontrager and Savannah Zook are just pretending to date—but could their feelings turn into so… read more

Similar categories in Amy Clipston's Breaking New Ground (An Amish Legacy #3) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of The Heart's Shelter (An Amish Legacy Novel) by Amy Clipston

23. The Heart's Shelter (An Amish Legacy Novel)

By: Amy Clipston

4.41

Format: 368 pages, Paperback

Kira has no interest in dating and putting down roots in Pennsylvania—that is, until she finds a ki… read more

Similar categories in Amy Clipston's The Heart's Shelter (An Amish Legacy Novel) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • clean romance
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers) by Jennifer Beckstrand

24. Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

By: Jennifer Beckstrand

4.48

Format: 296 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Known as “The Peanut Butter Brothers” for their Wisconsin family business, hardworking Andrew, Abra… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • clean romance
  • amish
  • humor
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • christian romance
Cover of The Amish Cookie Club (The Amish Cookie Club #1) by Sarah     Price

25. The Amish Cookie Club (The Amish Cookie Club #1)

By: Sarah Price

4.38

Format: 304 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Every other Friday, Edna Esh and three of her childhood friends meet to bake sugar cookies for thei… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Price's The Amish Cookie Club (The Amish Cookie Club #1) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of Rachael's Decision (Amish Charm Bakery, #6) by Molly Jebber

26. Rachael's Decision (Amish Charm Bakery, #6)

By: Molly Jebber

4.42

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

  Rachael Schlabach’s first chance for a husband ended in a tragic accident that left her with a li… read more

Similar categories in Molly Jebber's Rachael's Decision (Amish Charm Bakery, #6) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • amish fiction
  • fiction
  • amish
Cover of The Robin's Greeting (Amish Greenhouse Mystery #3) by Wanda E. Brunstetter

27. The Robin's Greeting (Amish Greenhouse Mystery #3)

By: Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.43

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

A Season of Hope Is Coming  For the past two years Belinda King, along with her two grown daughters… read more

Similar categories in Wanda E. Brunstetter's The Robin's Greeting (Amish Greenhouse Mystery #3) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
  • christian romance
Cover of Hannah's Courage (Amish Charm Bakery, #3) by Molly Jebber

28. Hannah's Courage (Amish Charm Bakery, #3)

By: Molly Jebber

4.44

Format: 336 pages, Kindle Edition

A loaf of fragrant cinnamon bread for breakfast . . . a sweet and creamy custard pie for dessert. I… read more

Similar categories in Molly Jebber's Hannah's Courage (Amish Charm Bakery, #3) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • amish fiction
  • christian
  • amish
Cover of The Amish Christmas Letters by Patricia Davids

29. The Amish Christmas Letters

By: Patricia Davids

4.30

Format: 354 pages, Kindle Edition

In this Amish romance anthology, three cousins in different states share holiday cheer and tales of… read more

Similar categories in Patricia Davids's The Amish Christmas Letters book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • contemporary
Cover of An Amish Cookie Club Courtship (The Amish Cookie Club Book 3) by Sarah     Price

30. An Amish Cookie Club Courtship (The Amish Cookie Club Book 3)

By: Sarah Price

4.36

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

With tourist season about to start, Edna Esh is busier than ever, baking with her Amish Cookie Club… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Price's An Amish Cookie Club Courtship (The Amish Cookie Club Book 3) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • romance
  • amish fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish
  • fiction
Cover of Ellie's Redemption (Amish Charm Bakery, #2) by Molly Jebber

31. Ellie's Redemption (Amish Charm Bakery, #2)

By: Molly Jebber

4.47

Format: 336 pages, Mass Market Paperback

The comforting aroma of fresh baked-and-buttered bread. The hearty spice of cinnamon-oatmeal bars a… read more

Similar categories in Molly Jebber's Ellie's Redemption (Amish Charm Bakery, #2) book and Jennifer Beckstrand's Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers)

  • fiction
  • christian fiction
  • christian
  • amish

25 Top fiction books like Abraham (The Petersheim Brothers) by Jennifer Beckstrand

Transform Your Habits

His Love Endures Forever (Land of Canaan #3)

Beth Wiseman

4.40

Transform Your Habits

The Decision (Prairie State Friends, #1)

Wanda E. Brunstetter

4.20

Transform Your Habits

The Wonder of Your Love (Land of Canaan #2)

Beth Wiseman

3.92

Transform Your Habits

A Picture of Love (Amish Inn #1)

Beth Wiseman

4.45

View all the books

18 Best fiction books like Letters of Trust (Friendship Letters #1) by Wanda E. Brunstetter

Transform Your Habits

Orchard

Lewis

4.38

Transform Your Habits

The Heirloom

Beverly Lewis

4.37

Transform Your Habits

Once Upon a Buggy (The Amish of Apple Creek #2)

Shelley Shepard Gray

4.30

Transform Your Habits

Happily Ever Amish (The Amish of Apple Creek #1)

Shelley Shepard Gray

4.42

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.