31 best-selling romance books like The Magic Between by Stephanie Hoyt

Cover of The Magic Between by Stephanie Hoyt

The Magic Between

By: Stephanie Hoyt

3.77

Format: 379 pages, ebook

The official release of The Magic Between includes an updated prologue not found in advanced copies…

If you liked the romance plot in The Magic Between by Stephanie Hoyt , here is a list of 31 books like this:

Cover of All Hail the Underdogs (Breakaway, #3) by E.L. Massey

1. All Hail the Underdogs (Breakaway, #3)

By: E.L. Massey

4.36

Format: 391 pages, Kindle Edition

When seventeen-year-old Patrick Roman is offered a scholarship to a top hockey preparatory school, … read more

Similar categories in E.L. Massey's All Hail the Underdogs (Breakaway, #3) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
"Jesus,"

-E.L. Massey, All Hail the Underdogs (Breakaway, #3)

"I hate you,"

-E.L. Massey, All Hail the Underdogs (Breakaway, #3)

"Go fuck yourself,"

-E.L. Massey, All Hail the Underdogs (Breakaway, #3)

"The feelings I have for you are not gross."

-E.L. Massey, All Hail the Underdogs (Breakaway, #3)

Cover of They Hate Each Other by Amanda Woody

2. They Hate Each Other

By: Amanda Woody

4.24

Format: 352 pages, Hardcover

Jonah and Dylan get along like oil and water. Until a fake dating ploy gives them new perspective, … read more

Similar categories in Amanda Woody's They Hate Each Other book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of Crushed Ice (Hockey Ever After, #4) by Ashlyn Kane

3. Crushed Ice (Hockey Ever After, #4)

By: Ashlyn Kane

3.88

Format: 424 pages, Paperback

When Liam Belanger gets a professional tryout with the Miami Caimans, he’s hoping to land a roster … read more

Similar categories in Ashlyn Kane's Crushed Ice (Hockey Ever After, #4) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of An Unrivaled Off Season (Hockey Ever After #3.5) by Ashlyn Kane

4. An Unrivaled Off Season (Hockey Ever After #3.5)

By: Ashlyn Kane

4.23

Format: 118 pages, Kindle Edition

Any other year, hockey player Grady Armstrong would be licking his wounds after a disappointing pla… read more

Similar categories in Ashlyn Kane's An Unrivaled Off Season (Hockey Ever After #3.5) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • adult
  • contemporary
  • sports
Cover of Unrivaled (Hockey Ever After, #3) by Ashlyn Kane

5. Unrivaled (Hockey Ever After, #3)

By: Ashlyn Kane

4.06

Format: 404 pages, Paperback

People say there’s a fine line between love and hate. If you ask Grady Armstrong, the line’s as obv… read more

Similar categories in Ashlyn Kane's Unrivaled (Hockey Ever After, #3) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
"Tell you what,"

-Ashlyn Kane, Unrivaled (Hockey Ever After, #3)

"I should be the lobster,"

-Ashlyn Kane, Unrivaled (Hockey Ever After, #3)

"This is what you got when you lost the bet?"

-Ashlyn Kane, Unrivaled (Hockey Ever After, #3)

"Chocolate might not fill the void inside him, but he’d never know until he tried."

-Ashlyn Kane, Unrivaled (Hockey Ever After, #3)

Cover of The Winging It Holiday Special (Hockey Ever After, #1.5) by Ashlyn Kane

6. The Winging It Holiday Special (Hockey Ever After, #1.5)

By: Ashlyn Kane

3.90

Format: 105 pages, Kindle Edition

Hockey’s started, holidays are looming, and NHL player Dante Baltierra’s husband is keeping secrets… read more

Similar categories in Ashlyn Kane's The Winging It Holiday Special (Hockey Ever After, #1.5) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
Cover of Like Real People Do (Breakaway, #1) by E.L. Massey

7. Like Real People Do (Breakaway, #1)

By: E.L. Massey

4.33

Format: 423 pages, ebook

Nineteen-year-old hockey phenom Alexander Price is the youngest-ever captain in the NHL. With a pol… read more

Similar categories in E.L. Massey's Like Real People Do (Breakaway, #1) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
"Apparently, Alex doesn't know how to handle emotions, and he's a dumpster fire of a human being."

-E.L. Massey, Like Real People Do (Breakaway, #1)

"The problem is he thinks he and Eli could be good for each other. Really good. Under different circumstances. In a different life. Or maybe, if he was just a little braver, in this one."

-E.L. Massey, Like Real People Do (Breakaway, #1)

Cover of Like You've Nothing Left to Prove (Breakaway, #2) by E.L. Massey

8. Like You've Nothing Left to Prove (Breakaway, #2)

By: E.L. Massey

4.40

Format: None pages, ebook

As the headline-stealing captain of the Houston Hell Hounds, nineteen-year-old Alexander Price has … read more

Similar categories in E.L. Massey's Like You've Nothing Left to Prove (Breakaway, #2) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
"He doesn't have words for this kind of thing. But 'love' seems really fucking trite for all the whatever that he feels. Or maybe other people shouldn't be allowed to use the word 'love' because they …"

-E.L. Massey, Like You've Nothing Left to Prove (Breakaway, #2)

Cover of Scoring Position (Hockey Ever After, #2) by Ashlyn Kane

9. Scoring Position (Hockey Ever After, #2)

By: Ashlyn Kane

3.91

Format: 378 pages, Paperback

Ryan Wright’s new hockey team is a dumpster fire. He expects to lose games—not his heart. Ryan’s l… read more

Similar categories in Ashlyn Kane's Scoring Position (Hockey Ever After, #2) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of Game Misconduct (Penalty Box, #1) by Ari Baran

10. Game Misconduct (Penalty Box, #1)

By: Ari Baran

3.85

Format: None pages, ebook

Two bitter rivals go head-to-head in this age-gap, enemies-to-lovers hockey romance. Michael Sato i… read more

Similar categories in Ari Baran's Game Misconduct (Penalty Box, #1) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • adult
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of Season's Change (Trade Season #1) by Cait Nary

11. Season's Change (Trade Season #1)

By: Cait Nary

3.98

Format: 380 pages, ebook

A veteran hockey player and a rookie can't get away from each other—or their own desires—in this se… read more

Similar categories in Cait Nary's Season's Change (Trade Season #1) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • adult
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of Delay of Game (Penalty Box, #2) by Ari Baran

12. Delay of Game (Penalty Box, #2)

By: Ari Baran

3.86

Format: 308 pages, Kindle Edition

Two polar opposite teammates battle their rivals—and their own issues—in this friends-to-lovers hoc… read more

Similar categories in Ari Baran's Delay of Game (Penalty Box, #2) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of XOXO (Roosevelt College, #1) by Christina  Lee

13. XOXO (Roosevelt College, #1)

By: Christina Lee

3.86

Format: 278 pages, Kindle Edition

Lark Levitt doesn’t belong at Roosevelt College, at least in theory. Most students who attend the p… read more

Similar categories in Christina Lee's XOXO (Roosevelt College, #1) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of Chasing The Alpha's Son (The Alpha's Son #2) by Penny Jessup

14. Chasing The Alpha's Son (The Alpha's Son #2)

By: Penny Jessup

4.05

Format: 340 pages, Paperback

The second book in Penny Jessup's best selling The Alpha's Son series. It's been three months since… read more

Similar categories in Penny Jessup's Chasing The Alpha's Son (The Alpha's Son #2) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • fantasy
  • queer
Cover of Lucky Bounce by Cait Nary

15. Lucky Bounce

By: Cait Nary

3.72

Format: 251 pages, Kindle Edition

 A single dad pro hockey player falls for his biggest fan—who just happens to be his five-year-old … read more

Similar categories in Cait Nary's Lucky Bounce book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • adult
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of Winging It (Hockey Ever After, #1) by Ashlyn Kane

16. Winging It (Hockey Ever After, #1)

By: Ashlyn Kane

3.82

Format: 282 pages, Paperback

Hockey is Gabe Martin's life. Dante Baltierra just wants to have some fun on his way to the Hockey … read more

Similar categories in Ashlyn Kane's Winging It (Hockey Ever After, #1) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of Square to the Puck (Offsides #2) by J.J. Mulder

17. Square to the Puck (Offsides #2)

By: J.J. Mulder

3.91

Format: 272 pages, Kindle Edition

Corwin Sanhover could almost convince himself that the night six years ago didn’t happen. But when … read more

Similar categories in J.J. Mulder's Square to the Puck (Offsides #2) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • adult
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
"Above me, Nigel is muttering in rapid French; I hope he's not telling me what to do, because my limited knowledge of the language does not yet include instructions on how to give head properly."

-J.J. Mulder, Square to the Puck (Offsides #2)

Cover of Icebreaker by A.L. Graziadei

18. Icebreaker

By: A.L. Graziadei

4.03

Format: 320 pages, Hardcover

A. L. Graziadei's Icebreaker is a YA debut about two hockey players fighting to be the best—and the… read more

Similar categories in A.L. Graziadei's Icebreaker book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
"I don't wanna be just another one of your former teammates."

-A.L. Graziadei, Icebreaker

"I get through the first few weeks of college without dropping out, but that's only because I don't want to deal with Dad whining about it for the next twenty years."

-A.L. Graziadei, Icebreaker

"Gdyby @mjames17 dodał sobie te jedenaście punktów do wzrostu, może wtedy bym się przejął.' Siedzę obok niego, podjadam ze wspólnej paczki czipsy solone z octem i odpowiadam: 'Mickey James III @mjames…"

-A.L. Graziadei, Icebreaker

Cover of Love & Other Inconveniences by Catherine Cloud

19. Love & Other Inconveniences

By: Catherine Cloud

3.99

Format: 404 pages, Kindle Edition

Morgan Boyle wants two things in life: to play hockey and to be left alone. Noah Andersson is l… read more

Similar categories in Catherine Cloud's Love & Other Inconveniences book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
"Nate wouldn't say he panicked. Nate would not say he shat his metaphorical pants. Nate would not say those things, but they were still true."

-Catherine Cloud, Love & Other Inconveniences

"He has no idea how this happened. He's not in love with Noah, but he also doesn't want to lose him, but he also can't pretend he's something he's not, but then, on some nights, he isn't even sure who…"

-Catherine Cloud, Love & Other Inconveniences

Cover of Changing the Game (Offsides #1) by J.J. Mulder

20. Changing the Game (Offsides #1)

By: J.J. Mulder

3.77

Format: 325 pages, Kindle Edition

Former college hockey player, Sam Jameson, is coming off of a bad summer. After the derailment of h… read more

Similar categories in J.J. Mulder's Changing the Game (Offsides #1) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • adult
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of Star of the Game (Stick Side #6) by Amy Aislin

21. Star of the Game (Stick Side #6)

By: Amy Aislin

4.08

Format: 374 pages, Kindle Edition

Felix only wants two things: 1. To make music. 2. His best friend, Emery. But he’s not willing… read more

Similar categories in Amy Aislin's Star of the Game (Stick Side #6) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of The Alpha's Son (The Alpha's Son, #1) by Penny Jessup

22. The Alpha's Son (The Alpha's Son, #1)

By: Penny Jessup

3.37

Format: 393 pages, Kindle Edition

Max Remus couldn’t care less about finding his mate—unlike the rest of his fate-obsessed pack. He t… read more

Similar categories in Penny Jessup's The Alpha's Son (The Alpha's Son, #1) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • fantasy
  • queer
Cover of Rookie Recovery (Bobcat Boys #1) by Lex Easton

23. Rookie Recovery (Bobcat Boys #1)

By: Lex Easton

3.92

Format: 335 pages, Kindle Edition

Jamie Sullivan does not date hockey players. As the PT for the Bringham Bobcats, he knows they're l… read more

Similar categories in Lex Easton's Rookie Recovery (Bobcat Boys #1) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • adult
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of The Magic Between by Stephanie Hoyt

24. The Magic Between

By: Stephanie Hoyt

3.77

Format: 379 pages, ebook

The official release of The Magic Between includes an updated prologue not found in advanced copies… read more

Similar categories in Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • adult
  • magic
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • fantasy
  • queer
Cover of Shots on Net (SCU Hockey, #1) by J.J. Mulder

25. Shots on Net (SCU Hockey, #1)

By: J.J. Mulder

3.92

Format: 318 pages, Kindle Edition

Carter Morgan III hates everything about South Carolina University except for one thing: hockey. As… read more

Similar categories in J.J. Mulder's Shots on Net (SCU Hockey, #1) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of The Inside Edge by Ashlyn Kane

26. The Inside Edge

By: Ashlyn Kane

3.65

Format: 228 pages, Paperback

What does a work-life balance look like to recently retired professional athletes? Ex-hockey pl… read more

Similar categories in Ashlyn Kane's The Inside Edge book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of Sparks Fly by Birdie Lynn

27. Sparks Fly

By: Birdie Lynn

4.02

Format: 284 pages, Paperback

Arthur Pham didn't expect to spend his final year at the Stonebury Conservatory for Young Mages dat… read more

Similar categories in Birdie Lynn's Sparks Fly book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • magic
  • fantasy
  • queer
Cover of Snow Boys by Simon Doyle

28. Snow Boys

By: Simon Doyle

4.35

Format: 410 pages, Kindle Edition

Dean O’Donnell is a wallflower with a secret and a voice that could steal the show. Preferring to b… read more

Similar categories in Simon Doyle's Snow Boys book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • gay
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • queer
Cover of Between the Pipes (Offsides #3) by J.J. Mulder

29. Between the Pipes (Offsides #3)

By: J.J. Mulder

3.97

Format: 261 pages, Kindle Edition

Nico Mackenzie is angry and argumentative— in every way, he is the exact opposite of NHL goaltender… read more

Similar categories in J.J. Mulder's Between the Pipes (Offsides #3) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • adult
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of Caught Off Guard by Catherine Cloud

30. Caught Off Guard

By: Catherine Cloud

3.93

Format: 258 pages, Kindle Edition

Matthias Brandl always knew he wouldn’t spend his entire career with the same team. He does have tw… read more

Similar categories in Catherine Cloud's Caught Off Guard book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • adult
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer
Cover of Home Ice Advantage (Penalty Box #3) by Ari Baran

31. Home Ice Advantage (Penalty Box #3)

By: Ari Baran

4.19

Format: 341 pages, Kindle Edition

Two former hockey pros. One struggling team. And a battle of wills that might just turn two headstr… read more

Similar categories in Ari Baran's Home Ice Advantage (Penalty Box #3) book and Stephanie Hoyt's The Magic Between

  • romance
  • m m romance
  • lgbt
  • contemporary
  • sports
  • queer

28 must-read contemporary books like The Magic Between by Stephanie Hoyt

Transform Your Habits

All Hail the Underdogs (Breakaway, #3)

E.L. Massey

4.36

Transform Your Habits

They Hate Each Other

Amanda Woody

4.24

Transform Your Habits

Crushed Ice (Hockey Ever After, #4)

Ashlyn Kane

3.88

Transform Your Habits

An Unrivaled Off Season (Hockey Ever After #3.5)

Ashlyn Kane

4.23

View all the books

21 Top contemporary books like Winging It (Hockey Ever After, #1) by Ashlyn Kane

Transform Your Habits

Breakaway (Scoring Chances, #1)

Avon Gale

4.17

Transform Your Habits

Bromantic Puckboy (Puckboys, #6)

Eden Finley

4.22

Transform Your Habits

Like Real People Do (Breakaway, #1)

E.L. Massey

4.33

Transform Your Habits

Like You've Nothing Left to Prove (Breakaway, #2)

E.L. Massey

4.40

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.