Their Make-Believe Match
By: Jackie Stef
4.52
Format: 224 pages, Mass Market Paperback
Their pretend relationship… Is becoming all too real Irrepressible Sadie Stolzfus refuses to wed s…
Want to Read $ 4.99If you liked the amish plot in Their Make-Believe Match by Jackie Stef , here is a list of 16 books like this:
1. The Amish Matchmaking Dilemma (Amish Country Matches #1)
By: Patricia Johns
4.41
Format: 224 pages, Mass Market Paperback
They’re not compatible on paper… But might be the perfect match. Amish bachelor Mose Klassen know… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Patricia Johns's The Amish Matchmaking Dilemma (Amish Country Matches #1) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- harlequin
- amish
- love inspired
2. Someone to Trust (North Country Amish,#5)
By: Patricia Davids
4.58
Format: 216 pages, Kindle Edition
Some connections go beyond words…in this novel by USA TODAY bestselling author Patricia Davids.On a… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Patricia Davids's Someone to Trust (North Country Amish,#5) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- harlequin
- amish
- love inspired
3. An Unexpected Amish Harvest (The Amish of New Hope #2)
By: Carrie Lighte
4.36
Format: 208 pages, Kindle Edition
Coming soon! An Unexpected Amish Harvest by Carrie Lighte will be available Aug 24, 2021. read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Carrie Lighte's An Unexpected Amish Harvest (The Amish of New Hope #2) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- amish
- love inspired
4. A Convenient Amish Bride
By: Lucy Bayer
4.49
Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition
Two girls need a mother… And she’s ready for the job. After the loss of her perfect match, Amish wa… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Lucy Bayer's A Convenient Amish Bride book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- amish
5. Hiding Her Amish Secret (The Amish of New Hope #1)
By: Carrie Lighte
4.34
Format: 208 pages, Kindle Edition
Forgiveness for her past could change her future… The guilt of her past weighs heavy… Can love s… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Carrie Lighte's Hiding Her Amish Secret (The Amish of New Hope #1) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- amish
- love inspired
6. The Prodigal Cowboy (Mercy Ranch #5)
By: Brenda Minton
4.45
Format: 212 pages, Kindle Edition
Can an unexpected reunion change his wandering ways?His last chance to make things right…means reun… read more
Want to Read $ 1.99Similar categories in Brenda Minton's The Prodigal Cowboy (Mercy Ranch #5) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- harlequin
- love inspired
7. A Secret Amish Crush (Brides of Lost Creek #5)
By: Marta Perry
4.38
Format: 202 pages, Kindle Edition
A second chance at her first love?A man from her past. A heartbroken child.Could she be their answe… read more
Want to Read $ 5.99Similar categories in Marta Perry's A Secret Amish Crush (Brides of Lost Creek #5) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- amish
- love inspired
8. Rebuilding Her Life (Kendrick Creek #1)
By: Ruth Logan Herne
4.60
Format: 206 pages, Kindle Edition
Coming soon! Rebuilding Her Life by Ruth Logan Herne will be available Apr 01, 2021. read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Ruth Logan Herne's Rebuilding Her Life (Kendrick Creek #1) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- love inspired
9. Courting His Amish Wife
By: Emma Miller
4.48
Format: 207 pages, Kindle Edition
He offers her his hand, but will she ever take his heart? When Levi Miller learns Eve Summy w… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Emma Miller's Courting His Amish Wife book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- amish
- love inspired
10. The Amish Midwife's Bargain
By: Patrice Lewis
4.44
Format: 206 pages, Kindle Edition
An accident on a stormy night Will change the course of their lives… Grieving after the loss … read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Patrice Lewis's The Amish Midwife's Bargain book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- amish
11. Their Make-Believe Match
By: Jackie Stef
4.52
Format: 224 pages, Mass Market Paperback
Their pretend relationship… Is becoming all too real Irrepressible Sadie Stolzfus refuses to wed s… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- harlequin
- amish
- love inspired
12. A Haven for Christmas (North Country Amish #4)
By: Patricia Davids
4.50
Format: 218 pages, Kindle Edition
An Amish widow. An Englisch cowboy. And a Christmas to remember. An accident landing an Englischer… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Patricia Davids's A Haven for Christmas (North Country Amish #4) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- amish
- love inspired
13. In Love with the Amish Nanny
By: Rebecca Kertz
4.45
Format: 224 pages, Mass Market Paperback
She could never marry for love. But what about for a family? Still grieving her beloved fiancé’s de… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Rebecca Kertz's In Love with the Amish Nanny book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- amish
- love inspired
14. The Nanny's Amish Family (Redemption's Amish Legacies #1)
By: Patricia Johns
4.46
Format: 212 pages, Kindle Edition
They need her help. She needs them…An Amish bachelor. A motherless child.Can she turn them into a r… read more
Want to Read $ 1.99Similar categories in Patricia Johns's The Nanny's Amish Family (Redemption's Amish Legacies #1) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- amish
- love inspired
15. Trusting Her Amish Heart
By: Cathy Liggett
4.46
Format: 218 pages, Kindle Edition
Her heart may learn to love again… But can it trust? Running from betrayal, Leah Zook finds purpose… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Cathy Liggett's Trusting Her Amish Heart book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- harlequin
- amish
- love inspired
16. The Secret Amish Admirer (Bluebird Hills #2)
By: Virginia Wise
4.40
Format: 210 pages, Kindle Edition
This could be her one chance To win his heart…For years, Eliza Zook has been content to love Gabrie… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Virginia Wise's The Secret Amish Admirer (Bluebird Hills #2) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- amish
- love inspired
17. Their Unlikely Protector
By: Meghann Whistler
4.77
Format: 208 pages, Mass Market Paperback
To give two little boys a home… She must take a chance on forgiveness. The last person Valerie W… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Meghann Whistler's Their Unlikely Protector book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
- harlequin
- love inspired
18. A Mother's Homecoming
By: Lisa Carter
4.57
Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition
The children she never thought she’d know… She’d put the past behind her… But her secret has … read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Lisa Carter's A Mother's Homecoming book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- love inspired
19. Her Amish Adversary (Indiana Amish Market Book 2)
By: Vannetta Chapman
4.58
Format: 217 pages, Kindle Edition
Coming soon! Her Amish Adversary by Vannetta Chapman will be available Jan 24, 2023. read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Vannetta Chapman's Her Amish Adversary (Indiana Amish Market Book 2) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- amish
- love inspired
20. Her Pretend Amish Beau (Amish Country Matches #5)
By: Patricia Johns
4.72
Format: 368 pages, Paperback
Falling for each other was never part of the plan. With four sons and a flower farm, widow Delia… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Patricia Johns's Her Pretend Amish Beau (Amish Country Matches #5) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- amish
21. Healed by the Amish Nanny (Bluebird Hills #3)
By: Virginia Wise
4.67
Format: 217 pages, Kindle Edition
Can an unconventional woman… Bring a family together? Away from home for the first time, free-spiri… read more
Want to Read $ 4.99Similar categories in Virginia Wise's Healed by the Amish Nanny (Bluebird Hills #3) book and Jackie Stef's Their Make-Believe Match
- romance
