10 Best adult fiction books like Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1) by Amy Lillard

Cover of Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1) by Amy Lillard

Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

By: Amy Lillard

3.57

Format: 360 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Not every murder is by the book… As Sugar Springs gears up for its all-class high school reunion…

If you liked the adult fiction plot in Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1) by Amy Lillard , here is a list of 10 books like this:

Cover of A Knit before Dying  (Tangled Web Mystery, #2) by Sadie Hartwell

1. A Knit before Dying (Tangled Web Mystery, #2)

By: Sadie Hartwell

3.77

Format: 342 pages, ebook

A new business might add some much-needed charm to downtown Dorset Falls--and draw tourists to Josi… read more

Similar categories in Sadie Hartwell's A Knit before Dying (Tangled Web Mystery, #2) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery
  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
Cover of Death by Coffee by Alex Erickson

2. Death by Coffee

By: Alex Erickson

3.59

Format: None pages, Paperback

When Krissy Hancock and her best friend Vicki decide to open a bookstore cafe in their new town of … read more

Similar categories in Alex Erickson's Death by Coffee book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • books about books
  • audiobook

3. Mission Impawsible (Paws and Claws Mystery, #4)

By: Krista Davis

3.82

Format: 148 pages, Paperback

From the "New York Times" bestselling author of "Murder Most Howl "comes another Paws & Claws myste… read more

Similar categories in Krista Davis's Mission Impawsible (Paws and Claws Mystery, #4) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

Cover of Murder at the Blueberry Festival (Beacon Bakeshop, #3) by Darci Hannah

4. Murder at the Blueberry Festival (Beacon Bakeshop, #3)

By: Darci Hannah

4.23

Format: 319 pages, Paperback

After a career on Wall Street, Lindsey is making a different kind of dough in a pretty lakeside vil… read more

Similar categories in Darci Hannah's Murder at the Blueberry Festival (Beacon Bakeshop, #3) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of A Limited Edition Murder (Beyond the Page Bookstore Mystery, #10) by Lauren  Elliott

5. A Limited Edition Murder (Beyond the Page Bookstore Mystery, #10)

By: Lauren Elliott

4.27

Format: 320 pages, Mass Market Paperback

While in England, a first edition of Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights leads bookstore owner Addie G… read more

Similar categories in Lauren Elliott's A Limited Edition Murder (Beyond the Page Bookstore Mystery, #10) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • adult
  • books about books
  • audiobook
Cover of Little Bookshop of Murder (Beach Reads Mystery, #1) by Maggie Blackburn

6. Little Bookshop of Murder (Beach Reads Mystery, #1)

By: Maggie Blackburn

3.33

Format: 329 pages, Hardcover

A Shakespearean scholar inherits a beachside bookshop--and a murder mystery--in this delightful new… read more

Similar categories in Maggie Blackburn's Little Bookshop of Murder (Beach Reads Mystery, #1) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • adult fiction
  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
  • books about books
  • audiobook
Cover of Murder at the Beacon Bakeshop (Beacon Bakeshop, #1) by Darci Hannah

7. Murder at the Beacon Bakeshop (Beacon Bakeshop, #1)

By: Darci Hannah

4.20

Format: 280 pages, Kindle Edition

In the first of a new series, after Lindsey Bakeswell catches her celebrity chef fiancé sizzling in… read more

Similar categories in Darci Hannah's Murder at the Beacon Bakeshop (Beacon Bakeshop, #1) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • adult fiction
  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Murder at a Cape Bookstore (Cozy Capers Book Group Mystery, #5) by Maddie Day

8. Murder at a Cape Bookstore (Cozy Capers Book Group Mystery, #5)

By: Maddie Day

4.06

Format: 326 pages, Mass Market Paperback

It's mud season in Cape Cod, and when an ill wind blows in a murder with a twist in the tale, bicyc… read more

Similar categories in Maddie Day's Murder at a Cape Bookstore (Cozy Capers Book Group Mystery, #5) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • adult fiction
  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Fatal First Edition (Library Lover's Mystery, #14) by Jenn McKinlay

9. Fatal First Edition (Library Lover's Mystery, #14)

By: Jenn McKinlay

4.06

Format: 280 pages, Kindle Edition

People are dying to get their hands on a rare, valuable book in the newest Library Lover’s Mystery … read more

Similar categories in Jenn McKinlay's Fatal First Edition (Library Lover's Mystery, #14) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • adult fiction
  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • adult
  • books about books
  • audiobook
Cover of The Plot and the Pendulum (Library Lover's Mystery, #13) by Jenn McKinlay

10. The Plot and the Pendulum (Library Lover's Mystery, #13)

By: Jenn McKinlay

4.09

Format: 296 pages, Hardcover

Library director Lindsey Norris is happy to learn the Briar Creek Public Library is the beneficiary… read more

Similar categories in Jenn McKinlay's The Plot and the Pendulum (Library Lover's Mystery, #13) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • adult fiction
  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • adult
  • books about books
  • audiobook
Cover of The Dog Across the Lake (Paws and Claws Mystery, #9) by Krista Davis

11. The Dog Across the Lake (Paws and Claws Mystery, #9)

By: Krista Davis

4.32

Format: 336 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Holly and Trixie meet a strange new dog in Wagtail that leads them right into murder. . . . Holl… read more

Similar categories in Krista Davis's The Dog Across the Lake (Paws and Claws Mystery, #9) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • adult fiction
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • audiobook
Cover of A Midsummer Night's Fudge (Candy-Coated, #10) by Nancy CoCo

12. A Midsummer Night's Fudge (Candy-Coated, #10)

By: Nancy CoCo

4.07

Format: 279 pages, Kindle Edition

During the Midsummer Night’s Festival, Allie decides to take her bichonpoo, Mal, home to spare her … read more

Similar categories in Nancy CoCo's A Midsummer Night's Fudge (Candy-Coated, #10) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • audiobook
Cover of The Sign of Four Spirits (Sherlock Holmes Bookshop Mystery, #9) by Vicki Delany

13. The Sign of Four Spirits (Sherlock Holmes Bookshop Mystery, #9)

By: Vicki Delany

4.09

Format: 272 pages, Kindle Edition

Gemma Doyle won’t be spooked when a body shows up at the psychic fair in bestselling author Vicki D… read more

Similar categories in Vicki Delany's The Sign of Four Spirits (Sherlock Holmes Bookshop Mystery, #9) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • adult fiction
  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • audiobook
Cover of Deep Fried Death (A Country Store Mystery) by Maddie Day

14. Deep Fried Death (A Country Store Mystery)

By: Maddie Day

4.17

Format: 327 pages, Paperback

In the latest Country Store Mystery by Agatha and Macavity Award-winning author Maddie Day, a kille… read more

Similar categories in Maddie Day's Deep Fried Death (A Country Store Mystery) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Four Leaf Cleaver (Country Store Mysteries, #11) by Maddie Day

15. Four Leaf Cleaver (Country Store Mysteries, #11)

By: Maddie Day

4.18

Format: 309 pages, Paperback

In the latest Country Store Mystery by Agatha and Macavity Award-winning author Maddie Day, it’s Sa… read more

Similar categories in Maddie Day's Four Leaf Cleaver (Country Store Mysteries, #11) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Murder Uncorked (Cece Barton Mystery, #1) by Maddie Day

16. Murder Uncorked (Cece Barton Mystery, #1)

By: Maddie Day

3.67

Format: 288 pages, Hardcover

Raise a glass to Cece Barton, a widowed single mom and recent L.A. transplant to California wine co… read more

Similar categories in Maddie Day's Murder Uncorked (Cece Barton Mystery, #1) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • audiobook
Cover of Murder at the Pumpkin Pageant (Beacon Bakeshop #4) by Darci Hannah

17. Murder at the Pumpkin Pageant (Beacon Bakeshop #4)

By: Darci Hannah

4.10

Format: 353 pages, Kindle Edition

The latest installment in Darci Hannah’s delicious Beacon Bakeshop Mystery series set in small-town… read more

Similar categories in Darci Hannah's Murder at the Pumpkin Pageant (Beacon Bakeshop #4) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Buried in a Good Book (By the Book Mysteries, #1) by Tamara Berry

18. Buried in a Good Book (By the Book Mysteries, #1)

By: Tamara Berry

3.83

Format: 333 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Don't miss the first book in a brand-new gripping and hilarious bookish cozy mystery series by auth… read more

Similar categories in Tamara Berry's Buried in a Good Book (By the Book Mysteries, #1) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • adult fiction
  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
  • books about books
  • audiobook
Cover of Murder Off the Books (By the Book Mysteries, #3) by Tamara Berry

19. Murder Off the Books (By the Book Mysteries, #3)

By: Tamara Berry

3.99

Format: 336 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Author Tess Harrow and her daughter, Gertrude, are starting to get a bad reputation due to their in… read more

Similar categories in Tamara Berry's Murder Off the Books (By the Book Mysteries, #3) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • books about books
  • audiobook
Cover of Public Anchovy #1: A Deep Dish Mystery (Deep Dish Mysteries, 3) by Mindy Quigley

20. Public Anchovy #1: A Deep Dish Mystery (Deep Dish Mysteries, 3)

By: Mindy Quigley

4.17

Format: 320 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Public Anchovy #1 is the third book in Mindy Quigley's delectable Deep Dish Mystery series, set in … read more

Similar categories in Mindy Quigley's Public Anchovy #1: A Deep Dish Mystery (Deep Dish Mysteries, 3) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • audiobook
Cover of Murder at the Blarney Bash (Beacon Bakeshop #5) by Darci Hannah

21. Murder at the Blarney Bash (Beacon Bakeshop #5)

By: Darci Hannah

4.15

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

Follow the aroma of shamrock sugar cookies to the Beacon Bakeshop, a lighthouse on the shores of La… read more

Similar categories in Darci Hannah's Murder at the Blarney Bash (Beacon Bakeshop #5) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Baking Spirits Bright (True Confections Mystery #2) by Sarah    Fox

22. Baking Spirits Bright (True Confections Mystery #2)

By: Sarah Fox

4.00

Format: 288 pages, Mass Market Paperback

In a cute new culinary cozy from USA Today bestselling author Sarah Fox, budding chocolatier Becca … read more

Similar categories in Sarah Fox's Baking Spirits Bright (True Confections Mystery #2) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Snow Place for Murder (Mountain Lodge Mysteries #3) by Diane Kelly

23. Snow Place for Murder (Mountain Lodge Mysteries #3)

By: Diane Kelly

4.04

Format: 304 pages, Mass Market Paperback

The third in the charming and engrossing Mountain Lodge mystery series by Diane Kelly, in Snow Plac… read more

Similar categories in Diane Kelly's Snow Place for Murder (Mountain Lodge Mysteries #3) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • audiobook
Cover of Six Sweets Under (True Confections Mystery, #1) by Sarah    Fox

24. Six Sweets Under (True Confections Mystery, #1)

By: Sarah Fox

3.82

Format: 304 pages, ebook

Former actress Becca Ransom lived her dream in Hollywood for seven years before returning to her ho… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Fox's Six Sweets Under (True Confections Mystery, #1) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Pint of No Return (Shake Shop #1) by Dana Mentink

25. Pint of No Return (Shake Shop #1)

By: Dana Mentink

3.96

Format: 288 pages, Mass Market Paperback

The first in new dessert cozy mystery series! A murder in town is bound to shake things up... Af… read more

Similar categories in Dana Mentink's Pint of No Return (Shake Shop #1) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1) by Amy Lillard

26. Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

By: Amy Lillard

3.57

Format: 360 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Not every murder is by the book… As Sugar Springs gears up for its all-class high school reunion… read more

Similar categories in Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • adult fiction
  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
  • books about books
  • audiobook
Cover of A Flicker of a Doubt (A Fairy Garden Mystery, #4) by Daryl Wood Gerber

27. A Flicker of a Doubt (A Fairy Garden Mystery, #4)

By: Daryl Wood Gerber

4.33

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

From Agatha Award-winning author Daryl Wood Gerber, the fourth in an enchantingly whimsical series … read more

Similar categories in Daryl Wood Gerber's A Flicker of a Doubt (A Fairy Garden Mystery, #4) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of A Wicked Yarn (Craft Fair Knitters Mysteries #1) by Emmie Caldwell

28. A Wicked Yarn (Craft Fair Knitters Mysteries #1)

By: Emmie Caldwell

3.90

Format: 285 pages, Mass Market Paperback

A killer may craft the perfect crime, but as every knitter worth her yarn knows--murder wool out. … read more

Similar categories in Emmie Caldwell's A Wicked Yarn (Craft Fair Knitters Mysteries #1) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • adult fiction
  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
Cover of Death Unfiltered (A Ground Rules Mystery #4) by Emmeline Duncan

29. Death Unfiltered (A Ground Rules Mystery #4)

By: Emmeline Duncan

3.91

Format: 256 pages, Paperback

As the owner of Portland, Oregon’s popular Ground Rules coffee cart, hard-working young master bari… read more

Similar categories in Emmeline Duncan's Death Unfiltered (A Ground Rules Mystery #4) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
Cover of Death in Bloom (A Flower House Mystery #1) by Jess Dylan

30. Death in Bloom (A Flower House Mystery #1)

By: Jess Dylan

3.71

Format: 320 pages, Mass Market Paperback

The first in a sweet and colorful cozy mystery series from Jess Dylan, Death in Bloom introduces fl… read more

Similar categories in Jess Dylan's Death in Bloom (A Flower House Mystery #1) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook
Cover of Peking Duck and Cover (Noodle Shop Mystery, #10) by Vivien Chien

31. Peking Duck and Cover (Noodle Shop Mystery, #10)

By: Vivien Chien

4.12

Format: 304 pages, Mass Market Paperback

Lana Lee and friends return for a fiery Chinese New Year celebration that rattles their quaint comm… read more

Similar categories in Vivien Chien's Peking Duck and Cover (Noodle Shop Mystery, #10) book and Amy Lillard's Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1)

  • mystery thriller
  • cozy mystery
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • adult
  • audiobook

29 must-read fiction books like Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder (Main Street Book Club Mysteries #1) by Amy Lillard

Transform Your Habits

A Knit before Dying (Tangled Web Mystery, #2)

Sadie Hartwell

3.77

Transform Your Habits

Death by Coffee

Alex Erickson

3.59

Transform Your Habits

Murder at the Blueberry Festival (Beacon Bakeshop, #3)

Darci Hannah

4.23

Transform Your Habits

A Limited Edition Murder (Beyond the Page Bookstore Mystery, #10)

Lauren Elliott

4.27

View all the books

21 must-read fiction books like Pint of No Return (Shake Shop #1) by Dana Mentink

Transform Your Habits

Murder at the Blueberry Festival (Beacon Bakeshop, #3)

Darci Hannah

4.23

Transform Your Habits

No Good Tea Goes Unpunished (Seaside Café Mystery, #2)

Bree Baker

4.02

Transform Your Habits

Live and Let Chai (Seaside Café Mystery, #1)

Bree Baker

3.93

Transform Your Habits

Tide and Punishment (Seaside Café Mystery, #3)

Bree Baker

4.10

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.