21 best-selling reverse harem books like Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players) by Grace McGinty

Cover of Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players) by Grace McGinty

Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

By: Grace McGinty

4.07

Format: 337 pages, Kindle Edition

My name is Nova Stone and I was a ghost in my own life until a knock at the door changed my whole w…

If you liked the reverse harem plot in Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players) by Grace McGinty , here is a list of 21 books like this:

Cover of Packed In The Penalty Box (Pucking Alphas, #1) by Melissa Huxley

1. Packed In The Penalty Box (Pucking Alphas, #1)

By: Melissa Huxley

3.99

Format: 382 pages, Kindle Edition

Molly always pictured herself as a one alpha kind of omega. University life suited her: books an… read more

Similar categories in Melissa Huxley's Packed In The Penalty Box (Pucking Alphas, #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • hockey
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of Plus Two (The Omega Exchange, #3) by Jillian West

2. Plus Two (The Omega Exchange, #3)

By: Jillian West

4.16

Format: 386 pages, Kindle Edition

Melody Webber spent ten years waiting for bonds and babies, but she learned the hard way that her e… read more

Similar categories in Jillian West's Plus Two (The Omega Exchange, #3) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • menage
Cover of Unbreak Me by Reese Rivers

3. Unbreak Me

By: Reese Rivers

4.05

Format: 406 pages, Kindle Edition

There’s ninety two dollars and fifty seven cents hidden in a Ziploc bag in the lining of the couch … read more

Similar categories in Reese Rivers's Unbreak Me book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • polyamory
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Knot Your Damn Omega (Slate City Omegaverse, #1) by Devyn Sinclair

4. Knot Your Damn Omega (Slate City Omegaverse, #1)

By: Devyn Sinclair

4.11

Format: 524 pages, Kindle Edition

She’s famous, beautiful, and the one Omega who’s name everyone knows. She’s my twin sister. Everyon… read more

Similar categories in Devyn Sinclair's Knot Your Damn Omega (Slate City Omegaverse, #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
Cover of Knot Her Goal (MVP: Most Valuable Pack, #1) by Ari Wright

5. Knot Her Goal (MVP: Most Valuable Pack, #1)

By: Ari Wright

4.10

Format: 446 pages, Kindle Edition

They are pro-sports’ Most Valuable Pack. One spoiled quarterback, a dominant billionaire, an all-p… read more

Similar categories in Ari Wright's Knot Her Goal (MVP: Most Valuable Pack, #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of A Pack for Christmas (The Omega Exchange, #1) by Jillian West

6. A Pack for Christmas (The Omega Exchange, #1)

By: Jillian West

4.26

Format: 272 pages, Kindle Edition

The Omega Exchange: The Lodge #1 Three years ago, Everly Chastain headed home for Christmas with… read more

Similar categories in Jillian West's A Pack for Christmas (The Omega Exchange, #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
Cover of Out of Options by Jillian West

7. Out of Options

By: Jillian West

4.24

Format: 338 pages, Kindle Edition

Not all alphas are good men. Charlie learned that lesson the hard way. After losing her daughter's… read more

Similar categories in Jillian West's Out of Options book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • menage
Cover of Knot All that Glitters (Slate City Omegaverse, #2) by Devyn Sinclair

8. Knot All that Glitters (Slate City Omegaverse, #2)

By: Devyn Sinclair

4.18

Format: 468 pages, Kindle Edition

All she ever wanted was a quiet life doing what she loved. Her family had other plans. Being the… read more

Similar categories in Devyn Sinclair's Knot All that Glitters (Slate City Omegaverse, #2) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
Cover of Give Me Peace by M.K. Harper

9. Give Me Peace

By: M.K. Harper

4.13

Format: 587 pages, Kindle Edition

Did you know, roughly twenty-seven percent of child abductions are carried-out by an acquaintance o… read more

Similar categories in M.K. Harper's Give Me Peace book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • polyamory
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
Cover of Dance Butterfly Dance (Masked Duet, #1) by Reese Rivers

10. Dance Butterfly Dance (Masked Duet, #1)

By: Reese Rivers

4.32

Format: 449 pages, Kindle Edition

A contemporary why choose romance set in the third year of university. Multi POV, multiple love int… read more

Similar categories in Reese Rivers's Dance Butterfly Dance (Masked Duet, #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of Burn Butterfly Burn (Masked Duet, #2) by Reese Rivers

11. Burn Butterfly Burn (Masked Duet, #2)

By: Reese Rivers

4.18

Format: 396 pages, Kindle Edition

Secrets and lies rang through the night The Butterfly took wing and flew out of sight Ragged … read more

Similar categories in Reese Rivers's Burn Butterfly Burn (Masked Duet, #2) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of Not Many Options by Jillian West

12. Not Many Options

By: Jillian West

4.22

Format: 320 pages, Kindle Edition

Riley Thomas has made some mistakes in life. She took a few wrong turns and has no idea what to do … read more

Similar categories in Jillian West's Not Many Options book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • menage
"Men are handy to lift shit and kill spiders, but they aren't necessary to be happy."

-Jillian West, Not Many Options

"Biology doesn't necessarily make a family. Giving love, being there no matter what, putting up with those terrible teenage years despite the kid's shitty attitude… All those things are what defines a…"

-Jillian West, Not Many Options

"You're a great mom. No matter who else they have in their lives they'll always love you in a completely different way than anyone else. You survived in triage mode for too long. Everything that had t…"

-Jillian West, Not Many Options

Cover of Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players) by Grace McGinty

13. Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

By: Grace McGinty

4.07

Format: 337 pages, Kindle Edition

My name is Nova Stone and I was a ghost in my own life until a knock at the door changed my whole w… read more

Similar categories in Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • polyamory
  • hockey
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • sports
  • sports romance
  • contemporary
  • menage
  • m f romance
Cover of Captivate (Knot Their Omega, #1) by E.J. Lawson

14. Captivate (Knot Their Omega, #1)

By: E.J. Lawson

3.96

Format: 338 pages, Kindle Edition

I don’t need a pack. I’m doing just fine on my own. Until one tiny mistake has me perfuming enou… read more

Similar categories in E.J. Lawson's Captivate (Knot Their Omega, #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
"Come on, I’ll pour you some special Omega tea. It’s made with oppression and tears."

-E.J. Lawson, Captivate (Knot Their Omega, #1)

Cover of One Pucked Up Pack (Pucked Up Omegaverse, #1) by Sarah   Blue

15. One Pucked Up Pack (Pucked Up Omegaverse, #1)

By: Sarah Blue

3.94

Format: 434 pages, Kindle Edition

Winter break wasn’t supposed to turn into a whirlwind romance for Charlotte Hodges. She finds her d… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Blue's One Pucked Up Pack (Pucked Up Omegaverse, #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • hockey
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of Knot Her Shot (MVP: Most Valuable Pack, #2) by Ari Wright

16. Knot Her Shot (MVP: Most Valuable Pack, #2)

By: Ari Wright

4.15

Format: 476 pages, Kindle Edition

What do you get when you put a happy-go-lucky hockey star, a controlling CEO, and a grumpy goalie t… read more

Similar categories in Ari Wright's Knot Her Shot (MVP: Most Valuable Pack, #2) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • polyamory
  • hockey
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of He's So Slick (Knot Pucking Mine Omegaverse, #1) by Sinclair Kelly

17. He's So Slick (Knot Pucking Mine Omegaverse, #1)

By: Sinclair Kelly

4.03

Format: 318 pages, Kindle Edition

This Omega doesn’t do drama, drugs, or hockey players. The first two for obvious reasons. The last … read more

Similar categories in Sinclair Kelly's He's So Slick (Knot Pucking Mine Omegaverse, #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • hockey
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of Knot Guaranteed (Ruined Records: Chicago #1) by Jillian West

18. Knot Guaranteed (Ruined Records: Chicago #1)

By: Jillian West

4.24

Format: 364 pages, Kindle Edition

Tinley Rhodes is an anomaly. Despite her anatomy and pheromones, she still hasn’t had a heat, meani… read more

Similar categories in Jillian West's Knot Guaranteed (Ruined Records: Chicago #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
Cover of Pack Plus Three (Pucking Pregnant, #1) by Melissa Huxley

19. Pack Plus Three (Pucking Pregnant, #1)

By: Melissa Huxley

3.92

Format: 326 pages, Kindle Edition

He’s the famous hockey player, and I’m the pregnant Omega next door… My past was filled with mis… read more

Similar categories in Melissa Huxley's Pack Plus Three (Pucking Pregnant, #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • hockey
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports
Cover of On Thin Ice (The Seattle Omegas, #1) by Calliope Stewart

20. On Thin Ice (The Seattle Omegas, #1)

By: Calliope Stewart

4.13

Format: 421 pages, Kindle Edition

The Winter Olympics in Oslo, Norway were amazing, with athletes coming from all over the world to c… read more

Similar categories in Calliope Stewart's On Thin Ice (The Seattle Omegas, #1) book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • hockey
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • sports romance
  • contemporary
  • menage
  • sports
Cover of Pucking the Players by Jarica James

21. Pucking the Players

By: Jarica James

3.87

Format: 232 pages, Kindle Edition

She thought her heart was frozen for good, too bad these hockey players are experts on ice. After M… read more

Similar categories in Jarica James's Pucking the Players book and Grace McGinty's Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players)

  • romance
  • polyamory
  • hockey
  • contemporary romance
  • reverse harem
  • contemporary
  • sports romance
  • sports

21 Top contemporary books like Sticks and Stone (Penalty Box Players) by Grace McGinty

Transform Your Habits

Packed In The Penalty Box (Pucking Alphas, #1)

Melissa Huxley

3.99

Transform Your Habits

Plus Two (The Omega Exchange, #3)

Jillian West

4.16

Transform Your Habits

Unbreak Me

Reese Rivers

4.05

Transform Your Habits

Knot Your Damn Omega (Slate City Omegaverse, #1)

Devyn Sinclair

4.11

View all the books

15 must-read contemporary books like Knot Her Shot (MVP: Most Valuable Pack, #2) by Ari Wright

Transform Your Habits

Packed In The Penalty Box (Pucking Alphas, #1)

Melissa Huxley

3.99

Transform Your Habits

Knot Just Their Nanny

Eve Newton

3.74

Transform Your Habits

Queen of Spades (High Roller Omegas)

Jillian West

4.27

Transform Your Habits

Knot Her Shot (MVP: Most Valuable Pack, #2)

Ari Wright

4.15

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.