27 best-selling fiction books like Those Who Prey by Jennifer Moffett

Cover of Those Who Prey by Jennifer Moffett

Those Who Prey

By: Jennifer Moffett

3.50

Format: 416 pages, Hardcover

Sadie meets The Girls in this riveting debut psychological thriller about a lonely college freshman…

If you liked the fiction plot in Those Who Prey by Jennifer Moffett , here is a list of 27 books like this:

Cover of The Cemetery Boys by Heather Brewer, Z Brewer

1. The Cemetery Boys

By: Heather Brewer , Z Brewer

3.19

Format: 288 pages, Hardcover

When Stephen is forced to move back to the nowhere town where his father grew up, he’s already sure… read more

Similar categories in Heather Brewer's The Cemetery Boys book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
"I swallowed hard. It was my life. And it was my choice how I decided to live it."

-Heather Brewer, The Cemetery Boys

"We were the new people here. We weren’t part of their group. We had to prove ourselves."

-Heather Brewer, The Cemetery Boys

Cover of I Hate Everyone But You (I Hate Everyone But You, #1) by Gaby Dunn, Allison Raskin

2. I Hate Everyone But You (I Hate Everyone But You, #1)

By: Gaby Dunn , Allison Raskin

3.47

Format: 344 pages, Hardcover

Gaby Dunn and Allison Raskin’s I Hate Everyone But You is a hilarious and heartfelt debut novel abo… read more

Similar categories in Gaby Dunn's I Hate Everyone But You (I Hate Everyone But You, #1) book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • fiction
  • new adult
  • young adult
  • contemporary
"I don't subscribe to labels. Unless I'm labeling other people."

-Gaby Dunn, I Hate Everyone But You (I Hate Everyone But You, #1)

Cover of The Sacred Lies of Minnow Bly by Stephanie Oakes

3. The Sacred Lies of Minnow Bly

By: Stephanie Oakes

3.95

Format: 400 pages, Kindle Edition

With a harrowing poetic voice, this contemporary page-turner is perfect for fans of Laurie Halse An… read more

Similar categories in Stephanie Oakes's The Sacred Lies of Minnow Bly book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • cults
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
"That’s all religion is. Strategy."

-Stephanie Oakes, The Sacred Lies of Minnow Bly

"Growing up, I believed in miracles. I guess I don’t anymore."

-Stephanie Oakes, The Sacred Lies of Minnow Bly

"When I lost my son, I became a citizen of a country I never knew existed."

-Stephanie Oakes, The Sacred Lies of Minnow Bly

"Jude taught me what love was: to be willing to hold on to another person's pain. That's it."

-Stephanie Oakes, The Sacred Lies of Minnow Bly

4. Underwater

By: Marisa Reichardt

4.18

Format: None pages, Hardcover

"Forgiving you will allow me to forgive myself." Morgan didn't mean to do anything wrong that day. … read more

Similar categories in Marisa Reichardt's Underwater book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

Cover of This Wretched Valley by Jenny Kiefer

5. This Wretched Valley

By: Jenny Kiefer

3.33

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

Four ambitious climbers hike into the Kentucky wilderness. Seven months later, three mangled bodies… read more

Similar categories in Jenny Kiefer's This Wretched Valley book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of Our Last Echoes by Kate Alice Marshall

6. Our Last Echoes

By: Kate Alice Marshall

3.56

Format: 394 pages, Hardcover

A supernatural thriller about one girl's hunt for the truth about her mother's disappearance. So… read more

Similar categories in Kate Alice Marshall's Our Last Echoes book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The One That Got Away with Murder by Trish Lundy

7. The One That Got Away with Murder

By: Trish Lundy

3.77

Format: 382 pages, Kindle Edition

Be careful who you fall for... Robbie and Trevor Cresmont have a body count—the killer kind. Han… read more

Similar categories in Trish Lundy's The One That Got Away with Murder book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
"Until something crashes down around us, and he's screaming. I inhale ash. His burning skin. His burning hair. It suffocates me."

-Trish Lundy, The One That Got Away with Murder

"We write one thing we're going to leave behind in the old season and then we burn it. We start off every year with a clean slate."

-Trish Lundy, The One That Got Away with Murder

"Suddenly, everything around me is on fire. I lurch forward, stumbling because I'm drunk. Sweating because it's hot as hell. The smoke is black as night and I can't see anything. Then I feel his hand,…"

-Trish Lundy, The One That Got Away with Murder

Cover of The Mary Shelley Club by Goldy Moldavsky

8. The Mary Shelley Club

By: Goldy Moldavsky

3.92

Format: 468 pages, Hardcover

New girl Rachel Chavez is eager to make a fresh start at Manchester Prep. But as one of the few sch… read more

Similar categories in Goldy Moldavsky's The Mary Shelley Club book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
"Fear is where the truth lies."

-Goldy Moldavsky, The Mary Shelley Club

"He's the Stu to my Billy Loomis"

-Goldy Moldavsky, The Mary Shelley Club

"If you want this to be over, just make sure she screams."

-Goldy Moldavsky, The Mary Shelley Club

"We were staked out at the playground across the street, an optimal vantage for us to watch the house, and for me to watch Bram watch his girlfriend get scared."

-Goldy Moldavsky, The Mary Shelley Club

Cover of The Feast Makers (The Scapegracers, #3) by H.A. Clarke

9. The Feast Makers (The Scapegracers, #3)

By: H.A. Clarke

4.39

Format: 416 pages, Hardcover

The Craft for Gen The Feast Makers , indie bestselling author H. A. Clarke crafts an action-packed… read more

Similar categories in H.A. Clarke's The Feast Makers (The Scapegracers, #3) book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • young adult
Cover of Don't Breathe a Word by Jordyn Taylor

10. Don't Breathe a Word

By: Jordyn Taylor

3.84

Format: 352 pages, Hardcover

Present Day: Eva has never felt like she belonged... not in her own family or with her friends in … read more

Similar categories in Jordyn Taylor's Don't Breathe a Word book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • contemporary
Cover of All Eyes on Her by Laurie Elizabeth Flynn

11. All Eyes on Her

By: Laurie Elizabeth Flynn

3.71

Format: 384 pages, Hardcover

Perfect for fans of One of Us is Lying and We Were Liars, All Eyes on Her by L.E. Flynn is a grippi… read more

Similar categories in Laurie Elizabeth Flynn's All Eyes on Her book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
"Everyone says boys will be boys, but girls? Girls will be monsters."

-Laurie Elizabeth Flynn, All Eyes on Her

"She's her full height, confidence sweeping behind her like the train of a wedding dress."

-Laurie Elizabeth Flynn, All Eyes on Her

"We're girls, Elle. We make one wrong move, and we're villains. There's no in between. We never had it both ways."

-Laurie Elizabeth Flynn, All Eyes on Her

"When you're a girl, you have to scream to get anybody's attention. And even then, all they want you to do is shut up."

-Laurie Elizabeth Flynn, All Eyes on Her

Cover of Very Bad People by Kit Frick

12. Very Bad People

By: Kit Frick

3.38

Format: 416 pages, Hardcover

In this dark academia young adult thriller for fans of The Female of the Species and People Like Us… read more

Similar categories in Kit Frick's Very Bad People book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of The Ballad of Darcy and Russell by Morgan Matson

13. The Ballad of Darcy and Russell

By: Morgan Matson

3.88

Format: 400 pages, Hardcover

Darcy believes in love at first sight. Even though it’s never happened to her, she’s spent her whol… read more

Similar categories in Morgan Matson's The Ballad of Darcy and Russell book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Marble Queen by Anna Kopp

14. The Marble Queen

By: Anna Kopp

3.62

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

The Marble Queen is a YA Fantasy graphic novel that’s the political drama of Nimona meets the heart… read more

Similar categories in Anna Kopp's The Marble Queen book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • fiction
  • young adult
"I’m not the strong, brave queen Iliad deserves."

-Anna Kopp, The Marble Queen

"It seems so natural. Like she’s done it a hundred times. Does she prefer dancing with women? I thought this marriage was only an arrangement. And if I’m right and it is, then why do I feel so strange?"

-Anna Kopp, The Marble Queen

Cover of Those Who Prey by Jennifer Moffett

15. Those Who Prey

By: Jennifer Moffett

3.50

Format: 416 pages, Hardcover

Sadie meets The Girls in this riveting debut psychological thriller about a lonely college freshman… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • cults
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • contemporary
  • cult classics
  • new adult
Cover of The White Guy Dies First: 13 Scary Stories of Fear and Power by Terry J. Benton-Walker

16. The White Guy Dies First: 13 Scary Stories of Fear and Power

By: Terry J. Benton-Walker

3.89

Format: 306 pages, Hardcover

13 SCARY STORIES. 13 AUTHORS OF COLOR. 13 TIMES WE SURVIVED THE FIRST KILL. The White Guy Dies Fir… read more

Similar categories in Terry J. Benton-Walker's The White Guy Dies First: 13 Scary Stories of Fear and Power book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
  • young adult
Cover of Every Single Lie by Rachel Vincent

17. Every Single Lie

By: Rachel Vincent

3.97

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

In this gripping YA novel about social media bullying and half-truths, one girl's discovery of a de… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Vincent's Every Single Lie book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of All That Consumes Us by Erica Waters

18. All That Consumes Us

By: Erica Waters

3.75

Format: 416 pages, Hardcover

Ninth House meets The Dead and the Dark in this gothic dark academia novel that delves into the hum… read more

Similar categories in Erica Waters's All That Consumes Us book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • young adult
"We are like a mockery to the dead-so young and so alive, our blood beating hot and excited in our veins. If the roles were reversed and it were me who lay beneath the earth, beneath this thoughtless …"

-Erica Waters, All That Consumes Us

Cover of All Eyes on Us by Kit Frick

19. All Eyes on Us

By: Kit Frick

3.52

Format: 384 pages, Hardcover

Pretty Little Liars meets People Like Us in this taut, tense thriller about two teens who find the… read more

Similar categories in Kit Frick's All Eyes on Us book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of After the Ink Dries by Cassie Gustafson

20. After the Ink Dries

By: Cassie Gustafson

4.18

Format: 416 pages, Hardcover

What does it mean when you thought you knew someone? What does it mean when that person is your new… read more

Similar categories in Cassie Gustafson's After the Ink Dries book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery
  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Go Hunt Me by Kelly deVos

21. Go Hunt Me

By: Kelly deVos

3.23

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

For Dracula lovers and fans of Diana Urban’s All Your Twisted Secrets, this spine-tingling thriller… read more

Similar categories in Kelly deVos's Go Hunt Me book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
"I think that's what attracted me to horror films. The best scary movies were about people who faced their demons and emerged as something different."

-Kelly deVos, Go Hunt Me

Cover of Sometime After Midnight by L.  Philips

22. Sometime After Midnight

By: L. Philips

3.73

Format: 385 pages, Hardcover

#AlexFromTarget meets queer Prince Charming in this glittering romcom following a teen music prodig… read more

Similar categories in L. Philips's Sometime After Midnight book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Four for the Road by K.J. Reilly

23. Four for the Road

By: K.J. Reilly

4.08

Format: 288 pages, Hardcover

The Perks of Being a Wallflower meets The End of the F***ing World in this dark young adult comedy … read more

Similar categories in K.J. Reilly's Four for the Road book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of Scout's Honor by Lily  Anderson

24. Scout's Honor

By: Lily Anderson

3.79

Format: 416 pages, Hardcover

Prudence Perry is a third-generation Ladybird Scout who must battle literal (and figurative) monste… read more

Similar categories in Lily Anderson's Scout's Honor book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Breakup Lists by Adib Khorram

25. The Breakup Lists

By: Adib Khorram

3.92

Format: 336 pages, Hardcover

Love is more complicated than “boy meets boy” in bestselling author Adib Khorram’s sharply funny ne… read more

Similar categories in Adib Khorram's The Breakup Lists book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • fiction
  • young adult
  • contemporary
Cover of I Was a Teenage Slasher by Stephen Graham Jones

26. I Was a Teenage Slasher

By: Stephen Graham Jones

3.68

Format: 373 pages, Hardcover

From New York Times bestselling horror writer Stephen Graham Jones comes a classic slasher story wi… read more

Similar categories in Stephen Graham Jones's I Was a Teenage Slasher book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • fiction
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of Looking for Smoke by K.A. Cobell

27. Looking for Smoke

By: K.A. Cobell

4.27

Format: 416 pages, Hardcover

Since moving to the Blackfeet Reservation with her parents, Mara Racette has felt like an outsider,… read more

Similar categories in K.A. Cobell's Looking for Smoke book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of Two Sides to Every Murder by Danielle Valentine

28. Two Sides to Every Murder

By: Danielle Valentine

3.67

Format: 282 pages, Hardcover

From the author of How to Survive Your Murder comes a propulsive thriller about two teens who retur… read more

Similar categories in Danielle Valentine's Two Sides to Every Murder book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery thriller
  • young adult
  • fiction
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
"Even strong people need to fall apart."

-Danielle Valentine, Two Sides to Every Murder

"You have to feel your feelings, even the unpleasant ones."

-Danielle Valentine, Two Sides to Every Murder

Cover of Baby & Solo by Lisabeth Posthuma

29. Baby & Solo

By: Lisabeth Posthuma

4.38

Format: 416 pages, Hardcover

Joel’s new job at the video store is just what the therapist ordered. But what happens if the first… read more

Similar categories in Lisabeth Posthuma's Baby & Solo book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • contemporary
  • fiction
  • young adult
  • historical fiction
Cover of Bad Graces by Kyrie McCauley

30. Bad Graces

By: Kyrie McCauley

3.79

Format: 320 pages, Hardcover

Yellowjackets meets House of Hollow in award-winning author Kyrie McCauley’s gripping and magical Y… read more

Similar categories in Kyrie McCauley's Bad Graces book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fiction
  • young adult
Cover of This Town is on Fire by Pamela N. Harris

31. This Town is on Fire

By: Pamela N. Harris

3.97

Format: 448 pages, Hardcover

From the critically acclaimed author of  When You Look Like Us  comes a page-turning YA contemporar… read more

Similar categories in Pamela N. Harris's This Town is on Fire book and Jennifer Moffett's Those Who Prey

  • young adult
  • contemporary

23 Top contemporary books like Those Who Prey by Jennifer Moffett

Transform Your Habits

The Cemetery Boys

Heather Brewer , Z Brewer

3.19

Transform Your Habits

I Hate Everyone But You (I Hate Everyone But You, #1)

Gaby Dunn , Allison Raskin

3.47

Transform Your Habits

The Sacred Lies of Minnow Bly

Stephanie Oakes

3.95

Transform Your Habits

This Wretched Valley

Jenny Kiefer

3.33

View all the books

27 Best fiction books like Sometime After Midnight by L. Philips

Transform Your Habits

A Boy Worth Knowing

Jennifer Cosgrove

3.88

Transform Your Habits

The Dangerous Art of Blending In

Angelo Surmelis

4.00

Been Here All Along

Sandy Hall

3.50

Transform Your Habits

Otherworldly

F.T. Lukens

3.99

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.