5 best-selling high school books like I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2) by Whitney G.

Cover of I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2) by Whitney G.

I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

By: Whitney G.

3.89

Format: 276 pages, Kindle Edition

I should've known better. I should've left her alone… She told me she was twenty-one. I found …

If you liked the high school plot in I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2) by Whitney G. , here is a list of 5 books like this:

Cover of Older by Jennifer Hartmann

1. Older

By: Jennifer Hartmann

4.13

Format: 436 pages, Kindle Edition

Before he discovered my age, he uncovered my heart. Bruised and abused, and victim to a loveless… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Hartmann's Older book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of Cold Hearted Casanova (Cruel Castaways, #3) by L.J. Shen

2. Cold Hearted Casanova (Cruel Castaways, #3)

By: L.J. Shen

4.30

Format: 422 pages, Kindle Edition

From USA Today bestselling author L.J. Shen comes a witty romance about a woman desperate to marry … read more

Similar categories in L.J. Shen's Cold Hearted Casanova (Cruel Castaways, #3) book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of My Anti-Hero by Tijan

3. My Anti-Hero

By: Tijan

4.12

Format: 534 pages, Kindle Edition

I shouldn't have agreed to this. What was I thinking?Appearing on a local news show? Just because s… read more

Similar categories in Tijan's My Anti-Hero book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Damaged Goods (All Saints High, #4) by L.J. Shen

4. Damaged Goods (All Saints High, #4)

By: L.J. Shen

4.01

Format: 418 pages, Kindle Edition

Underneath the goody two-shoes persona is damaged goods…but can the bad boy across the street save … read more

Similar categories in L.J. Shen's Damaged Goods (All Saints High, #4) book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of The Pieces We Try to Forget by Elle  Mitchell

5. The Pieces We Try to Forget

By: Elle Mitchell

4.32

Format: 201 pages, Kindle Edition

“But in the pit of my stomach, at the core of my being, I’m still holding onto ghosts. And I fear t… read more

Similar categories in Elle Mitchell's The Pieces We Try to Forget book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
Cover of What Happens at the Lake by Vi Keeland

6. What Happens at the Lake

By: Vi Keeland

4.20

Format: 355 pages, Paperback

When life took an unexpected turn, I decided to get out of New York for a while. What better place … read more

Similar categories in Vi Keeland's What Happens at the Lake book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Not Made to Last by Jay McLean

7. Not Made to Last

By: Jay McLean

4.15

Format: 364 pages, Kindle Edition

Two simple words hold the truth of our love: wait and hope. Olivia Rhys Garrett—recent high sch… read more

Similar categories in Jay McLean's Not Made to Last book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of Brutal Arrangement (Brutal Billionaires #3) by Laurelin Paige

8. Brutal Arrangement (Brutal Billionaires #3)

By: Laurelin Paige

4.16

Format: 462 pages, Kindle Edition

He can have any woman he wants. He wants his brother’s. Alex Sebastian is the billionaire who k… read more

Similar categories in Laurelin Paige's Brutal Arrangement (Brutal Billionaires #3) book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of I Thought of You by Jewel E. Ann

9. I Thought of You

By: Jewel E. Ann

4.46

Format: 335 pages, Kindle Edition

I wanted to conquer the world. She wanted to gaze at the stars. It’s been twelve years since I la… read more

Similar categories in Jewel E. Ann's I Thought of You book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of My Dark Desire (Dark Prince Road, #2) by L.J. Shen

10. My Dark Desire (Dark Prince Road, #2)

By: L.J. Shen

4.23

Format: 426 pages, Paperback

She’s his sweetest desire... and his darkest secret. The task was simple. Sneak into Potomac’s… read more

Similar categories in L.J. Shen's My Dark Desire (Dark Prince Road, #2) book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of The Surrogate by Penelope Ward

11. The Surrogate

By: Penelope Ward

4.21

Format: 335 pages, Kindle Edition

From New York Times bestselling author Penelope Ward comes a new, STANDALONE novel… ABBY I’m fa… read more

Similar categories in Penelope Ward's The Surrogate book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of The Lovely Return by Carian Cole

12. The Lovely Return

By: Carian Cole

4.34

Format: 524 pages, Kindle Edition

What if love can transcend time and death? When I was three years old, I started drawing a house… read more

Similar categories in Carian Cole's The Lovely Return book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
"The undercurrent of us is still there- still buzzing with buried secrets and longings that words are too weak to touch."

-Carian Cole, The Lovely Return

Cover of The Love You Fight For (Next Life #3) by Brit Benson

13. The Love You Fight For (Next Life #3)

By: Brit Benson

4.34

Format: 366 pages, Kindle Edition

The mask she wears for the world is flawless.
 But I want the mess that she hides underneath. S… read more

Similar categories in Brit Benson's The Love You Fight For (Next Life #3) book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of You Promised Me Forever by L.A. Cotton

14. You Promised Me Forever

By: L.A. Cotton

3.77

Format: 396 pages, Kindle Edition

From bestselling author L A Cotton comes an emotional and angsty coming-of-age story about loss, lo… read more

Similar categories in L.A. Cotton's You Promised Me Forever book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of Eleven Eleven by Micalea Smeltzer

15. Eleven Eleven

By: Micalea Smeltzer

4.13

Format: 524 pages, Paperback

After my divorce, I decide to move across the country away from family and friends for a new start.… read more

Similar categories in Micalea Smeltzer's Eleven Eleven book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
"Fuck, look at us, angel. Look at the way your pussy grips my cock. It's like I belong inside you."

-Micalea Smeltzer, Eleven Eleven

Cover of Merciless (The Hartleys) by Valeria Heights

16. Merciless (The Hartleys)

By: Valeria Heights

3.81

Format: 331 pages, Kindle Edition

A complete, full-length standalone. Clementine Hartley is a cruel, merciless human being.She made … read more

Similar categories in Valeria Heights's Merciless (The Hartleys) book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary
Cover of The Pieces We Leave Behind (Lost Hollow, #1) by Elle  Mitchell

17. The Pieces We Leave Behind (Lost Hollow, #1)

By: Elle Mitchell

4.03

Format: 333 pages, Kindle Edition

"It gets easier…I know it hurts now, but one day, you'll wake up, and you'll just be okay. It'll ha… read more

Similar categories in Elle Mitchell's The Pieces We Leave Behind (Lost Hollow, #1) book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
Cover of I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2) by Whitney G.

18. I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

By: Whitney G.

3.89

Format: 276 pages, Kindle Edition

I should've known better. I should've left her alone… She told me she was twenty-one. I found … read more

Similar categories in Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2) book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • high school
  • young adult
  • contemporary
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
Cover of Mr. Raredin by Shana Vanterpool

19. Mr. Raredin

By: Shana Vanterpool

3.93

Format: 281 pages, Kindle Edition

Lace My mom cared about three things. And neither one of them were me. It’s the way things w… read more

Similar categories in Shana Vanterpool's Mr. Raredin book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • high school
Cover of The Professor (Tanglewood University, #1) by Skye Warren

20. The Professor (Tanglewood University, #1)

By: Skye Warren

3.94

Format: 366 pages, Kindle Edition

New York Times bestselling author Skye Warren, delivers the sizzling first book in a brand new tril… read more

Similar categories in Skye Warren's The Professor (Tanglewood University, #1) book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • new adult
  • contemporary
"It reminds me that we're all fighting here, even as we smile and study and behave like good little girls. Like Juliet. We're all fighting to control our own destinies. Even if it ends in tragedy."

-Skye Warren, The Professor (Tanglewood University, #1)

Cover of The Rocker's Muse by Penelope Ward

21. The Rocker's Muse

By: Penelope Ward

4.25

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

From New York Times bestselling author Penelope Ward comes a new, STANDALONE novel… No one but m… read more

Similar categories in Penelope Ward's The Rocker's Muse book and Whitney G.'s I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2)

  • romance
  • contemporary romance
  • contemporary

19 must-read contemporary books like I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You (Forbidden Wishes #2) by Whitney G.

Transform Your Habits

Older

Jennifer Hartmann

4.13

Transform Your Habits

Cold Hearted Casanova (Cruel Castaways, #3)

L.J. Shen

4.30

Transform Your Habits

My Anti-Hero

Tijan

4.12

Transform Your Habits

Damaged Goods (All Saints High, #4)

L.J. Shen

4.01

View all the books

8 must-read fiction books like Eleven Eleven by Micalea Smeltzer

Transform Your Habits

The Season of Secrets (Secrets, #1)

Q.B. Tyler

3.89

Transform Your Habits

Stay With Me (Sugarland Creek, #2)

Brooke Montgomery

4.00

Transform Your Habits

Crossroads (Haven River Ranch, #1)

Devney Perry

4.20

Transform Your Habits

The Love You Fight For (Next Life #3)

Brit Benson

4.34

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.