15 Best mystery books like Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2) by Janice Thompson

Cover of Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2) by Janice  Thompson

Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

By: Janice Thompson

3.98

Format: 272 pages, Hardcover

When Priscilla discovers an inscribed World War I sword hidden behind a painting on her bedroom wal…

If you liked the mystery plot in Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2) by Janice Thompson , here is a list of 15 books like this:

Cover of Whispers Through the Trees (Mysteries of Sparrow Island #1) by Susan Plunkett, Krysteen Seelen

1. Whispers Through the Trees (Mysteries of Sparrow Island #1)

By: Susan Plunkett , Krysteen Seelen

3.60

Format: 404 pages, Paperback

Abby Stanton, a noted East Coast bird specialist, rushes home to the magnificent San Jan Islands in… read more

Similar categories in Susan Plunkett's Whispers Through the Trees (Mysteries of Sparrow Island #1) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
  • cozy mystery

2. Mandie and the Secret Tunnel (Mandie, #1)

By: Lois Gladys Leppard

3.17

Format: 120 pages, Paperback

Mandie Shaw, almost a teenager, is certain God no longer loves her as she watches her father being … read more

Similar categories in Lois Gladys Leppard's Mandie and the Secret Tunnel (Mandie, #1) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

3. The Inn at Ocean's Edge (Sunset Cove, #1)

By: Colleen Coble

3.87

Format: 252 pages, Paperback

Claire's visit to a luxury hotel in Maine awakens repressed memories, threatening all she holds dea… read more

Similar categories in Colleen Coble's The Inn at Ocean's Edge (Sunset Cove, #1) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

Cover of Nowhere to Turn (Hidden Identity, #2) by Lynette Eason

4. Nowhere to Turn (Hidden Identity, #2)

By: Lynette Eason

4.35

Format: 316 pages, Paperback

The day Danielle Harding takes her 11-year-old son, Simon, and flees from her abusive husband, is t… read more

Similar categories in Lynette Eason's Nowhere to Turn (Hidden Identity, #2) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
Cover of No Place to Hide (Hidden Identity, #3) by Lynette Eason

5. No Place to Hide (Hidden Identity, #3)

By: Lynette Eason

4.36

Format: 332 pages, Paperback

It's not every day you see your childhood friend and one-time crush on national news. Jackie Seller… read more

Similar categories in Lynette Eason's No Place to Hide (Hidden Identity, #3) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction

6. If I'm Found (If I Run #2)

By: Terri Blackstock

4.00

Format: 212 pages, Paperback

Is Dylan hunting Casey to prosecute her or protect her? Casey Cox is still on the run, fleeing pros… read more

Similar categories in Terri Blackstock's If I'm Found (If I Run #2) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

7. If I Run (If I Run, #1)

By: Terri Blackstock

1.75

Format: 134 pages, Paperback

Casey knows the truth. But it won't set her free. Casey Cox's DNA is all over the crime scene. Ther… read more

Similar categories in Terri Blackstock's If I Run (If I Run, #1) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

Cover of Impending Strike (Elite Guardians Collection, #2) by Lynette Eason

8. Impending Strike (Elite Guardians Collection, #2)

By: Lynette Eason

4.43

Format: 298 pages, Paperback

Protecting him just might cost her everything… Elite Guardian Charlie Lee knows that there is no… read more

Similar categories in Lynette Eason's Impending Strike (Elite Guardians Collection, #2) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
Cover of Murder in the Tea Leaves (A Tea Shop Mystery, #27) by Laura Childs

9. Murder in the Tea Leaves (A Tea Shop Mystery, #27)

By: Laura Childs

3.94

Format: 291 pages, Kindle Edition

It’s Lights, Action, Murder as tea maven Theodosia Browning scrambles for clues in this latest inst… read more

Similar categories in Laura Childs's Murder in the Tea Leaves (A Tea Shop Mystery, #27) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Museum of Lost Quilts (Elm Creek Quilts, #22) by Jennifer Chiaverini

10. The Museum of Lost Quilts (Elm Creek Quilts, #22)

By: Jennifer Chiaverini

4.11

Format: 307 pages, Hardcover

Jennifer Chiaverini’s beloved and bestselling Elm Creek Quilts series returns with the first Elm Cr… read more

Similar categories in Jennifer Chiaverini's The Museum of Lost Quilts (Elm Creek Quilts, #22) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

Cover of Life Flight (Extreme Measures, #1) by Lynette Eason

11. Life Flight (Extreme Measures, #1)

By: Lynette Eason

4.20

Format: 336 pages, Paperback

EMS helicopter pilot Penny Carlton is used to high stress situations, but being forced to land on a… read more

Similar categories in Lynette Eason's Life Flight (Extreme Measures, #1) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
Cover of The Sisters of Sea View (On Devonshire Shores, #1) by Julie Klassen

12. The Sisters of Sea View (On Devonshire Shores, #1)

By: Julie Klassen

4.19

Format: 448 pages, Paperback

When their father's death leaves them impoverished, Sarah Summers convinces her sisters to open the… read more

Similar categories in Julie Klassen's The Sisters of Sea View (On Devonshire Shores, #1) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • christian fiction
"A solitary soul can do little. But together...what lasting beauty we create."

-Julie Klassen, The Sisters of Sea View (On Devonshire Shores, #1)

"Of course the disease was not your fault, " Mr. Hornbeam said more softly. "But we choose how we respond to life's misfortunes."

-Julie Klassen, The Sisters of Sea View (On Devonshire Shores, #1)

Cover of If I Live (If I Run, #3) by Terri Blackstock

13. If I Live (If I Run, #3)

By: Terri Blackstock

4.36

Format: 352 pages, Kindle Edition

Casey is hiding again—in Memphis this time—but it’s different now. She knows without a doubt that D… read more

Similar categories in Terri Blackstock's If I Live (If I Run, #3) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
Cover of In This Moment (Timeless, #2) by Gabrielle  Meyer

14. In This Moment (Timeless, #2)

By: Gabrielle Meyer

4.48

Format: 416 pages, Paperback

Maggie inherited a gift from her time-crossing parents that allows her to live three separate lives… read more

Similar categories in Gabrielle Meyer's In This Moment (Timeless, #2) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • christian fiction
Cover of Just for the Summer by Melody Carlson

15. Just for the Summer

By: Melody Carlson

3.49

Format: 288 pages, Paperback

Ginny Masters manages a popular boutique hotel in Seattle and manages it with aplomb. But the daily… read more

Similar categories in Melody Carlson's Just for the Summer book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • christian fiction
Cover of Murder in the Storybook Cottage (Book Retreat Mysteries, #6) by Ellery Adams

16. Murder in the Storybook Cottage (Book Retreat Mysteries, #6)

By: Ellery Adams

4.15

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

In the sixth Book Retreat Mystery by New York Times bestselling author Ellery Adams, resort owner J… read more

Similar categories in Ellery Adams's Murder in the Storybook Cottage (Book Retreat Mysteries, #6) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
  • murder mystery
Cover of Dreadful by Caitlin Rozakis

17. Dreadful

By: Caitlin Rozakis

3.72

Format: 347 pages, Paperback

A sharp-witted, high fantasy farce featuring killer moat squid, toxic masculinity, evil wizards and… read more

Similar categories in Caitlin Rozakis's Dreadful book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
"Gug." Ah, monosyllables, his old friend. They would always be there, even when all other concepts of fundamental liguistics deserted him."

-Caitlin Rozakis, Dreadful

"It occured to him that a spell to make one's enemies into idiots via the power of breasts might be immensely helpful. Then again, it might not be a spell. It might have only been the breasts."

-Caitlin Rozakis, Dreadful

Cover of The Thief of Lanwyn Manor (Cornwall, #2) by Sarah E. Ladd

18. The Thief of Lanwyn Manor (Cornwall, #2)

By: Sarah E. Ladd

3.99

Format: 352 pages, Paperback

In Regency England an advantageous match could set up a lady for life. Julia knows Matthew Blake, c… read more

Similar categories in Sarah E. Ladd's The Thief of Lanwyn Manor (Cornwall, #2) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
"The heart freely given is a heart that is open to pain. But it is also open to the joys."

-Sarah E. Ladd, The Thief of Lanwyn Manor (Cornwall, #2)

"Isaac-you possess a maturity beyond your years. I tell you this not to puff your pride, but rather to increase your awareness of it. If the only way we respond to anger is with our fist, the balance …"

-Sarah E. Ladd, The Thief of Lanwyn Manor (Cornwall, #2)

Cover of Wildfire (Mysteries of Silver Peak #4) by Carole Jefferson

19. Wildfire (Mysteries of Silver Peak #4)

By: Carole Jefferson

4.20

Format: None pages, Hardcover

Sadie Speers’s friend Virginia asks her to help research the history of Silver Peak’s first schoolh… read more

Similar categories in Carole Jefferson's Wildfire (Mysteries of Silver Peak #4) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
Cover of Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2) by Janice  Thompson

20. Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

By: Janice Thompson

3.98

Format: 272 pages, Hardcover

When Priscilla discovers an inscribed World War I sword hidden behind a painting on her bedroom wal… read more

Similar categories in Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
  • cozy mystery
  • murder mystery
Cover of Silver Surprise (Mysteries of Silver Peak #3) by Carole Jefferson

21. Silver Surprise (Mysteries of Silver Peak #3)

By: Carole Jefferson

4.14

Format: 250 pages, Hardcover

2014 Guideposts hardcover, Carole Jefferson (Nobody's Safe). Welcome to Silver Peak, a jewel of a t… read more

Similar categories in Carole Jefferson's Silver Surprise (Mysteries of Silver Peak #3) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

Cover of The Light at Wyndcliff (Cornwall, #3) by Sarah E. Ladd

22. The Light at Wyndcliff (Cornwall, #3)

By: Sarah E. Ladd

4.09

Format: 320 pages, Paperback

In the third book of this sweet Regency Cornwall series, one young man must search for truth among … read more

Similar categories in Sarah E. Ladd's The Light at Wyndcliff (Cornwall, #3) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • christian fiction
Cover of Behind Love's Wall (Doors to the Past) by Carrie Fancett Pagels

23. Behind Love's Wall (Doors to the Past)

By: Carrie Fancett Pagels

3.82

Format: 315 pages, Kindle Edition

The Grand Hotel Slowly Reveals Her Secrets  Walk through Doors to the Past via a new series of hist… read more

Similar categories in Carrie Fancett Pagels's Behind Love's Wall (Doors to the Past) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • christian fiction
Cover of A Lode of Secrets by Carole Jefferson

24. A Lode of Secrets

By: Carole Jefferson

4.18

Format: 262 pages, Hardcover

Sadie Speers has been asked to act as a historical consultant for a TV series called American Treas… read more

Similar categories in Carole Jefferson's A Lode of Secrets book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • christian fiction
Cover of Time Will Tell by Carole Jefferson

25. Time Will Tell

By: Carole Jefferson

4.11

Format: 225 pages, Hardcover

When Silver Peak reopens an abandoned rail line as the Mountain Crest Railroad, it kicks off a week… read more

Similar categories in Carole Jefferson's Time Will Tell book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

Cover of A Code of Honor by Carole Jefferson

26. A Code of Honor

By: Carole Jefferson

4.06

Format: 276 pages, Hardcover

Part of the Mysteries of Silver Peak series. " Welcome to Silver Peak, a jewel of a town nestled hi… read more

Similar categories in Carole Jefferson's A Code of Honor book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of Tea is for Treasure (Tearoom Mysteries, #8) by Kristin Eckhardt

27. Tea is for Treasure (Tearoom Mysteries, #8)

By: Kristin Eckhardt

4.31

Format: 260 pages, ebook

As the first harbingers of spring reach the tearoom, so does an unexpected package. When the cousin… read more

Similar categories in Kristin Eckhardt's Tea is for Treasure (Tearoom Mysteries, #8) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Trouble Brewing (Tearoom Mysteries, #9) by Susan Page Davis

28. Trouble Brewing (Tearoom Mysteries, #9)

By: Susan Page Davis

4.17

Format: 291 pages, Hardcover

When Jan Blake and Elaine Cook arrive at Lancaster Community Church to prepare for the Mother Daugh… read more

Similar categories in Susan Page Davis's Trouble Brewing (Tearoom Mysteries, #9) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Mystery and Macarons (Tearoom Mystery, #10) by Elizabeth Adams

29. Mystery and Macarons (Tearoom Mystery, #10)

By: Elizabeth Adams

4.13

Format: 310 pages, Hardcover

When a Tea for Two patron’s wallet goes missing, the owners, Jan and Elaine, are determined to figu… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Adams's Mystery and Macarons (Tearoom Mystery, #10) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • mystery
  • cozy mystery
Cover of The Tea Will Tell (Tearoom Mysteries, #11) by Elizabeth Ludwig

30. The Tea Will Tell (Tearoom Mysteries, #11)

By: Elizabeth Ludwig

4.29

Format: 249 pages, Hardcover

In the height of Lake Chickadee’s tourist season, a spate of home invasion burglaries begins making… read more

Similar categories in Elizabeth Ludwig's The Tea Will Tell (Tearoom Mysteries, #11) book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

  • cozy mystery
Cover of Empty Saddle by Carole Jefferson

31. Empty Saddle

By: Carole Jefferson

4.17

Format: 261 pages, Hardcover

When Sadie Speer's granddaughter, Sara, goes horseback riding by herself, Daisy returns to the stab… read more

Similar categories in Carole Jefferson's Empty Saddle book and Janice Thompson's Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2)

15 best-selling christian fiction books like Like a Fish Out of Water (Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard, #2) by Janice Thompson

Transform Your Habits

Whispers Through the Trees (Mysteries of Sparrow Island #1)

Susan Plunkett , Krysteen Seelen

3.60

Transform Your Habits

Nowhere to Turn (Hidden Identity, #2)

Lynette Eason

4.35

Transform Your Habits

No Place to Hide (Hidden Identity, #3)

Lynette Eason

4.36

Transform Your Habits

Impending Strike (Elite Guardians Collection, #2)

Lynette Eason

4.43

View all the books

20 Top fiction books like Just for the Summer by Melody Carlson

Transform Your Habits

The Summer We Started Over

Nancy Thayer

4.00

Transform Your Habits

Summers at the Saint

Mary Kay Andrews

4.14

Transform Your Habits

The Roads We Follow (Fog Harbor, #2)

Nicole Deese

4.39

Transform Your Habits

Just for the Summer

Melody Carlson

3.49

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.