10 Top mystery books like The Isle of Sin and Shadows by Keri Lake

Cover of The Isle of Sin and Shadows by Keri Lake

The Isle of Sin and Shadows

By: Keri Lake

4.15

Format: 523 pages, Paperback

This island alone boasts more ghost stories than all of Louisiana combined. And I'm one of them.…

If you liked the mystery plot in The Isle of Sin and Shadows by Keri Lake , here is a list of 10 books like this:

Cover of Demon snów (W mrokach Luizjany, #2) by Ludka Skrzydlewska

1. Demon snów (W mrokach Luizjany, #2)

By: Ludka Skrzydlewska

3.58

Format: 408 pages, Paperback

Miłość, która rodzi się pomiędzy jawą a snem. Poznaj dalsze losy potężnych czarownic z serii W mrok… read more

Similar categories in Ludka Skrzydlewska's Demon snów (W mrokach Luizjany, #2) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Lovely Violent Things (Hollow's Row, #2) by Trisha Wolfe

2. Lovely Violent Things (Hollow's Row, #2)

By: Trisha Wolfe

4.12

Format: 332 pages, Kindle Edition

He’s the devil. And she’s his wicked game. Book two in the Hollow's Row series. The night I g… read more

Similar categories in Trisha Wolfe's Lovely Violent Things (Hollow's Row, #2) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • adult
"Overman. A ridiculous translation."

-Trisha Wolfe, Lovely Violent Things (Hollow's Row, #2)

Cover of Quicksilver (Fae & Alchemy, #1) by Callie Hart

3. Quicksilver (Fae & Alchemy, #1)

By: Callie Hart

4.46

Format: 588 pages, ebook

Do not touch the sword.Do not turn the key.Do not open the gate.In the land of the unforgiving dese… read more

Similar categories in Callie Hart's Quicksilver (Fae & Alchemy, #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • adult
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Nectar of the Wicked (Deadly Divine, #1) by Ella Fields

4. Nectar of the Wicked (Deadly Divine, #1)

By: Ella Fields

4.04

Format: 338 pages, Kindle Edition

There is no escaping the middle lands, the gloomy buffer between the human kingdom and the faerie r… read more

Similar categories in Ella Fields's Nectar of the Wicked (Deadly Divine, #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • dark
  • paranormal
  • adult
  • fantasy
"You will wish for nothing, butterfly. You will have every comfort you need, including the protection of my court in your precious search for this home you desire. Just be mindful that should you find…"

-Ella Fields, Nectar of the Wicked (Deadly Divine, #1)

Cover of Gothikana by RuNyx

5. Gothikana

By: RuNyx

3.84

Format: 456 pages, Kindle Edition

The eternal romance of Beauty and the Beast meets the gothic suspense of Dracula in this erotic dar… read more

Similar categories in RuNyx's Gothikana book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • dark
  • fantasy
  • mystery
  • adult
  • paranormal
"We shouldn’t be doing this,"

-RuNyx, Gothikana

"If this is madness,' she whispered almost against his lips, 'drown me in it."

-RuNyx, Gothikana

"And this mountain would crack before it let anything happen to your castle. Remember that."

-RuNyx, Gothikana

"I would’ve kissed you bathed in blood, Corvina. If I had a chance to kiss you while a thousand ghosts rose from their graves, I would have kissed you. Don’t doubt that."

-RuNyx, Gothikana

Cover of Lovely Bad Things (Hollow's Row, #1) by Trisha Wolfe

6. Lovely Bad Things (Hollow's Row, #1)

By: Trisha Wolfe

3.74

Format: 334 pages, Kindle Edition

He's the devil. And she's his wicked game. Halen: They say eyes are the windows to the soul—but… read more

Similar categories in Trisha Wolfe's Lovely Bad Things (Hollow's Row, #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • adult
  • fantasy
"To be revered, first, you go stark raving mad, then you exit this world in a blaze."

-Trisha Wolfe, Lovely Bad Things (Hollow's Row, #1)

Cover of A Ship of Bones & Teeth by Karina Halle

7. A Ship of Bones & Teeth

By: Karina Halle

3.81

Format: 442 pages, Kindle Edition

A standalone adult dark fantasy pirate romance re-telling of The Little Mermaid from the New York T… read more

Similar categories in Karina Halle's A Ship of Bones & Teeth book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • dark
  • paranormal
  • adult
  • fantasy
Cover of The Coven (Coven of Bones, #1) by Harper L. Woods

8. The Coven (Coven of Bones, #1)

By: Harper L. Woods

3.84

Format: 298 pages, Kindle Edition

Raised to be my father’s weapon against the Coven that took away his sister and his birthright, I w… read more

Similar categories in Harper L. Woods's The Coven (Coven of Bones, #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • dark
Cover of Blood Orange (The Dracula Duet, #1) by Karina Halle

9. Blood Orange (The Dracula Duet, #1)

By: Karina Halle

3.84

Format: 314 pages, Kindle Edition

From New York Times bestselling author Karina Halle comes a dark and delicious Dracula retelling fi… read more

Similar categories in Karina Halle's Blood Orange (The Dracula Duet, #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • dark
  • paranormal
  • adult
  • fantasy
"To anyone who has felt alienated, unappreciated and misunderstood: There’s nothing wrong with you. You just need to find your people."

-Karina Halle, Blood Orange (The Dracula Duet, #1)

Cover of Black Rose (The Dracula Duet, #2) by Karina Halle

10. Black Rose (The Dracula Duet, #2)

By: Karina Halle

3.73

Format: 408 pages, None

From the New York Times best-selling author of River of Shadows and Black Sunshine comes a new dark… read more

Similar categories in Karina Halle's Black Rose (The Dracula Duet, #2) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • dark
Cover of The Isle of Sin and Shadows by Keri Lake

11. The Isle of Sin and Shadows

By: Keri Lake

4.15

Format: 523 pages, Paperback

This island alone boasts more ghost stories than all of Louisiana combined. And I'm one of them.… read more

Similar categories in Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • gothic romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of The Cruel Dark by Bea Northwick

12. The Cruel Dark

By: Bea Northwick

4.18

Format: 226 pages, Hardcover

Millicent Foxboro is haunted. Not by ghosts but by the anguish of her past and the uncertainty o… read more

Similar categories in Bea Northwick's The Cruel Dark book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • gothic romance
  • dark
  • mystery
  • fantasy
Cover of The Cursed (Coven of Bones, #2) by Harper L. Woods

13. The Cursed (Coven of Bones, #2)

By: Harper L. Woods

3.69

Format: 324 pages, Kindle Edition

Betrayal. He was the deception waiting in the night; the truth I never saw coming. After a lifet… read more

Similar categories in Harper L. Woods's The Cursed (Coven of Bones, #2) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Bewitched (Bewitched, #1) by Laura Thalassa

14. Bewitched (Bewitched, #1)

By: Laura Thalassa

3.96

Format: 443 pages, Kindle Edition

Come to me, Empress … At age twenty, Selene Bowers desperately hopes to be accepted into Henbane… read more

Similar categories in Laura Thalassa's Bewitched (Bewitched, #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • adult
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Ocean of Sin and Starlight by Karina Halle

15. Ocean of Sin and Starlight

By: Karina Halle

3.86

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

PRIEST. PIRATE. MONSTER. From New York Times bestselling author Karina Halle comes Ocean of Sin … read more

Similar categories in Karina Halle's Ocean of Sin and Starlight book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
  • dark
Cover of Marrow by Trisha Wolfe

16. Marrow

By: Trisha Wolfe

3.97

Format: 322 pages, Kindle Edition

Two rival serial killers. One common enemy. Forensic anthropologist Dr. Jack Sorensen is the … read more

Similar categories in Trisha Wolfe's Marrow book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
  • adult
Cover of Hollow Heathens: Book of Blackwell (Tales of Weeping Hollow, #1) by Nicole Fiorina

17. Hollow Heathens: Book of Blackwell (Tales of Weeping Hollow, #1)

By: Nicole Fiorina

4.03

Format: 475 pages, Paperback

A forbidden, timeless, and haunting love story. Once upon a time, there lived a girl named Fallo… read more

Similar categories in Nicole Fiorina's Hollow Heathens: Book of Blackwell (Tales of Weeping Hollow, #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • dark
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
"Yet, still, I fell in love with the moon. And she, too, fell in love with me."

-Nicole Fiorina, Hollow Heathens: Book of Blackwell (Tales of Weeping Hollow, #1)

"No dawn, no day, no nightfall. A space-time, where we only heard the anticipating thudding of our hearts. Like Wicked Death Wish."

-Nicole Fiorina, Hollow Heathens: Book of Blackwell (Tales of Weeping Hollow, #1)

"her beauty. No one would believe me if I said the moon breathed life into me, that it was here, inside her, where I found myself again."

-Nicole Fiorina, Hollow Heathens: Book of Blackwell (Tales of Weeping Hollow, #1)

"So, I kissed the night, got lost in his sky and suspended in his time. I kissed the darkness too, as if it was all I knew because it was a part of him."

-Nicole Fiorina, Hollow Heathens: Book of Blackwell (Tales of Weeping Hollow, #1)

Cover of The Poisoner (The Poisoner, #1) by I.V. Ophelia

18. The Poisoner (The Poisoner, #1)

By: I.V. Ophelia

3.74

Format: 442 pages, Hardcover

"Have you ever wondered how long it would take for a lethal dose of arsenic to kill you? Thirty-fi… read more

Similar categories in I.V. Ophelia's The Poisoner (The Poisoner, #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • dark
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
"Personal pleasures were like drying flowers, best kept away from the light to preserve their vibrance."

-I.V. Ophelia, The Poisoner (The Poisoner, #1)

"My father said unmarked hands were a sign of a man who had not worked for his achievements. He was most likely referring to a future husband, but I decided that it was a standard I wished to hold mys…"

-I.V. Ophelia, The Poisoner (The Poisoner, #1)

Cover of Grimstone (Grimstone #1) by Sophie Lark

19. Grimstone (Grimstone #1)

By: Sophie Lark

3.66

Format: 362 pages, Kindle Edition

Remi Hayes is beginning to think she’s cursed —her fiancé cheated on her, her brother Jude is a maj… read more

Similar categories in Sophie Lark's Grimstone (Grimstone #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • gothic romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of Lovely Wicked Things (Hollow's Row, #3) by Trisha Wolfe

20. Lovely Wicked Things (Hollow's Row, #3)

By: Trisha Wolfe

4.23

Format: 382 pages, Kindle Edition

Halen: I’ve created a monster. When past and present collide, the fallout feels like the death of… read more

Similar categories in Trisha Wolfe's Lovely Wicked Things (Hollow's Row, #3) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • dark
  • contemporary
  • mystery
  • thriller
Cover of Hollow (A Gothic Shade of Romance, #1) by Karina Halle

21. Hollow (A Gothic Shade of Romance, #1)

By: Karina Halle

3.90

Format: 362 pages, Paperback

Ever since she was a child, Kat Van Tassel knew that her parents had arranged for her to marry her … read more

Similar categories in Karina Halle's Hollow (A Gothic Shade of Romance, #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • dark
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Fairydale by Veronica Lancet

22. Fairydale

By: Veronica Lancet

4.13

Format: 772 pages, Kindle Edition

𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐜𝐨𝐮𝐥𝐝 𝐩𝐨𝐬𝐬𝐢𝐛𝐥𝐲 𝐠𝐨 𝐰𝐫𝐨𝐧𝐠 𝐢𝐧 𝐚 𝐭𝐨𝐰𝐧 𝐭𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐫𝐡𝐲𝐦𝐞𝐬 𝐰𝐢𝐭𝐡 𝐟𝐚𝐢𝐫𝐲𝐭𝐚𝐥𝐞? August 1955, When Miss Dar… read more

Similar categories in Veronica Lancet's Fairydale book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • dark
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
"Maybe you’ve know what it’s like to be at the bottom, but I doubt you’ve known hell."

-Veronica Lancet, Fairydale

Cover of Legend (A Gothic Shade of Romance, #2) by Karina Halle

23. Legend (A Gothic Shade of Romance, #2)

By: Karina Halle

3.79

Format: 402 pages, Kindle Edition

In the scorching and riveting conclusion to Hollow, a dark academia and gothic romance reimagining … read more

Similar categories in Karina Halle's Legend (A Gothic Shade of Romance, #2) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • dark
  • fantasy
  • adult
  • paranormal
Cover of Cliffhaven: A Novel Of Romantic Suspense by A. M. Grimm

24. Cliffhaven: A Novel Of Romantic Suspense

By: A. M. Grimm

4.19

Format: 354 pages, Kindle Edition

A gothic mansion crumbling to ruin. A tortured, brooding artist. And a brave art restorer determine… read more

Similar categories in A. M. Grimm's Cliffhaven: A Novel Of Romantic Suspense book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • gothic
Cover of The Monster of Hotel No. 7 (Stitches and Teeth, #1) by K.V. Rose

25. The Monster of Hotel No. 7 (Stitches and Teeth, #1)

By: K.V. Rose

4.30

Format: 358 pages, Kindle Edition

LITTLE SUN I am the princess of Writhe, a secret society slithering with evil. But I have everyt… read more

Similar categories in K.V. Rose's The Monster of Hotel No. 7 (Stitches and Teeth, #1) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • gothic romance
  • dark
  • fantasy
Cover of Bone Island: Book of Danvers (Tales of Weeping Hollow, #2) by Nicole Fiorina

26. Bone Island: Book of Danvers (Tales of Weeping Hollow, #2)

By: Nicole Fiorina

4.40

Format: 680 pages, Kindle Edition

𝐒𝐡𝐞 𝐜𝐫𝐚𝐯𝐞𝐝 𝐚𝐧 𝐞𝐬𝐜𝐚𝐩𝐞. 𝐇𝐞 𝐜𝐫𝐚𝐯𝐞𝐝 𝐭𝐨 𝐛𝐞 𝐟𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐝. 𝐓𝐰𝐨 𝐬𝐢𝐥𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐡𝐞𝐚𝐫𝐭𝐬 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐫𝐬𝐭𝐲 𝐮𝐧𝐭𝐢𝐥 𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐲 𝐛𝐨𝐭𝐡 𝐝𝐫𝐨𝐰𝐧𝐞𝐝. … read more

Similar categories in Nicole Fiorina's Bone Island: Book of Danvers (Tales of Weeping Hollow, #2) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • gothic romance
  • dark
  • fantasy
  • paranormal
Cover of Fables & Other Lies by Claire Contreras

27. Fables & Other Lies

By: Claire Contreras

3.62

Format: 224 pages, Kindle Edition

Do you believe in curses? I never did. Not until that fated night, six years ago, when I sat… read more

Similar categories in Claire Contreras's Fables & Other Lies book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • gothic
  • gothic romance
  • dark
  • fantasy
  • mystery
  • paranormal
"— Why does anyone reread a book or rewatch a movie? It brings a sense of comfort."

-Claire Contreras, Fables & Other Lies

"We were never all good, despite how much we tried to be, or all bad, despite what others said about us."

-Claire Contreras, Fables & Other Lies

Cover of Amid Clouds and Bones by Ella Fields

28. Amid Clouds and Bones

By: Ella Fields

4.15

Format: 403 pages, Kindle Edition

A princess determined to survive an arranged marriage to a heartless faerie prince is saved by a tw… read more

Similar categories in Ella Fields's Amid Clouds and Bones book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • paranormal
  • fantasy
Cover of Heart of Frost and Scars (Frozen Fate #3) by Pam Godwin

29. Heart of Frost and Scars (Frozen Fate #3)

By: Pam Godwin

4.58

Format: 650 pages, Kindle Edition

I’m the silent ache, the shadow that lingers, the present from your past, the knife in your heart. … read more

Similar categories in Pam Godwin's Heart of Frost and Scars (Frozen Fate #3) book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • mystery
  • dark
  • contemporary
Cover of Za kamerami by Aleksandra Pilch

30. Za kamerami

By: Aleksandra Pilch

3.65

Format: 440 pages, Paperback

Duszne wakacje na poddaszu i nieznane dotąd uczucia oraz dwie osoby, które pozornie nie mają ze sob… read more

Similar categories in Aleksandra Pilch's Za kamerami book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

Cover of Cracked Blue Sky by Shiloh  Sloane

31. Cracked Blue Sky

By: Shiloh Sloane

4.40

Format: None pages, None

Cracked Blue Sky is an enemies-to-lovers, pitch dark romance about a werewolf cowboy and a hellbent… read more

Similar categories in Shiloh Sloane's Cracked Blue Sky book and Keri Lake's The Isle of Sin and Shadows

  • romance
  • paranormal
  • dark

7 must-read contemporary books like The Isle of Sin and Shadows by Keri Lake

Transform Your Habits

Lovely Violent Things (Hollow's Row, #2)

Trisha Wolfe

4.12

Transform Your Habits

Lovely Bad Things (Hollow's Row, #1)

Trisha Wolfe

3.74

Transform Your Habits

The Isle of Sin and Shadows

Keri Lake

4.15

Transform Your Habits

Marrow

Trisha Wolfe

3.97

View all the books

20 Top contemporary books like Lovely Violent Things (Hollow's Row, #2) by Trisha Wolfe

Transform Your Habits

Butcher & Blackbird (The Ruinous Love Trilogy, #1)

Brynne Weaver

4.09

Transform Your Habits

Where's Molly

H.D. Carlton

4.20

Transform Your Habits

Little Stranger (The Web of Silence Duet, #1)

Leigh Rivers

3.81

Transform Your Habits

Driving My Obsession (Ride or Die Romances)

Lauren Biel

3.65

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.