15 must-read fantasy books like The Midnight Show by Sarah Pennington

Cover of The Midnight Show by Sarah  Pennington

The Midnight Show

By: Sarah Pennington

4.33

Format: 126 pages, Kindle Edition

This mystery is the case of his dreams — and her nightmares. By day, Dayo Temitrope is a swingin…

If you liked the fantasy plot in The Midnight Show by Sarah Pennington , here is a list of 15 books like this:

Cover of The Oldest Flame (Mrs. Meade Mystery, #3) by None, Elisabeth Grace Foley

1. The Oldest Flame (Mrs. Meade Mystery, #3)

By: None , Elisabeth Grace Foley

4.22

Format: 67 pages, Kindle Edition

The fire wasn't an accident. Mrs. Meade hopes it wasn't what the sheriff thinks it is. Mrs. Mead… read more

Similar categories in None's The Oldest Flame (Mrs. Meade Mystery, #3) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • mystery
  • historical fiction
Cover of Creating Character Arcs: The Masterful Author's Guide to Uniting Story Structure, Plot, and Character Development by K.M. Weiland

2. Creating Character Arcs: The Masterful Author's Guide to Uniting Story Structure, Plot, and Character Development

By: K.M. Weiland

4.31

Format: 215 pages, Kindle Edition

About the BookPowerful Character Arcs Create Powerful StoriesHave you written a story with an excit… read more

Similar categories in K.M. Weiland's Creating Character Arcs: The Masterful Author's Guide to Uniting Story Structure, Plot, and Character Development book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

Cover of The League Of The Scarlet Pimpernel by Emmuska Orczy

3. The League Of The Scarlet Pimpernel

By: Emmuska Orczy

3.42

Format: None pages, Paperback

More adventures amongst the terrors of revolutionary France. No one has uncovered the identity of t… read more

Similar categories in Emmuska Orczy's The League Of The Scarlet Pimpernel book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • historical fiction
Cover of Homer Price by Robert McCloskey

4. Homer Price

By: Robert McCloskey

4.09

Format: 149 pages, Paperback

Welcome to Centerburg! Where you can win a hundred dollars by eating all the doughnuts you want; wh… read more

Similar categories in Robert McCloskey's Homer Price book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

"By the time Uncle Ulysses and the sheriff arrived and pushed through the crowd, the lunchroom was a calamity of doughnuts! Doughnuts in the window, doughnuts piled high on the shelves, doughnuts stac…"

-Robert McCloskey, Homer Price

"Homer got down from the chair and pushed a button on the machine marked, "start". Rings of batter started dropping into the hot fat. After a ring of batter was cooked on one side, an automatic gadget…"

-Robert McCloskey, Homer Price

5. The Silent Hour (Mrs. Meade Mysteries #4)

By: None

3.50

Format: 36 pages, Kindle Edition

Major Cambert and his grandson Jim were known to have quarreled bitterly over Jim's choice of a wif… read more

Similar categories in None's The Silent Hour (Mrs. Meade Mysteries #4) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

6. Stiff Upper Lip, Jeeves (Jeeves, #13)

By: P.G. Wodehouse

3.43

Format: 232 pages, Hardcover

Bertie Wooster vows that nothing will induce him to return to Totleigh Towers, lair of former magis… read more

Similar categories in P.G. Wodehouse's Stiff Upper Lip, Jeeves (Jeeves, #13) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

Cover of In Search of a Prince (In Search of a Prince, #1) by Toni Shiloh

7. In Search of a Prince (In Search of a Prince, #1)

By: Toni Shiloh

4.19

Format: 374 pages, Paperback

Brielle Adebayo is fully content teaching at a New York City public school and taking annual summer… read more

Similar categories in Toni Shiloh's In Search of a Prince (In Search of a Prince, #1) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

Cover of Wishtress by Nadine Brandes

8. Wishtress

By: Nadine Brandes

4.03

Format: 453 pages, Hardcover

She didn't ask to be the Wishtress. Myrthe was born with the ability to turn her tears into wish… read more

Similar categories in Nadine Brandes's Wishtress book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fantasy
"When one fills each day with life, it makes time multiply"

-Nadine Brandes, Wishtress

"We may be on opposite sides, but that doesn't mean we're enemies."

-Nadine Brandes, Wishtress

"I've heard you. I want you to know that.' He held my gaze, his expression intense and determined. 'I know you're trying to get to the Well."

-Nadine Brandes, Wishtress

Cover of The Hart of Christmas (Dating a Denver Dragon #1) by Latisha Sexton

9. The Hart of Christmas (Dating a Denver Dragon #1)

By: Latisha Sexton

4.00

Format: 217 pages, Kindle Edition

Sometimes life takes a detour... Millie Jane Brooks’ dream of stardom falls apart when she can’t… read more

Similar categories in Latisha Sexton's The Hart of Christmas (Dating a Denver Dragon #1) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

Cover of Wormwood Abbey (The Secrets of Ormdale, #1) by Christina Baehr

10. Wormwood Abbey (The Secrets of Ormdale, #1)

By: Christina Baehr

4.28

Format: 208 pages, Kindle Edition

As a Victorian clergyman’s daughter, Edith Worms has seen everything — until a mythical salamander … read more

Similar categories in Christina Baehr's Wormwood Abbey (The Secrets of Ormdale, #1) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • historical fiction
Cover of The Golden Prince by Alice Ivinya

11. The Golden Prince

By: Alice Ivinya

4.06

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

A perfect prince. An engagement to save a kingdom. Too bad it’s all a lie. Prince Thomas has al… read more

Similar categories in Alice Ivinya's The Golden Prince book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fairy tales
  • retellings
  • fairy tale retellings
  • fantasy
Cover of Miss Percy's Pocket Guide to the Care and Feeding of British Dragons (Miss Percy Guide, #1) by Quenby Olson

12. Miss Percy's Pocket Guide to the Care and Feeding of British Dragons (Miss Percy Guide, #1)

By: Quenby Olson

4.12

Format: None pages, ebook

Miss Mildred Percy inherits a dragon. Ah, but we’ve already got ahead of ourselves… Miss Mil… read more

Similar categories in Quenby Olson's Miss Percy's Pocket Guide to the Care and Feeding of British Dragons (Miss Percy Guide, #1) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • mystery
  • fantasy
  • historical fiction
Cover of Dungeons and Drama (Dungeons and Drama, #1) by Kristy Boyce

13. Dungeons and Drama (Dungeons and Drama, #1)

By: Kristy Boyce

4.17

Format: 304 pages, Paperback

When it comes to romance, sometimes it doesn't hurt to play games. A fun YA romcom full of fake dat… read more

Similar categories in Kristy Boyce's Dungeons and Drama (Dungeons and Drama, #1) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

Cover of The School for Whatnots by Margaret Peterson Haddix

14. The School for Whatnots

By: Margaret Peterson Haddix

3.79

Format: 304 pages, Hardcover

From master of suspense author Margaret Peterson Haddix comes another page-turning stand-alone adve… read more

Similar categories in Margaret Peterson Haddix's The School for Whatnots book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • mystery
  • fantasy
Cover of Blizzard at Three Bears Lake (Once Upon a Western #1.5) by Rachel Kovaciny

15. Blizzard at Three Bears Lake (Once Upon a Western #1.5)

By: Rachel Kovaciny

3.91

Format: 30 pages, Kindle Edition

Goldilocks and the Three Bears... reimagined.Adventurous, imaginative Mary Rose simply wants to exp… read more

Similar categories in Rachel Kovaciny's Blizzard at Three Bears Lake (Once Upon a Western #1.5) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fairy tales
  • retellings
  • fairy tale retellings
  • historical fiction
Cover of Meant to Bee by Storm Shultz

16. Meant to Bee

By: Storm Shultz

4.33

Format: 161 pages, Paperback

Can accidentally becoming a beekeeper lead to love? Single mom Cordy Brown can’t catch a break. … read more

Similar categories in Storm Shultz's Meant to Bee book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

Cover of The Midnight Show by Sarah  Pennington

17. The Midnight Show

By: Sarah Pennington

4.33

Format: 126 pages, Kindle Edition

This mystery is the case of his dreams — and her nightmares. By day, Dayo Temitrope is a swingin… read more

Similar categories in Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fairy tales
  • retellings
  • fairy tale retellings
  • historical fiction
  • mystery
  • fantasy
Cover of Bennett Turns Into a Cat (Witches of Olderea #2.5) by Ireen Chau

18. Bennett Turns Into a Cat (Witches of Olderea #2.5)

By: Ireen Chau

4.62

Format: 120 pages, Paperback

This illustrated novella can be read after The Herbwitch Princess. Beauty Without Brains: How Wi… read more

Similar categories in Ireen Chau's Bennett Turns Into a Cat (Witches of Olderea #2.5) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fantasy
Cover of Unbetrothed by Candice Pedraza Yamnitz

19. Unbetrothed

By: Candice Pedraza Yamnitz

4.08

Format: 287 pages, Paperback

Around Agatha Sea, princesses are poised, magically gifted, and betrothed. So, when seventeen-ye… read more

Similar categories in Candice Pedraza Yamnitz's Unbetrothed book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fantasy
Cover of The Orb and the Airship (Turrim Archive, #1) by Jenelle Leanne Schmidt

20. The Orb and the Airship (Turrim Archive, #1)

By: Jenelle Leanne Schmidt

4.44

Format: 360 pages, Hardcover

A rogue airship captain. An ambitious youth. A clash of powers beyond their imagination. With sc… read more

Similar categories in Jenelle Leanne Schmidt's The Orb and the Airship (Turrim Archive, #1) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fantasy
"–it was nice to have someone cheering wholeheartedly for him the way that only a sibling could."

-Jenelle Leanne Schmidt, The Orb and the Airship (Turrim Archive, #1)

"They could not make out the exact words coming from their captain’s mouth, but it was fairly clear he wasn’t reciting poetry."

-Jenelle Leanne Schmidt, The Orb and the Airship (Turrim Archive, #1)

"The cruiser was his prize, and he’d fall to his death before he let another group of marauders steal what he had rightfully commandeered."

-Jenelle Leanne Schmidt, The Orb and the Airship (Turrim Archive, #1)

"He did not know how things were going to end, but he now knew that even in the midst of the darkest night, there was always a shard of light."

-Jenelle Leanne Schmidt, The Orb and the Airship (Turrim Archive, #1)

Cover of Break the Beast (A Classic Retold, #1) by Allison Tebo

21. Break the Beast (A Classic Retold, #1)

By: Allison Tebo

4.64

Format: None pages, ebook

Who is to say who is the real beast? Grendel haunts the land of Frisia in a restless need for ve… read more

Similar categories in Allison Tebo's Break the Beast (A Classic Retold, #1) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fairy tales
  • retellings
  • fairy tale retellings
  • fantasy
Cover of Yesterday or Long Ago (Evraft) by Jenni Sauer

22. Yesterday or Long Ago (Evraft)

By: Jenni Sauer

4.19

Format: 244 pages, Kindle Edition

"They’d write about her in books she’d never be allowed to read.” Rinity Garrick isn’t allowed i… read more

Similar categories in Jenni Sauer's Yesterday or Long Ago (Evraft) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fairy tales
  • retellings
  • fantasy
Cover of When a Dragon Comes Courting (Tales from Karneesia #1) by Claire Trella Hill

23. When a Dragon Comes Courting (Tales from Karneesia #1)

By: Claire Trella Hill

4.03

Format: 72 pages, Kindle Edition

A young mother and a dragon in a man’s guise meet in the unlikeliest of places….After her husband i… read more

Similar categories in Claire Trella Hill's When a Dragon Comes Courting (Tales from Karneesia #1) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fantasy
Cover of Mrs. Meade and the Schoolboy Prank: A Short Story (The Mrs. Meade Mysteries) by Elisabeth Grace Foley

24. Mrs. Meade and the Schoolboy Prank: A Short Story (The Mrs. Meade Mysteries)

By: Elisabeth Grace Foley

3.83

Format: 32 pages, Kindle Edition

“I do believe in coincidences, surely,” said Mrs. Meade, “but when they coincide with perfect alibi… read more

Similar categories in Elisabeth Grace Foley's Mrs. Meade and the Schoolboy Prank: A Short Story (The Mrs. Meade Mysteries) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • mystery
  • historical fiction
Cover of Fairer Than Beauty (A Twist of Adventure, #6) by Kendra E. Ardnek

25. Fairer Than Beauty (A Twist of Adventure, #6)

By: Kendra E. Ardnek

4.09

Format: 57 pages, Kindle Edition

Amara's life is going to be a fairy tale. She even has one picked out - Fairer-than-a-Fairy - which… read more

Similar categories in Kendra E. Ardnek's Fairer Than Beauty (A Twist of Adventure, #6) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

Cover of Steal the Morrow (A Classic Retold, #3) by Jenelle Leanne Schmidt

26. Steal the Morrow (A Classic Retold, #3)

By: Jenelle Leanne Schmidt

4.48

Format: 210 pages, Kindle Edition

The city may be dangerous, but it holds his only hope… Abandoned on a remote highway after bandits … read more

Similar categories in Jenelle Leanne Schmidt's Steal the Morrow (A Classic Retold, #3) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • retellings
  • fantasy
"Olifur licked his lips and gave a small croak. “Please, sir."

-Jenelle Leanne Schmidt, Steal the Morrow (A Classic Retold, #3)

"Dojhur listened carefully, not interrupting, until the story had finished. “You’re lucky,"

-Jenelle Leanne Schmidt, Steal the Morrow (A Classic Retold, #3)

Cover of Her Fake Superhero Boyfriend (Superhero Romance Project, #5) by H.L. Burke

27. Her Fake Superhero Boyfriend (Superhero Romance Project, #5)

By: H.L. Burke

4.76

Format: None pages, ebook

He's a villain pretending to be a hero. She's a disaster who needs to prove she's got it together. … read more

Similar categories in H.L. Burke's Her Fake Superhero Boyfriend (Superhero Romance Project, #5) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

Cover of The Snow Queen's Shattered Mirror (Once Upon a Twisted Time, #4) by Kendra E. Ardnek

28. The Snow Queen's Shattered Mirror (Once Upon a Twisted Time, #4)

By: Kendra E. Ardnek

4.16

Format: 17 pages, Kindle Edition

She is left with a shattered mirror and a shattered kingdom. The Snow Queen's brother wrecked th… read more

Similar categories in Kendra E. Ardnek's The Snow Queen's Shattered Mirror (Once Upon a Twisted Time, #4) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fantasy
Cover of The Dragon's Princess (Once Upon a Twisted Time, #3) by Kendra E. Ardnek

29. The Dragon's Princess (Once Upon a Twisted Time, #3)

By: Kendra E. Ardnek

4.22

Format: 11 pages, Kindle Edition

The dragon doesn’t mean to collect maidens. And yet the maidens come, flocking to his cave for s… read more

Similar categories in Kendra E. Ardnek's The Dragon's Princess (Once Upon a Twisted Time, #3) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • fairy tales
  • retellings
  • fantasy
Cover of The American Pony (Mrs. Meade Mysteries #5) by Elisabeth Grace Foley

30. The American Pony (Mrs. Meade Mysteries #5)

By: Elisabeth Grace Foley

4.17

Format: None pages, Kindle Edition

Was it a joke gone wrong—or something more sinister? It’s summer in Colorado, and Sir Edmund Mar… read more

Similar categories in Elisabeth Grace Foley's The American Pony (Mrs. Meade Mysteries #5) book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

  • mystery
  • historical fiction
Cover of Dear Mouse Princess by Candice Pedraza Yamnitz

31. Dear Mouse Princess

By: Candice Pedraza Yamnitz

5.00

Format: 108 pages, Paperback

None read more

Similar categories in Candice Pedraza Yamnitz's Dear Mouse Princess book and Sarah Pennington's The Midnight Show

8 Best historical fiction books like The Midnight Show by Sarah Pennington

Transform Your Habits

The Oldest Flame (Mrs. Meade Mystery, #3)

None , Elisabeth Grace Foley

4.22

Transform Your Habits

The League Of The Scarlet Pimpernel

Emmuska Orczy

3.42

Transform Your Habits

Wormwood Abbey (The Secrets of Ormdale, #1)

Christina Baehr

4.28

Transform Your Habits

Miss Percy's Pocket Guide to the Care and Feeding of British Dragons (Miss Percy Guide, #1)

Quenby Olson

4.12

View all the books

15 must-read fiction books like Blizzard at Three Bears Lake (Once Upon a Western #1.5) by Rachel Kovaciny

Transform Your Habits

The Border Legion

Zane Grey

4.57

Transform Your Habits

Mansfield Park

Jane Austen

3.87

Transform Your Habits

The Mysterious Rider

Zane Grey

4.00

Transform Your Habits

Love Blooms (Bluestar Island, #1)

Jennifer Faye

4.32

View all the books

Never miss a story from us, get weekly updates in your inbox.